Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Chase Young trade is a win for both the Bears and the 49ers

I actually think [the Chase Young trade] is good for both the Bears and the Niners. The Niners get like a rental. Don't think they're gonna extend him... and he has to slot in underneath [Nick] Bosa.

Young was productive for the Niners during their Super Bowl run, and the trade allowed the Bears to clear space and focus on Montez Sweat.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Eberflus doesn't deserve credit for 'overcoming adversity' when the adversity is his own bad coaching

Ryan Poles also credited Matt Eberflus for taking on adversity and overcoming adversity. I don't think you get credit when the adversity is being a bad coach. Like he's doing a great job coaching a bad coach team. Yeah, but he's the coach. Imagine having to coach a bad coach team that you made a bad coach team. That's adversity.

This is an inherently subjective critique of coaching narratives.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Bet on any team playing the Bears to win their division

I've told everyone, If, you want to If you like the Saints this week. Which you should. 'cause they'll beat the Bears. Bet 'em to win the, the, the division. Now's the time. It's a free win bet. Every team who play, every team who plays the Bears just bet that team to win the division. 'cause you know, you'll get at least better odds once they beat the Bears.

This is a strategy take rather than a specific prediction, but the Saints (the team they were discussing) did not win the division; the Buccaneers did.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The relief in the Raiders' locker room after Josh McDaniels' firing will be insane

Josh McDaniels has to be the number one guy... thank God that asshole's gone. Like the relief in that locker room has to be insane.

Reports following the firing confirmed significant player celebration and a major shift in locker room atmosphere.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills vs. Bengals Sunday night game is a must-win for both teams

I think it's a must win for both these teams. Separation Sunday. Joe Burrow looks healthy. Everything looks like it's clicking. I'm so excited for this game.

The Bengals won the game, significantly boosting their momentum at the time, while the Bills' struggles continued.
Void
Clinton PortisClinton Portis

The 'running back by committee' approach is killing back pay and star development

A lot of those guys are so talented that teams only highlighted, you know, you just highlight that specialty. Instead of allowing those guys to become the total package, like force those guys to be three down backs. Everybody is kind of running back by committee... that's the reason why [they don't get paid]. 'cause you don't get to display an, it's higher body of work.

A veteran player's subjective analysis of league trends.
Void
Clinton PortisClinton Portis

The 2001 Miami Hurricanes' defense was harder to play against than any college opponent

My competition was, we gotta figure out how we kick Ed Reed ass today. We gotta figure out how we kick Philip Buchanan ass today. That's Wilford. Like Jonathan Vilma... That was our competition. It was the defense... our practices used to be so crazy... If, if I walked up and one of you guys walked up, I'm like, that's a wasted rep to me.

Recounting personal experience of practice intensity.
Void
Clinton PortisClinton Portis

The Redskins missed a window for a Super Bowl run by not hiring Gregg Williams to replace Joe Gibbs

I honestly think [if Gregg Williams took over]... that team was so put together from Coach Gibbs and Coach Williams' philosophy was kind of that hardnosed, just like Coach Gibbs. I think we had an opportunity for more playoffs and possibly to make a run with the team built the way that it was. And then once you switched to the new guy [Jim Zorn], it was downhill.

This is a counterfactual historical opinion that cannot be definitively proven.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially all in on the San Francisco 49ers

I would like to officially announce I'm all in on the Niners now. I Trent Williams, chase Young Kyle Shanahan. I said this on, on Monday's show. But if you're a fan of a shitty franchise, the best you can do sometimes is to just root for your guys to win somewhere. So I'm, I'm gonna put a big future on the Niners. They're my team.

The Niners made the Super Bowl but lost, so while they were a good bet, they didn't win the title PFT implies with 'big future'.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is the GOAT of being a bad teammate and employee.

James Harden... he's got GOAT tendencies because he somehow has gotten traded now three times where everyone's like, he's got no leverage... he deserves at least respect for being how bad of like a teammate and employee is. Like he's the GOAT at that.

This is a subjective evaluation of a player's reputation and career conduct.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Oregon is currently the best team in the Pac-12 despite their loss to Washington

I do think Oregon, what they did in Utah on Saturday, like that doesn't happen to Utah. They bullied him. Oregon. It's weird because even though they lost to Washington, they look like they're the best team in that conference right now.

Washington beat Oregon for a second time in the Pac-12 Championship game, proving they were the superior team in that conference for 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney deserves at least one bad year given the high expectations he's fulfilled at Clemson.

Dabo came, they won more than 10 games seven years in a row, won two national titles. Bad year. I think he deserves at least one bad year.

This is a subjective opinion on how a coach should be treated by fans/media.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Hockey coaches are the second most important in sports, behind football but ahead of baseball and basketball.

Football's one... let's put hockey number two behind football... I would say baseball's in front of hockey—actually let's put hockey number two... Basketball's the last one.

This is an inherently subjective ranking of sports philosophy.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Phil Kessel has had a better career than Connor McDavid if they both retired today.

I guess Phil Kessel [if he retired today]. But McDavid was more dominant. But if you're looking at a career, I mean, he broke the Ironman streak and has three Stanley Cups and 400 or 500 goals. So Kessel.

Subjective comparison of two different types of greatness.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Brock Bowers is better than Rob Gronkowski and Travis Kelce

I can't believe how good he, like I, I think it could be, he could be better than Kelsey and Gronk... that guy's insane.

Too early to definitively judge a pro career, but Bowers was a high first-round pick. This remains subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins was on the verge of the MVP conversation before his season-ending injury

The big story from this game was the unfortunate injury to Kirk Cousins, which sucks beyond belief... he also was playing awesome ball. Like he was on the precipice of being in the MVP conversation because the Vikings started to win games... and it all comes crashing down with the Achilles.

Cousins led the NFL in passing touchdowns (18) at the time of his injury and had a 103.8 passer rating, putting him firmly in the statistical conversation.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers are officially a bad football team

I foolishly thought this was the spot to back the Packers because it was the Vikings off a big win against the Niners. The Packers look terrible. Turns out the Packers are just dog shit... yeah, the Packers are bad. Yeah, they're officially a bad team.

The Packers eventually righted the ship, finishing 9-8 and beating the Cowboys in a playoff game, meaning they weren't 'dog shit' for the full season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Howell is the franchise quarterback for the Washington Commanders

Sam Howell is the guy. He was amazing today. He might've been the best quarterback in the NFL this entire week... Sam Howell is the fucking guy. He's the most guy ever. Oh, okay. He is the guy. The guy a guy... he's the goddamn motherfucking guy bitch.

Howell was eventually benched later in the season for Jacoby Brissett and the Commanders traded him to Seattle in the offseason to draft Jayden Daniels.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers' recipe for winning ugly games only works if they make plays in the fourth quarter

The Steelers have a recipe with this Steelers team on how to win games. And it's to make it ugly play defense and then have this heroic fourth quarter, like couple balls bounce your way... When the recipe works like three quarters of the way and then it fails in the fourth because [Pickett] got hurt, they just look like a bad football team.

The Steelers finished the season 10-7 and made the playoffs despite an ugly offense, largely validating the 'winning ugly' identity.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Tennessee Titans should not be allowed to wear Houston Oilers throwback uniforms

The Tennessee Titans should not be allowed to [wear Oilers uniforms]. It's bullshit... They gave up the rights to that when the team moved and they decided to rebrand... The franchise I understand, can move around. It sucks, but it can. But the colors stay.

This is a subjective opinion on NFL branding rules.
Void
MemesMemes

Zach Wilson is incapable of playing good football in the rain

I think [Zach Wilson] would've played better if it didn't rain. I said it a couple weeks ago. Can't play in the rain. Yeah, that's true. You did say that. You called that he can't play in the rain.

Wilson famously struggled in rain games, including against the Patriots and Jaguars earlier in his career, though he struggled in most other conditions as well.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Seahawks are a legitimate, for-real football team

I think the Seahawks are for real... the Seahawks have actually found themselves in that position where they, they're in first place in the division... I did not see the 49ers losing. They are in first place right now.

The Seahawks finished 9-8 and missed the playoffs, while the 49ers reclaimed the division and went to the Super Bowl. They were not 'for real' as division contenders.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The San Francisco 49ers are officially in trouble

The Niners are in trouble... You can't lose a can't lose... Their defense has been bad the last two weeks... The Niners defense is the issue. Yeah. I don't think Brock pa, he didn't play that poorly today... their defense just stunk.

The 49ers eventually turned it around, finished as the 1 seed in the NFC, and reached the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cincinnati Bengals are back and healthy for the season

The Bengals are all the way back. These are the Bengals that If, you were a Bengals fan... This was the Bengals announcing their back because Joe Burrow was outta this world good... He's healthy. And this is what you want from the Bengals.

Joe Burrow suffered a season-ending wrist injury just two weeks later in a Thursday night game against the Ravens, ending the 'Bengals are back' narrative for 2023.
Loss
HankHank

Francis Ngannou actually won the fight against Tyson Fury

Tyson Fury, they boxed Tyson Fury, Francis Ngannou this weekend... Francis Ngannou also has the, the perfect, he like champion fighters... Split decision. But a lot of people were saying that he won.

The official result was a split decision victory for Tyson Fury, making Ngannou the technical loser regardless of public opinion.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tyson Fury was embarrassingly out of shape for the Ngannou fight

Tyson Fury always looks a little bit outta shape, but he looked so outta shape next to Ngannou. Just like they look like different species... he was the heaviest he's ever been was he? That's what they said. Which bullshit for the announcers to say that.

Fury weighed in at 277 lbs, which was actually a few pounds lighter than his previous fight against Derek Chisora (268 lbs), though he did appear less toned than usual.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Todd Bowles is a creative but poor head coach who bores fans

Todd Bowles, he's boring and not good, which is the worst combination. But he does find creative ways to be bad. Whatever that was at the end of the half. You were was a very creative way to be bad.

This is subjective, but Bowles led the Bucs to a division title and a playoff victory in 2023, making the 'not good' label debatable.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Al Michaels is the perfect broadcaster for Thursday Night Football because the games are usually bad

Maybe Al Michaels is the perfect guy for Thursday night football. Yeah. Because like, you don't want to peak too early. No. You want to kind of ease your way into the weekend.

Broadcasting preference is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars vs. Steelers game is the best matchup of the early Sunday slate

I think the best game is Jaguar Steelers in the noon slate. Jaguar's about to go on their buy, Steelers off a big win. Mike Tomlin is a home dog... it's a terrible towel statement game.

The Jags beat the Steelers 20-10 in a game that was mostly defensive; while it had some intrigue, other games that day (like Bengals-Niners) were arguably 'better' in quality.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Warren is a great running back and the Steelers need to give him the ball more

The Steelers are finally realizing that Jalen Warren is really fucking good... give Jalen Warren the ball more. Maybe make Najee Harris like a junior tight end.

Warren finished the 2023 season with over 1,000 total yards and was widely considered the most explosive back on the roster, proving Big Cat's assessment correct.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts' knee injury is a significant concern that is affecting his play

I think that Jalen Hurt's knee is a problem. And he also was asked about it... he said, 'I hope not.' The fact that we're even talking about it is kind of an issue. I just, he's throwing a lot of picks. Fumbles. The knee.

Hurts played through the injury but his rushing production dipped and the Eagles eventually collapsed in December, validating the concern that something was 'off'.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Arthur Smith is a sneaky genius for limiting Bijan Robinson's touches to keep him fresh

Could Arthur Smith be a sneaky genius? Could he be saying we just spent a lot of money on this first round pick running back. Don't put too many miles on him early in the season. Bijan is gonna look that much faster late in the year.

Arthur Smith was fired at the end of the season partly due to offensive underperformance and poor usage of star players. Robinson's production did not significantly peak later.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Trent Williams is the most important player on the 49ers offense

I think Trent Williams is [the most important player on the offense] for sure. Christian McCaffrey at 85% without Deebo Samuel and without Trent Williams... things look different.

Inherently subjective as it's an opinion on player importance.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Seahawks defense is genuinely elite and for real

I do believe in the Seahawks defense. I feel like they are, they're for real. They're, I'm gonna say it, really good Seahawks defense for real.

Seattle's defense fell apart late in the season, finishing 30th in total yards allowed and 25th in points allowed. They were not for real.
Void
Kyle LongKyle Long

Andy Reid understands the offensive line position as well as any coach in the NFL

Andy Reid understands the offensive line position as well as anybody I've played around. He also gives the keys to the car to Andy Heck... Andy Reid knows that that's the strength of the football team. He talks to the lineman. He knows the lineman better than anybody.

This is a subjective assessment from a professional peer, widely supported by Reid's background as an offensive line coach and his historical success.
Void
Kyle LongKyle Long

The Chiefs have the best interior offensive line in the league

If we're gonna go group [of interior linemen], I'm gonna go Kansas City. Group is Kansas City. Because you're only as strong as the guy next to you. Tackle the tackle the inside three, they're great.

All three players were Pro Bowlers or All-Pros in this window; the unit is consistently ranked as top-3 by PFF and other analysts.
Void
Kyle LongKyle Long

Offensive line sacks should be timed; after 5 seconds, it's the quarterback's fault

I think after five seconds it should be considered a tackle for loss [instead of a sack]... these dbs are supposed to cover for 10 seconds. That shouldn't be a completion against me.

This is a proposed rule/stat change, not a verifiable fact.
Win
Kyle LongKyle Long

The Bears must pay cornerback Jalen Johnson his contract extension

Pay Jalen Johnson. Lose the orange sleeves. Pay Jalen Johnson. Yes. Pay Jalen Johnson. I remember Joey, our Cap guy... I said, 'How much does [Jamie Collins] make?' He told me, I said, 'fucking watch this.' ... You sign early and then you get hurt, you're still taken care of.

The Bears did eventually pay Johnson, signing him to a 4-year, $76 million extension in March 2024 after he earned Second-team All-Pro honors.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I have a rational confidence that I could pass the multiple-choice portion of the Bar Exam without studying

I have a rational confidence that I could pass the multiple choice part [of the bar exam]. If I studied I could definitely do it... I'm good at reading a test question and figuring out what they're trying to ask me. I've watched enough SVU I think to pass the bar exam.

PFT immediately goes 1-for-3 on sample questions provided by Big Cat, suggesting his confidence is indeed delusional.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The quick turnarounds of the Diamondbacks and Rangers are a testament to why fans should never give up on their teams

The Texas Rangers were 60 and 102. The Arizona Diamondbacks were 52 and 110. It's insane. This is what sports are about. If you're a fan, the ability to have your franchise turn that quickly... it's a true testament. This is why you stick with your team because a quick turnaround like this is right around the corner.

Both teams reached the 2023 World Series after being bottom-dwellers in 2021, proving his point about quick turnarounds in modern MLB.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The MLB Wild Card format is great because it allows long shots like the Diamondbacks to make the World Series

So for everybody that's saying, I mean, Dodgers fans that are saying that the new wild card format is [bullshit], that they should go back. Well, one of the, one of the teams got to the World Series... because I love, I love long shots. If your team's not in it, it's hard to, to not root for a long shot and an underdog.

The Diamondbacks did reach the World Series as a 6-seed, proving the format enables long-shot runs.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I love that the Rangers spent a massive amount of money to buy a winning team

I also love on the other side, the Rangers, they spent a lot of money and Astros fans being extra salty... Isn't that exactly what every fan wants their team to do? Yeah. I want my team to spend all the money every year, especially in baseball, when there's no real salary cap. Just spend it all.

The Rangers' heavy spending on Seager, Semien, and pitching directly led to their title, making the 'buying wins' strategy objectively successful in this case.
Void
MaxMax

Every game for the rest of my life is a must-win

Every game ever. For the rest of my life is a must win.

This is a personal philosophy/vow that cannot be factually proven right or wrong.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs are the only truly dominant team in the NFL as the NFC is wide open

The 49ers for the first five games felt like they were unbeatable. Now the NFC feels like it's very wide open, like even more wide open than it was before. And I, I don't think there's any like, truly dominant team outside of the Kansas City Chiefs.

The Chiefs did go on to win the Super Bowl, proving they were the most dominant team, while the NFC remained a battle between the Niners, Lions, and Eagles.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

James Franklin is a loser who cannot win the big game

James Franklin loser because he can't win the big game. Yeah... James Franklin now is one in nine verse Ohio State. Three in 16 verse top 10 teams.

Franklin's record against top-ranked opponents remained poor throughout the 2023 season, including a loss to Michigan.
Win
Dan OrlovskyDan Orlovsky

Matthew Stafford is throwing the ball as well as he ever has in his career

Stafford is throwing the absolute piss out of the football. It's, I mean, he's throwing it just as good as maybe he's ever thrown it.

Stafford finished the 2023 season with a Pro Bowl nod and led the Rams to the playoffs, statistically supporting Orlovsky's eye test.
Win
Dan OrlovskyDan Orlovsky

The Steelers offense has a complete lack of creativity and relies entirely on George Pickens

Kenny Pickett in Pittsburgh... if they didn't throw the ball to George Pickens, they'd have nothing. All they're doing is throwing back shoulder fades to George Pickens. So there's such a lack of creativity in Pittsburgh. There's definitely a disservice.

The Steelers eventually fired OC Matt Canada mid-season due to these exact issues, validating Orlovsky's assessment of the scheme.
Void
Dan OrlovskyDan Orlovsky

Jared Goff and Kirk Cousins are both top 5 'Mid' quarterbacks in the league

Number one, Dak Prescott for sure. Jared Goff... Kirk Cousins for sure. Baker Mayfield. And Geno Smith. This would be my top five guys that are like, again, I think that those guys could play as high as like a top seven, top eight, top nine quarterback. Or if, you know, my tackle's out and my number one receiver's not there, I might play as a top 12 or top 13 dude.

Highly subjective ranking of QB tiers.
Void
Dan OrlovskyDan Orlovsky

Colony Grill in Fairfield, CT is the best pizza in the world

Number one pizza is Colony Grill. Yes. No questions asked in Fairfield though. It's gotta be the one in Fairfield.

Pizza preference is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens are a true Super Bowl contender

If the Ravens could ever figure out that step on the throat mentality, they could be a true Super Bowl contender. And this was the first game where it's like they went, you know, playing against a very good Lions team and completely obliterated.

The Ravens went on to secure the #1 seed in the AFC, proving Big Cat's assessment that they were legitimate contenders.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers