Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Brandon Marshall, Sean Payton Leaves The Saints, MLB HoF Continues To Suck & FAQ's

Wednesday, January 26, 202219 takes

Sean Payton is leaving the Saints ( - ). Bears hire a new GM and we are still buzzing from Chiefs/Bills ( - ). MLB Hall of Famer voters refuse to put Barry Bonds into the Hall and its stupid ( - ). Hot Seat/Cool Throne ( - ). 6X Pro Bowler Brandon Marshall joins the show in studio to talk about his career, what makes good coaches, the intricacies playing Wide Receiver and more ( - ). We finish with listener FAQ's

Brandon Marshall on AB, Jay Cutler, and the Next Gen of QBs

The NFL landscape changed forever this week with Sean Payton officially stepping away from the Saints. Big Cat is already looking at the television horizon for the legendary coach, envisioning a future where he trades the visor for a headset in a much different capacity.

Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#9202
Big CatBig Cat

Sean Payton will join Amazon for their NFL coverage

I'm like 90% sure I can predict what's going to happen in the next two years for Sean Payton, Amazon. Amazon... They might put them in a booth with Drew Brees.

Sean Payton joined FOX Sports as a studio analyst for the 2022 season, not Amazon.

While New Orleans loses a legend, PFT is looking at the ripple effects in Big D. With Payton on the market, Mike McCarthy might want to start updating his LinkedIn, because the shadow of a Super Bowl-winning coach in New Orleans is going to loom large over Jerry World all season.

Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#9201
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McCarthy will be fired as Cowboys head coach exactly one year from today

Mike McCarthy is the lamest of ducks right now because he knows that Sean, this is Sean Payton's job. I'm first reporting it right now. Mike McCarthy has been fired as head coach of the Dallas Cowboys exactly a year from today, minus two weeks.

Mike McCarthy was still the head coach of the Cowboys a year later and remained so through the 2024 season.

Hall of Fame Frustrations

The MLB Hall of Fame results dropped and, once again, the writers decided to be the protagonists of baseball history. Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are officially off the ballot, which led to a heated discussion about the gatekeepers of Cooperstown. PFT didn't mince words about the legacy of the greatest hitter to ever live.

Void
Jan 26, 2022
#9204
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Barry Bonds is the best baseball player of all time and should be the first person re-inducted into the Hall of Fame

Barry Bonds is a Hall of Famer. He's the best baseball player of all time. You could say that Barry Bonds should be the first—if you were to get rid of everybody in the Hall of Fame, Barry Bonds should be the first person re-inducted.

Bonds has still not been inducted into the Hall of Fame by the writers or committees.

Big Cat and PFT pointed out the blatant hypocrisy of writers like Tom Verducci, who built their careers on the back of the very era they now pretend never happened. The guys argued that you simply cannot tell the story of baseball without the most dominant players of the nineties.

Void
Jan 26, 2022
#21907
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The steroid era saved Major League Baseball and the jobs of the writers who now refuse to honor it

The steroid era literally saved Tom Verducci's job. In the mid-nineties baseball was dead after the players strike... And they brought in replacement players and baseball was dead. And what happens over the course of the next three years? Oh yeah, Mark McGwire starts hitting the moon... Sammy Sosa and McGwire summer saved baseball.

This is a subjective historical interpretation, though the 1998 home run chase is widely credited with bringing fans back after the 1994 strike.

Brandon Marshall in Studio

Six-time Pro Bowler Brandon Marshall stopped by the studio for an incredible, wide-ranging conversation that touched on everything from his relationship with Jay Cutler to the current state of the league. Having just interviewed Antonio Brown on his own show, Marshall gave a blunt assessment of AB's future in the NFL.

Win
Jan 26, 2022
#9209
Brandon MarshallBrandon Marshall

Antonio Brown has only a 10% chance of ever playing in the NFL again

I would say a 10% chance. I love Antonio because we shared a locker room... but at the end of the day, he put himself in this situation. Look at the market for him last off-season.

Antonio Brown never signed with another NFL team after his release from the Buccaneers.

Marshall also weighed in on the current crop of young signal-callers after the weekend's insane Bills-Chiefs game. While everyone is debating the tier list, he thinks the guy at the top is undeniable.

Win
Jan 26, 2022
#9210
Brandon MarshallBrandon Marshall

Patrick Mahomes is the clear #1 young quarterback with no debate

If I had to rank these guys, Patrick Mahomes, number one, easy, easy. It's not even a debate. Patrick Mahomes... you gotta go win the Super Bowl and you gotta go do what he's done consistently year after year.

Mahomes has won two more Super Bowls since this take, further proving Marshall right.

One of the most interesting parts of the interview was Marshall comparing the swagger of today's stars to his former teammates. He sees a lot of his old friend Jay Cutler in the way Joe Burrow carries himself, though maybe with a bit more of a killer instinct.

Void
Jan 26, 2022
#21909
Brandon MarshallBrandon Marshall

Joe Burrow is the savage version of what Jay Cutler was supposed to be

I was watching Joe Burrow's interview yesterday... just his personality and also like his confidence slash cockiness. And I was like, that's what Jay [Cutler] was supposed to be. Joe Burrow really, he's a savage.

Burrow has led the Bengals to a Super Bowl and multiple AFC Championship games, arguably exceeding Cutler's career impact.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne and FAQ's

During Hot Seat/Cool Throne, Hank brought some bad news for Patriots fans everywhere. After listening to the latest from Tom vs. Time, Hank is convinced that the GOAT is finally ready to hang up the cleats and prioritize his family over the gridiron.

Win
HankHank

Tom Brady is going to retire after this season

Tom Brady, Tom vs. Time... for my personal takeaway, it seems like he's gone. She [Gisele] deserves what she needs from me as a husband and my kids deserve what they need from me as a dad... from right now where I stand, I feel like he's gonna walk.

Brady announced his retirement on Feb 1, 2022, less than a week after this episode.

To wrap things up, the guys took a listener question about building a youth basketball dynasty. While most would suggest fundamentals or conditioning, Big Cat has a secret weapon that would make Kareem Abdul-Jabbar proud.

Void
Jan 26, 2022·FAQ
#21910
Big CatBig Cat

The best way to build a youth basketball dynasty is to teach every player how to shoot skyhooks

This is actually serious. If you really want to be a dynasty and don't like be a Dick about it and run them too hard, teach them all how, how to shoot skyhooks. You can't guard it. You would not be able to guard it. Skyhooks for everyone.

Subjective coaching strategy.

Just remember, if a kid can reach the ball, Hank expects them to bring it down every single time.

nflmlbsaintsbearshall-of-famewide-receiver

More Takes

Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#21905
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adam Schefter will likely leave ESPN in the near future

Schefter... maybe Schefter thinking, you know, I'm going to be leaving ESPN soon. I can start giving a couple back here... Do you think Schefter lets Rappaport break the news that he leaves ESPN?

Adam Schefter signed a massive multi-year extension with ESPN in March 2022, just months after this prediction.
Open
Jan 26, 2022
#21904
Big CatBig Cat

Hiring an executive from the Kansas City Chiefs organization is always a winning move for the Chicago Bears

The Bears got a new GM, Ryan Poles... pretty much the news there is that he's from the Chiefs. Chiefs have good players. It's never been a bad thing for the Bears to hire someone from the Chiefs staff.

Ryan Poles has overseen a massive rebuild with the Bears, including drafting Caleb Williams, but the overall success of the franchise remains to be seen compared to the Chiefs' dynasty.
Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#9203
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Ravens might move on from Lamar Jackson

What if the Ravens moved on from Lamar Jackson? Why? He got hurt. They got rid of his offensive coordinator... I just said, keep an eye on it. This is complete and utter reckless speculation.

The Ravens did not move on; they eventually signed him to a massive extension in 2023.
Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#21906
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers is definitely going to play for the Denver Broncos next season

I actually am sure about this one... Denver for Aaron Rodgers. You sure about that? I actually am sure about this one.

Rodgers returned to the Packers for the 2022 season after signing a new contract extension.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Defense no longer wins championships in the modern NFL

I did, did you guys see that, that one tweet where someone was like, this must be what it feels like for kids to find out Santa Claus isn't real. And it was a text someone shared from their dad saying defense no longer wins championships.

The Rams won Super Bowl LVI shortly after this, largely due to a defensive line that recorded 7 sacks and held the Bengals to 20 points.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is unhappy living in Brooklyn

James Harden is upset. This is going well. I fucking love the Nets—they're going to Kevin Durant's hurt, Kyrie plays half the games. And I saw the quote... James Harden doesn't enjoy living in Brooklyn, not just because of the climate, but also the state income tax is different than Texas.

Harden was traded to Philadelphia on Feb 10, 2022, confirming his desire to leave.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

SEC stadiums are louder than NFL stadiums

Joe Burrow, mid controversial statement of saying SEC stadiums louder than NFL stadium... which was now brought up by an NFL veteran who thought that it was quite good.

While noise levels are subjective and vary by venue, the claim is a matter of record for Burrow.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Using an 'all-star' officiating crew for the Super Bowl is a bad idea due to lack of chemistry

Penalty flags... they announced a Super Bowl crew, Ron Torbert—they are collabing. It's not a crew he's worked with... chemistry is more important than—you want a crew that's been solid together. They're greater than the sum of their parts.

Subjective opinion on team dynamics, though Super Bowl LVI officiating had some controversial late calls.
Void
Jan 26, 2022
#21908
Big CatBig Cat

NFL coaches often fail because their organizations are poorly structured, not because they are bad at coaching

I've kind of changed my thought process on the Bears and the NFL in totality that like coaches can fail, but it's really the organization fails them. I'm now starting to realize like the Bears are screwed no matter what... there was never a structure that was put in place to have [Marc Trestman] succeed.

This is a subjective assessment of organizational health and its impact on coaching success.
Loss
Jan 26, 2022
#9212
HankHank

If a wide receiver touches the ball, he is responsible for catching it

Anytime it barely grazes wide receivers' fingers, Hank will be like, well, I thought it was, if you touch it, you can catch it... just because he touches it doesn't mean you can catch it... [Hank]: Millions of dollars. He gets paid millions of dollars to make that catch.

Physically and technically, a fingertip touch on an off-target pass is not a reasonable catch expectation, as Marshall explains.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers