Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Red Sox Win WS, Week 8 NFL Recap + Andy Staples Talks CFB

Monday, October 29, 201816 takes

NFL Week 8 fastest 2 minutes ( - ). The Red Sox won the World Series and we recap the end of the baseball season. David Price is clutch now, Clayton Kershaw isn't, and how did Dave Roberts keep putting Ryan Madson into games? ( - ) NFL Week 8 recap. Hue Jackson is historically bad, Jameis gets the Done Chain, Todd Gurley screwed America, and the Panthers are really good plus more from the weekend in the league ( - ). Whos back of the week ( - ). SI CFB writer Andy Staples joins the show to break down what the first playoff rankings will look like on tuesday, how anyone can beat Alabama, Pac 12 mess and will the Big Ten be the same? ( - ) Segments include Football guy of the week, trouble in paradise for Ty Lue, in defense of Joe Buck

Red Sox World Series Win, Week 8 NFL, and Andy Staples on CFB

The Boston Red Sox have officially conquered the baseball world, finishing off the Dodgers in five games. While Hank celebrates yet another championship for the city of Boston, Big Cat and PFT were more focused on the individual narratives that shifted over the course of the series. David Price finally shed the playoff choker label, while Clayton Kershaw seemed to lean even further into it.

Win
Oct 29, 2018
#12727
Big CatBig Cat

Clayton Kershaw is still kind of a bum in the playoffs

Clayton Kershaw still kind of a bum. Whew. That was tough. If [David] Price had done what Kershaw did, you'd be killing him. Bum is hard. But today was a moment... when you give up a two-run homer in the first inning, that's tough.

Kershaw had a 7.36 ERA in the 2018 World Series and famously struggled in postseasons for much of his career until 2020.

David Price dominated when it mattered most, but the real story of the series for many fans was the emergence of a true baseball antagonist. Manny Machado spent the series blowing bubbles, pimping singles that didn't leave the park, and accidentally-on-purpose stepping on first basemen.

Void
Oct 29, 2018
#12728
Big CatBig Cat

Manny Machado is the perfect villain for baseball

Manny Machado, the world's biggest jerk. I love Manny Machado. I don't want him on the Cubs, but I love this guy... It was his coming out party as a real asshole, and I love it. Because the world... we need villains. And Manny Machado was the perfect villain.

This is a subjective opinion on entertainment value, but Machado remained one of the most polarizing figures in the sport.

While the Dodgers' star power underwhelmed, their bullpen was a disaster waiting to happen. PFT was quick to remind everyone that he saw this coming from a mile away.

Win
Oct 29, 2018
#12729
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dodgers' bullpen would be their undoing

I said that the Dodgers' bullpen was going to be their undoing. From the start. I also said Red Sox in five. So not to brag, but I called it.

The Red Sox did win in 5 games, and the Dodgers' relief pitching (Madson) was a major factor in the collapse.

Week 8 NFL Chaos

Moving to the gridiron, Todd Gurley committed what some might call a war crime against the gambling community. Running free for a late touchdown that would have covered the spread and hit the over, Gurley instead took a knee at the one-yard line to seal the game for the Rams.

Void
Oct 29, 2018
#12730
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Never trust a 'cat guy' like Todd Gurley

This goes along with my long-held opinion. You don't trust a cat guy. [Todd Gurley]'s got two cats. Anybody that makes the honest decision to have an animal live in your house that also craps in there, I will not trust you with a single thing.

The take is about personal trust and pet ownership, which is inherently subjective/comedic.

The guys also broke down the Sunday Night Football matchup between the Saints and Vikings. While Kirk Cousins put up respectable numbers on paper, the eye test told a different story for anyone hoping he could lead Minnesota to the promised land.

Push
Oct 29, 2018
#12731
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins will not win big games for the Vikings

But that's one of those games that if you're a Vikings fan, you have to ask yourself, we paid Kirk Cousins to win those type of games, and Kirk Cousins isn't going to win those type of games. He's not going to win those type of games... Kirk Cousins will not win big games, but he can win enough games to get you in the playoffs.

Cousins eventually won a playoff game against the Saints in 2020, but the narrative of him struggling in big/prime-time games largely persisted throughout his Vikings career.

In Cleveland, the wheels have completely fallen off. Hue Jackson and Todd Haley are reportedly at each other's throats, and the statistical reality of Hue's tenure is starting to become impossible for even the most patient owners to ignore.

Win
Oct 29, 2018
#12732
Big CatBig Cat

Hue Jackson is statistically the worst coach in NFL history

Out of 219 coaches with a minimum of 40 games coached, Hue Jackson ranks 218th all-time in winning percentage. The only one who is worse, former Eagles head coach Burt Bell.

At the time of his firing, Jackson's .205 winning percentage was indeed near the bottom for qualifying coaches.

Andy Staples and the Playoff Picture

With the first College Football Playoff rankings dropping Tuesday, Andy Staples joined the show to help make sense of a top-heavy landscape. While everyone is chasing Alabama, Andy thinks there is only one team in the country with the roster to actually trade blows with Nick Saban's squad.

Win
Oct 29, 2018
#12736
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Clemson is the only team that can go toe-to-toe with Alabama

Clemson feels like the only team that could go toe to toe with Alabama. And I'm not sure. Cause if you get Clemson, when they hit kill mode, I don't think Notre Dame or Michigan or LSU would be able to hang with him.

Clemson famously beat Alabama 44-16 in the National Championship game, proving they could not only hang with them but dominate them.

Andy also looked ahead to the potential final four, noting that Michigan is making a strong case to join the usual suspects at the end of the year if they can avoid their annual Big Ten stumble.

Push
Oct 29, 2018
#12735
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

The 2018 College Football Playoff will include Alabama, Notre Dame, Clemson, and Michigan

The Final Four, if I'm projecting it out at the end of the season, would be Alabama, Notre Dame, Clemson, in some order... And then Michigan. My top four now are Alabama, Notre Dame, Clemson, LSU. But I'm projecting, obviously, that Alabama beats LSU.

The final 2018 Playoff was Alabama, Clemson, Notre Dame, and Oklahoma. Michigan lost to Ohio State 62-39 at the end of the season, knocking them out.

Monday Segments

Football Guy of the Week featured some heavy hitters, including Mike Gundy trying to fight Tom Herman and Mike Leach sprinting away from sideline reporters at halftime. Big Cat noted that Oklahoma State's success might have more to do with their aesthetic choices than their actual play-calling.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Winning big college football games requires changing up jerseys to get everyone excited

That's how you win football games. That's how you win big football games. You change up the jerseys, get everyone excited, don't pay the players, put all that money into doing different jerseys every week. New helmets.

Hot TakeCFBHotSubjectiveSarcastic
This is a satirical take on momentum and superstition.

Finally, the guys checked in on the disaster in Cleveland following Ty Lue's firing. With the Cavs sitting at 0-6, PFT has a radical solution to fill the leadership void in the locker room.

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cleveland Cavaliers should hire J.R. Smith as a player-coach

I am in full support of player coach J.R. Smith. J.R. Smith, player coach. Get it trending. Do it. Petty War. NBA Twitter, you got this.

J.R. Smith was never hired as a player-coach; he was eventually exiled from the team and then joined the Lakers.

Hopefully J.R. Smith remembers the score better as a coach than he did as a player.

nflworld-seriesred-soxcollege-footballbrownsrams

More Takes

Loss
Oct 29, 2018
#20742
Big CatBig Cat

David Price should have been the World Series MVP

I thought David Price should have been the MVP. [He] had a very low bar to clear, and he cleared it really well. But still, the expectation versus reality, he absolutely dominated in that perspective.

Steve Pearce was officially named World Series MVP.
Loss
Oct 29, 2018
#20743
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Packers will build off their close loss to the Rams

This is going to be a loss that the Packers can build off of. Well, they have a tough schedule coming up. They're going to build off this loss... I would be very woke on them.

The Packers went 2-5 over their next seven games and missed the playoffs.
Win
Oct 29, 2018·Who's Back
#12733
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will be in first place in the NFC North (for now)

The Bears are back. They're number one. NFC North. Just saying. I don't know if we'll hold on to it for very long, but you have to enjoy the small steps, okay?

The Bears actually did much better than 'holding on for a bit' — they won the NFC North in 2018 with a 12-4 record.
Push
Oct 29, 2018·Who's Back
#12734
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm withholding all judgment on Josh Rosen for his rookie year

I'm officially saying this whole year, too early to judge. I learned my lesson from Jared Goff. I like that. What about Sam Darnold? Too early to judge.

While wise to wait, Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold did eventually prove to be busts, so early negative indicators were actually correct.
Loss
Oct 29, 2018
#20744
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

I have very little faith in Ohio State winning the rest of their games

Ohio State, I have very little faith in them to win the rest of their games. Because they give up so many big plays on defense... They have like one of those [Purdue losses] a year now.

Ohio State won all five remaining games, including the Big Ten Championship and the Rose Bowl.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Buck is the best announcer of the last 30 years

Do you think that Joe Buck is the best announcer of the last 30 years? Yes. I think Joe Buck, although he's getting so much credit now... Throw your Joe Buck sucks take out the window. Which is true.

Subjective media opinion, though Buck's resume of World Series and Super Bowls is unmatched in that window.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers