Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Whitney Talking Stanley Cup Playoffs, Warriors And Nuggets Advance, Kentucky Derby + Jordon Update Of The Week

Monday, May 5, 202519 takes

Incredible weekend of sports as we had Game 7's(-). Warriors beat the Rockets and Nuggets take down the Clippers further cementing James Harden as the biggest choker ever(-). Pacers take Game 1 and the Kentucky Derby was an awesome sloppy mess(-). Who's back of the week including Scottie Scheffler and Lebron James injuries after the playoffs are over for him(-). Ryan Whitney joins the show to talk an incredible first round of the NHL playoffs, including an absolute stunner Game 7 in Winnipeg and Dallas(-). He ranks the remaining teams, who we should be rooting for to win the Cup and more. We finish with some kidney stone talk and Jordon forced her way into a Super Bowl commercial(-).

Ryan Whitney on Stanley Cup Playoffs, James Harden's Choke, and Kentucky Derby Mud

The NBA and NHL gave us a weekend of Game 7 madness that has left Big Cat and PFT reeling. The Golden State Warriors somehow survived the Houston Rockets despite seemingly procrastinating for the entire series. Steph Curry did Steph Curry things, and Buddy Hield channeled his inner Klay Thompson by going nuclear from deep. While the Rockets' season ended in H-Town, Big Cat is still high on what Ime Udoka is building down there.

Push
May 5, 2025
#29089
Big CatBig Cat

The Houston Rockets have a very bright future despite their Game 7 loss

The Rockets, as I expected going into this series, they're a very good team. They have a very bright future... they will be back. They could make a move for Giannis.

The Rockets significantly improved but remained a middle-of-the-pack West team in the immediate aftermath; the Giannis move did not happen.

On the other side of the bracket, we witnessed a legacy-defining performance from James Harden—and not the good kind. The Nuggets absolutely dismantled the Clippers on Saturday night, but the real story was Harden once again turning into a ghost when the lights got the brightest. Big Cat and PFT are officially ready to crown him the most consistent disappearing act in sports history.

Win
May 5, 2025
#19318
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is the biggest choker in NBA history

Is he the biggest choker? I don't know if it's choker or just Bright lights scares him away guy of all time because at this point it is now four different teams that he's done this with. It is, he's great in the regular season. He can be great in the beginning of a series... But then when the Bright, the lights get the brightest and it's game seven, he's a complete no show. And it's, it's not even, there's not even a debate anymore. I think he is [number one all time].

Harden has a well-documented history of poor shooting and high turnovers in elimination games across several franchises (Rockets, 76ers, Clippers).
Void
May 5, 2025
#19320
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Harden stops playing in big games because he simply doesn't want to work anymore

I don't think it's necessarily even an insult to say that to him. Because I, I actually believe that James Harden is like, I don't wanna work anymore. I'm, I'm gonna get paid essentially the same if I, if I get eliminated now or if I get eliminated in two weeks... He doesn't really have any upside besides the glory of winning, which I don't think he necessarily cares that much about.

This is an unconfirmable subjective opinion on a player's internal motivation.

Big Cat is also calling out the NBA schedule-makers for the absolute absurdity of the turnaround times. Between the Nuggets and Warriors, it feels like the league is setting up these older teams for a disaster after grueling seven-game battles.

Push
May 5, 2025
#19322
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA's scheduling makes Game 1 an automatic loss for teams coming off a Game 7

Why are the nuggets playing on Tuesday night... that's the most auto loss I've ever seen on a schedule ever... the nuggets in Game one and the Warriors in Game one, it feels like they're just going in to to die. Yeah. They just played a seven game series. Both a little bit older teams and they have 48 hours to turn around.

The Nuggets lost Game 1 to the Clippers (who won the series 1-0 initially but the Nuggets came back to win in 7). The Warriors also had scheduling challenges. The general principle had some validity but wasn't universally true.

NHL Playoff Fever with Ryan Whitney

Ryan Whitney joined the show to recap a first round that basically turned into a 10-day bender for hockey fans. We just watched the Winnipeg Jets pull off an absolute miracle, scoring twice with the goalie pulled to force overtime against St. Louis before winning in double OT. Whitney thinks the Jets' netminder is still the guy to beat for the league's top honors despite some shaky moments.

Push
May 5, 2025
#29093
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Connor Hellebuyck will win the NHL MVP award this season

Arne [Knott] stuck to his, what what will probably be the MVP of the league. I think he might win MVP, forget the Vezina. He's got that locked up.

Nathan MacKinnon won the Hart Trophy (MVP) in 2024; Hellebuyck finished 6th in voting but did win the Vezina.

Looking ahead to the second round, Whitney is doing his best to be objective, though his heart is clearly with the Oilers. He gave us his full power rankings for the remaining eight teams, and it’s not looking great for the city of Toronto.

Push
May 5, 2025
#19334
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Florida is the favorite and Toronto is the least likely to win the Stanley Cup among the final eight teams

Florida one. Dallas two. Vegas three. Washington four Edmonton five... Winnipeg six, Carolina seven. [Leafs?] Leafs eights perfect. You what? I guys I can admit Edmonton's an underdog here. And they get through Vegas and, and, and, and I come back on like if they beat Vegas, they're number one.

Florida did win the Stanley Cup as Whitney predicted them as the favorite. However, Toronto made it to the second round and took Florida to 7 games, performing better than 'least likely.'

Whitney also highlighted some veterans who are overdue for a ring, specifically pointing to a certain captain in Dallas who has been a warrior for nearly two decades.

Void
May 5, 2025
#19330
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Jamie Benn is the player who deserves a Stanley Cup more than anyone else in the league

Number one, Jamie Benn. That's kind, that's kind of my, my player right now. Who doesn't have one that, that I feel like, God, that guy deserves one. He's, I mean, I think, 16 years in 17... a warrior, a beast, a true captain, a leader, and he is done it like teammates love him. He's done it for so long that if Dallas were to get one, that's kind of my guy.

Deserving a trophy is a matter of opinion.

Who’s Back and Kentucky Derby Mess

The Kentucky Derby was a beautiful, sloppy mess in the mud, and PFT was mesmerized by the ghost-like Sandman. In Who's Back, PFT celebrated the return of Alcatraz—not for the tourists, but because Donald Trump wants to reopen the prison. This naturally led to a breakdown of why *The Rock* is the pinnacle of cinema.

Void
May 5, 2025·Who's Back
#29092
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Rock is the best movie ever made

The Rock is Back. And if you haven't seen The Rock it may, it might be the best movie ever made... It is the perfect movie. It's got everything. Sean Connery, Nick Cage, prisons, terrorists.

Purely subjective opinion on cinematic quality.

LeBron James also made the list after his camp released a report stating he wouldn't have been able to play a hypothetical Game 6 due to injury. PFT isn't buying the timing of the "narrative building."

Void
May 5, 2025·Who's Back
#19328
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James only releases post-elimination injury reports to build a protective narrative for his legacy

With LeBron it's interesting because the, the whole like you know, build, building in your narrative. Your excuse after the fact. It's something he's done a couple times... but he always has to remind us that he's injured always. And to not play a hypothetical game, it was just so extra to be like, if game six had happened tonight, yeah. He would not be playing.

While LeBron's medical status is objective, the intent behind releasing the information is a subjective interpretation.

The Kidney Stone Chronicles

It wouldn't be a Monday show without some medical trauma. Big Cat spent his Derby Saturday in the ER dealing with the return of his recurring nemesis: kidney stones. After being asked by his son if he was "eating rocks," Big Cat decided it’s time to actually listen to a professional.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am going to hire a dietician to help prevent future kidney stones

I think this one, I'll say this, I think I'm gonna start making some lifestyle changes. I'm thinking... I think I'm gonna to get a dietician. I understand. But I need someone to tell me what to do. I am not going to do that on my own volition. I need someone to basically be like, here's what you can and cannot eat.

Personal health/lifestyle claim about hiring a dietician. Cannot verify Big Cat's personal health decisions.

PFT is also trying to turn over a new leaf, or at least a head of lettuce, by promising to make one specific dietary change to avoid the same fate.

Loss
May 5, 2025
#29096
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am committing to eating one salad every single day to improve my health

I've committed to eating salad every day. Having one salad a day is a pretty good compromise that you can make with yourself.

He admits in the next breath that he already failed the commitment.

We wrapped things up with an update on Jordon, Bill Belichick's better half, who reportedly forced her way into a Super Bowl commercial just to get a bag. If you're going to use your leverage, that's how you do it.

Always remember to pay your Twitter bets or risk being labeled a loser for an entire calendar year.

nflnhl-playoffsnba-playoffskentucky-derbygolden-state-warriorshouston-rocketskidney-stones

More Takes

Void
May 5, 2025
#29090
Big CatBig Cat

The 2012 Thunder only reached the Finals because James Harden was their sixth man

[Harden] was the sixth man on that team though, wasn't he? Yeah. So it wasn't like they were counting on him for anything. No, that's that's why they were able to get the finals.

Subjective historical analysis of Harden's impact on that OKC team.
Loss
May 5, 2025
#29091
Big CatBig Cat

The Cavaliers will still win the series against the Pacers despite losing Game 1

I don't think the Cavs should panic... I think the Cavs are still gonna win the series.

The Pacers actually won this series in 7 games.
Void
May 5, 2025
#19324
HankHank

I wouldn't be worried about the Knicks even if the Celtics go down 0-2

Not worried about the Knicks. Even if we lose, I'll say it right now. If somehow we lose game one, we could lose two games and I wouldn't be worried. [Down 0-2?] Still not worried. I'll say it.

Whether he is 'worried' is subjective, but it stakes a claim on the Celtics' eventual superiority.
Void
May 5, 2025·Who's Back
#19326
Big CatBig Cat

Abdul Carter is a loser for trying to take the retired numbers of Lawrence Taylor and Phil Simms

Is Abdul Carter a loser? I it's very weird. A weird tumble guy of all time... to on day one, go into your new company and be like, I want the numbers of the two most famous guys that everybody loves. Lawrence Taylor... then he's like, all right, how about Phil Simms? No, pick your own number man.

Subjective opinion on etiquette and respect in sports.
Win
May 5, 2025
#29094
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Florida is the perfect team of rats and dirtbags that can bully anyone

Florida is just the fact they added Brad Marchand guys... I don't know if I've ever seen a player fit more perfectly into a team than the way he's kind of come into this team of rats and dirt bags. And that's a compliment by the way. And they bully teams.

The Panthers' physical style led them to a Stanley Cup victory in 2024, validating the assessment.
Loss
May 5, 2025
#29095
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Washington Capitals can physically beat up the Carolina Hurricanes in the second round

I think Washington can really kind of beat them up... I don't know if physically the, the Canes can play with Washington... Carolina fans are kind of all always all over biz... I don't even think if Carolina gets by Washington, like they can win the cup.

The Hurricanes actually beat the Islanders in the first round (not the Caps who were swept by the Rangers), so the premise of the matchup was incorrect for that specific year's bracket.
Win
May 5, 2025
#19332
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Carolina cannot win the Cup because Sebastian Aho is not a true superstar

Carolina fans are kind of all always all over biz. And I, and I gave them a bunch of props... and all those fans tell me aho aho I'm like, I love aho. But I just, he's like one little notch beneath like the true superstars. And, and so I don't, I don't even think if Carolina gets by Washington, like they can win the cup.

Carolina did not win the Cup. They beat the Capitals in the second round but lost to the Panthers 4-1 in the Eastern Conference Final. While Aho's status is debatable, the prediction that Carolina wouldn't win was correct.
Void
May 5, 2025
#19336
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Dallas is the best warm-weather hockey town in North America

I think Dallas... those playoff games. It's crazy that arena gets loud, sneaky La Kings are, are awesome... but LA and Dallas kind of stick out and the, the, the Panthers fans have come on here. They, they've made these games a complete party.

Subjective ranking of fan engagement.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers