Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Playoffs With Pete Prisco, Eagles Collapse, Hank Is Back From Dallas And Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, January 17, 202421 takes

The Eagles collapse has finally been set but first as Max predicted everyone is still talking about the Cowboys (-). We talk Steelers/Bills (-) and the Eagles despicable performance on Monday night plus Baker’s redemption and what Max hopes Philly does from here (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Hank’s return from Dallas (-). Pete Prisco joins the show to talk NFL Playoffs, what happened to the Jaguars, what are the fixes for the teams bounced in the first round and coaching vacancies (-). We finish with guys on Chicks (-).

Pete Prisco on NFL Playoffs, Eagles Collapse, and Hank’s Dallas Trip

Super Wild Card Weekend is officially in the books, and while there were some actual football games played on Monday, Big Cat and PFT aren't quite ready to stop dancing on the grave of the Dallas Cowboys. The fallout from the Packers' absolute dismantling of America's Team is still the biggest story in the league, even if Jerry Jones is staying uncharacteristically quiet. PFT, ever the voice of reason for rival fanbases, has a very specific recommendation for how the Cowboys should handle this disaster.

Push
Jan 17, 2024
#14816
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cowboys should extend both Dak Prescott and Mike McCarthy

I still think with the, you know, benefit of hindsight, another day to think about it. You gotta extend both Dak Prescott and Mike McCarthy. Yeah, I think listen, you won 13 games, right? ... sometimes stability is your best stability.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The Cowboys did retain Mike McCarthy for the 2024 season, though Dak Prescott's long-term extension remained a point of contention until just before the next season.

The Bills managed to handle the Steelers in a game that felt like it was over in ten minutes before the Bills remembered they love to keep things stressful. Buffalo is moving on, but they're doing it with a defensive roster that looks like a MASH unit. Big Cat is already looking ahead to the divisional round matchup with the Chiefs, and the outlook for the Bills' secondary isn't exactly sunny.

Win
Jan 17, 2024
#14818
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills defense will have a hard time stopping Patrick Mahomes with their current injuries

I am very nervous for the Bills defense going up against Patrick Mahomes in the Playoffs. It feels like they're gonna have to patchwork something together here. And maybe, maybe they just have to just do like their offense just has to go nuclear. ... they've lost everything [on defense].

The Chiefs beat the Bills 27-24 in the divisional round; the Bills defense struggled to stop the Chiefs on critical drives.

The Eagles’ Historic Meltdown

Max is officially in a dark place after the Eagles put up a truly "despicable" performance against the Buccaneers. It wasn't just that they lost; it was the way they looked like they’d never seen a blitz before. Max is calling for a total house cleaning in Philly, with only one man safe from the chopping block.

Push
Jan 17, 2024
#14824
MaxMax

The Eagles should fire everyone on the coaching staff except Big Dom

I want every one of them go ... Big dom stays. Big dom has stayed through multiple coaching generations. ... We need a leader of men on this team.

The Eagles fired offensive coordinator Brian Johnson and defensive coordinator Sean Desai/Matt Patricia, but retained head coach Nick Sirianni.

This wasn't just a bad end to a season. For Max, this was a failure of monumental proportions. The Eagles went from being a "coin flip" away from a Super Bowl title to a team that looked like they didn't even want to be on the field in Tampa.

Void
Jan 17, 2024
#22795
MaxMax

The Eagles' end-of-season collapse is the worst in the history of sports

This is also the worst collapse in like the history of sports. It really is actually... the Eagles were very good last year and went to the Super Bowl and then the 10 and 1. It was a coin flip Super Bowl game.

Inherently subjective hyperbole, though the 2023 Eagles collapse is statistically one of the worst in NFL history given their record.

While the coaching staff is catching all the heat, the conversation turned to Jalen Hurts. Despite the stagnant offense and the lingering knee issues that Big Cat and PFT have been pointing out since October, Max isn't ready to give up on his franchise guy. He still thinks the talent is there, even if the scheme was a disaster.

Void
Jan 17, 2024
#14827
MaxMax

Jalen Hurts is still a top 10 quarterback despite the poor season ending

Jalen is still a good quarterback. ... I would say I, I, I, well a thousand percent say that. I think he's top 10. I think he was borderline top five going to this year. I think he's probably between five and 10.

Quarterback rankings are subjective.

Pete Prisco and the Coaching Carousel

Our good friend Pete Prisco joined the show to break down what exactly happened to his Jacksonville Jaguars (who he definitely didn't pick to be the one seed) and look ahead to the divisional round. Pete was high on the Packers' performance and had some massive praise for Jordan Love, which Big Cat was surprisingly quick to agree with.

Open
Jan 17, 2024
#22799
Big CatBig Cat

Jordan Love is playing so well that I've admitted he is probably a future Hall of Famer

Jordan loves playing incredible football. I've just admitted that he's probably a future hall of famer. ... That guy has a little bit of 'it' to it. You know, you can't see that when, when a guy comes out in the draft.

It is far too early to judge Hall of Fame status for a player in his first full season as a starter.

Prisco also weighed in on the CJ Stroud phenomenon. The Texans' rookie has been so good that Pete is reaching back into the history books for a comparison that will make any football fan sit up a little straighter.

Void
Jan 17, 2024
#14843
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

CJ Stroud reminds me of Dan Marino in his heyday

He makes me think of Dan Marino in his heyday. ... He makes it look so easy with the quick release and the ability to throw out. ... The ability to decipher it and put it right on the numbers and make it makes it look easy. There, there are a few guys that walk into this league and make it look that easy. That's why he reminds me of Marino.

Player comparisons are subjective.

With so many high-profile openings, the coaching search talk is reaching a fever pitch. Pete shared his predictions for where the big names will land, including a move for Bill Belichick that would be the ultimate "cuck move" for the Falcons according to Big Cat.

Loss
Jan 17, 2024
#14846
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Bill Belichick will be the next head coach of the Atlanta Falcons

Belichick's gonna go to Atlanta. ... because all you wanna do, if you're, if you're Arthur Blank, all you wanna do is win.

The Falcons hired Raheem Morris on January 25, 2024.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne and Dallas Hank

Hank is finally back in the studio after a "hellacious" travel experience from Dallas. While the New York Post might be speculating on his relationship status with Tiffany Gomas, Hank officially set the record straight on the couch. It turns out that a difference in football ideology—specifically whether Dak Prescott is good or should be replaced by Bill Belichick—was the ultimate dealbreaker.

Void
HankHank

Romantically, things are not going to happen with Tiffany Gomas

I would like to, you know, set the record straight that we're not [dating]. ... we just kind of said, let's, let's just, you know, call a spade a spade and go our separate ways. ... I just think romantically it's not, it's not not gonna happen.

Personal relationship status is subjective to the individual's claim.

In a lighter moment of Hot Seat/Cool Throne, the guys discussed the GPA of the Liberty football team and Big Cat’s philosophy on higher education. According to the middle-aged man who once took a class called "Dinosaurs," college is really just about navigating the system.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

College is a sham where you just have to find the hacks and tricks to get through

College is a sham. It's a big trick. You just gotta get through the tricks. You just find tricks and then you're like, alright, this class is easy... I hit 120 [credits] the last second. It's really, college is like, can you find the, the hacks?

Inherently a subjective take on the value and structure of the university system.

We wrapped things up with a very hygiene-focused Guys on Chicks. The debate over how many wipes is too many wipes led to some harrowing revelations about Jake Marsh’s folding techniques and Big Cat’s firm stance on modern bathroom amenities.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

I have completely converted to being a wipes person for bathroom hygiene

I buy them at stores 'cause I'm just like, I I've completely converted to a wipes person. ... You have to finish [with them].

Personal preference and habit, stated as a lifestyle change.

Just remember, if you ever find yourself in a freezing cold pool, try not to put your knee through a drywall on the way to the shower.

nfl-playoffsphiladelphia-eaglesdallas-cowboyspete-priscohiring-cycle

More Takes

Void
Jan 17, 2024
#22794
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Vrabel is the perfect culture fit to be the next head coach of the Steelers

I think Vrabel obviously, he's the culture fit there. Be perfect, be perfect fit for Pittsburgh.

While Mike Tomlin stayed with the Steelers, Vrabel was not hired, and the take is a subjective evaluation of fit.
Void
Jan 17, 2024
#14820
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Safeties should be worth between three and five points

Safety should be worth more than two points. Safety should be worth between four, three and five points. ... Safeties are so hard to do. And they're so awesome when they happen. ... The fact that they're only worth two points is just, it doesn't make any sense.

This is a subjective rule change proposal.
Win
Jan 17, 2024
#14830
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jim Harbaugh will be interviewed by the Falcons

Next up hasn't been reported yet. Harbaugh will be interviewed by the Falcons. The plane, I believe just picked him up and is flying back to Atlanta with 'em right now for the interview.

Jim Harbaugh did interview with the Falcons on January 16, 2024, and a second interview was reported shortly after.
Loss
Jan 17, 2024
#22796
MaxMax

I would take Mike Vrabel for sure to be the next head coach of the Eagles

I would take [Mike Vrabel] for sure. Leader of men. Leader of men. Leader of men.

The Eagles retained Nick Sirianni for the 2024 season, so this hiring never occurred.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I don't believe for a second that Lions fans actually booed Matthew Stafford's daughters

Kelly Stafford came out and said that Lions fans booed her four little daughters. She's since retracted. But that was a crazy lie... no one's like to say that your daughters got booed is insane. I stand with Lions fans. There's no way... unless you show me a video of a Lions fans pointing at the daughter and being like, 'see you little girl, boo.' No chance.

Kelly Stafford later clarified that the fans were booing the team/Stafford and not her children specifically.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Liberty Football's 2.96 GPA is actually good for a team GPA

Liberty Football. They tweeted ... 2.96 cumulative GPA. ... It's actually not terrible for a team. It's really good. ... football team. It's the old, 'I didn't play school'.

This is a subjective assessment of academic performance in sports.
Void
Jan 17, 2024
#14840
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Green Bay dominating Dallas was the biggest surprise of Wild Card weekend

I think the biggest surprise has to be Green Bay going in and winning the way they did. I thought they would hang around in the game, but to go in there and dominate the way they did, that was a bad look for Dallas.

This is a subjective expert opinion.
Open
Jan 17, 2024
#22800
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Patrick Mahomes might end up passing Tom Brady as the greatest of all time in every category

He might end up passing Brady as the greatest of all time in terms of Super Bowls, MVPs, numbers, the whole deal. I mean that's, he's special and he carries that team every single week.

Mahomes won his 3rd Super Bowl later that season, but remains 4 rings and several MVPs/records behind Brady.
Loss
Jan 17, 2024
#14853
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Bears will be a playoff team next year no matter who is at quarterback

The Bears will be a playoff team next year, no matter who plays quarterback. ... They got good tackles. ... You have the, the weapons, the runners.

The Bears finished the 2024 regular season with a 7-10 record, missing the playoffs.
Win
Jan 17, 2024
#14848
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Jim Harbaugh will be the next head coach of the Chargers

I think Harbaugh to the Chargers makes all the sense. Yeah, in large part because it's the best job. You get the quarterback, you don't have to worry about the quarterback. And, and so I think that's the best scenario for him. I think he does end up going there.

The Chargers officially hired Jim Harbaugh on January 24, 2024.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers