Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL With Fred Smoot In Studio, Week 3 Picks And Preview, Bills Start 3-0 + Fyre Fest Of The Week

Friday, September 19, 202518 takes

Bills beat the Dolphins in a surprisingly competitive game and the tush push is going to be ref'd harder (-). Playoff baseball is imminent (-). We then get to week 3 Picks and Preview for every game including hard conversations with CJ Stroud, do we believe in Carson Wentz again, Eagles vs Rams, Bears gateway game and more (-). We then do our picks, parlay and Jerry's fantasy minute (-). Fred Smoot joins us in studio to talk ball, starting 0-2, how much he hates pumpkins, Defensive Back celebrations and more (-). We finish with Fyre Fest of the week (-).

Fred Smoot on NFL Week 3, Pumpkin Hate, and the Bills' 3-0 Start

The Buffalo Bills are officially 3-0 after a Thursday night win where Tua Tagovailoa just couldn't stop throwing the ball to people in the wrong jersey. While the Dolphins showed more life than expected, Big Cat is starting to think the Bills are operating on a different level than everyone else in the AFC East right now.

Push
Sep 19, 2025
#15352
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills are currently in a mode where they can casually beat teams by 10 points without playing perfectly

It does feel like the Bills are in that mode, that they don't have to play perfect. And they can still, they can still just kind of like casually beat you by 10 points.

The Bills did start 3-0 and were dominant in several early games, though they had lulls later in the season.

Before diving into the Week 3 slate, the conversation took a sharp turn into cultural shifts. Big Cat made a bold declaration regarding physical preferences in the year 2025, noting that the pendulum has swung back toward the classics after a long run by the "ass boys."

Void
Sep 19, 2025
#15353
Big CatBig Cat

I'm officially declaring that tits are back and the era of the 'ass boys' is over

I said, tits are back. I said, the, the ass, the the ass boys had their little run, but tits are all the way back. And people were like, bro, you're fucking 50 and you're talking about this, like, yeah. That's awesome.

This is entirely a matter of aesthetic preference and cultural vibes, which are inherently subjective.

Week 3 Picks and Preview

The board is loaded with backup quarterbacks this week, which led to a heavy discussion on whether certain guys are actually fixable. PFT is out on the Carson Wentz experience as he prepares to start for his sixth team in six years.

Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#15354
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I don't think Carson Wentz is fixable as a quarterback due to his extensive scar tissue

I'm not ready to say that about Cars. I don't, I don't think that Carson Wentz is fixable. Yeah. I think he's got too, too much scar tissue.

Wentz's tenure with the Vikings was short-lived and he did not reclaim his Pro Bowl form, supporting PFT's claim.

In the NFC East, Max is sweating the Eagles-Rams matchup, mostly because Saquon Barkley has historically treated the Rams' defense like a Pop Warner squad. Despite the offensive coordinator concerns in Philly, Big Cat pointed out that Jalen Hurts just finds ways to win regardless of the style points.

Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#15355
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts is a winner who doesn't care about anything but the final result

Jalen Hurts in games that he has started and finished. He's 18 and oh in his last 18 games that he started and finished... The, the Eagles. And he doesn't give a fuck about how they just keep winning.

The stat was accurate at the time of the recording for regular season games he completed.

Looking at the early window, PFT is worried about the vibes in Tennessee. Between the penalties and the lack of identity, it feels like the Brian Callahan era might be over before it truly begins.

Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#29596
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Titans head coach Brian Callahan is destined to be another forgettable name in the franchise's coaching history

The Titans, they're starting the conversation regarding their head coach because he falls firmly into the Ken Whisenhunt, Mike Malarkey pantheon of kind of forgettable guys that have coached the Titans over the years.

Brian Callahan was fired after just one season in 2025, confirming PFT's suspicion that he wouldn't last or leave a mark.

Meanwhile, in Arizona, Kyler Murray is facing some heat for his social media presence. Big Cat isn't questioning the talent, but he is questioning the decision-making of a guy who thinks a Michael Vick jersey and a pitbull is a good look for a franchise QB.

Void
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#15357
Big CatBig Cat

Kyler Murray's decision to post a photo with a pitbull and a Michael Vick jersey shows a lack of judgment

If your quarterback's making, if this is the judgment of your quarterback, that's a bad song. The decision making process is lacking.

While subjective, the backlash Murray faced and the subsequent deletion of the photo suggests many agreed it was a PR lapse.

Finally, the Bears and Cowboys meet in what Big Cat has dubbed a "Gateway Game." It’s the kind of matchup that determines if Chicago fans can actually start dreaming of a winning record or if they should start looking at mock drafts by October.

Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#15358
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears-Cowboys matchup is a 'Gateway Game' that will define the rest of Chicago's season

This is a gateway game. If the Bears win this game... don't be shocked if the Bears are five and four or six and three... but if they don't win this game, none of this matters. They're own three and they just suck.

The Bears lost this game and did indeed struggle for much of the first half of the season, falling to 0-3.

Fred Smoot in Studio

Friend of the program Fred Smoot joined the show to bring some much-needed energy to the commanders' fan base. He touched on the new ownership, the potential return to D.C., and why he thinks the team is finally in a Super Bowl window.

Loss
Sep 19, 2025
#29602
Fred SmootFred Smoot

The Commanders are legitimate Super Bowl contenders this season

No, we thinking Super Bowl. It's been generations since we could think Super Bowl and just to be in that window to think Super Bowl is a privilege... Congratulations to the team by the way. We moving back to the nation's capital.

The Commanders did not make the Super Bowl in 2025, though they did make the playoffs.

Smoot also broke down his philosophy on DB celebrations, explaining the "DB Love Kiss" where a quarterback overthrows a receiver by ten yards and the corner acts like he just locked down Prime Deion. He also offered a vivid, if slightly unsettling, analogy for why people should stop falling in love with the Denver Broncos defense.

Win
Sep 19, 2025
#29603
Fred SmootFred Smoot

The Denver Broncos are a beauty queen with a dead tooth in her mouth

The Broncos right now... a good analogy for this is a beauty queen with a dead tooth in her mouth. You walk up to her, she looking at you, then you start to talk to her and you be like, yeah, I see why now. See that dead tooth in your mouth? That had just killed everything I felt before I got here.

The Broncos' elite defense was consistently let down by poor quarterback play in 2025, perfectly matching this analogy.

Outside of football, Smoot went on an all-time rant against the seasonal obsession with pumpkins. According to Fred, nobody actually likes them; we’re just being bullied by Big Pumpkin into drinking lattes that smell like candles.

Void
Sep 19, 2025
#15359
Fred SmootFred Smoot

Pumpkins are useless food that only hippos and squirrels actually enjoy

I got a vendetta against everything pumpkin... nobody likes pumpkins, we're just forced to do a lot of stuff that we just forced to do as human beings... The only animal [that eats it] is the hippopotamus and squirrels.

His claim that nobody likes them is hyperbole, making it subjective food commentary.

Fyre Fest of the Week

It was a bad week to own a vehicle at PMT. Hank had his gym bag stolen out of his unlocked car, only to find a pair of sunglasses he lost a year ago in the process. PFT, however, took the biggest loss. He fell for the classic "parking lot dent repair" scam at a car wash, paying $250 to a guy who essentially just rubbed foam on his car and told him to wait for it to "set."

Memes rounded out the show by putting Lions DC Aaron Glenn on the hottest seat imaginable. If the Detroit defense can't handle a depleted Bucs offensive line, Memes is ready to call for heads.

Loss
Sep 19, 2025·Fyre Fest
#15361
MemesMemes

Lions defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn should be fired if the defense gets embarrassed by a backup offensive line

I was saying if the defense gets embarrassed by an all backup offensive line... he should probably be [fired]. Must compete. I wanna see a competitive football team against a team that has 2% of their offense.

Aaron Glenn was not fired in 2025 and actually improved the defense as the season went on.

Good luck to everyone this weekend, except the guy who scammed PFT at the car wash.

nflbuffalo-billschicago-bearswashington-commandersfantasy-football

More Takes

Void
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#29597
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Marcus Mariota is the best backup quarterback in the NFL

I think [Marcus Mariota] is probably the best backup quarterback in the NFL. He was great last year. He was awesome against the Cowboys. And this is actually... for all the talk about Jayden [Daniels] possibly being injury prone, this is the first start that he will miss.

Whether Mariota is the 'best' backup is subjective, but he played well in relief during the 2025 season.
Loss
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#15356
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Spencer Rattler will get his first NFL win as a starter this week against the Seahawks

I think, I think they're gonna win. [Spencer Rattler] is gonna get his first win this week. First win as a starter.

Rattler and the Saints did not beat the Seahawks in this matchup.
Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#29598
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bears-Cowboys matchup is a 'Gateway Game' specifically for how people view Caleb Williams as a quarterback

I think it might be a gateway game for your feelings about Caleb Williams as a quarterback... Because if they go 0-3, it's gonna be just full, like Caleb's gotta look good.

Williams had a standout performance in this game, which cemented his status as a franchise piece despite early team struggles.
Win
Sep 19, 2025·Picks
#29599
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs aren't capable of blowing teams out right now because Patrick Mahomes lacks explosive weapons

I kind of like the Giants in this game. No, I don't think, I think the Chiefs are gonna win six points. I don't think the Chiefs can blow anyone out right now. Mahomes, you don't have enough guys.

The Chiefs famously played 11 straight one-score games during the 2025 season, making this take extremely accurate.
Win
Sep 19, 2025
#29600
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derwin James should be in the conversation for NFL Defensive Player of the Year

I walked away from that game thinking that we should be talking more about Derwin James. I love watching him play... I feel like he should be in that conversation for defensive player of the year.

Derwin James finished in the top 5 for DPOY voting in 2025, validating PFT's take.
Win
Sep 19, 2025
#29601
Fred SmootFred Smoot

The Miami Dolphins culture is currently falling apart from the inside

That apple was rotting before it hit the ground. It feel like that house is just falling apart. You go into survival mode. Everybody in the building goes into survival mode... It's like jumping overboard. They like let the kids and the children go first. I gotta go too.

The Dolphins' season spiraled into a 4-13 finish with multiple staff changes, confirming the internal collapse Smoot predicted.
Win
Sep 19, 2025
#15360
Fred SmootFred Smoot

The Indianapolis Colts are a legitimately good team without a clear-cut weakness right now

The Colts have really jumped off the screen. Like even if they had lost a game, I'd still be like, that's a good football team. Yep. That's a legit good football team.

The Colts were a competitive playoff contender throughout the season, validating Smoot's positive assessment.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers