Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
RA
Rick Ankiel

As a pitcher, I would have definitely struck myself out as a hitter

Could you strike out you at your best as a hitter without even with blindfolded probably? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, definitely strike me out. Throw the Hammer High fastball.

This is a hypothetical self-assessment from a professional two-way athlete.
Push
RA
Rick Ankiel

David Ross will be a successful manager because he won't let superstars get bigger than the team

David [Ross] has always been that leader on the team anyway... what they did was was you know, they didn't let a superstar get outside of the team. So I think when you understand what he was as a player who he was him stepping into the manager role, it's not I don't think it's really going to be much different for him.

Ross managed the Cubs from 2020-2023, leading them to one playoff appearance in the shortened 2020 season but ultimately being replaced by Craig Counsell after failing to make the playoffs in three full seasons.
Void
Mike FlorioMike Florio

The NFL arranged Colin Kaepernick's workout as a legal strategy to prevent a second lawsuit

I really do think that they are worried they're going to get another lawsuit filed by Colin Kaepernick... It doesn't feel like a genuine attempt to help the guy. It feels like some sort of strategy... to make the league look better.

The workout ended in a location dispute and Kaepernick remained unsigned, supporting the theory that it was more of a PR/legal maneuver than a genuine job offer.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

George Kittle is the best tight end in the NFL

They were missing George Kittle though... that is a big loss because he's probably the best tight end in the NFL.

Kittle was an All-Pro in 2019, making this a highly defensible and common elite ranking at the time.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson is the one player I would trust most with the ball late in a game.

He is for my money the number one guy and I know it kind of spits in the face of the fact that he threw an interception. He is the one guy who I would want trust the most with the ball down late in the game.

Wilson's clutchness is a matter of opinion, though he lead the NFL in fourth-quarter comebacks in 2019.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Monday night is for cleaning up your life, not drinking and eating wings

I'm more confused to your Monday night like Monday night is for watching football and cleaning up your life not drinking and eating what planet are you? Monday night is not your get your act together sitting at home watching money. Football with beers and wings. That's the cleanup game brother.

This is a subjective lifestyle preference.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Monday night is for easing yourself back into the work week with beers

Incorrect Monday night is ease yourself back into the work week taper off from your Sunday and your Saturday. I'm drinking.

Subjective lifestyle preference.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jackass is the greatest humor of all time.

Jackass is the greatest humor of all time when they fart baby powder in each other's faces... so fucking funny and I'm not being sarcastic whatsoever. Jackass is a masterpiece.

The quality of humor is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes has officially let the Bears off the hook for passing on him by liking a tweet defending the Mitchell Trubisky pick.

Patrick Mahomes liked that tweet... Patrick Mahomes is basically letting Ryan Pace off the hook. He has acknowledged that it was not the right choice for him to be drafted by the Bears and go to Chicago and get ruined.

This is a satirical interpretation of social media activity by a frustrated fan.
Void
Jerry RiceJerry Rice

I would have cut my own finger off like Ronnie Lott to avoid missing any playing time

They told me that story man and I was like, wow, did he actually do that? For real? For real? Did he didn't want to miss any time. So he decided to tell them to just you know, nip the edge... [Big Cat: Would you have done the same?] Without any hesitation. No. Okay. There you go.

This is a subjective claim about his own dedication.
Void
Jerry RiceJerry Rice

Modern NFL players do not commit to their craft as hard as players did in the past.

I think players, they thought I was crazy and they don't have to do [that training] anymore. It's a lot different now and I think guys they just don't—maybe that's not right for me to say—they just don't commit to their craft like we did back in the day.

The comparative work ethic of different eras is an unprovable opinion.
Void
Jerry RiceJerry Rice

It is harder to catch a spiral from a left-handed quarterback than a right-handed one.

It is harder to catch a spiral from a lefty. The ball spins a different direction. I had a trainer that was a lefty and he threw me so many balls... I had never caught a ball from a lefty and I had to retrain. It just became natural eventually.

This is a subjective experience from one of the greatest catchers of all time.
Void
Jerry RiceJerry Rice

Walter Payton is the greatest football player in Mississippi history

All time I love I love sweetness. Okay. Number one. I will say then myself. [Big Cat: That's a very smart classy move].

This is a subjective ranking of legends.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Astros' sign-stealing is blatant cheating and disgusting

The Astros have been cheating and cheating a lot... it's blatant cheating. There's I like baseball when there is like a little He's been ship a little this little that... but this seems like they were actually using high like high-tech cameras in the Outfield yet relaying it to The Dugout and real time... which is so blatant lie cheat ice gusting.

The MLB investigation confirmed the Astros used a camera system and trash-can banging to steal signs in 2017.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Astros scandal makes the Nationals' 2019 World Series win more impressive

This makes the Nationals world series title even more impressive. Yeah the fact that they were able to beat him. While they're eating Cheetos... 60% of the Astros runs were scored in the first inning before the Nationals would change how they were doing their signs.

Subjective interpretation of the difficulty of winning against a cheating opponent.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Having pictures with professional cheerleaders on your dating profile is a normal way for guys to show they can act around attractive women.

Taking pictures with professional cheerleaders... and slapping that all over every single social media thing that you have is just part of being a guy. You want to show that you know how to act normal around attractive women, even if they were paid to be there.

This is a humorous commentary on dating app tropes.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A boyfriend yelling at kids on Call of Duty shows passion and means he's a keeper.

Keep him. I think it shows he's got passion. If he wasn't swearing at people, that means he would be good at Call of Duty and that means that he puts in way too much time. You want your boyfriend in that perfect zone where he wants to play video games but then gets smoked so bad that he's like 'Fuck this, I'm out.'

Relationship advice is inherently subjective.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings can beat any team in the NFC

The Vikings definitely need to be taken for real in terms of the NFC. Like they are a team that could beat anyone in my mind. I don't think there's one team in the NFC where you're like, man, that team [is untouchable] besides maybe the 49ers.

The Vikings won a playoff game against the Saints but were soundly beaten by the 49ers in the Divisional round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Freddie Kitchens is a legitimately 'dumb, dumb person'

Do you think Freddie just outsmarts himself all the time? No, I think he's legitimately a dumb, dumb person.

Subjective opinion on a coach's intelligence, though Kitchens was fired after just one season due to poor results and decision-making.
Loss
HankHank

The Lions should realistically be over .500

And the Lions got fucked over by the refs twice. They should realistically be over .500.

The Lions finished the 2019 season 3-12-1, far below .500 even accounting for officiating.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brian Flores should be in the Coach of the Year conversation over Frank Reich

I think Brian Flores should be mentioned before Frank Reich in Coach of the Year conversations. [Big Cat: For winning with a tanking team.] Yes. He does more with less.

Neither coach won; John Harbaugh won NFL Coach of the Year in 2019. Flores did receive some votes after finishing 5-11 with a poor roster.
Void
Herm EdwardsHerm Edwards

The most important people to recruit in a living room are the mom and grandma

It's mom and grandma. There's no doubt about that now... They want to know the man in charge, is he going to make sure that he's in good hands?

This is a subjective expertise-based opinion on recruiting strategy.
Push
Warren SharpWarren Sharp

The Buffalo Bills are fraudulent because their run defense is weak

Buffalo... you can run on that defense. So I'm going to be interested to see this weekend if the Cleveland Browns can help support Baker Mayfield by running the football a little bit on the Buffalo Bills defense.

The Bills finished the season 10-6 and made the playoffs, though they did lose to the Browns that weekend 19-16.
Loss
Warren SharpWarren Sharp

Kyle Allen is the best backup quarterback currently playing in the NFL

It's definitely got to be Kyle Allen to me... from an ability to make the throws at this level, he's got that ability to make those throws more so than most of those other guys that you mentioned [Minshew, Moore, etc].

Kyle Allen's career stalled significantly after 2019, proving to be a career backup rather than a top-tier starter.
Win
Warren SharpWarren Sharp

The Steelers offense has no confidence in Mason Rudolph

They came out with the wildcat... to me that speaks of we don't have a lot of confidence in this guy... they spent our time teaching our running backs to throw the football in this Wildcat grouping... the team doesn't have a lot of confidence in him.

Rudolph was eventually benched for Duck Hodges later in the 2019 season.
Void
Warren SharpWarren Sharp

Russell Wilson is currently the best quarterback in the NFL

Russ is the best quarterback in the NFL right now from passer rating, from yards per attempt, from I think he's like second best in completion percentage above expectation when he's under pressure.

Lamar Jackson won the MVP unanimously in 2019, though Wilson was widely considered the second-best or the most efficient for the first half of the season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

NFL coaches who challenge pass interference are fucking morons

If you're a coach and you challenge pass interference you are a fucking moron. All that the rule has done is just figured out which coaches were dumb and it's given more time for advertisements for the NFL.

The rule was so poorly implemented and the overturn rate was so low that it was widely considered a failure and was removed after one season.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Daniel Jones is just a slightly shittier update of the Eli Manning model

Daniel Jones, who is he really is Eli Manning if Eli Manning like he just a little bit shittier version. They updated the model and he has the same type of fumbles interceptions. He can run a little bit.

Daniel Jones has continued to struggle with turnovers (fumbles and interceptions) throughout his career, mirroring Eli's career-long trend.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If you are down 14 points and score a touchdown, you should always go for two

I understand that when you're down 14 and score a touchdown, you should go for two. That's not a brag. I just understand the math, but I think people—coaches now—are getting [criticized] more for being conservative and it's like flipped on its head.

Modern NFL analytics largely support going for two when down 14 after scoring a touchdown to maximize win probability.
Win
HankHank

The word 'Boomer' has jumped the shark

Boomer just the word Boomer has invaded like meme and American culture to a point where like I'm sick of it. It's kind of jumped the shark a little bit. But now it's at one of those things where it's like so mainstream it's like harambee after like two months where I was funny in the beginning.

Memes by nature have short lifespans, and 'OK Boomer' did indeed fade from mainstream cultural relevance shortly after the 2019 peak.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Angela Duckworth is just monetizing the fact that untalented people are too dumb to quit

I saw who wrote the study and it was Angela Duckworth Who is the lady that wrote the grit book. She is grit exploitation. She is the big grit industrial complex. Most of us out there learn to appreciate grit because we had to because we lack talent and sports... we're also dumb enough to not quit. So therefore that's a good quality and I'm going to call it grit and she comes along and she's trying to make money off it.

This is a philosophical critique of a psychological theory.
Void
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Matt Painter is the new Bo Ryan and will win 20 to 25 games every year regardless of his roster

Matt Painter's the new Bo Ryan. Regardless of who he has, he's going to win 20 to 25 games every year. So it's death, taxes, Matt Painter.

Since this take, Matt Painter has continued to be highly successful at Purdue, consistently winning 25+ games most seasons.
Void
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Harvard has the most talented Ivy League roster I have ever covered

Harvard, most talented Ivy League roster I've ever covered. Tommy [Amaker] has eight high major players. You look at Harvard, you see a team that has the chops to be a second weekend type team in the NCAA tournament talent-wise.

Harvard finished 21-8 but the postseason was canceled. They were very talented, but claiming they were the most talented Ivy roster ever is a high bar given historical Penn and Princeton teams.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If you are going to threaten someone on Twitter, you should give your home address, not your team's facility address

My problem with what [Jermaine Whitehead] did. Not that he threatened people... My problem is he said meet me at this address and then gave the facility address. If you tell someone to meet you somewhere, it has to be your house, right? Man up.

This is a humorous take on 'internet tough guy' etiquette.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

NFL players shouldn't be allowed to claim to have a broken hand on social media if it's not on the injury report

He's joking, playing with a broken hand? Because that's something you should actually be able to tell everyone like, 'Hey, actually I have a broken hand.' [If he's not on the injury report] Freddie Kitchens might be in trouble.

The NFL has strict injury reporting rules; failure to report a known injury like a broken hand would lead to fines.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots beat themselves more than the Ravens beat them

I think the Ravens played a good game. I think Lamar Jackson is very good. But I think the Patriots beat themselves more than the Ravens beat them... turnovers will bounce their way, but it looks like the Patriots fucked themselves today with too many penalties and too many turnovers.

While the Patriots had errors, the Ravens dominated physically and Lamar Jackson had a legendary performance. Most analysts credited the Ravens more.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars must start Nick Foles over Gardner Minshew

I think this is a no-brainer. You have to start Nick Foles. And that's not saying Gardner Minshew isn't a quarterback in the NFL going forward, but you have money invested in Nick Foles... Gardner Minshew basically made it so either he plays so well that it's a no-doubter or he shits the bed right before Nick Foles came back. And guess what? He shit the bed.

The Jaguars did start Nick Foles in Week 11, but he was benched back for Minshew after three starts.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins is the quarterback you'd least want in the fourth quarter

If you had to ask yourself starting quarterbacks, who is the guy that you would at least want to have the ball in the fourth quarter to bring a team back to win? I actually think it's Kirk Cousins... He had the ball twice at the end of the game [against the Chiefs], three and out, three and out, and not even close.

Cousins has statistically improved in late-game situations over time, but in 2019, this was a widely held opinion.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Andy Reid is one of the best coaches in NFL history.

Andy Reid deserves more credit for being one of the best coaches in the NFL, probably NFL history. I hope he wins the Super Bowl at some point because this is the 11th season where he's won a game with multiple quarterbacks. He made Matt Moore look good; this is a classic case of coaching matters.

Andy Reid won the Super Bowl later that season and is widely considered one of the greatest coaches ever.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tyreek Hill would be a better safety than Rob Gronkowski for end-of-game defensive situations.

Why don't they just have Tyreek Hill play safety in end-of-game situations when you just need to chase? He could run down a hook and ladder four different times; he can run down anyone. I would much rather have him than Rob Gronkowski playing safety for them.

This is a subjective hypothetical about player utility in specific situational roles.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Nagy needs to stop calling plays for the Bears

Matt Nagy needs to stop calling football games. He needs to hand over the play calling. It's not for him. It's not working. I like everything is broken. It's not working to do the same thing week in week out is fucking insane.

Nagy eventually handed over play-calling to Bill Lazor multiple times during his tenure before being fired after the 2021 season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson is the #1 quarterback you want in a 4th-quarter comeback

I think Russell Wilson is number one now in the NFL. He is the guy who, if you're down in the fourth, you want him to have the ball... He had five touchdowns today. I think that was his fifth comeback fourth-quarter comeback this season.

Wilson led the NFL in game-winning drives (5) in 2019 and was widely considered elite in these moments.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Carson is the greatest running back in the NFL who actually sucks.

I like Chris Carson, the running back on the Seattle Seahawks, I think he is very good. But he is the best running back in the NFL that sucks. He's the greatest who sucks because he fumbles the ball so frequently; he's got terrible, terrible ball security. He's really good, but he sucks.

This is an oxymoronic opinion based on real turnover stats vs production.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Patricia is a 'fake football guy' who just plays one on TV.

Matt Patricia has begun to strike me as a fake football guy. I think he idolizes football guys and aspires to be a football guy who hangs out around football... Basically Matt Patricia is like, 'I play a football guy on TV.' You have to have results to be a true bona fide football guy.

This is a subjective character assessment of a coach.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Browns should fire Freddie Kitchens

Freddie Kitchens is an absolute joke of a head coach. What do you do if you're the Browns? Freddie's got to be one and done. He is in way over his head. You just need to demote him and tell him he still has his job and he's just the offensive coordinator.

Freddie Kitchens was indeed fired after his first and only season as Browns head coach.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Coaching is the only job in the world that is truly recession-proof.

Coaching is the only job that's recession-proof. Because if the rich guys [boosters] lose money, they're not going to buy out, so every coach is safe. You want to be in nursing homes and coaching.

This is a humorous socio-economic theory that can't be definitively proven but makes logical sense in context.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Nate Diaz vs. Jorge Masvidal fight was stopped too early

They called the fucking fight early... Nate Diaz is the type of guy that I actually like his chances the more he gets the shit kicked out of him in the first three rounds. It wakes him up a little bit. The little nerdy doctor was like, 'No, this guy can't fight,' where Nate Diaz was like, 'No, I have not yet begun to fight.'

This is a subjective opinion on fighter safety vs. entertainment, though widely shared by MMA fans at the time.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Washington Nationals' World Series win has officially turned around the Chicago Bears' season

I need to say thank you because the Nationals have directly turned around the bear season Matt Nagy put a Out there showing the Nationals today. He is insane. He's mad [Nagy] is so insane fucking to this a fucking PowerPoint.

The Bears went 8-8 and missed the playoffs in 2019, failing to see a real 'turnaround' despite the inspiration.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

AJ Hinch should have left Zack Greinke in Game 7 of the World Series

I thought they were out of it. I thought that they were going to leave [Zack] Greinke in which they probably should have done. They took Greinke out after 81 pitches. I was one hit and a walk and they said you're out. If you pull Zack Greinke you put in Gerrit Cole. If you pull Zack Greinke and you put in whoever the hell they put in... that looked like he sells head units at Best Buy.

The Astros led 2-1 when Greinke was pulled; they immediately surrendered a 2-run homer and eventually lost 6-2. Most analysts agree pulling him was the turning point.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Nationals were right to shut down Stephen Strasburg in 2012

I'm going to say they did the right call on the Strasburg shutdown. I'd agree and I want to write they want Flags fly forever. That's right. Absolutely correct.

Strasburg went on to win World Series MVP in 2019, justifying the long-term health management strategy in the eyes of many fans.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers