Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

3X Super Bowl Champion Willie McGinest + Week 1 Recap

Monday, September 10, 201815 takes

The fastest 2 minutes are back. Week 1 recap, the Bears broke Big Cat's heart ( -) Andrew Luck is back, Ryan Fitzpatrick torched the Saints, and the Browns tied a football game ( - ). Football guy of the week including Larry Fedora's memory hole and Syrup Coach ( - ). Who's back of the week ( - ). 3X Super Bowl Champion Willie McGinest joins the show to talk about his career in the NFL, playing for Bill Belichick, being friends with Snoop Dogg, and predictions for the 2018 Football Season ( - ). Talking Tennis, Serena Williams in the US Open, Hermatology Herm Edwards is actually good? And our newest segment "Whats the Beef" where we get an explainer on KD vs Lebron, Eminem vs Machine Gun Kelly, Cardi B vs Nikki Minaj. Plus a bonus embrace debate for football watching sundays.

Willie McGinest on the Patriot Way and Week 1 Overreactions

The Fastest 2 Minutes are back, and football is officially here to ruin our lives. Big Cat is currently in the middle of a full-scale emotional collapse because, while we taped the first half of the recap during Sunday Night Football, the second half of the game actually happened. Khalil Mack looked like a god among men for thirty minutes, but Aaron Rodgers eventually rose from the dead on one leg to remind the world that being a Bears fan is a life sentence of pain.

Before the wheels completely fell off in Green Bay, Big Cat was ready to plan a parade route through downtown Chicago.

Win
Sep 10, 2018
#12660
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears defense is elite and can beat anyone

This Bears defense can beat anyone. [The 20-0 halftime lead] feels like a pivotal era in the Bears history where it's like everything's going to be good from this point forward.

The Bears did have an elite defense in 2018 (ranked #1 in DVOA), though they lost this specific game.

While Big Cat mourns, PFT is busy analyzing the Pittsburgh-Cleveland tie, which is easily the most Browns way to start a season. The big takeaway from that rain-soaked mess? Ben Roethlisberger has lost too much weight and, frankly, he’s lost his powers along with his padding.

Loss
Sep 10, 2018
#12666
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ben Roethlisberger is bad now because he's too skinny

He's bad now that he's skinny. He doesn't know how to operate without all that extra padding around him. He just drops back, and since he doesn't have that padding, he's used to defensive ends just hitting him and bouncing off him or just being absorbed by his fat.

Roethlisberger actually led the NFL in passing yards in 2018 with over 5,000, so he wasn't 'bad'.

We also have to address the elephant in the room: Patrick Mahomes. After a summer of the guys questioning if he was actually good, Mahomes went out and scorched the Chargers. Big Cat is a big enough man to admit when he’s dead wrong, even if it hurts his pride as much as the Rodgers comeback.

Win
Sep 10, 2018
#12667
Big CatBig Cat

I was wrong: Patrick Mahomes is electric and I'm a believer

One person that I do have to take back my take is Patrick Mahomes. I said Patrick Mahomes stinks and is going to be terrible... I will admit my mistakes. He's electric. No, I'm actually a believer in him now.

Mahomes won the MVP that season and became the face of the league.

Willie McGinest in Studio

Three-time Super Bowl champion Willie McGinest joined us to provide some actual football expertise and explain what it’s like to survive the Belichick regime. Willie didn't hold back on the "Patriot Way," explaining that it isn't for everyone—referencing guys like Reggie Wayne and Ocho Cinco who couldn't hack the culture of accountability. He also gave us the lowdown on the mysterious Ernie Adams, describing him as a CIA-level information collector who once predicted a gadget play so accurately it felt like magic.

Of course, we had to ask about the future of the TB12 Method and how much longer the bad man will be in the league. Willie has a very specific timeline for the GOAT.

Push
Sep 10, 2018
#12674
Willie McGinestWillie McGinest

Tom Brady will play three more years and win one more Super Bowl

Gun to your head, Tom Brady, how many more years does he play? Three. How many more Super Bowls does he win? One.

Brady played 5 more seasons (retired after 2022) and won 2 more Super Bowls (LIII with NE and LV with TB).

Willie also took a look at the current landscape, identifying the Chargers as his dark horse team for 2018, provided they can actually start a season with a winning record for once.

Win
Sep 10, 2018
#28307
Willie McGinestWillie McGinest

The Chargers are my dark horse team and they will make the playoffs if they start at least 2-2

Chargers... they're my dark horse this year. They've got to get off to a fast start. They've never done that in the history of that franchise... until I see them at least 2-2, then I'll be like, okay, they're going to the playoffs.

The Chargers started 2-2 and finished 12-4, making the playoffs as a Wild Card.

Talking Tennis and Hermatology

Outside of the gridiron, the US Open was pure chaos. Serena Williams had a legendary meltdown involving a chair umpire, a stolen point, and a smashed racket. While the internet was divided, Big Cat felt the theatrics were a bit much for someone who was already getting beat on the court.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Serena Williams was being a baby and stole the moment from Naomi Osaka

It felt to me like she was being a little bit of a baby and she was losing and wanted to kind of make a scene. And it sort of stole the moment from the person who actually did win, Naomi Osaka.

This is a subjective assessment of a sporting controversy.

In a shocking twist, Herm Edwards might actually be a good football coach. After Arizona State knocked off Michigan State, the guys are officially drinking the Herm-flavored Kool-Aid. The CEO approach is working, and the clock management was—dare we say—competent.

Push
Sep 10, 2018·Hermatology
#12678
Big CatBig Cat

I actually believe in Herm Edwards at Arizona State

We were very wrong about Herm Edwards. I can't believe I'm sitting here saying this, but I think I believe in Herm. Herm Edwards could recruit me.

Herm had a decent run at ASU (7-6, 8-5) before it fell apart due to recruiting violations and a losing 2021-2022 period.

We finished the show with a vital debate about the etiquette of watching football at a friend’s house. Big Cat has developed a scientific formula to determine if you are allowed to use a friend's bathroom for a major delivery based on distance and bathroom-to-guest ratios.

Void
Sep 10, 2018·Null
#12680
Big CatBig Cat

You can't take a shit at a friend's house if the bathroom is less than 30 'bathroom feet' away

It's actually a formula that you multiply the number of bathrooms times the feet from the couch to the bathroom. And if it's anything under 30, then you can't take a shit there. So if there's a bathroom 20 feet away from the couch, but there's only one bathroom in the whole house, you can't do it.

This is a social etiquette opinion.

If the bathroom is twenty feet from the couch and there are five people in the room, just hold it until you get home or find a gas station.

nflbearspatriotspatrick-mahomesserena-williamsherm-edwards

More Takes

Win
Sep 10, 2018
#12662
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens are going to win the AFC North

The Ravens do look like a good football team. John Harbaugh is a week one gangster. Yeah, they're going to win that division.

The Ravens did win the AFC North in 2018 with a 10-6 record.
Loss
Sep 10, 2018
#12664
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals are going to win the AFC North

Yeah, so my team that's going to win the [AFC] North, the Cincinnati Bengals... They have a ton of talent, and as long as Andy Dalton... Their color rush unis were fire.

The Bengals finished last in the AFC North in 2018 with a 6-10 record.
Loss
Sep 10, 2018
#12668
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will get a Patrick Mahomes tattoo if Big Cat eats horse poop

I'm going to get a Patrick Mahomes tattoo. You want to bet? You have to eat horse poop if I get a Mahomes tattoo?

Neither event happened.
Loss
Sep 10, 2018
#12670
Big CatBig Cat

Whoever loses Bears vs. Seahawks in Week 2 will miss the playoffs

Whoever loses that game is not going to make the playoffs. Can I just do it right now? Can I just say it's a win? You don't have to play it?

The Seahawks lost this game but actually made the playoffs as a Wild Card. The Bears won and also made the playoffs.
Loss
Sep 10, 2018
#12672
Willie McGinestWillie McGinest

Jeremy Hill will be the most physical running back in New England since Corey Dillon

[Jeremy] Hill, the new running back that they got in town. He's going to be the most physical running back in New England since Corey Dillon. Maybe even more physical.

Jeremy Hill tore his ACL in Week 1 of the 2018 season and never played for the Patriots again.
Void
Sep 10, 2018
#28308
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derwin James is the next Ed Reed and Sean Taylor 2.0

Derwin James, the new safety. He's going to be the next Ed Reed. I love him... He's Sean Taylor 2.0.

While James became an All-Pro as a rookie, comparing any rookie to Reed or Taylor is a subjective high bar.
Void
Sep 10, 2018
#28309
Willie McGinestWillie McGinest

Matt Ryan was a product of Kyle Shanahan's system

I think [Matt Ryan] was a product of Kyle Shanahan's system. How about that? He was 13-3, I believe, without Kyle Shanahan. He's top 10.

This is an ongoing debate in NFL circles regarding Ryan's efficiency drop-off after Shanahan left for San Francisco.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers