Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers are a factor in the AFC playoff race

I'm ready to declare the Steelers are back. No, they're a factor. That's what I'm going to call them. They're going to be a factor. They could make some noise. Big Ben plays better when he's dead.

The Steelers finished 9-6-1 and missed the playoffs entirely, so they weren't really a factor in the postseason.
Void
Mark LeibovichMark Leibovich

Incompetent leadership is the biggest long-term threat to the NFL

I think ultimately the incompetence of the people who run it is going to wear it down because there is no long-term thinking among any of these owners... So I think that the crisis of leadership is the biggest long-term threat to the league, perhaps.

This is an ongoing subjective assessment of league business health.
Loss
Dana HolgorsenDana Holgorsen

Will Grier is the best player in college football

I don't know where that [big balls narrative] come from, honestly, because I got the best player in college football in Will Grier, so those decisions are pretty easy.

Kyler Murray won the Heisman Trophy in 2018, and Tua Tagovailoa was widely considered the top player; Grier finished 4th in Heisman voting.
Loss
HankHank

Soap can't get dirty because it cleans itself

My friend uses a bar of soap to clean his ass crack and uses it the next day on his whole body... He says soap can't get dirty, so it's fine. [Hank says] He's right. You're wrong. It's like soap cleans itself all the time because it's layers.

Scientifically, bacteria can live on the surface of bar soap, even if it is technically a cleaning agent.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys stink and Jerry Jones has no idea what is going on anymore

The Cowboys stink. And Jerry Jones is either dead or has no idea what's going on anymore. He actually has changed the narrative on everyone because he's so scared of firing Jason Garrett and not having full control of his team.

The Cowboys actually turned their season around shortly after this, finishing 10-6 and winning a playoff game, though the Jason Garrett era did eventually end due to the stagnation Big Cat mentions.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jerry Jones is no longer making the calls for the Cowboys

Jerry Jones is not making the calls anymore. I think he's a figurehead right now. He's the emperor with no clothes... Steven Jones, he's taken over the kingdom from his father. It's like at the end of Braveheart where the old guy's dying and the son's making the calls.

While Stephen Jones took on more responsibility, Jerry Jones remains the official GM and face of the franchise's decisions.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Titans should not have signed Malcolm Butler

Malcolm Butler fucking stinks. He's so bad. He's been terrible. [Bill Belichick] duped over his own former player. You are the Titans, yes. You should not have signed Malcolm Butler.

Butler had a very poor start to his Titans career in 2018, though he eventually improved. At the time of the take, he was statistically one of the worst-performing corners.
Void
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Joe DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak is likely the most unbreakable record in sports

I agree. My longest hitting streak was 16 games. And so to think somebody could go 56 games without going 0 for 4 is amazing to me. And I think the pressure of the consecutive games hitting streak... because of the media coverage and the scrutiny, that creates more pressure. And so I think that's almost unattainable.

DiMaggio's record hasn't been seriously challenged in decades, supporting the idea of its unbreakability.
Void
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Certain players have an intangible value that isn't captured by modern sabermetrics

I think that certain players have an intangible value that's not measurable in the way that they're measuring everything nowadays. But, I mean, it's like Eddie Murray was our fourth hitter. He could be 0 for 50... But if Eddie was not in our lineup, we felt like we didn't have a good lineup. He stabilized the whole lineup.

This is a philosophical debate in sports analytics; data often fails to find evidence for 'protection,' but players and managers swear by it.
Void
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Accomplishments from the steroid era are unfairly diminished by the widespread use of PEDs

For someone that's been in it, it kind of bothers me that when they look back, said it was the steroid era. And then, therefore, it kind of takes away your accomplishments during that time frame... It makes a light of your accomplishments.

This is a subjective perspective from a Hall of Famer who played through the era.
Void
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Players should act like they've been there before and avoid bat flipping

I don't like that [bat flipping]... you were considered more of a sportsman. So your entertainment value was in the quality of your sport and how you competed... but I always felt that and maybe it's John Riggins like if you score a touchdown, you know, act like you've been there before.

The culture of baseball has moved toward 'letting the kids play,' making Ripken's view somewhat contrarian today.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Allowing a single player to score 50 points is a bad sign for the Celtics' team defense

It does look bad if somebody's putting up 50 on you. Not a great sign for the Celtics this year. Like, it does say something about team defense if one guy's able to do that against, like, five.

The Celtics finished the 2018-19 season with a top-10 defense (7th in defensive rating), suggesting this game was an outlier rather than a systemic failure.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Tomlin's quotes make no sense despite sounding smart

We've never been more right than we were with our Mike Tomlin take on Monday, basically saying every quote from him is just – makes no sense. But it makes enough sense that you walk away being like, oh, that was smart... You take three steps and you start writing it up, and then you're like, wait a second. These words have never been put together.

This is a recurring observational bit about Tomlin's unique communication style.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Le'Veon Bell screwed himself by holding out because it allows the Steelers to transition tag him

The Le'Veon Bell thing... he's screwed himself over because he can now get transition tagged by the Steelers, which means that they can just keep him around for another year... and pay him less.

The Steelers chose not to place the transition tag on Bell, allowing him to become an unrestricted free agent in March 2019.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The loss to the Saints was a statement loss for the Rams that showed championship resolve

I think that was a statement loss for the Rams. Okay. Because they basically had everything go wrong in the first half... And the way they came out in the second half, even though they didn't win the game, that was championship resolve.

The Rams went on to represent the NFC in the Super Bowl that year.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Darnold is bad and investors should sell the stock

Sam Darnold. Trash. He's bad. Sell the stock.

Darnold's tenure with the Jets was largely considered a failure, though he revived his career years later.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am sick of John Harbaugh and his obsession with mock turtlenecks

I don't say this lightly, but I'm sick of John Harbaugh's mock turtlenecks. I think that's what the problem is. Find you somebody in this world that loves you as much as John Harbaugh likes wearing mock turtlenecks.

The Ravens finished 10-6 and won the division, suggesting Harbaugh's 'mock turtleneck' era wasn't a total failure in 2018.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Floyd Mayweather is a certified idiot if he agrees to anything other than a boxing match against Tenshin Nasukawa

If it's anything but a boxing match, Floyd Mayweather is a certified idiot. ... That's why I think he's going to get kicked in the face. Yeah, this is all fake.

The fight was eventually sanctioned as an exhibition boxing match, proving PFT right that Floyd wouldn't risk an MMA/kickboxing match.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Herman's complaints about Will Grier's celebration are hypocritical given his own past behavior

If you remember just a year ago when they were in a bowl game against Missouri and [Herman] was mocking Drew Lock in his gun salute, he was basically showing up the other team. And then when he loses, he's crying to the media and saying that Will Grier was unfair.

This is a subjective assessment of Herman's character and consistency.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bob Ryan's 'true sports fan' tweet was essentially correct despite the backlash

Everyone hated him for this. I don't think it's – I think he obviously went a little too hard. But the bones of this argument are kind of right. There are people who I think are fans of their teams only. And then there are people who are fans of sports in general. I think that's the better argument.

This is a subjective opinion on how to define a 'true fan.'
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders are the worst team in the NFL

The Raiders are the worst team in the league. And that is also considering the fact they beat the Browns. But they are the worst team in the league.

The Raiders finished 2018 at 4-12. While they were bottom-tier, the Cardinals (3-13) statistically had a worse record.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Saints' 'dome magic' has returned to the Superdome

I want to say the Saints, the dome magic might be coming back... Ever since the ceremony with Drew Brees in the dome, the dome recaptured that magic.

The Saints went 13-3 and reached the NFC Championship game in 2018, confirming their home dominance that season.
Void
Daniel CormierDaniel Cormier

I would fight Jon Jones again even if he is on performance-enhancing drugs

At the end of the day, he won the fights, and that's all I want to do is win the fights. So if that means fighting him again, even if he's on the stuff, I mean, you have to do it. So, yeah, of course I want to fight him again.

They never fought a third time, so this remains a subjective statement of intent.
Void
Daniel CormierDaniel Cormier

Conor McGregor cannot win a rematch against Khabib Nurmagomedov due to the matchup

Matchup-wise, this is just a bad matchup... Khabib doesn't get hit clean right away to get knocked out. He also has the ability to take him down, and also he's in great shape. He's not going to get tired... With Khabib, it didn't seem to have the same effect because Khabib's so big.

A rematch never happened, but Khabib's dominance over other similar strikers suggests DC's assessment of the style clash was accurate.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Witten is clearly over his head and won't have a job at ESPN by the end of the year

I officially, officially feel bad for Jason Witten. He is so clearly over his head... And now I just feel bad because it feels like he's not going to have a job at the end of the year. And this is painful.

Witten finished the 2018 season but was widely criticized and returned to the Cowboys for the 2019 season, effectively ending his initial broadcasting stint after one year.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Football season is a legitimate legal excuse to postpone jury duty

[The jury duty official] asked me, he's like, so what's your excuse? I was like, well, it's football season and I got a lot of travel and football season. And he's like, okay... so come back after the Super Bowl. Shout out to that guy for taking 'it's football season' as a legitimate excuse for not wanting to be on jury.

He did successfully postpone it, so the take proved true for him.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bulls didn't get blown out by the Warriors, they simply ran out of time

The Bulls just ran out of time. That was simply what it was. I mean, maybe the Warriors scored 92 points in the first half, and Klay Thompson scored 52 points in 25 minutes, but we don't have to get into that. The point is, the Bulls just ran out of time. That was simply what it was. The Warriors' greatest weapon is the clock.

The Bulls were outscored by 25 points and were never competitive; the claim they 'ran out of time' is ironically incorrect.
Void
Mark WahlbergMark Wahlberg

Dodgers fans are fair-weather fans who just jump between whoever is winning in LA

The Dodgers got fair-weather fans. I mean, you talk about guys who will go from the Kings to the Dodgers to the Clippers to the Lakers... it's like enough already.

Fan loyalty is subjective and can't be definitively proven across a whole city.
Void
Mark WahlbergMark Wahlberg

Bill Belichick is hilarious in real life

I've spent some quality time with Bill... Is he funny in real life? Oh, he's hilarious... I know [him] off the field... he's the best of the best.

This is a personal character assessment of a public figure.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Manning family has brainwashed everyone into over-respecting Eli Manning

I disagree [that Eli deserves more respect]. I think that you've been brainwashed by Archie Manning. I have a theory that the Mannings have brainwashed [everyone].

It is an unprovable conspiracy theory about media influence.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

You have to bet on the Steelers when Ben Roethlisberger thinks he is injured

This actually, if you are a betting man, and we are, you have to take the Steelers this weekend. Because an injured Big Ben, or even a Big Ben who thinks he is injured, always is dangerous. Because if he is actually feeling pain somewhere, then that's a big part of his brain that's not able to fuck everything up for the rest of his body.

The Steelers beat the Ravens 23-16 on Nov 4, 2018, confirming the bet worked.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I refuse to sign up for any app that doesn't use the standard phone number keypad for data entry

If you're still making apps in the year of our Lord 2018 that doesn't let me just do the phone keyboard with the numbers [instead of the long horizontal keyboard], I'm absolutely not signing up for your app. That's how lazy I've got.

This is a personal preference and a boycott that is subjective to the speaker.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Pardon My Take crew is officially 'Team Cardi B'

We are team Cardi B through and through. They call us the Cardi three. Me, Hank, and Big Cat.

It is an alliance statement and a joke, which is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Clayton Kershaw is still kind of a bum in the playoffs

Clayton Kershaw still kind of a bum. Whew. That was tough. If [David] Price had done what Kershaw did, you'd be killing him. Bum is hard. But today was a moment... when you give up a two-run homer in the first inning, that's tough.

Kershaw had a 7.36 ERA in the 2018 World Series and famously struggled in postseasons for much of his career until 2020.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Manny Machado is the perfect villain for baseball

Manny Machado, the world's biggest jerk. I love Manny Machado. I don't want him on the Cubs, but I love this guy... It was his coming out party as a real asshole, and I love it. Because the world... we need villains. And Manny Machado was the perfect villain.

This is a subjective opinion on entertainment value, but Machado remained one of the most polarizing figures in the sport.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

David Price should have been the World Series MVP

I thought David Price should have been the MVP. [He] had a very low bar to clear, and he cleared it really well. But still, the expectation versus reality, he absolutely dominated in that perspective.

Steve Pearce was officially named World Series MVP.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins will not win big games for the Vikings

But that's one of those games that if you're a Vikings fan, you have to ask yourself, we paid Kirk Cousins to win those type of games, and Kirk Cousins isn't going to win those type of games. He's not going to win those type of games... Kirk Cousins will not win big games, but he can win enough games to get you in the playoffs.

Cousins eventually won a playoff game against the Saints in 2020, but the narrative of him struggling in big/prime-time games largely persisted throughout his Vikings career.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will be in first place in the NFC North (for now)

The Bears are back. They're number one. NFC North. Just saying. I don't know if we'll hold on to it for very long, but you have to enjoy the small steps, okay?

The Bears actually did much better than 'holding on for a bit' — they won the NFC North in 2018 with a 12-4 record.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm withholding all judgment on Josh Rosen for his rookie year

I'm officially saying this whole year, too early to judge. I learned my lesson from Jared Goff. I like that. What about Sam Darnold? Too early to judge.

While wise to wait, Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold did eventually prove to be busts, so early negative indicators were actually correct.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Clemson is the only team that can go toe-to-toe with Alabama

Clemson feels like the only team that could go toe to toe with Alabama. And I'm not sure. Cause if you get Clemson, when they hit kill mode, I don't think Notre Dame or Michigan or LSU would be able to hang with him.

Clemson famously beat Alabama 44-16 in the National Championship game, proving they could not only hang with them but dominate them.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Buck is the best announcer of the last 30 years

Do you think that Joe Buck is the best announcer of the last 30 years? Yes. I think Joe Buck, although he's getting so much credit now... Throw your Joe Buck sucks take out the window. Which is true.

Subjective media opinion, though Buck's resume of World Series and Super Bowls is unmatched in that window.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions are not sure they're bad and could win their division

I actually think the Lions could be okay. They could win that division, you think? Are we sure they're good? We're not sure they're bad.

The Lions finished 6-10 and last in the NFC North in 2018.
Void
Randy CoutureRandy Couture

The Muhammad Ali Act should be amended to include MMA fighters to break the promoters' monopoly

If I could change anything in the sport, I would amend the definition of a combative sports athlete for the federal legislation and the Muhammad Ali Act to include all combative sports athletes, not just boxers... right now in MMA, the flaw in our system is that the promoter and the sanctioning body are the same guy... It's not a competitive sport.

This is a policy opinion that has been a point of legal and legislative debate for years but has not been enacted as federal law for MMA.
Void
Randy CoutureRandy Couture

George St-Pierre and BJ Penn are on the MMA GOAT list

George St-Pierre. George has got to be on the list. Absolutely got to be on the list... [and] BJ Penn's got to be on there.

The 'Greatest of All Time' is a subjective debate in sports.
Void
Randy CoutureRandy Couture

Jon Jones would defeat Brock Lesnar in a fight

I think probably Jon [Jones], his athleticism and length is going to pose a problem for Lesnar. And Brock, as amazing athlete as he is and as big and strong as he is, he still hasn't really made friends with getting punched in the face.

The fight never occurred, so it remains a subjective hypothetical.
Void
TT
Tyler Trent

Purdue fans have grown up 'disappointed' by the 'Purdue Way'

Growing up a Purdue fan, unfortunately you kind of not grow up disappointed of sports, I would say, but you kind of learn not quote unquote the Purdue way. Purdue has not been known as a powerhouse football wise since Drew Brees was at Purdue.

This is a fan's assessment of the program's history and culture.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

David Price officially has the clutch gene

Does David Price have the clutch gene? That is the question. That is the segment. And I'm going to say yes. He does. When it matters the most.

Price won the 2018 World Series with a 1.98 ERA in the series, including the series-clinching win.
Void
HankHank

Chris Paul is the worst teammate in the NBA

Chris Paul, worst teammate in the league... It says all of his former teammates. Ryan Hollins and Glen Davis [say it].

Whether someone is a 'bad teammate' is subjective, though many former teammates have since spoken both for and against CP3's leadership style.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Durant is a 'baby back bitch'

Kevin Durant, actually. I want to call him a baby back bitch to his face... [and] I think he would actually be good after a while, after we got the old baby back bitch shit out of the way.

Characterizing a player's personality or toughness is a matter of opinion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dodgers' bullpen is their one true weakness

The bullpen wasn't great for the Dodgers. That's their one weakness that they have. Bullpen pitchers are just pitchers that couldn't be starting pitchers.

The Dodgers bullpen struggled in the 2018 World Series, particularly in Game 4 where they blew a 4-0 lead.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers