Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Former Alabama QB And National Champion Greg McElroy

Friday, September 1, 201721 takes

REAL Football is officially back. College Football talk and Tiger Woods is swinging a golf club again ( - ) . Kyrie Irving trade has been finalized ( - ). The end of Mt Rushmore season with the Mt Rushmore of things we'll miss about the summer ( - ). Former Alabama Starting QB and National Champion joins the show to talk about playing for Nick Saban, his career with the Jets, Rex, Tim Tebow, and the upcoming college football season ( - ). Segments include Uhhh Ya Think for Big Baller Brand, Pussification of America for England, Connect the Dots, Thats too much internet for today, and Jimbos of the week

Greg McElroy on Saban’s Smile, the Jets’ QB Room, and 2017 SEC Predictions

September is finally here, which means real football has arrived and Big Cat is officially back to licking his lips in anticipation of 70-degree weather. While the end of summer is always a tragedy, it marks the return of the only thing that matters: the gridiron. PFT is already leading the charge on the seasonal shift, even if the calendar hasn't officially flipped yet.

Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6235
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Fall starts when August ends

This is what I consider to be the start of fall. I'm a big September 21st truther. I think that fall starts when August ends.

Fall astronomical start is usually September 21-23.

The guys are looking ahead to the massive opening weekend, including Ohio State's trip to Bloomington. Big Cat isn't even entertaining the idea of an upset, putting his full confidence behind the Buckeyes in a way that will almost certainly end up on a freezing cold takes account later tonight.

Win
Sep 1, 2017
#6236
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State has a 0% chance of losing to Indiana

I said, nope, I'm just going to say it on the show. There's a 0% chance Ohio State loses this game [to Indiana]. So now if it happens, it'll be funny.

Ohio State won the game 49-21 on August 31, 2017.

The National Champion Greg McElroy

Former Alabama quarterback and national champion Greg McElroy joined the show to give us a peek behind the curtain of the Nick Saban machine. Having played for both Saban and Rex Ryan, McElroy has seen the polar opposites of the coaching spectrum. He confirmed our suspicions about Saban's legendary inability to enjoy anything, even a championship win.

Win
Sep 1, 2017
#6241
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Nick Saban smiles for less than two minutes after winning a national championship

Oh, fellas, you said two minutes. I'd take the under. I really would. That's a lock of the decade. Because even after we won the national championship, in the locker room, not kidding, we have the crystal ball in hand... He went into the locker room and said, 'hey, guys, great job... you know that's not how we play in the second half.'

Anecdotal but widely corroborated by other former Alabama players.

McElroy was refreshingly honest about his own career, acknowledging that his Bama tenure was defined more by the elite talent around him than his own arm talent. He even went so far as to admit that the 2010 Crimson Tide would have been in serious trouble against Texas if a certain star quarterback hadn't gone down early in the Rose Bowl.

Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6242
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Alabama would have lost by 40 points to Texas in 2010 if Colt McCoy didn't get hurt

I think we would have lost by at least 40. It's in large part, too, because if you guys have been to the Rose Bowl in January, it's that humidity. It's the humidity in the air that gets you, and I'm just not sure we were conditioned well enough to hang if Colt didn't get hurt.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
This is a hyperbolic hypothetical. Alabama won the game 37-21; a 40-point swing is clearly an intended joke.
Win
Sep 1, 2017
#22637
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

I was carried by my defense while playing quarterback at Alabama

The national championship ring still meant something because I knew that I was carried by my defense, so just being a good teammate was a big part of what I wanted to do that year.

The 2009 Alabama defense was historically elite, allowing only 11.7 points per game. McElroy was a solid game manager, but the defense was the primary engine.

After his time in Tuscaloosa, McElroy found himself in the middle of the most chaotic quarterback room in NFL history: the 2012 New York Jets. He broke down the dynamic between himself, Mark Sanchez, and Tim Tebow, noting that while they were thick as thieves, the body fat percentages in that room were vastly different. Despite the butt fumbles and the circus atmosphere, McElroy still sees hope for the future of the position, pointing toward a specific rookie class that he thinks will buck the recent trend of poor quarterback play.

Push
Sep 1, 2017
#6243
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson will be part of a 'sneaky good' QB class

I have a feeling this year's class... Pat Mahomes, Mitch Trubisky, Deshaun Watson, and even DeShone Kizer, all four have a chance to be sneaky good, I think, in the NFL. So maybe that trend's reversing back a little bit.

Mahomes and Watson became elite stars. Trubisky was a bust/journeyman and Kizer was out of the league quickly. Overall, the class was indeed legendary due to the top two.

SEC Stakes and Season Previews

Looking ahead to the college season, McElroy isn't just a Bama homer. He’s keeping a close eye on the rest of the SEC and some dark horses out west. While everyone is penciling in the usual suspects for the Playoff, Greg thinks there is a team in the Pac-12 that is being criminally overlooked.

Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6245
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Stanford is a surprise playoff contender for 2017

Watch out for Stanford... Bryce Love is a kid who is really, really talented... Stanford is a team that nobody's really talking about right now... they could be sitting there at 10 wins, 11 wins near season's end and on the cusp of a potential playoff berth.

Stanford finished 9-5 and lost the Pac-12 Championship, missing the playoff.

As for the SEC, he’s not convinced the conference is as deep as the media would have you believe. He's fading the depth of the conference at the top, though he does have a clear favorite if Saban's squad somehow slips up.

Push
Sep 1, 2017
#6244
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Auburn is the team to beat in the SEC if Alabama falters

If Alabama does not win the SEC title, what team does? Auburn. This guy, Jared Stidham, is the real deal by all accounts... Auburn offensively is going to be significantly improved.

Auburn did win the SEC West but lost to Georgia in the SEC Championship game.
Win
Sep 1, 2017
#6246
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Under 4.5 SEC teams will finish in the AP Top 10

Over, under, four and a half [SEC] teams in the top 10 at the end of the season? I'm going to lean towards the under... I'm going to jump wholeheartedly on the under four and a half teams in the top ten.

The final AP Top 10 featured only three SEC teams (Alabama, Georgia, Auburn).

Mount Rushmore of Things We’ll Miss About Summer

It was a somber moment in the studio as the guys completed the final Mount Rushmore of the season. The snake draft covered everything from outdoor showers to the smell of sunscreen. Hank tried to pander to the audience by drafting Billy Football, while Bubba decided to use his platform to voice a truly insane opinion regarding men’s fashion.

Void
Sep 1, 2017·Mt. Rushmore
#6240
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

Men should cover up their legs and never wear shorts

Hot take. The once and future king of Mount Rushmore season, shorts. Cool take. I kind of hate shorts. I think men should cover up their legs.

This is a subjective fashion opinion.

We also checked in on the Kyrie Irving trade finalization, which led to a discussion on Dan Gilbert’s business acumen and LeBron James’ reputation as a teammate. Big Cat and PFT are convinced that the Cavaliers essentially won twice: once in the trade and once by getting Dan Gilbert’s son back on national television with his bow tie.

Void
Sep 1, 2017
#22636
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

LeBron James is the biggest dickhead to play with of all time

Basically saying LeBron James is the biggest dickhead to play with of all time. So [Kyrie] can't maximize himself in Cleveland, right?

Whether LeBron is a difficult teammate is entirely subjective and a matter of persistent debate in NBA media.

To wrap things up, we hit Jimbos of the week, featuring a graduate who learned the hard way that you cannot trip acid and expect to keep up with current college students. Bubba summed it up perfectly: youth is the ultimate unfair advantage in the partying world.

Void
Sep 1, 2017·Jimbos
#22640
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

Being young is a performance-enhancing drug for partying

Being younger is like a PED for partying. If you meet someone who's under 25 years old, cross the street. Yes, go far away.

Biological factors generally support the idea that younger individuals recover faster and have more stamina for social activities involving alcohol.

Football is officially back, so go buy a new phone and spend the weekend alone with it on the couch.

nflcollege-footballalabamajetsmount-rushmoretiger-woods

More Takes

Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6237
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

Nick Saban would score 100 points on Lane Kiffin if they played

He's [Saban] not playing against Lane Kiffin. So make that 10-1. Saban would probably go like, he'd put up a 100 burger.

OpinionCFBHotSarcastic
While they played several times, Saban never put up 100 points on Kiffin.
Void
Sep 1, 2017
#6238
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL players should lose their Twitter checkmark if they get cut

They cut him before it was over, but he gets to keep the jersey picture, but I say that you should lose your checkmark. The NFL's a checkmark league.

This is a subjective opinion on social media policy.
Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6239
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tiger Woods should only play par-3 courses to save his back

He needs to revamp his whole game a little bit because once he starts getting above a five iron is when his spinal column collapses like a termite mound. So he needs to just go to par three courses.

OpinionGolfMediumSarcastic
Tiger eventually won the Masters in 2019, proving he could still play full courses.
Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#22635
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Gilbert and the Cavaliers fleeced Danny Ainge and the Celtics in the Kyrie Irving trade

Dan Gilbert fleeced Danny Ainge. No. They [Cavaliers] fleece themselves. Congratulations. I was about to say, the world is off its axis if Dan Gilbert's smarter than Danny Ainge.

The trade is generally viewed as a win for the Celtics; Kyrie was a star in Boston (initially) while Isaiah Thomas never recovered his form and the draft pick (Sexton) didn't elevate Cleveland to the same degree.
Void
Sep 1, 2017
#22638
Big CatBig Cat

The quarterback position in the NFL has never been worse

It feels like the quarterback position in the NFL has never been worse in some ways, and these guys are somehow getting more money than ever.

This is a subjective assessment of league-wide talent that changes year to year based on individual performance and incoming draft classes.
Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#22639
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Georgia is a year away from being a serious contender

I think Georgia's like a year away. Because Georgia... they're still a little bit young in the trenches offensively. Defensively, they're really, really good. But I think their offense is about a year away up front.

Georgia was far from a year away; they went 13-2 and were one play away from winning the National Championship in the 2017 season.
Loss
Sep 1, 2017
#6247
Big CatBig Cat

The New York Jets will win fewer than four games

Are you on board there? Under four [wins for the Jets]? Agreed.

The 2017 Jets exceeded expectations and finished with 5 wins.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NCAA will investigate LaMelo Ball for selling shoes

Yes, this is going to pique their [NCAA] interest a little. If you take any dollar out of the NCAA's pockets, they will come down on you. So yes, I think the NCAA will look into this.

LaMelo eventually lost his NCAA eligibility and played overseas before the NBA.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A-Rod is attempting to transform Jennifer Lopez into himself

I think A-Rod is trying to turn J-Lo into himself. Because we all know that he loves himself... recently she's been doing a lot of workouts with him in the gym.

This is a comedic theory about celebrity relationship dynamics.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers