Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Whitney and Trill Withers (@TylerIAm)

Wednesday, February 15, 201714 takes

Welcome to the only podcast officially banned by the Westminster Kennel Club. The boys attempted to go to the Best In Show competition at Madison Square Garden with fake credentials and were promptly detained by the NYPD ( -) - . Hot Seat/Cool Throne ( - ). Trill Withers joins the show to talk NBA, the official debut of the Mickstape podcast and who's mans is it for all of the contending teams ( - ). Ryan Whitney from spittin chiclets joins the show to talk NHL, is this the Caps year, and whether or not peaking too early is a real thing in hockey ( - ). Segments include respect the biz, the debut of "is ____ a bad sports town?", Lebron Blames, hmmmm, and not to brag but we called it.

Ryan Whitney and Trill Withers on Dog Show Bans and NBA 'Mans'

The show opens with some heavy news: Barstool Sports is officially and permanently banned from all Westminster Kennel Club events. Big Cat, PFT, and Hank attempted to infiltrate the prestigious dog show at Madison Square Garden with credentials that were essentially pieces of paper glue-sticked together at a FedEx. While they successfully breezed past MSG security and made it all the way to the dog staging area, things went south when PFT started snapping iPhone photos like a commoner rather than a seasoned journalist.

Hank and PFT were eventually detained by a high-ranking security official who seemed way too excited to make an arrest at a dog show. While the guys were threatened with felonies and questioned about their potential ties to PETA, Big Cat was still roaming the hallways in a sport coat over a hoodie, unsuccessfully trying to bribe a "stoolie cop" to let his friends go. They eventually received a lifetime ban from the nerd in a purple bowtie running the club, which PFT noted felt like being back in eighth grade getting kicked out of a mall.

Transitioning to sports that don't involve grooming, Trill Withers (TylerIAm) joined the show to break down the NBA landscape now that football season is over. The guys played a game of "Whose Mans?" to determine the true alpha of the league's top contenders. While they touched on the Cavs and Celtics, the conversation got interesting when discussing the Warriors' power structure.

Void
Feb 15, 2017
#16898
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Luke Walton was a better coach for the Golden State Warriors than Steve Kerr

I would actually say [the Warriors are] Luke Walton's team. People forget he was their coach in the first half last year. They were a lot better then.

While Walton did have a historic start as interim coach, Steve Kerr is widely recognized as the architect of the dynasty. This is a satirical take on coaching credit.

When the discussion shifted to the Clippers and Rockets, Trill had some very specific thoughts on how teams improve by simply losing certain high-profile players.

Win
Feb 15, 2017
#16900
Trill WithersTrill Withers

The Houston Rockets got 100 times better simply by letting Dwight Howard leave

I went Dwight Howard. Like, he just left, and [the Rockets] got 100 times better. Addition by subtraction. I love it.

The 2016-17 Rockets did improve significantly without Howard, winning 55 games compared to 41 the previous year, though the addition of Mike D'Antoni and James Harden's shift to PG were major factors.
Void
Feb 15, 2017
#22503
Trill WithersTrill Withers

Austin Rivers is the guy whose 'mans' it is for the Clippers because of his dad

Austin Rivers. His dad is the coach and the GM. That's a good call. Austin Rivers, no one likes the coach's son.

This is a subjective assessment of team hierarchy and identity.

Ryan Whitney then hopped on to provide some much-needed hockey expertise as the NHL season hits the home stretch. PFT was riding high on his Washington Capitals, and Whitney was right there with him, confirming that the Caps look like a certified wagon this year despite their history of second-round exits.

Loss
Feb 15, 2017
#16902
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Washington Capitals will finally win the Stanley Cup this year

The Washington Capitals, it's their year. I think this is the year they finally win the Stanley Cup. They certainly have all the pieces. They have all the pieces.

The Capitals actually lost in the second round of the playoffs in 2017 to the Penguins. They didn't win the Cup until the following year (2018).

Whitney also broke down the bizarre news of Claude Julien being hired by the Montreal Canadiens just a week after being fired by the rival Bruins. Big Cat was particularly hung up on the specific language requirements for coaching in Quebec.

Void
Feb 15, 2017
#22502
Big CatBig Cat

It is dumb that the Montreal Canadiens will only hire coaches who speak French

Part of it goes into this foolish, I don't even know what to call it, that the Canadiens will only hire—you have to speak French to coach the Canadiens, which is so dumb. If you're going to win a Stanley Cup, I don't know why you have to—it doesn't matter what you speak.

The policy exists but its effectiveness or stupidity is a matter of hockey opinion.

As a Blackhawks fan, Big Cat wanted to know if the veteran core in Chicago still had enough gas in the tank to make another run. Whitney wasn't just optimistic; he was predicting a total Western Conference takeover by the guys in the Indian head sweaters.

Loss
Feb 15, 2017
#16905
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Chicago Blackhawks will win the Western Conference this year

No, I actually think [the Blackhawks] are going to win the West. I love their team this year. I think that they're really deep. Kane and Toews will be there when it matters. I love their team. They've got a lot of young guys that are playing really well.

While the Blackhawks finished as the #1 seed in the West, they were shockingly swept in the first round by the Nashville Predators.
Loss
Feb 15, 2017
#16906
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Chicago Blackhawks will win at least one Stanley Cup in the next three years

I love their team. They'll be right there. I wouldn't be worried at all. They're right in the midst of that window to win a couple more. I think they at least get one in the next three years.

The Blackhawks did not win another Stanley Cup after 2015. Their era of dominance effectively ended with the first-round sweeps in 2016 and 2017.

Before letting Whitney go, they discussed Gustav Nyquist’s recent high-sticking incident that left everyone a bit shocked by the lack of immediate discipline. Whitney, ever the traditionalist, suggested a much steeper penalty than a simple suspension.

Loss
Feb 15, 2017
#22504
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Gustav Nyquist should get five to seven years in prison for his high-sticking incident

I think you should get five to seven years in prison for that. [on Gustav Nyquist hitting a guy in the face with a stick].

Nyquist received a 6-game suspension, not prison time.

The show wrapped up with a new segment called "Bad Sports Town," focusing on Lawrence, Kansas, after fans were seen leaving the Jayhawks' epic comeback win over West Virginia early. PFT offered a rare defense of the fans, suggesting there are just too many other cool things to do in a cosmopolitan hub like Lawrence.

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lawrence, Kansas is a great everything-else town, but college sports is on the back burner

I don't think that necessarily [Lawrence is] a bad sports town. I just think that they're a great everything else town. And, you know, they keep it in the right perspective, and college sports is on the back burner.

Hot TakeCBBScorchingSarcastic
Lawrence is widely considered one of the best college sports towns in America, making the claim that sports are on the 'back burner' absurdly incorrect.

Between the dog show arrests and the realization that Meryl Streep is actually a massive football fan, it’s clear that even without the NFL, the content machine never stops.

At least we still have Ice Cube coming on Friday to keep the energy up.

westminster-dog-shownbanhllebron-jameschicago-blackhawksstanley-cup

More Takes

Void
Feb 15, 2017
#22501
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UConn's women's basketball team wins so much because they sync up their periods and bond

I actually think that if this game were being played 300 years ago, they would be accused of being witches... Nobody has ever won 100 games until these women, but I think it's because men's teams don't have periods that they can sync up. Same wavelength. That's why women are able to become better teammates than men because the entire team gets on their [period]. They get to basically do trust falls six or seven times a season when they're all on their periods together. It's a bonding experience.

The biological claim that period syncing leads to 100-game winning streaks in basketball is scientifically unproven and intended as a joke.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James is a coward for not participating in the NBA Dunk Contest

LeBron James that's not in the dunk contest again. Kind of a coward move. Michael Jordan was in the dunk contest. Back in the day, you had your best athletes in it. Vince Carter. You had your Vinces, your J.R. Smiths. You had everybody.

LeBron James never participated in the NBA Slam Dunk Contest during his career, making PFT's claim about him avoiding it factually accurate and his opinion on the matter subjective but persistent.
Push
Feb 15, 2017
#16904
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Maple Leafs and Islanders will take the final two playoff spots in the East

I like the Leafs and the Islanders out of that [group]. The Leafs are really exciting. I think they'll get in. They got a great coach... and then the Islanders have just kind of turned things around with Doug Weight as their coach.

The Maple Leafs did make the playoffs in 2017, but the Islanders missed out by a single point, with the final spot going to the Maple Leafs and the Bruins.
Loss
Feb 15, 2017
#16908
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Floyd Mayweather and Conor McGregor are stuck in Zeno's Paradox and will never actually fight

If I shot an arrow at you, it would never actually hit you because in order for the arrow to get to you, it would have to travel half the distance to you, and then it would have to travel half that distance... That's what's happening with McGregor and Mayweather. They're just getting closer and closer and closer and closer until they just get old and die.

They actually did fight on August 26, 2017, so they did not 'just get old and die' without fighting.
Void
Feb 15, 2017·Media
#16909
Big CatBig Cat

Paul Tagliabue is the smartest person in the world for making Roger Goodell his concussion scapegoat

Paul Tagliabue basically said, I've known about concussions forever, but I kind of don't want to be asked about this anymore. So here, Roger Goodell, you look stupid enough to take this job and have everyone come at you and hate you. And that's exactly what happened. So he's actually the smartest person in the world.

While Tagliabue did face criticism for his handling of concussions, Roger Goodell became the public face of the league's struggle with the issue. The 'smartest person' claim is subjective but has a logical basis in the perception of Goodell's role.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers