Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

The Boys Are Back In Studio, NFL 2025 QB Tiers, Mt Rushmore Of Minor Embarrassing Moments, Is Joey Chestnut A Top 5 Athlete Of All Time? + Catching Up After Vacation

Monday, July 7, 202518 takes

The boys are back after a 10 day break from being together so we went no guest to catch up with each other. We talk Joey Chestnut greatness (-), Lebron possibly going back to Cleveland (-). Baseball talk and All Star Snubs (-). Our Annual QB Tier list (-). Who's back of the week including Tiffany Gomas and Bradley Beal maybe getting traded (-). Mt Rushmore of minor embarrassing things (-) plus we recap our week off (-).

QB Tiers, Joey Chestnut GOAT Status, and Mt. Rushmore of Minor Embarrassments

The boys are back in town after a ten-day hiatus, and the studio energy is at an all-time high. Everyone is tan, Max is looking more Italian than ever after dodging sunscreen all week, and the natural chemistry is firing on all cylinders as they catch up on everything they missed while raw-dogging the sun on the 4th of July.

The Greatness of Joey Chestnut

Big Cat opened the show with a heavy hitter, declaring that we are officially living in the greatest era of competitive eating. After watching Chestnut dominate yet again, Big Cat is ready to put him on the Mount Rushmore of all-time sports legends.

Void
Jul 7, 2025
#11731
Big CatBig Cat

Joey Chestnut is a top five athlete of all time

I really do think that Joey Chestnut might be the greatest athlete of all time. I actually like broke it down... however you slice it, he's like top five athlete of all time.

This is an inherently subjective ranking of athletes across disparate disciplines.

PFT took the hypothetical even further, debating a race between Chestnut and Usain Bolt that involves a mandatory hot dog stop. While Bolt has the speed, PFT is banking on the lung capacity and sheer grit of the Glizzy GOAT over a longer distance.

Void
Jul 7, 2025
#11733
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joey Chestnut would beat Usain Bolt in a mile race if they both had to eat a hot dog first

Usain Bolt has literally never run a mile in his entire life... I think it switches at a mile. I think Joey Chestnut beats him.

This is a hypothetical scenario that was never tested. It's an untestable thought experiment.

LeBron to Cleveland and MLB Snubs

LeBron James has been acting extremely suspicious in Akron lately. Between working out at the Cavs facility and wearing "Welcome Home" gear, Big Cat is convinced the King is planning one final return to Ohio.

Push
Jul 7, 2025
#11734
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is actively trying to work his way back to the Cleveland Cavaliers

I don't know, is LeBron, is he trying to work his way back to Cleveland? I think that would be good. Yeah. I would like to see it... he's doing this on purpose to get everyone talking about it and then he's gonna do it. I think he's gonna do it.

LeBron James has not yet returned to Cleveland as of Feb 2026, but there is 'rampant speculation' and multiple reports suggesting he will return to the Cavaliers for the 2026-27 season. The rumor mill Big Cat described has become reality.

Switching to the diamond, PFT had some choice words for the Washington Nationals front office. Firing Mike Rizzo right before the draft felt like a slap in the face to a guy who was never given the budget to keep his superstars.

Void
Jul 7, 2025
#11735
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Firing Nationals GM Mike Rizzo because of the team's record is nonsensical due to budget constraints

Firing a GM because you didn't give him enough money to spend on good food... That's like divorcing your wife because you got fat.

Subjective opinion on management quality vs. ownership spending.

Max also chimed in on the MLB All-Star snubs, particularly the omission of Trea Turner, while the group collectively shuddered at the thought of the "Ass Eating" pact potentially coming to fruition if Christian Yelich wins the Home Run Derby.

Void
Jul 7, 2025
#11740
Big CatBig Cat

If Christian Yelich wins the Home Run Derby, Pardon My Take is officially over

If Christian competes in the home run derby and wins the home run derby... you know that your job would be, you wouldn't have a job. Why? Because the show would end. The last scene of this show would be us eating each other's ass. We can't come back from that. It'd be over.

Yelich did not win the Home Run Derby (Cal Raleigh won), so the conditional premise of this humorous take was never triggered.

The 2025 QB Tier List

It’s July, which means it’s time for the annual exercise in making every fan base in America furious. Big Cat and PFT broke down their QB tiers, and while some picks were consensus, others were designed to start a civil war.

Void
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#11741
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is the best quarterback in the NFL

I think Josh Allen should be one. I had Josh Allen one, Patrick Mahomes two, Lamar three.

Subjective ranking of players' current skill levels.

Hank, ever the contrarian, wasn't sold on the defending champ's longevity, suggesting that the era of Mahomes dominance might be showing some cracks.

Loss
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#11743
HankHank

Patrick Mahomes might be washed

Mahomes might be washed. He just discussed, he didn't play great at the end of the year. They choked in the Super Bowl.

Calling a prime Patrick Mahomes 'washed' is historically and statistically incorrect.

The most controversial part of the list? The ranking of Dak Prescott. After years of being the "17th best QB," the guys decided the Dak era of mediocrity has officially plummeted him down the list into the "Accurate Ranking" tier.

Void
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#11747
Big CatBig Cat

Dak Prescott is the 24th best quarterback in the NFL

Make the accurate ranking tier. Just be 23 Daniel Jones, 24 Dak... I googled QB Rankings for 2025 Pro Football Focus. Where do you think they had Dak Prescott? 18, 17... I couldn't make him the 17th best anymore.

Subjective ranking compared to league peers.

Who’s Back and Mt. Rushmore of Minor Embarrassments

Who's Back featured a hilarious breakdown of Jerry O'Connell’s investigative journalism at Tiffany Gomas's house, confirming that Hank did indeed leave a permanent mark on her wall. Zach also introduced the legend of Brian Steele, the lawyer who seems physically incapable of losing a case.

Void
Jul 7, 2025·Who's Back
#11753
ZacZac

Brian Steele is the greatest defense attorney of all time

Brian Steele might just be the greatest defense attorney of all time... he has beat racketeering charges for his clients for the second time... Young Thug... Sean Combs.

Subjective 'GOAT' claim for a legal professional.

The show wrapped with a Mount Rushmore of Minor Embarrassing moments. We’ve all been there: the public trip-and-fall, the accidental wave to a stranger, or the absolute horror of a grown man trying to look cool while wearing a bike helmet.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

It is embarrassing for a grown man to wear a bike helmet

You just can't, you just look like a fucking fool and you look like an idiot. Especially when you get off the bike and you're like, walking without the bike.

Purely a matter of personal opinion on fashion and social etiquette.

Big Cat and Zach bonded over the shared shame of physical activity, noting that almost any form of running or getting hit in the head with a ball makes a grown man look like a toddler in the worst way possible.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Getting hit in the head with a ball is always embarrassing regardless of the situation

Getting hit in the head with a ball, no matter how it happens, is always embarrassing. Like I'm saying, you could be playing catch it hits you in the head. That's very embarrassing. But even when we're playing hoops out here and like everyone's shooting around and you're not even looking and the ball hits you in the back of the head, you're embarrassed.

Subjective feeling of embarrassment.

It's good to have the guys back in the lab before they head to Tahoe for what promises to be a legendary Chill Week.

nfljoey-chestnutlebron-jamesmlb-all-starmount-rushmoreqb-rankings

More Takes

Open
Jul 7, 2025·Who's Back
#11751
Big CatBig Cat

The Philadelphia 76ers will win the 2026 NBA Finals

I'm gonna match and double. I'm gonna say they're gonna win the finals. They're gonna win a chip. Love it.

The 2025-26 NBA season has not happened.
Push
Jul 7, 2025
#11737
MaxMax

Trea Turner not receiving an MLB All-Star reserve spot is a snub

Trea Turner leads league in hits and he didn't even get a reserve spot... say what? Christopher Sanchez should have been in over MacKenzie Gore. That makes no sense.

Turner was eventually named an injury replacement/reserve, partially vindicating the 'snub' talk, but the initial roster excluded him.
Void
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#11745
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jaden Daniels is the fifth best quarterback in the NFL

I watched an hour of his highlights in the 4th of July... I think he's five. I think just, yeah, he's five.

Ranking Daniels 5th is subjective. The Commanders had a terrible 2025 with injuries to Daniels.
Open
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#23687
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams has to prove himself before being ranked as a top NFL quarterback

I have Caleb [Williams] down. He's gotta prove it. He's gotta prove it... he just was on a bad team and Jaden Daniels was significantly better.

This is a wait-and-see stance on a rookie's performance.
Loss
Jul 7, 2025·Picks
#23688
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Daniel Jones might make a successful comeback this season

I think Daniel Jones might come back... I've been thinking about Daniel Jones a lot the last couple weeks... He spent six months with Kevin O'Connell. What's better? Spending six months with Kevin O'Connell, or spending six months with Brian Schottenheimer?

PFT predicted Daniel Jones might make a successful comeback in 2025. Jones signed with the Colts on a 1-year deal and was named starting QB, but tore his Achilles in December 2025. The Colts went 8-9. It was not a successful comeback.
Open
Jul 7, 2025·Who's Back
#11749
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Gallagher brothers should break up during the Oasis reunion tour to stay true to their brand

I would be disappointed if they didn't break up during the tour. That means that they've changed. And I want the same Oasis. If you're buying tickets for this, part of the rush is spending all that money... not knowing if that concert's ever gonna go.

The tour hasn't happened yet.
Void
MaxMax

It's embarrassing for a person to use an umbrella even though it's better than getting wet

Holding an umbrella... even though it's obviously way better than being wet... there's something about holding an umbrella that just sucks.

Subjective opinion on social embarrassment.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers