Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm challenging the Bagel Boss guy to a fist fight at Rough N' Rowdy.

I'm challenging him to a fist fight. So I'm trying to track him down. I'm officially challenging him to Rough N' Rowdy if I can find this guy. I would defeat him easily.

The fight never occurred as the Bagel Boss guy (Chris Morgan) passed away in 2024.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jay Williams claiming Duke could beat the Cavs was his 'arrival moment' in the hot take industry.

The saying, 'Duke can beat the Cavs,' is like Jay Williams' arrival moment. He's just letting everyone know, hey, I'm here now to just spew some bullshit out here. I'm for real.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Simmons 'spiked the football' too early on the 2018-19 Celtics.

Attacking that little extra part at the end, [Bill Simmons said] 'they're going to be up 30 points in a lot of them.' In a lot of them. Yeah, that's just spiking the football when you haven't even scored yet.

Simmons' prediction was objectively incorrect as the Celtics struggled and were bounced early.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson is one bad weekend in Vegas away from becoming 'real chonk'.

I've said he's [Zion] one bad weekend in Vegas away from real chonk.

Zion's weight has been a recurring issue throughout his career.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson is the rare Duke player that everyone will root for.

Zion is like the rare dude from Duke that everyone is going to root for.

Zion was arguably the most popular and beloved prospect since LeBron James entering the league.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Zion Williamson would actually play worse if he lost weight.

I think [Zion Williamson] would actually get worse if he lost weight. There's something about his body. He's got power that he can just jump into. It doesn't look as much like an offensive foul if a fat guy runs into you as opposed to like a big jacked up dude.

This remains a debated topic throughout Zion's career, as weight is often linked to his frequent injuries, though his power is undeniable.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Waiters only offer you mushrooms at Chili's if you give off a 'drug guy' vibe.

You put out the drug guy vibe. I understand why she would try to offer that to you.

Subjective opinion on personal 'vibes'.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

I'd like to thank my family for believing in me while winning 'Blake of the Year' despite the haters.

First off, I'd like to thank my family for believing me this whole time. Obviously, there's been a lot of ups and downs and a lot of naysayers, a lot of haters, but somehow we made it here. I don't know, man. I'm at a loss for words.

The 'haters' and 'ups and downs' are part of the comedic framing of the Blake of the Year contest.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Vlad Guerrero Jr. should be in every single Home Run Derby for the rest of time

I want Vlad Guerrero in every single home run derby for the rest of time. He is electric... if you watch Vlad Guerrero take any of his practice swings like a week ago, you knew that he was going to be a show. You knew he was going to be awesome to watch.

Vlad Jr. has been a frequent participant and highlight of the derby since 2019, confirming he is a 'show'.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Mic'ing up baseball players might actually save baseball

We were watching and they had someone at bat who was mic'd up. I think it was Freddie Freeman. And I have to admit, I think it might save baseball. With all that said, it could definitely save baseball.

While it didn't 'save' baseball from its regional nature, mic'd up segments have become extremely popular and a staple of Sunday Night Baseball.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am in favor of the 'footballization' of every other sport

I'm in support of the footballization of any other sport. I want there to be a [challenge] flag. I want there to be the footballization of any other sport.

This is a subjective preference for how sports should be structured.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Challenges and replay in sports are bad because they prevent fans from complaining about being screwed

I'm firmly in the stance that everyone who wants more replay and more challenges, what you're going to do is you're going to get a world where we can't complain about anything. And watching sports is half of it is winning. And the other half is saying why your team didn't lose. They got screwed.

Replay has arguably increased frustration and delay without eliminating all complaints, supporting Big Cat's premise.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I love Cameron Payne playing in the NBA Summer League after four years in the NBA

My hot seat is the summer league... except Cameron Payne, who is in the summer league, and he's just finished his fourth year in the NBA. He is competing in the summer league. I fucking love this... I hope he plays past when he retires from the NBA and he keeps showing up for the summer league.

Cameron Payne used that Summer League stint to get another chance and eventually became a high-level backup for the Suns.
Loss
Dan HarenDan Haren

The Clippers are a better team than the Lakers heading into the 2019 season

Well, I think the Clippers are better, and I wanted them to get like a knockdown shooter to go along with those two guys... when they struck out on Kawhi, it's just they got a bunch of kind of filler pieces. I mean, I guess they're a little deeper maybe than the Clippers, but I don't know.

The Lakers won the 2020 NBA Championship while the Clippers collapsed in the second round of the playoffs.
Loss
Dan HarenDan Haren

The Lakers are Anthony Davis' team, not LeBron James'

I mean, it's Anthony Davis' team. LeBron... you know, I wasn't a huge fan of the whole LeBron thing in the first place, and he was all right last year... I'd rather have Kawhi than LeBron, obviously.

LeBron James was the Finals MVP and clear leader of the 2020 title team, though AD was arguably the best regular season player.
Win
Dan HarenDan Haren

Analytics actually work and players eventually buy in when they see the results

I think people were opposed to it at first, and then guys realized how much it works... when analytics was first a thing, guys didn't want to buy it, and now they see how much it works, and you can just see it.

His observation of the shift in MLB culture is consistent with the widespread adoption of analytics across the league.
Win
Dan HarenDan Haren

I was one of the last 'crafty righties' in Major League Baseball

The type of pitcher that I was is just completely gone now. Like, there's not too many guys. I mean, there's a few like crafty lefties, but very few crafty righties. I was one of the last crafty righties. That's for sure.

The increase in average fastball velocity has indeed marginalized the 'crafty righty' archetype that Haren embodied.
Void
Jilly FootballJilly Football

The Bachelorette having four fantasy suite dates instead of three is a smart life hack

Hannah couldn't decide who to give the final rose to... so she gave them both a rose, which means Hannah will have four fantasy suite dates instead of three... She just hacked the bachelorette by having more sex. She was like i realized that i could get more laid than other bachelorettes

This is a subjective evaluation of a reality TV strategy.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If you have a stubborn fart, you should get on all fours like a dog to release it

You know when you've got to really fart bad and you can't and you get on all fours? That's a good position... Someday my son's going to come out and be like, well, dad, why are you on the floor? I got to fart. Son, this is how we fart.

Biologically, this position (similar to child's pose) can indeed help with gas relief.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA has the best offseason in sports

The NBA by far and away has the best offseason in terms of the free agency period and players moving around and teams completely changing the course of their next four to five years in a matter of moments.

While subjective, the NBA offseason is widely cited as the most transactional and dramatic in North American sports.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James no longer controls the NBA like he used to

The immediate reaction that I had was LeBron James does not control this league like he used to.

The NBA entered a period of 'duos' rather than LeBron-centric superteams following this move.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Wimbledon is a top-tier sport to take a nap through

Mount Rushmore of sports to take a nap through. I've been napping a lot through Wimbledon because it's the green. It's early to quiet. It's just a little bit of grunts here and there. But other than that, it's a nice little ease into a nap Wimbledon.

This is a subjective opinion on the watchability of tennis.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Peter King is a hypocrite for criticizing the Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest

It is unbelievable to watch where Peter King draws the line. Putting a serial rapist into the Hall of Fame. Okay. Darren Sharper. Eating too many hot dogs on 4th of July? Nuh-uh. Don't do it. Covering a sport for 30, 40 years... where guys are dying from brain injuries... Okay. Watching Joey Chestnut eat 71 hot dogs on July 4th? Uh-uh. That's Peter King's line.

This is a subjective critique of King's consistency as a moral arbiter in sports.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian Yelich is making the smart decision by skipping the Home Run Derby to protect his swing and back

I think that you're making the smart call. First of all, if you compete in the home run derby, there's a chance you could ruin your swing... I'm really glad that it's not [happening].

This is a matter of baseball theory and medical caution.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 'ass-eating' bet with Christian Yelich is a lifetime commitment

I think it only should count for the one time. Like, you can't do the home run derby every year. I think it should be a home run derby. The next one you do, when you have to enter it and play in it, and that will be the bet.

Christian Yelich never won a Home Run Derby, and the hosts never had to fulfill the bet.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Buying illegal drugs for the first time is a drug in itself

Buying drugs for the first time is absolutely it is a drug in itself. It's like the rush that you get after the transaction's over. It could be the world's shittiest drugs but you're like super excited you're like oh my god I did this.

Subjective personal experience.
Void
HankHank

Waking up after a blackout and realizing you still have your phone and wallet is an all-time thrill

Drinking too much, like completely blacking out... And waking up and checking your pants to see if your wallet and phone isn't there... That, that wake up of like... Oh my God, do I have my shit? That is a thrill in itself.

Subjective assessment of thrills.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Recognizing a flea flicker as it unfolds is one of the greatest thrills in sports

My last one is when you realize that it's not a handoff, but you recognize that it's a flea flicker. When the running back is going deep. When the running back tosses back, everybody who's watching the TV stands up. They're like, oh, shit.

Subjective sports opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Winning a bet that was a sure loser is an all-time thrill

Winning a bet that was a sure, sure, sure loser. Like dead in the water. You have an over and it comes back out of nowhere. Where you just wrote it off. That is an all-time thrill.

This is a subjective experience of gambling.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tim Howard is the greatest male U.S. soccer player of all time

I would say the greatest, the greatest male U.S. soccer player. Landon Donovan, Cobi Jones, Alexi Lalas, Dempsey, Dempsey, Freddie Adu. That's it. That's the list.

Whether Howard is the GOAT of US male soccer is a subjective debate frequently had by fans and pundits.
Void
Tim HowardTim Howard

Kicking a soccer ball is incredibly easy compared to kicking a football

I think kicking a soccer ball is incredibly easy compared to kicking a football... It's a different skill set kicking a football from a soccer ball. It's terribly different.

Highly subjective opinion from an athlete experienced in one but not the other professionally.
Void
JB SmooveJB Smoove

I would have been a better cast member than a writer at Saturday Night Live

I really was probably better off as a cast member. I wasn't a writer when I got on the show. I think because I actually auditioned for cast... I came in with no writing experience, but I were amazing with your ideas.

Subjective professional reflection.
Void
CF
Cecil Fielder

My son Prince hits bombs, but I hit balls that leave stadiums

I told him one time, he hits bombs, I leave stadiums, and that's it.

Both players are among the few to hit 50 home runs in a season, making distance comparisons a matter of opinion and legendary anecdotes.
Void
CF
Cecil Fielder

If you can hit left-handed, you can own the game of baseball

Lefties are really on the game. I mean, if you can hit left-handed, you can own the game. During [Prince Fielder's] career, he owned the game while he was playing it.

The advantage of left-handed hitting is a widely debated but statistically supported theory in baseball.
Win
Ike TaylorIke Taylor

The Steelers locker room culture fell apart because Le'Veon Bell left

The locker room wasn't the locker room until Le'Veon left. Like, Le'Veon is the mediator of everything. He's somebody you want to have in that locker room.

Insiders have confirmed the friction that followed Bell's holdout and departure.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Smooth by Santana and Rob Thomas is the ultimate #1 summer song

Smooth. Carlos Santana and Rob Thomas. 20 years ago. It feels like it came out yesterday. It does. The way that they play it on every sporting event.

Subjective ranking of music.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Blue Sky by The Allman Brothers is the best summer car song

Allman Brothers, Blue Sky. When that song hits, when you're in the car, oof, nothing better, nothing better.

Subjective music opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The White Walkers fight like a bunch of seven-year-olds playing soccer where everyone just runs to the ball

The White Walkers... they're super aggressive, right? But they're dumb as shit... They básicamente are... I mean, they're all just running... it's like basically playing... they fight like a bunch of like seven-year-olds play basketball. Everyone runs to the ball. Bunch ball. And no one's spacing anything out.

The tactical efficiency of fictional zombies is a matter of critical opinion.
Void
HankHank

Theon Greyjoy had the best redemption and performance in the Battle of Winterfell

My best performance is Theon. Dude, Theon fought his ass off... Bran did say, you're a good man. Bran was basically like, alright, Theon, you're done.

Subjective character analysis.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The ending of Game of Thrones was as cheesy as the Seinfeld finale

The whole thing was cheesy as fuck, and then they're sitting around, like, the ending of, like, Seinfeld sitting in the jail. Where they're all sitting around the table at King's Landing, like, ha-ha, whoa, we gotta get more wheat for the winter... it turned into them playing SimCity around a table at the end.

Subjective critique of a TV series finale.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyrie Irving and Kevin Durant are the two NBA personalities least likely to get along long-term

Having Kyrie and KD together, those are the two personalities I think are least likely to get along. It's going to be great.

While they did 'get along' personally, their tenure together was a professional disaster that ended in a total blow-up of the roster.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jimmy Butler's move to Miami is perfect because he just wants to be himself and doesn't care about competing for titles

J-Butt in Miami, which I think it's kind of solid. It's almost the perfect J-Butt move... He just wants to be J-Butt and... be with Mark Wahlberg... But now he's on a team that's not really going to compete, but he's going to have a good time.

Butler led the Heat to two NBA Finals appearances (2020, 2023), proving he was extremely interested in competing at the highest level.
Loss
HankHank

Kemba Walker is a better player than Kyrie Irving

Hank, the Celtics definitely won by getting Kemba... [Hank:] Yes. [Big Cat:] OK. [PFT:] No, I agree with Hank on this take. I think that he's a better fit up there.

Kyrie Irving is widely considered a superior talent and has had a much better career post-2019 than Kemba Walker, whose career was derailed by knee injuries.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If Kawhi Leonard signs with the Lakers, it will ruin NBA parity and revert the league back to a boring superteam era

If Kawhi goes to the Lakers... it's basically like we took all these steps forward to getting everyone even, all the Warriors died, and now we're just going to have the Lakers be the super team.

Kawhi Leonard ultimately signed with the Clippers, preventing the Lakers superteam from forming in the way Big Cat feared.
Void
Dwight HowardDwight Howard

Wilt Chamberlain is the greatest basketball player of all time

I think Wilt Chamberlain is the best player. Wilt Chamberlain has 68 of the 72 NBA records... He got 23,000 rebounds.

The GOAT debate is inherently subjective.
Void
Dwight HowardDwight Howard

Kobe Bryant was a more skilled offensive player than Michael Jordan

When I say Kobe is better than Michael Jordan, I'm talking about as far as skilled in the overall game... Kobe can do everything Michael Jordan can do, but he learned how to do it better offensively.

This is a classic basketball debate that cannot be objectively settled.
Win
Dwight HowardDwight Howard

Kobe Bryant was right that I was 'soft' in terms of my mental stability and letting things get into my head

He said something, and I finally understood what he was saying... I don't think he was ever talking about something physical. I think he was talking about more like mental stability, where I allowed things to get in my head that I shouldn't have.

Howard is agreeing with an assessment made about his own character, making it correct in his own view.
Void
Dwight HowardDwight Howard

Sean Bradley wasn't actually a bad player; he just was a frequent victim of being dunked on

Sean Bradley wasn't that bad. He just got dunked on a lot.

Bradley had a long career and was an elite shot-blocker, but is universally remembered for being dunked on. His quality as a 'good' player is subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Clothing companies should manufacture pants with built-in iPhone chargers in the pockets

I have a really good drunk idea... It's shorts that have an iPhone charger built into the pocket... You plug your pants into the wall... It's a Mophie that you can wear.

This is a comedic business idea that has not become a mainstream commercial product.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

MLB should continue to play games in international stadiums with tiny dimensions to ensure high-scoring slugfests like the London Series

If they bring baseball games to different countries, just keep doing exactly like that... just runs, runs, runs... dimensions are so distorted that we keep having exactly this.

The 2019 London Series featured 50 total runs over two games, making it one of the most high-scoring series in MLB history.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers