Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Super Bowl 51 Recap and Jim Rome

Monday, February 6, 201715 takes

Super Bowl 51 recap. Was it the greatest game ever? Is Matt Ryan elite? Did Kyle Shanahan care too much about his new job? Did the Patriots win it or did the Falcons lose it? Embrace Debate and much more. Who's back of the week. Football guy of the week. Jim Rome joins the show to talk about controversies, smack offs, and our favorite game Rome vs Rome (PFT does a mean impression of him in his face). Segments include Kings stay Kings. Thoughts and Prayers, Put one in his earhole. Stay Classy, PR 101, Is Pat Riley Dead Yet and Respect The Biz - stories from our day on Radio Row.

Super Bowl 51 Recap and Jim Rome on the Jungle, Clones, and Fixes

The world just witnessed the greatest Super Bowl comeback in history, and Big Cat and PFT Commenter are here to sort through the wreckage of the Falcons' second-half collapse. While the rest of the sports world is trying to be serious, the guys are focused on the important things, like whether Matt Ryan was playing through a severe case of Super Bowl nerves and if Kyle Shanahan already had one foot in San Francisco.

Win
Feb 6, 2017
#29495
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Super Bowl 51 is the best Super Bowl of all time

Number one, right off the bat, is this the best Super Bowl of all time? ... [Big Cat] well, people forget there's never been an overtime. [PFT Commenter] That's a good point.

Widely regarded as one of, if not the greatest Super Bowl due to the unprecedented comeback and first-ever overtime.

Big Cat and PFT Commenter are convinced this wasn't just a Patriots win, but an all-time Falcons choke job. Between the Matt Ryan fumble and the refusal to just run the ball and kick a field goal late in the fourth, the Falcons handed the trophy over on a silver platter.

Void
Feb 6, 2017
#11565
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons lost Super Bowl 51 more than the Patriots won it

Maybe the biggest thing that we're going to talk about is, did the Patriots win this game or did the Falcons lose it? Ooh, I think they lost it. I think the Falcons lost it.

Subjective sports debate, though the Falcons blowing a 28-3 lead is widely considered the greatest choke in Super Bowl history.

Tom Brady gets the headlines for his fifth ring, but the guys aren't letting James White’s legendary performance go unnoticed. White was the engine that kept the comeback moving while Brady was busy shaking off a rocky start.

Loss
Feb 6, 2017
#11566
Big CatBig Cat

James White should have been the Super Bowl 51 MVP over Tom Brady

James White had a great game. Getting in on the fun. He should have been MVP. He had three touchdowns. He was all over the field. They had no answer for him. Tom Brady did the old Brett Favre. It was a participation trophy for Tom Brady. It was a lifetime achievement award.

Tom Brady was officially named MVP. While White had a historic game, Brady threw for a then-record 466 yards in the greatest comeback ever, making his win justifiable even if White was a strong candidate.

The Jungle Comes to PMT

Legendary sports talk host Jim Rome joined the show from the sidewalk outside the Super Bowl. In a true "meeting of the minds" or just three alphas shouting over a black helicopter, the guys grilled Rome on his career, his beefs, and his transition from being the king of the jungle to a careful tweeter.

Big Cat didn't hold back, immediately asking Rome about his infamous run-ins with commissioners. While Roger Goodell is usually the target, Rome still has some residual heat for the NBA's former boss.

Void
Feb 6, 2017
#11570
Jim RomeJim Rome

David Stern was a worse commissioner than Roger Goodell

Which commissioner do you think has done a worse job, Roger Goodell or David Stern when he got into that beef with you? Yeah, that's going to be a tough call... David Stern. Yeah, Stern was not happy with me that day. He was not happy with me asking him something that I've probably asked him 20 times before. [The frozen envelope].

Personal opinion and preference between two controversial commissioners.

Rome also leaned into his reputation for having strong opinions, even if he doesn't call them "hot takes." He might not be looking for a debate with Skip Bayless anytime soon, but he's got plenty of thoughts on the validity of literally every event in human history.

Loss
Feb 6, 2017
#11571
Jim RomeJim Rome

Everything in the history of the world is fixed, including every sports game

My take is, I don't know for certain, which is why I asked the question. ... Everything in the history of the world is fixed. Every game is fixed. Everything is fixed. The Bible is fixed.

This is a conspiratorial claim meant for entertainment value; it's factually incorrect but delivered as a high-conviction satirical take.

To wrap up the interview, PFT Commenter debuted a Rome-on-Rome impression that Rome himself gave a measly 1.9 rating. Despite the low score, Rome still played along with a debate on the GOAT, proving he still has that clutch gene.

Void
Feb 6, 2017
#11572
Jim RomeJim Rome

Michael Jordan is better than LeBron James because he has the clutch gene

LeBron is a fraud. He's a hot fraud. Michael Jordan's all that. He's an all that guy. Get your 32, 11, 6, bank it. More importantly, clutch gene.

This is the eternal NBA GOAT debate and cannot be definitively proven.

Who's Back and Respecting the Biz

In Who’s Back, Tiger Woods’ back is unfortunately back in the news after a withdrawal in Dubai, and Roger Goodell is officially "back" in the eyes of the show after taking a massive verbal beating from every single person in New England.

Void
Feb 6, 2017·Who's Back
#11569
Big CatBig Cat

Roger Goodell is back after taking his medicine from Patriots fans

The boos that were rained down on Roger Goodell... He stood up there. He overdosed on his medicine. I think he's back. I think it's now fair's fair.

Goodell continued to be a lightning rod for controversy, but the specific Deflategate tension peaked at this trophy presentation.

For a special Super Bowl edition of Respect the Biz, Big Cat and PFT Commenter detailed their undercover mission onto Radio Row. Armed with a fake pass featuring a Captain Crunch barcode and the name "Tony Tomsula," the guys proved that NFL security is mostly just about looking like you belong in a Hawaiian shirt.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Super Bowl security will be significantly upgraded next year after how easily we snuck in

My prediction is that next year there's going to be a major upgrade in security. Because we were able to get around way too, way too easily. ... We had the Captain Crunch barcode.

Super Bowl security generally tightens every year, and the Barstool/PMT antics historically led to more scrutiny from NFL security in subsequent years.

Finally, the guys gave a well-deserved shout-out to the halftime show, making it clear that if you didn't enjoy Lady Gaga jumping off the roof of the stadium, you're probably a globalist with a dark agenda.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Lady Gaga's Super Bowl halftime performance was stellar

Lady Gaga's halftime performance, which was stellar, by the way. Anyone who hated that, get out of my face. Stop listening to this show.

Subjective opinion on an entertainment performance.

One thing we can all agree on is that the Falcons have a long offseason of looking at that 28-3 lead ahead of them.

nflsuper-bowlpatriotsfalconstom-bradyjim-rome

More Takes

Win
Feb 6, 2017
#11567
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Brady is the greatest quarterback of all time

That's why he's the greatest quarterback of all time. No, we can say he is the greatest quarterback of all time.

Brady is widely considered the GOAT after winning his 5th ring here, and eventually a 6th and 7th.
Void
Feb 6, 2017
#11568
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Shanahan was too focused on his new head coaching job with the 49ers during the Super Bowl

Kyle Shanahan, was he too focused on his new job? Absolutely. Yes. His mind was on West Coast time. No doubt.

While subjective, this became a major talking point in the aftermath of the 28-3 collapse.
Loss
Feb 6, 2017
#29496
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFC South is the new Buffalo Bills

Is the NFC South the new Buffalo Bills? Big losers. Big losers in the South, yes. They don't win Super Bowls. Well, the Saints won one, but yeah, you know what.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Since this take, the Buccaneers (NFC South) won Super Bowl LV, largely debunking the 'don't win Super Bowls' claim for the division as a whole.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Terrell Owens not being in the Hall of Fame is the biggest joke of all time

But seriously, T.O. not being in the Hall of Fame is probably the biggest joke of all time. What is he, second most in reception yards?

TO was eventually inducted in 2018, acknowledging his statistical greatness.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Atlanta Falcons might not actually be good

Are the falcons good? I don't know... they had some bad losses. They lost the chiefs, the chargers too, right?... The Falcons might not be good. Actually, if you look at the first half of the Super Bowl, they were good. Second half, not so good. You know what I'm doing? I'm crossing them off my list.

The Falcons went 10-6 in 2017 and won a playoff game, proving they were still 'good' even if they regressed.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mark Wahlberg leaving the Super Bowl early was a bad move

Marky Mark, Miami Heat fan slash New England Patriot fan. Left in, what, like 10 minutes left in the fourth quarter? Yeah, he left really early... how about you respect your favorite player, I assume, Tom Brady, and his ability to come back in a game. That's a bad look... that was a fucked up move for you to leave.

Wahlberg was widely mocked for leaving early. He later claimed he left because his son was feeling sick.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers