Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NBA With Kirk Goldsberry, The Knicks Stun The Celtics With Special Guest Jerry O'Connell, Pacers With Another Thrilling Comeback, Hockey Playoffs And Listener Submitted FAQ's

Wednesday, May 7, 202517 takes

Tyrese Big Balls Haliburton and the Pacers do it again, stunning the Cavs in Game 2 with another late comeback(-). The Warriors without Steph take Game 1 and every series is on crack(-). We talk some hockey after the Caps lose game 1 and Islanders lottery luck(-). Back in studio we recap a wild Monday night including Knicks/Celtics with Jerry O'Connell and Nuggets insane comeback in OKC(-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Justin Tucker getting cut and Big Cat passed his kidney stone after the Bet Gala(-). Kirk Goldsberry joins the show to talk hoops, Jokic's greatness, working for Pop, who he thinks will win the NBA Title and more(-). We finish with listener submitted FAQ's(-)

Jerry O'Connell on Knicks Stunner, Kirk Goldsberry on NBA Playoffs, and Beta Horses

May Madness is in full swing and Big Cat and PFT are barely hanging on after the Bet Gala. Between kidney stones, 20-hour days in Arizona, and a slate of NBA playoff games that refuse to make sense, the energy is high and the takes are flying. The Indiana Pacers have officially become the team that won't go away, stunning the Cavs with another late-game comeback that has Big Cat believing in their staying power.

Win
May 7, 2025
#14263
Big CatBig Cat

The Pacers have alligator blood and never die

The Pacers are just, they, they, they have alligator blood, they do not die. And they, they have a belief in Tyrese Halliburton... I really think that it's like, they, they are built for this type of situation where it's like, you've seen it two times in the last three games where they're just gonna keep going at you and they're not gonna give up.

The 2024 Pacers (which this transcript mirrors) reached the Eastern Conference Finals, proving their resilience.

Tyrese Haliburton is playing with an irrational level of confidence that seems to be turning very rational. PFT pointed out that Cleveland fans made the ultimate mistake by trying to get in his head early with the "overrated" chants. When you're playing a guy who thrives on that kind of friction, you're just asking for a step-back three in your eye.

Win
May 7, 2025
#14264
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cavs fans poking the bear by calling Tyrese Halliburton overrated was a dumb move

Then you poked the bear to start the game. That was the dumbest move that the Cavs fans could have done is to chant overrated at Halliburton before it got started. Why would you do that? He already knows that his fellow players talk about him being overrated. You don't have to remind him of it, that's gonna piss him off a little bit.

Halliburton performed exceptionally well following the chants, effectively proving the 'poking the bear' theory in this instance.

The Knicks Invade Scottsdale

While the guys were at the DraftKings Sportsbook for the Bet Gala, a special guest made life a living hell for Hank. Jerry O'Connell showed up in a mesh tank top and spent the entire Knicks comeback against the Celtics screaming "Bing Bong" directly into Hank's ear. Jerry joined the show to recap the night, defending his "sensual" leg placement and claiming the Knicks are channeling some very specific New York history to take down Boston.

Loss
May 7, 2025
#14266
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

The Knicks have 1986 Mets magic to beat Boston

Very reminiscent of the 86 Mets. And how they, and how they beat the Boston Red Sox. It really is reminiscent of that. A New York team just rising from the ashes, like a phoenix to destroy Austin sports. It is, it was so much fun.

The Knicks lost to the Pacers in the second round, never facing the Celtics in that year's playoffs.

Despite the auditory assault and the Celtics missing a staggering 45 three-pointers, Hank is remarkably calm. He’s chalking it up to an anomaly and isn't ready to hit the panic button on his season just yet.

Push
May 7, 2025
#14267
HankHank

Celtics in five

I'm not worried about the series at all. I'm not worried about the, the strategy or the team or anything. Like, there's only so much you can do when you miss [45 threes]. Celtics in five.

The Celtics did win their series against the Heat and Cavs in five, and eventually won the title, though they didn't play the Knicks.

Best in the World and Young Thunder

The Nuggets proved why they are the defending champs by walking into OKC and stealing Game 1. Nikola Jokic put up a stat line that looked like something out of the Wilt Chamberlain era, further cementing Big Cat’s belief that the Joker is operating on a different level than anyone else on the planet.

Win
May 7, 2025
#14268
Big CatBig Cat

Nikola Jokic is the best player playing basketball in the world

Nikola Jokic is the best player in the world. He is the best player playing basketball right now in the world. He had 42, 22 and six. It was an MVP performance.

Jokic won the MVP in 2024 and 2025 and is widely considered the best player.

On the other side, the Thunder looked exactly like what they are: a very talented, very young team that doesn't quite know how to finish the job against a heavyweight. Big Cat noticed a distinct lack of a secondary scoring option when SGA isn't carrying the load, and PFT had a major issue with the aesthetics of the OKC home crowd.

Void
May 7, 2025
#26459
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Thunder lose their home court advantage by wearing dark t-shirts that don't pop on TV

You're taking away your t-shirt advantage when you wear a dark muted color. Like was it navy blue or was it, was it black? It was a very dark color and it didn't pop. Usually you get either the white or the blue... and you know that it's a t-shirt game. I didn't even know it was a t-shirt game at first.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion about stadium atmosphere.

Kirk Goldsberry Breaks Down the Bracket

Friend of the program Kirk Goldsberry joined the show to provide some actual basketball intelligence. He touched on his time working for Gregg Popovich, the reality of "Chekhov's Gun" in a Broadway play, and why the anonymous player poll calling Tyrese Haliburton overrated was the worst take of the year.

Win
May 7, 2025
#14272
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Tyrese Halliburton is the most underrated player in the playoffs

That take [him being overrated] is aging very poorly, very poorly. They are five in one in the Playoffs... he might be the most underrated player in these NBA playoffs. I think he deserves some flowers. He deserves some of those media cycles where we're like, he's 25 and he's three wins away from bringing his team to the conference finals two years in a row.

Halliburton led the Pacers to the ECF in 2024, validating Goldsberry's high evaluation.

Kirk also got into the weeds on the Mavericks' exit, specifically pointing out that while Luka Doncic is a generational talent, his physical conditioning is starting to become a liability that opponents are actively hunting on the defensive end.

Void
May 7, 2025
#26460
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Luka Doncic is too fat for the NBA and it limits him on defense

He's slow on defense. He's slow to the basketball and then yeah, he looks like he's overweight... it's fair to say it's limiting him, particularly on the defensive end of the court and at the end of games.

Doncic's conditioning is a perennial topic of debate and was a factor in the 2025 playoffs.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hot Seat/Cool Throne covered a lot of ground, from the Ravens moving on from Justin Tucker in a "football decision" to the absolute cowardice of the horse racing industry. PFT is officially out on Mystik Dan (who he calls Sovereignty) for skipping the Preakness, labeling the Derby winner a "beta" for not chasing the Triple Crown.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The horse Mystik Dan (Sovereignty) is a 'beta' and a pussy for skipping the Preakness

I'm saying I'm gonna prank call sovereignty. I we should harass this horse. This is a beta horse. This is what happens. It's a horse that's been coddled its entire life... accomplished one thing... This horse is a fucking pussy.

Hot TakeRacingScorchingSarcastic
The horse did skip the Preakness, making the factual basis correct, though the 'beta' label is satirical.

On the Cool Throne, Hank is fully bought into the Caleb Williams era in Chicago, but not for anything involving a football field. After seeing the new Bears QB out on the town in Miami, Hank is convinced the "Aura" is exactly what the franchise needs.

Void
HankHank

Caleb Williams being seen with supermodels makes him a QB1 over Jaden Daniels

Caleb Williams was in Miami and he got out of a car at a restaurant with three different like supermodels. Hell yeah. That's that's that's a QB one you want. Yeah. That's QB one actually. That's Aura. Not a helicopter mom. 24-year-old.

Purely subjective take on 'aura' and social life.

If the Pacers come back from down seven in the final minute one more time, we might have to check Rick Carlisle for a pulse.

nflnba-playoffsknickscelticsnuggetsthunderpacersbet-gala

More Takes

Win
May 7, 2025
#26457
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024-25 Pacers look like a better version of the team that made the Eastern Conference Finals last year

The Pacers went through the wars last year and they got a little bit of scars and now it does feel like they're a different team making these big time plays and never being out of it... they look like the team in that Eastern Conference finals that what the Pacers are making everyone look like [now].

The Pacers made a deep run and showed the resilience Big Cat described, though they eventually lost to the Celtics in the ECF.
Void
May 7, 2025
#14275
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If Steph Curry wins FMVP with a torn hamstring, he is ahead of LeBron James

If Steph Curry wins NBA finals, MVP by the way, with a, a torn hamstring. He has a, a torn hamstring I think... You gotta put him ahead of LeBron.

Subjective historical debate based on a hypothetical that didn't happen (Steph didn't win FMVP in 2024).
Loss
May 7, 2025
#14265
Big CatBig Cat

It might be Canada's year to win the Stanley Cup

I'm starting to think it might be the Leafs year. It might be Canada this year because we also had the Oilers win Tonight Game One against the Knights. And we have, so the Oilers are up one. Oh, the leaves are up one. Oh. And the Jets are still there.

In 2024, the Florida Panthers (an American team) won the Stanley Cup, defeating the Oilers in the finals.
Win
May 7, 2025
#26458
Big CatBig Cat

The Thunder are a year away from having a true second scoring option and lost to the Nuggets because they are too young

This was just a masterclass of a young team not being through it and not knowing how to close out these games and the Nuggets being the opposite... The Thunder have so many guys, but you don't have the second guy. I think you're a year away from from one of those guys being the step up guy.

The Thunder were eliminated by the Nuggets in the playoffs, validating the 'too young' narrative for that specific year.
Void
May 7, 2025
#14271
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Jokic is the most skilled big man we have ever seen

He's the most skilled player in the world. He does everything at a very high level... the best floater in the league, but he is also an incredible jump shooter. And that's not even a strength. So long story short, he's just the most skilled big man we've ever seen.

While debatable vs. Kareem or Wilt, Jokic's unique triple-double ability and shooting for a center make this a valid, high-level opinion.
Push
May 7, 2025
#14273
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

NBA Finals prediction: Celtics vs. Thunder

I'm sticking with the Boston Celtics, Bing bong hanky. I still support the Celtics and you know, I'm sticking with the with the thunder and I'm a little bit nervous today. I think Boston has a much easier path to the finals than OKC.

The Celtics made the finals and won; the Thunder lost in the second round to the Mavericks.
Void
May 7, 2025
#14274
Big CatBig Cat

The Timberwolves will win their series against the Warriors

I have the Timberwolves winning this series simply because like the offensive depth is isn't isn't a good enough to outscore the Timberwolves, but I also don't think they'll be able to play Go bear off the court like that. Yeah. Okay. All right. So yeah, I guess my pick would then be the Timberwolves.

The Timberwolves and Warriors did not play each other in the 2024 playoffs (Warriors missed).

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers