Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Nate Bargatze In Studio, Zach Wilson Disaster Class, CFB And The Return Of Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, November 8, 202315 takes

The world is ready to stop watching the Jets on MNF. We talk Monday Night Football, JMU's big win over Mich State and more (-). We then talk CFB, Alabama is back, the latest on Michigan, Bedlam Finale (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Craig Counsell to the Cubs and new Stella Blue Holiday Blends (-). Comedian Nate Bargatze joins the show in studio to talk comedy, his wild last 2 weeks, the art of joke writing, Vanderbilt football and being a suffering fan and tons more (-). We finish with the return of guys on chicks (-).

Nate Bargatze on SNL, the Jets' Disaster, and College Football Chaos

It is officially time to have a serious conversation about the New York Jets. Watching Zach Wilson in primetime has become a form of torture that the Geneva Convention probably missed. The defense is elite, the special teams are solid, and the quarterback is out there running backwards like he's trying to find a portal back to 2020. PFT didn't hold back on the solution for a team that is wasting an all-time defensive unit.

Void
Nov 8, 2023
#18283
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Josh Dobbs with zero practice reps would be a better fit for the Jets offense than Zach Wilson

Honestly, I think if they had Josh Dobbs at quarterback, they could figure it out. Josh Dobbs with zero practice reps is probably a better fit for that offense than Zach Wilson is.

While subjective, Dobbs performed well for the Vikings shortly after arriving without practice, while Wilson continued to struggle for the Jets.

Memes, as the resident Jets representative, went radio silent during the game, allegedly because he "lost his password." When he finally surfaced, the level of delusion was through the roof as he tried to defend his previous rankings.

Loss
Nov 8, 2023
#22854
MemesMemes

The Jets are the second-best team in the NFC

NFC standings took a hit [this week]. I put Lions one, Jets two, 49ers three, Seahawks four, Eagles five.

The Jets play in the AFC, not the NFC, and they finished the 2023 season 7-10, nowhere near the top of any power rankings.

While Zach Wilson is struggling to find the end zone, Aaron Rodgers is busy throwing passes in pre-game warmups just to make sure every camera in the building sees him. It’s the ultimate Rodgers move: staying in the spotlight without having to actually take a hit behind that offensive line. PFT has a theory on the whole rehab tour.

Win
Nov 8, 2023
#18284
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers is trolling the media and is not actually close to coming back from his Achilles injury

My theory about Aaron Rodgers is he is, he's a troll. He loves trolling. He loves fucking with the media a little bit... I don't think that he's gonna come back in a couple weeks. I think he's doing this knowing that the media will see him on TV and talk about Aaron Rodgers coming back.

Aaron Rodgers did not return during the 2023 season, despite his teases, proving PFT's skepticism correct.

The Tide Has Turned

College football is entering the home stretch, and the most terrifying realization for the rest of the country is that Nick Saban is lurking. Alabama looks like a completely different team than the one that struggled against USF earlier this year. Jalen Milroe has found his stride, and the defense is punishing. Big Cat is ready to give Saban his flowers for the turnaround.

Win
Nov 8, 2023
#18286
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama is all the way back and this is Nick Saban's best coaching job

Alabama is all the way back. Alabama is all the way back. Jalen Milroe has figured it out... I think our take was right from September, I think this is Nick Saban's best coaching job.

Saban led Alabama to an SEC Championship and a CFP berth in his final season, confirming it as one of his more impressive mid-season turnarounds.

As we look toward the playoff, the Big Ten is turning into a messy divorce. The anonymous coaches crying about Jim Harbaugh need to put their names on it or shut up. Between the sign-stealing drama and the upcoming schedule, the path to the final four is narrowing. Big Cat thinks the regular season is about to claim its biggest victim in late November.

Win
Nov 8, 2023
#22856
Big CatBig Cat

The Michigan vs. Ohio State game is a College Football Playoff elimination game

Michigan-Ohio State is an elimination game. The only way it's not is if other teams catch a couple losses... Michigan beats Ohio State close, Ohio State could find a way to sneak in essentially what happened last year.

Michigan beat Ohio State 30-24. Michigan went on to win the National Championship, while Ohio State missed the CFP entirely, making it an elimination game.

While the Big Ten eats itself, the SEC is positioning itself for the usual dominance. PFT sees a world where the committee just defaults to the names they know best, regardless of how much chaos happens elsewhere.

Loss
Nov 8, 2023
#18287
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Both Georgia and Alabama will make the College Football Playoff this year

I think we're gonna end up with Georgia and Alabama in the Final Four. I could be wrong.

Only Alabama made the playoff; Georgia was left out after losing the SEC Championship to Alabama.

Nate Bargatze in Studio

The funniest man in America, Nate Bargatze, stopped by the studio to talk about his massive month, including hosting Saturday Night Live and being the guest picker on College Game Day. Nate is a rare breed of comedian who stays completely clean without losing an ounce of the funny. He talked about the process of writing for SNL, the Washington measurement sketch, and why he’s stuck being a Vanderbilt fan for life. Nate’s perspective on making it in comedy is as grounded as his stand-up.

Void
Nov 8, 2023
#18292
Nate BargatzeNate Bargatze

You cannot have a backup plan if you want to make it in a creative field

If you do anything, you have to be obsessed with it. And if you're not obsessed with it and willing to like, basically just be like, no, I'll do the, there is no backup plan. You, you really are probably not gonna make it 'cause it's, you just can't have a backup plan.

Subjective career advice that resonates with many successful entertainers but is logically a matter of opinion.

We also touched on his golf game, his dad being a magician, and the absolute thrill of not using a phone case. There is nothing like the life-or-death stakes of holding a naked iPhone over a concrete sidewalk.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hank is on the Hot Seat for losing his laptop for an entire week, which conveniently happened right as he was supposed to finish his lighthouse presentation. He claims it was in a desk he walked by a hundred times, but we all know the truth: he’s dodging the work.

On the Cool Throne, the Chicago Cubs are making power moves. Firing David Ross to hire Craig Counsell away from a division rival is the kind of cutthroat business we love to see. Big Cat is officially drinking the Kool-Aid on the North Side.

Push
Big CatBig Cat

Craig Counsell to the Cubs is a sign the team is ready to spend and compete for World Series titles again

I also think this is the sign that the Cubs are ready to start spending and start competing for World Series again. Because you're not Craig Counsell... you don't go to the Cubs, your rival... unless you have a deal in place from Jed and Tom Ricketts being like, 'Hey, we're going for this.'

The Cubs did sign Shota Imanaga and re-signed Cody Bellinger, but they were not the biggest spenders in the league and missed the playoffs in Counsell's first year (2024).

We wrapped things up with the return of Guys on Chicks, featuring a heavy dose of Max being bullied for his Philly sports misery and Hank reading questions like a man who was truly born to read.

If the Patriots actually leave Bill Belichick in Germany this weekend, just know that PFT is ready to welcome him to DC with open arms. Anything to keep the dream alive.

jetsalabamasnlcollege-footballcubs

More Takes

Win
Nov 8, 2023
#22855
MemesMemes

The Jets should cut Dalvin Cook and give Breece Hall all the carries

When [the Jets] are playing that bad, I just don't know why they just don't give the ball to Breece Hall a thousand times. And then they put Dalvin Cook in who does nothing? So Breece Hall does good, put Dalvin Cook in, does absolutely nothing. They should cut him. I hate Dalvin Cook.

The Jets did eventually release Dalvin Cook on January 2, 2024, after he failed to make a significant impact on the offense.
Void
Nov 8, 2023
#18285
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Izzo is an overrated basketball coach

We just squatted on a take and said, Tom Izzo is overrated. We don't actually believe it now, but just wait. 'cause the conversation's gonna happen. We wanna be the first ones to say it. Now I'm starting to believe it a little bit.

Izzo is a Hall of Famer, but Michigan State's 2023-24 season was relatively disappointing compared to expectations, ending in a second-round tournament exit.
Loss
Nov 8, 2023
#18288
Big CatBig Cat

The Heisman will come down to Bo Nix vs. Michael Penix Jr. in the Pac-12 championship game

I think the Heisman is gonna just come down to if Oregon and Washington play in the Pac-12 championship game, Bo Nix or Michael Penix Jr. who plays better...

Both Nix and Penix Jr. were Heisman finalists, but Jayden Daniels (LSU) ultimately won the award.
Win
Nov 8, 2023
#18289
Big CatBig Cat

Deion Sanders made a mistake demoting Sean Lewis for Pat Shurmur at Colorado

I thought Deion putting Pat Shurmur as the offensive coordinator was a crazy move... Sean Lewis was not the problem with Colorado... it felt like Deion just needed someone to blame. And, and that sucks 'cause I don't, I don't think that was the right move.

Colorado's offense struggled significantly after the change, finishing the season on a 6-game losing streak and failing to score more than 17 points in three of their final four games.
Loss
Nov 8, 2023
#18290
Big CatBig Cat

Shedeur Sanders should declare for the NFL Draft this year

I think Shedeur should go pro.

Shedeur Sanders returned to Colorado for the 2024 season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would take Bill Belichick as the next head coach of the Commanders

I would take Belichick. I just wanna say that for the record. I, I think Bill Belichick is a good head coach and I would like to see him coaching my team. I, especially if it's instead of Hank's team.

Belichick was eventually let go by the Patriots after the season, but the Commanders hired Dan Quinn instead.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I want Jim Harbaugh to be the next head coach of the Chicago Bears more than anything

I think I want [Jim] Harbaugh in Chicago more than anything I've ever wanted in my life.

Jim Harbaugh eventually left Michigan for the NFL, but he signed with the Los Angeles Chargers, not the Bears.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers