Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

CFB W/ Tom Fornelli and Andy Staples, Fyre Fest + Worst Mt Rushmore Ideas

Friday, August 30, 201912 takes

Football is Back (again). The Colts are bringing in the best backups and the NCAA is stupid. (-) Fyre Fest Of The Week (-) plus the Mt Rushmore of worst Mt Rushmore ideas. (-) CBS CFB writer Tom Fornelli joins the show to preview the season, tell us who is winning the Big Ten and a guaranteed lock of the week. (-) The Athletic's Andy Staples joins the show to talk SEC, his final four, and how crazy college boosters are. (-) Segments include embrace debate carli lloyd,(-) sabermetrics, (- ) talking soccer (-) and Jilly Football's exit interview.(-)

Tom Fornelli and Andy Staples on CFB Preview and the Final Mt Rushmore

Football is back for roughly the sixteenth time this month, and Big Cat is waking up with an extra pep in his step despite a Saturday slate that offers very little outside of Oregon vs. Auburn. While the guys are ready for the grind of the season, the NFL news cycle is still spinning from the Andrew Luck retirement. Big Cat and PFT are already looking at the long game regarding Luck's potential return to the field.

Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#5125
Big CatBig Cat

There is a 100% chance Andrew Luck plays another snap in the NFL

I'm going to say there's a hundred percent chance that Andrew Luck plays another snap in the NFL. Oh, that's good. You know, why because I can basically keep saying it for the next ten years.

Andrew Luck never played another snap in the NFL after his retirement in August 2019.

PFT is taking the opposite approach, citing some very specific, scientific reasons why the Colts' former franchise guy might stay on the sidelines forever.

Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#5126
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andrew Luck's shoulder failed to heal because Indianapolis was the first city to get 5G service

There is a doctor out there. He specializes in holistic medicine... He thinks that Andrew Luck shoulder didn't heal correctly because Indianapolis was the first city in the country to get 5G service. And he thinks that all the data swimming through that City interferes with the Regeneration of stem cells. Oh, so he thinks that Andrew Luck's his shoulder is actually never going to repair because of that.

There is no scientific evidence that 5G service interferes with stem cell regeneration or caused Andrew Luck's injuries.
Win
Aug 30, 2019
#25140
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

There is a 0% chance that Andrew Luck ever plays another snap in the NFL

I'm going to say 0% for Andrew Luck [playing again]. I just don't see it happening. One of us is going to be right. It's a zero-sum game here. It's either going to play again or he's not.

Andrew Luck remained retired and never played in the NFL again.

Before getting into the previews, Big Cat and PFT shared their weekly frustration with the NCAA. This week’s target is the ruling against Virginia Tech’s Brock Hoffman, who was denied a waiver to play despite moving closer to his mother who is recovering from brain surgery. Big Cat thinks there is a method to the madness of these heartless rulings.

Void
Aug 30, 2019
#5127
Big CatBig Cat

The NCAA intentionally picks unjust transfer stories to distract from their multi-billion dollar business

I actually think the NCAA depicts these stories specifically they're like, we need to find a way where everyone would think our ruling is completely unjust and bullshit rule that way. So everyone talks about that and not the fact that we make billions of dollars and you know, like extort everyone and and and basically run a entire corporation that is bullshit.

This is a subjective opinion on NCAA strategy, though the NCAA did eventually relax many transfer rules years later due to legal pressure.

College Football Preview with Tom Fornelli

Tom Fornelli joined the show to help sort through the Big Ten hype, specifically the noise surrounding Nebraska. Big Cat admitted he’s starting to drink the Kool-Aid on the Cornhuskers, mostly because of their dynamic quarterback.

Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#25141
Big CatBig Cat

Adrian Martinez will be a Heisman finalist and Nebraska will win the Big Ten West

Adrian Martinez is going to get invited to Manhattan. They're going to win the Big Ten West and it's going to be the 80s and 90s all over again.

Nebraska finished 5-7 and Martinez was not a Heisman finalist.

While they touched on the Big Ten West, the conversation shifted to whether Jim Harbaugh can finally get over the hump in Ann Arbor. Tom is high on the Wolverines modernizing their offense under Josh Gattis and thinks this is the year they finally break through the glass ceiling.

Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#25142
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Michigan will win the Big Ten and make the College Football Playoff

I have them [Michigan] winning the Big Ten though. I have them getting the playoff. So I do think it happens this year.

Michigan finished 9-4 and did not win the Big Ten or make the Playoff.
Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#25144
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Oklahoma will beat Alabama in the College Football Playoff semifinals

I think Oklahoma beats Alabama in a semi this year just because... I look at their problem last year that defense dipped off now they're losing one of their best defenders. Jalen Hurts revenge game, that would be great.

Alabama did not make the College Football Playoff in 2019.

Andy Staples on the SEC and National Titles

Andy Staples hopped on to provide the SEC perspective and immediately ruffled Big Cat's feathers by suggesting Wisconsin has reached its absolute peak as a program. According to Andy, even the best coaches in the country couldn't move the needle much further in Madison.

Void
Aug 30, 2019
#25145
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Wisconsin has hit their ceiling and will never win a national title

I think they have got Wisconsin at about as close to the ceiling as you can be. I just don't know with Wisconsin. When they were rolling 10-11 wins every year, I think that's the ceiling right there.

Subjective opinion on the historical trajectory of a program.
Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#25146
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Clemson will win the national title

I have Clemson, Alabama, Oklahoma and Ohio State [in the Final Four]. With Clemson winning a national title.

Clemson lost to LSU in the national championship game.

They also discussed the nightmare scenario for the Pac-12, which involves Larry Scott continuing to ruin the conference with 9:00 AM local kickoffs. Big Cat is convinced that there is only one man who can save the conference, and he’s currently working in a TV studio.

Loss
Aug 30, 2019
#25143
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer will eventually take the head coaching job at USC

I think the only thing that's going to fix [the Pac-12] is Urban Meyer's going to go coach USC. As soon as that begins the Urban Meyer talk will start in earnest and I think that it's too obvious for a reason because we've seen Meyer do this before.

Urban Meyer never coached USC; he eventually took the Jacksonville Jaguars job.

Mt Rushmore of Worst Mt Rushmore Ideas

To close out the summer, the guys did the Mt Rushmore of worst Mt Rushmore ideas—topics that would either get them canceled immediately or put the entire audience to sleep. Big Cat led off with "Racial Slurs," while PFT suggested "True facts about why vaccines are bad." It was a race to the bottom that included child abductions, the gender pay gap, and Big Cat's personal favorite: "Favorite porn creampie scenes."

Segments and Jilly Football's Exit

In a special Embrace Debate, the guys discussed Carli Lloyd's potential NFL tryout. Big Cat is fully on board, noting that women might actually be physically superior when it comes to the mechanics of placekicking.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Women are naturally designed to be football kickers

I think that women actually might have a natural advantage in their bodies when it comes to kicking because they don't have those clumsy testicles that you squish them. Sure when you kick true... They're probably designed to be kickers. I'm all for it. Let her kick Let her kick why not her.

There is no physiological evidence supporting this specific claim, and no woman has yet played as a kicker in the NFL.

They also touched on Sabermetrics, where PFT cited a study from a Twitter user named after the Geico Gecko to prove that quarterbacks usually peak in their seventh season.

Void
Aug 30, 2019·Sabermetrics
#5129
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 'Seven-Year Bump' for NFL quarterbacks is real

Somebody actually put the stats together out there... they found out that nineteen out of twenty two quarterbacks entering year 7 had a better touchdown per attempt percentage... everyone except for Jay Cutler had a better completion percentage... Basically the seven-year bump is real.

While statistical trends can be found for certain cohorts, 'the seven-year bump' is more of a show-specific narrative than a universally accepted football principle.

Finally, the show wrapped up with Jilly Football’s official exit interview. Jill discussed learning the ropes of Twitter, roasting the guys one last time, and her confusion over what exactly a "Carstick" is used for.

We'll see if Jill actually stays retired or if she pulls an Andrew Luck and comes back the second she smells a fresh batch of cookies.

college-footballnflandrew-luckncaamt-rushmore

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers