Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Joe Flacco, Falcons Win A Thriller, Playoff Baseball And Pete Alonso Heroics + NFL Week 5 Picks And Preview

Friday, October 4, 202419 takes

Thursday Night Football was awesome for a change and Kirk Cousins is back (-). Pete Alonso saves the Mets season and playoff baseball absolutely rocks (-). We do a quick impromptu Mt Rushmore of Months (-). NFL Week 5 picks and preview for every game on Sunday + Fantasy Lad Boys (-). Colts QB Joe Flacco joins the show to talk about his game in relief Sunday, bonuses he doesn't even know about, the Browns not offering him a contract and more (-). We finish with Fyre Fest of the week (-).

Joe Flacco on Elite Longevity, Kirk Tober, and Playoff Baseball Chaos

October has officially arrived, and Big Cat and PFT are buzzing after a Thursday night that gave us everything. Kirk Cousins turned back the clock for 509 yards in an absolute thriller against the Bucs, while Pete Alonso potentially saved the Mets’ entire franchise trajectory with one swing in Milwaukee. PFT thinks the Falcons have officially inherited the chaos DNA of a certain NFC West team.

Win
Oct 4, 2024
#4904
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons have become the new Seattle Seahawks

The Falcons have become the Seahawks. Everything that the Seahawks have been for the last 10 years, I feel like that's, it's just utter chaos. Anytime the Falcons take the field, their last four games have been all insane.

The Falcons did have a string of extremely close games early in the 2024 season, including two one-point games and an overtime win.

While Kirk was doing his best Taylor Swift surfing dance on the field, Mike Evans was quietly putting together another masterclass. Big Cat is ready to start measurements for a gold jacket for Evans, who continues to be the most underrated consistent force in football.

Open
Oct 4, 2024
#4905
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Evans is a lock for the Hall of Fame and could finish top five all-time in touchdowns

Mike Evans... is gonna go down like top five six in touchdowns and receiving yards. He's just so consistently awesome. Mike Evans deserves all the credit in that respect.

Evans hit 100 TDs in this game. To reach the top 5, he needs 129 (currently Marvin Harrison is 5th at 128). He is on pace to get close if he plays 3-4 more years.

Playoff Baseball and Team of Destiny Vibes

Moving over to the diamond, the Mets are doing things that don't make sense to anyone except those who believe in magic. Pete Alonso was one strikeout away from being a pariah in Queens, and now he's the king of the city. Big Cat is convinced that regardless of the payroll, this group has that special something you can't buy.

Win
Oct 4, 2024
#24928
Big CatBig Cat

The Mets have undeniable 'Team of Destiny' vibes

I know the Tigers are also, they're the AL team of Destiny, but the Mets, the way they keep winning games is ridiculous. ... They undoubtedly have Team of Destiny vibes.

The Mets did have a deep run, reaching the NLCS, which validates the 'Team of Destiny' sentiment for 2024.

This doesn't bode well for Max, who is already in a state of pre-emptive mourning for the Phillies. Watching Max talk himself into a loss is a spectacle of its own, leading Big Cat to diagnose him with a specific condition shared by a certain New York sports legend.

Void
Oct 4, 2024
#24929
Big CatBig Cat

Max's pessimistic Phillies-Mets prediction is 'early onset Fleming'

There's gonna be multiple moments where like you and [Frank the Tank] are doing the same thing. And, we can be like Yeah. Early onset Fleming.

Subjective comparison of fan misery levels.

Max even went as far as to map out the exact heartbreaking sequence of a five-game series loss, proving that nobody hates their own team's success quite like a Philly fan who smells a threat.

Push
Oct 4, 2024
#4907
MaxMax

The Phillies will lose to the Mets in five games

I mean, it's, it's going to go five. The Phillies are gonna go up 2-1. I'm going be comfortable... then the Mets are gonna have a heroic comeback in game four and then game five, they're just gonna smoke us and it's gonna be, it'll be like 4-0 Mets in game five. That's how it's gonna go.

The Mets did win the series 3-1, not in 5 games, so Max's specific scenario of a Game 5 blowout was incorrect, though he correctly predicted the Phillies losing.

Mount Rushmore of Months

With the calendar turning, the guys did a quick impromptu Mount Rushmore of months. Big Cat didn't overthink it, taking the month where every sport is happening at once as his top pick.

Void
Oct 4, 2024·Mt. Rushmore
#4908
Big CatBig Cat

October is the clear 1.1 pick for best sports month

I'll take October first... October's one one... October's so good. October has, I've become everything. I've become more of an October boy.

This is entirely subjective.

While Big Cat focused on sports, Hank went for the vibes, arguing that the true start of summer is the only weekend that matters.

Void
Oct 4, 2024·Mt. Rushmore
#4909
HankHank

Memorial Day is the best weekend of the year

Memorial Day weekend's the best is the best weekend of the year. Hank knows start of the summer.

Subjective opinion on holidays.

NFL Week 5 Picks and Preview

As we look toward Sunday, the London game features a red-hot Sam Darnold taking on a Jets team that is currently vibrating with dysfunction. Between 'Cadence-gate' and Robert Saleh and Aaron Rodgers definitely not hugging, things are tense. Memes is fully on board the Vikings train, even if it means crowning them as the kings of the league.

Win
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4910
MemesMemes

The Vikings are the best team in the NFL and will beat the Jets in London

The Vikings are the best team in the NFL... Sam Darnold potential revenge game. ... But it's a bounce back. There won't be any rain [in London].

The Vikings beat the Jets 23-17 in London.

Big Cat is also looking at the Bears' upcoming stretch as the defining moment for Caleb Williams and Matt Eberflus. It starts with a revenge game against Andy Dalton and the Panthers, and for Big Cat, there is no room for error.

Win
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4914
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears season is over if they go worse than 3-2 in their next five games

The Bears next five games... If they go four in one, it's playoffs. If they go three and two, it's maybe playoffs... Anything worse than three and two? It's on to next year.

The Bears went 2-3 in their next five games (Wins vs Panthers, Jaguars; Losses vs Commanders, Cardinals, Patriots). Based on Big Cat's criteria, the season is officially 'on to next year.'

Joe Flacco Joins the Show

Our good friend and elite quarterback Joe Flacco called in from the carpool lane while waiting for his kids to get out of school. He talked about the adrenaline of coming off the bench for the Colts, his lack of knowledge regarding his own contract incentives, and why the Browns didn't even offer him a contract this offseason. At 39, Flacco is still slinging it, and he’s not looking at the exit ramp just yet.

Open
Oct 4, 2024
#4916
Joe FlaccoJoe Flacco

I want to play in the NFL until I'm 45

I wanna play as long as I possibly can... at 45 [my kids] would be in high school. I, I'd love to say I'd still be playing at that point. But, you know, the situation might have to be exactly right.

Flacco is currently 39. Whether he plays until 45 is a long-term prediction.

He also took a trip down memory lane regarding his time in Baltimore, specifically those legendary night games where the wardrobe choice did half the work before the first snap.

Win
Oct 4, 2024
#4917
Joe FlaccoJoe Flacco

Wearing all-black uniforms at night in Baltimore provides an extra confidence boost

There was something about it, man, when you showed up, when you had the black jersey in your locker and it was a big game. You're like, it gave you that little extra like, nudge of confidence... we're definitely winning.

Flacco is describing his personal feeling and team sentiment, which is an internal 'truth' for him.

We wrapped things up with a Fyre Fest of the week where Hank admitted he's a closet hoarder and PFT lived in fear that his car's mechanical failure was actually just him forgetting how gas works.

Just remember, if the Bears lose to a ginger who doesn't sweat, the season is officially on the brink.

nflmlb-playoffskirk-cousinsjoe-flaccobearsmets

More Takes

Win
Oct 4, 2024
#4906
Big CatBig Cat

Pete Alonso will definitely be back with the Mets next year after his heroics

[Pete Alonso] strikes out there and he's definitely not a Met next year. And now I feel like you can't, you have to give him all the money.

Pete Alonso did re-sign with the Mets, agreeing to a 2-year, $54 million deal for the 2025 season. Big Cat's prediction that the Mets had to bring him back after his playoff heroics was correct.
Win
Oct 4, 2024
#24930
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Travis Hunter is the Heisman Trophy winner

I'm gonna be watching the Padres play baseball. Yeah. And I'm gonna be like, you know what? That future, I cashed out on him. I'm actually happy that I did, because I invested it. I made money. Now I'm rolling that over. Invest in Travis Hunter. ... He's the Heisman Trophy winner.

Travis Hunter won the 2024 Heisman Trophy, beating out Ashton Jeanty, Dillon Gabriel, and Cam Ward.
Void
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4911
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Jefferson is the best wide receiver in the league and it's not close

Justin Jefferson is the best wide receiver in the league and it's not close. I agree. I know that not close is a stupid thing to say. He has scored in every single game this year. He's so goddamn good that it's, to me it's not close right now.

This is subjective, but Jefferson leads most statistical categories and expert rankings.
Open
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4912
Big CatBig Cat

Derrick Henry might be the last running back to reach 10,000 career yards

Derrick Henry is 17, 18 yards away from 10,000 yards. He could be the last running back we see get 10,000 yards. ... The only answer that I'm looking at ... is possibly Jonathan Taylor. 'cause he's got, he's halfway there.

Henry surpassed 10k yards later in the season. Whether he is the 'last' remains a long-term prediction.
Loss
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#24931
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels is already thinking about Super Bowls with the Commanders

I'm sorry. I don't like thinking about the Super Bowls with Jayden. My bad.

The Commanders had a great season but did not win the Super Bowl in 2024.
Loss
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4913
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Doug Pederson will be fired mid-season by the Jaguars

I do think that Doug is gonna be gone during the season. I think he might be a mid-season firing then.

Doug Pederson was not fired mid-season. He was fired on January 6, 2025 (Black Monday), one day after the Jaguars' 4-13 season ended. He lasted the entire season.
Win
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#24932
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears vs Panthers game is a 'must-win' for Chicago

Must win. Must win for the Bears. I'm I'm, I'm not going to waver on that. If on Sunday night the Bears lose ... I'm gonna be very upset.

The Bears won 36-10.
Loss
Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#4915
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins should start tanking for the #1 overall pick

The only team that I could say confidently that should tank as of right now is Miami Dolphins. Yeah. I think that's the only team I would say you should tank. 'cause you're gonna need a sit... because Tua, you can't, you can't say that he's gonna go through a whole season.

The Dolphins did not tank; they welcomed Tua back and continued to try and win games.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers