Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Joe Buck

Wednesday, July 12, 201715 takes

The guys are still in Miami, dying of heat exhaustion, and spending their off time living with a ghost. Recap of the 2017 ASG that didn't mean anything and the Home Run Derby that was awesome (-). We have an official Ghost diagnosis from a Paranormal Investigator and it turns out we are in fact haunted (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne (-). Joe Buck joins the show to talk about calling 2 of the craziest games in sports in the past year (Cubs World Series and Patriots Super Bowl Comeback), whether or not he's been thinking about Big Cat every time the camera zooms in on his face, why we should all stick to sports, and the Mt Rushmore of Voices (-). Segments include Mayweather/McGregor update (-), Put one in his earhole Nelson Cruz and Joe West(-), Stay Woke the Freeze lost his foot race but was it actually the Freeze and is Jeffery Loria counting fake attendance (-), and a Cease and Desist to Mark Cuban (-).

Joe Buck on the Cubs, Super Bowl LI, and the Mt. Rushmore of Voices

Big Cat and PFT are still rotting away in the Miami humidity, and the heat exhaustion is clearly starting to set in. After surviving the Home Run Derby and a fairly lackluster All-Star Game, the guys are convinced their hotel suite is haunted by an "intelligent spirit" that enjoys smashing wine glasses and overturning lamps. Between the paranormal activity and the suffocating air, Miami has officially broken Big Cat, who spent the opening of the show detailing his failed attempts to purchase a ghost in a shoebox.

All-Star Recap and Aaron Judge

The All-Star Game might have been a bit of a snooze, but the Home Run Derby lived up to the hype, largely thanks to Aaron Judge. Big Cat was left speechless by the sheer physics of Judge’s performance, watching him launch balls off the roof with minimal effort.

Void
Jul 12, 2017
#17752
Big CatBig Cat

I have never been as wowed by home runs as I was watching Aaron Judge at the Derby

I have never been wowed by home runs like I was... Aaron Judge's home runs made me just sit there like holy shit. How can a human being look so effortless and hit the ball 500 feet?

Subjective opinion on how impressive the performance was.

While the world is ready to crown Judge the new face of baseball, PFT is naturally looking for the football angle. He’s convinced that Judge’s physical stature will eventually cause a problem for the MLB because he simply looks too much like a tight end.

Loss
Jul 12, 2017
#17753
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Judge's height will eventually drive him toward playing football

With Aaron Judge, the thing about him is he could be the face of baseball. His problem is he's too tall. I'll tell you why. He is a guy that once he starts having a lot of success in a sport that's maybe not as athletic as some other sports, people will be like, why didn't you play football? And then he'll start talking about football. All roads lead back to football.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Aaron Judge has remained exclusively a baseball player and has become one of the greatest of his generation, never pursuing a football career.

With Producer Hank away in Boston, Producer Tom stepped into the hot seat for a trial run. He brought a heavy dose of negativity to the Yankees' new star, suggesting that the Derby curse is already looming over Judge’s second half.

Push
TomTom

Winning the Home Run Derby will mess up Aaron Judge's swing

I'm going Aaron Judge's swing. Because everyone knows the home run derby, whoever wins it, it messes up their swing. It absolutely does... He was on track to win Rookie of the Year, maybe Triple Crown, but watch out. I already saw chitter chatter on Twitter that watched out for his swing.

While Judge did have a slump in August 2017 (.179 average), he recovered to hit 15 home runs in September and finished as the unanimous Rookie of the Year and MVP runner-up.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hot Seat/Cool Throne took a dark turn toward the avian world as PFT aired his grievances with the Audubon Society. Apparently, things are looking grim for our feathered friends out West, though PFT remains skeptical of their motives.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Birds in the Western US are facing mass extinction due to declining water habitats

My hot seat is birds... A report came out from the Audubon Society... water and birds in the arid west... it's a problem. Habitats are in decline because water's going away. And so birds are going to face like a mass extinction out in the Western part of America.

Scientific reports from 2017 did highlight these risks for avian populations in the West.

Big Cat, never one to let a conspiracy die, doubled down with a grim prediction for the future of biodiversity. According to him, the pigeon is the ultimate survivor.

Open
Big CatBig Cat

Pigeons will eventually be the only birds left on Earth

The world is going to end up in a place where the pigeons are the king birds and they're the only birds left. It's going to be in like 100 years, it will just be birds are just pigeons.

PredictionLifeMediumSarcastic
Hyperbolic prediction for 100 years in the future.

In a rare moment of political commentary—which the guys immediately followed with a "stick to sports" chant—Big Cat touched on the constant cycle of Trump controversies. He’s noticed a pattern where every new headline is touted as "the one" only to fade into the background 24 hours later.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

No specific controversy will ever be enough to bring down the Trump family

People who think this is the controversy to bring down the Trumps, because my favorite part about whatever the Trumps are getting into the entire family is the reaction saying this is it. This is the one. And guess what? This probably isn't the one, so you only have about 24 hours to say it's the one until everyone's like, eh, nothing's probably going to happen.

The Trump presidency lasted its full term despite numerous controversies that media outlets labeled as 'the one' to end it.

Joe Buck in the Haunted Suite

Joe Buck joined the show in the middle of a literal ghost investigation to discuss calling two of the most iconic games in sports history back-to-back: the Cubs winning the World Series and the Patriots’ 28-3 comeback. Joe was surprisingly candid about the logistics of the new MLB home-field advantage rules, which abandoned the "This Time It Counts" format.

Win
Jul 12, 2017
#28432
Joe BuckJoe Buck

Determining MLB World Series home field by regular season record is logistically difficult

Now they're going to go for the first time to whichever team has the best record gets to host the World Series... But that could be determined literally the day before the World Series begins if there are any rain outs... everybody has to pick up and scramble to the American League city. I don't see how that works out.

The logistical challenges are a factual reality for the league office, though the system has since been implemented.

Big Cat, ever the problem solver, offered a much simpler solution that would keep the league pride intact without the travel headaches.

Void
Jul 12, 2017
#17756
Big CatBig Cat

The MLB should determine World Series home field by interleague play record

What they should do is whichever AL NL, whoever has a better record in interleague play. Boom. Problem solved. There's a little National League versus American League pride now.

The MLB opted for individual team record instead of league-wide interleague record.

Reflecting on the Cubs' historic win, Joe admitted that the weather might have played a larger role in the outcome than anyone wanted to admit at the time. He noted the visible panic in the Cubs' dugout before the clouds opened up.

Void
Jul 12, 2017
#28433
Joe BuckJoe Buck

The Cubs might not have won the 2016 World Series without the Game 7 rain delay

I actually don't [think they win if the rain delay didn't happen]. They had that look in the dugout... Aroldis Chapman pitched the most impressive inning I've ever seen after blowing it in the eighth... It's impossible to know the answer to that question, but I think they had the right guys coming up.

This is a counterfactual that can never be proven.

Looking ahead, Joe didn't shy away from making a big prediction for the 2017 Fall Classic, seeing a collision course between two powerhouses.

Win
Jul 12, 2017
#17757
Joe BuckJoe Buck

The Houston Astros and LA Dodgers are on a crash course for the 2017 World Series

Probably the Astros from Houston. I think the Astros are really good. I think the Dodgers are really good. I think they're on a crash course for the fall classic.

The Astros and Dodgers did indeed face each other in the 2017 World Series.

Joe also offered some veteran advice to Tony Romo, who is about to make the jump from the field to the lead booth at CBS. According to Joe, the transition is much harder than it looks, especially when the honeymoon phase ends and you actually have to be critical of your former peers.

Loss
Jul 12, 2017
#17758
Joe BuckJoe Buck

Tony Romo will struggle with the transition to sports broadcasting

I think he and the world is going to be surprised at what this job demands. Let's just say that you can't be nice all the time. Tony Romo is a nice guy... I think it's going to be a difficult transition. This is not the most forgiving society we live in these days.

Tony Romo was an immediate critical and fan success in his first year, widely praised for his ability to predict plays before they happened.

Before letting him go, the guys asked Joe about the Tim Tebow experiment with the Mets. While most see it as a circus, Joe recognizes the pure TV gravity that Tebow brings every time he steps into a batter's box.

Push
Jul 12, 2017
#28436
Joe BuckJoe Buck

Tim Tebow will be a massive TV draw if he's called up by the Mets

I think there are a handful of guys that when they come to the plate, whatever you're doing, you're not going to leave the television. And he will be that guy for the New York Mets... If he succeeds, it'll be unbelievable to me.

Tebow was indeed a massive draw in the minors, though he never made the major league roster.

Mayweather-McGregor and Stay Woke

The show wrapped up with a look at the Mayweather-McGregor press tour. Big Cat noted that while Floyd is the superior boxer, he is completely outclassed in the psychological warfare department when up against a fast-talking Irishman.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Floyd Mayweather is overmatched by Conor McGregor in trash talking

Mayweather for the first time in his life is very clearly overmatched in the shit talking game. So he's been known as a good shit talker but in reality he's just been like i'm gonna beat the fuck out of this guy... McGregor has that where basically anything McGregor says is funny because it's Irish.

While McGregor had many viral moments, the consensus on who 'won' the press conferences varied, and Mayweather ultimately won the fight comfortably.

Finally, the guys shared their biggest takeaway from Marlins Park. After being kicked off the Wi-Fi every ten minutes, Big Cat has a theory on how Jeffrey Loria is inflating those attendance numbers.

Loss
Jul 12, 2017·Stay Woke
#17760
Big CatBig Cat

The Marlins fake their attendance numbers using Wi-Fi logins

I bet the Marlins do their attendance based on how many people log into the Wi-Fi every night. It kept on kicking us out like every 10 minutes, and then it would just come right back on. I bet the Marlins count it as like 50 people... every single person counts for like 15.

Hot TakeBaseballFireSarcastic
While teams often inflate attendance numbers, there is no evidence the Marlins used Wi-Fi login cycles as a specific counting metric.

Hopefully, the ghost doesn't follow the guys back to New York.

mlb-all-star-gamecubsnfljoe-bucktony-romoghosts

More Takes

Void
Jul 12, 2017
#28431
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The MLB All-Star Game sucks because the teams don't have enough time to haze each other

The my theory as to why the All-Star game sucks is that the teams don't have enough time to haze each other so there's no team building before the game starts. You don't get to like tape a guy to a wall... there's not enough buy-in on the team.

This is a subjective comedic opinion on team chemistry.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers