Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Colt McCoy, NFL Agent Sean Stellato, Eagles Lose On MNF, Rashard Mendenhall's Hypothetical + Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, December 20, 202319 takes

The Eagles lose to the Seahawks and Drew Lock finally has his moment. We talk MNF and what it means for the NFC playoff picture going forward (-). Rashard Mendenhall poses a hypothetical to twitter on an all black vs all white NFL game and everyone debates it (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including PMT getting cancelled yet again by the Swifties (-). Colt McCoy joins the show to talk about his career in the NFL, Texas being back, being a backup quarterback and more (-). We then are joined by Tommy Devito's agent Sean Stellato in studio on the day he's inducted into the Italian American Sports Hall of Fame to talk about his career, being Italian, Rocky, the book he wrote and more (-). We finish with guys on chicks (-).

Colt McCoy and Sean Stellato on Texas, the Tommy DeVito Craze, and MNF

Drew Lock is officially back, and the Eagles are officially in a tailspin. Monday Night Football gave us a classic backup quarterback redemption story as Lock led a game-winning drive that had Big Cat and PFT ready to strap on their backpacks and secure the bag. While Lock was emotional at the podium, Max was busy mourning the death of the Eagles' season from behind the glass.

The Eagles Funeral and Jalen Hurts' Slide

Max didn't hold back, declaring the season effectively over after Philly dropped their third straight game. The guys looked at the offense and realized that without Shane Steichen, things have become clunky and predictable. Big Cat even pointed out that the current offensive coordinator might be the best argument for Steichen's legacy.

Void
Dec 20, 2023
#22833
Big CatBig Cat

Shane Steichen should get Coach of the Year because of how bad the Eagles' offense looks without him

Shane Steichen actually should get coached of the year by virtue of how bad the Eagle's offense [is].

The Eagles' offense significantly regressed after Steichen left, while Steichen led the Colts to a winning season with a backup QB. This is a common sentiment among analysts.

The conversation then turned to the face of the franchise. Jalen Hurts looked sick in more ways than one, and Big Cat is officially jumping off the bandwagon. Hurts' turnovers are piling up, and the elite status he earned last year is starting to evaporate.

Void
Dec 20, 2023
#12082
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts is no longer a top five quarterback in the NFL

He's [Jalen Hurts] outta my top five. No longer Elite. Top five is as as follows. Mahomes, Allen, Purdy, Lamar, Burrow.

This is a subjective ranking of NFL QBs at a specific point in time.

PFT even questioned if the Eagles were ever actually the juggernaut we thought they were, or if they just took advantage of a lucky break in the NFC Championship last year. Between the coaching issues and the aging roster, Max believes the window is slamming shut.

Void
Dec 20, 2023
#22834
MaxMax

The coaching staff is ruining the Eagles' Super Bowl window

The window continued into this year, but the coaching has been fucking horrible. This was a window ruining year.

The Eagles collapsed at the end of the season and lost in the first round of the playoffs, leading to the firing of both coordinators. Max's frustration was vindicated.

Colt McCoy on Texas and Backup Life

Texas legend Colt McCoy joined the show to discuss the Longhorns' return to glory and the upcoming Sugar Bowl. Colt has a unique perspective on the program's evolution and what it takes to win in Austin. He’s also the guy who helped recruit Arch Manning, and he’s been preaching the gospel of patience to the young phenom.

Void
Dec 20, 2023
#12089
Colt McCoyColt McCoy

Redshirting was the best thing that ever happened to me in college

The best thing that ever happened to me was I redshirted and was able to sit in the meetings and be at practice and run Scout team the year that we won the National Championship in '05 with Vince Young... I've told [Arch Manning], I said the best thing that ever happened to me was Redshirting. I know it's not that cool to do and it sucks, especially in this day and age, but like I'm just telling you, it was the best thing that ever happened to me.

Personal reflection on his own career trajectory.

Colt broke down the matchup against Washington, noting that while the Huskies have elite weapons on the outside, he feels confident in Sarkisian’s squad. He also shared some incredible stories about his 14-year NFL career, including his legendary love for raw milk and the time a coach had to tell players to attend the starter's party instead of his.

Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#22838
Colt McCoyColt McCoy

Texas has the upper hand against Washington in the Sugar Bowl

I still like Texas with the upper hand. I think Texas is gonna have to play well, but I still, I still like Texas with the upper hand.

Washington defeated Texas 37-31 in the Sugar Bowl on January 1, 2024.

Sean Stellato: The Italian Stallion of Agents

In one of the most electric studio appearances in a while, Tommy DeVito’s agent Sean Stellato stopped by on the very day he was being inducted into the Italian American Sports Hall of Fame. Rocking a custom suit and shoes featuring the boat his ancestors took to America, Stellato leaned into the "slimy" comments from Peyton Manning with grace and grit. He’s a guy who truly lives the Rocky lifestyle, complete with 5:00 AM ocean plunges in Salem.

Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#12090
Sean StellatoSean Stellato

Tommy DeVito hasn't even scratched the surface of what he will become

I don't even think he's scratched what he will become. 'cause he's got a boulder of cutlets on his shoulder... I think he's a phenomenal player. He's comfortable now. And he's won the locker room.

DeVito's 2023 magic faded, and he spent much of 2024 as a backup, making this prediction look overly optimistic.

Stellato didn't just talk about "Tommy Cutlets." He put his reputation on the line for another client, EJ Perry, claiming the kid is a physical freak who belongs in the league. If Stellato says he can play, given his track record with DeVito, you have to listen.

Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#12091
Sean StellatoSean Stellato

EJ Perry is an absolute baller who should be in the NFL

This EJ Perry is an absolute baller, hits a golf ball 360 yards, 360 dunks, and he'll go on the whiteboard and do some Matt Damon stuff from Goodwill Hunting. I'm telling you, I earned a little validation on my assessment of talent and he's phenomenal.

EJ Perry has yet to see meaningful NFL action, spending time on practice squads and in the UFL.

Hot Seat, Cool Throne and the All-White Team

Rashard Mendenhall set the internet on fire this week by suggesting an All-Black vs. All-White NFL game to settle the debate once and for all. PFT immediately started crunching the numbers on the All-White secondary, realizing that while the tight end room is stacked, they might have to recruit Julian Edelman to play cornerback just to survive Tyreek Hill.

Void
Dec 20, 2023
#12084
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian McCaffrey is the best player in the NFL right now

Christian McCaffrey is so good at football. Yes. That he could make an all white team beat an all black team. He's literally the best player in the NFL right now.

McCaffrey won Offensive Player of the Year in 2023, lending significant weight to this claim, though 'best' is subjective vs Lamar Jackson's MVP.

Finally, the guys took aim at the Swifties again after being "canceled" for pointing out Taylor's use of the F-word. In a world where Big Cat and PFT are defenders of the shield, they made it clear that some things are sacred.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

There is no room for swearing in sports

I've never seen Mahomes swear. I've never seen him swear. Never. Not once. I've never seen a coach swear. There's no, there's no room for swearing in sports... What I'm trying to say is there's no place for swearing at a football game in the stands.

This is entirely satirical. Everyone knows football is full of swearing.

If you see a guy in a fedora eating 24 inches of subs this Sunday, just know he's living his best life.

nfleaglestexas-longhornstommy-devitocollege-footballseahawks

More Takes

Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#12080
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drew Lock will make four career Pro Bowls

Drew Lock. My, my take that he would make four Pro Bowls, which I said like four years ago, three years ago in this program. Now it's at an all time high. I think it's even higher than it was when I set it. Yeah. At the time to be more likely. He's probably not gonna do that, but it's closer than it was yesterday.

Drew Lock has 0 career Pro Bowls as of the 2024 season and is a backup for the Giants.
Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#22832
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks' season is officially saved after the win over the Eagles

Drew Lock, the Seahawks season is saved where now they are still like neck and neck where they're tied at seven and seven with the Vikings and the Rams and the Saints. Drew Lock having that moment, having everyone talking about him.

The Seahawks finished the season 9-8 and missed the playoffs. While the win kept them in the hunt, their season was ultimately not 'saved' in terms of postseason success.
Win
Dec 20, 2023
#12081
MaxMax

The Eagles will not be winning the Super Bowl this year

The Eagles will not be winning the Super Bowl this year.

The Eagles lost in the Wild Card round to the Buccaneers.
Void
Dec 20, 2023
#22835
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles might never have been good; they might have just benefited from playing a 49ers team with no quarterback in the NFC Championship

Do we need to go back and think like, were the Eagles ever actually really good? Or did they just beat a San Francisco team with no quarterback? They might never have been good.

This is a deliberately provocative and unfalsifiable hot take meant to troll Eagles fans.
Loss
Dec 20, 2023
#12083
Big CatBig Cat

The 2023 Super Bowl might have been Jalen Hurts' peak

What if the Super Bowl was Jalen Hurts' peak? It might've been. That's what I'm saying.

The 2023 Super Bowl was NOT Hurts' peak. Eagles won SB LIX (Feb 2025, beat Chiefs 40-22) and went 11-6 in 2025.
Void
Dec 20, 2023
#22836
Big CatBig Cat

Trevor Lawrence is starting to feel the heat as the media narrative shifts against him

Trevor Lawrence is starting to feel the heat. He is starting to get blind resumed a lot... Once you see the blind resumes, it's like uhoh, here comes the narrative changing, shifting on you. It's like the first sign.

The narrative around Lawrence has indeed become more critical as he hasn't yet reached the 'elite' tier many expected.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

No long-haired quarterback has ever won a Super Bowl

No long-haired quarterback has ever won a Super Bowl. People forget that.

Depends on the definition of 'long'. QBs like Joe Namath and Ken Stabler had shaggy hair, but true 'flow' like Lawrence is historically rare for winners.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Dylan Raiola is already a bust after his commitment poem

What is this? So fellow fans await with hope in the air for Dylan to choose his purpose to declare in a weekend's decision, destiny calls to fulfill his purpose. Where a new dynasty enthralls... He's already a bust in my eyes. I'm happy for Nebraska fans, but you can't be feeling good about that poem.

Raiola is a true freshman in 2024; his career is just beginning.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA In-Season Tournament should have one traveling banner instead of permanent ones

There should just be one banner. And the team that wins it should get to have it in their arena for the remainder of that year into next year where they have to give it up and another team then gets to possess that banner because you can't have every NBA team eventually having an in season tournament banners.

This is a suggestion for league policy, inherently subjective.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Syracuse football is having the best off-season in all of college football

My Cool Throne is my alma mater. Syracuse football. They are having arguably the best off-season in all of college football. Almost... in my book.

Purely subjective comparison of transfer portal and coaching successes.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers