Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Jim Gaffigan, Coaching Carousel + Don't F*ck With Cats Documentary Review

Wednesday, January 8, 202017 takes

The Coaching carousel is spinning round and round. Matt Rhule goes to Carolina and Joe Judge to New York. Mike McCarthy had a sleepover and has the perfect job in Dallas. (-) Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Dwyane Wades 3 night retirement tour. (-) Comedian Jim Gaffigan joins the show to talk about his new movie Troop Zero, being a comedian for multiple decades, playing football with Jim Schwartz, and slob life. (-) Segments include bachelor talk for guys that dont watch the bachelor, (-) guys on chicks, (-) and a review of the very fucked up documentary Don't F*ck with Cats (-)

Jim Gaffigan on Slub Life, Coaching Carousel, and Documentary Review

The coaching carousel is spinning out of control, and Big Cat and PFT are here to judge every single move. The Giants finally landed on Joe Judge, a name that sent half of New York to Wikipedia to figure out who he was. While he comes from the Saban and Belichick trees, the guys are already looking for the silver lining.

Loss
Jan 8, 2020
#969
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You have to compare Joe Judge immediately to John Harbaugh

You have to compare [Joe Judge] immediately to John Harbaugh. Of course. And say, okay, this guy could work. Because not enough special team guys get opportunities.

The comparison was common at the time, but Joe Judge was ultimately fired after two seasons, unlike Harbaugh's sustained success.

Down in Carolina, Matt Rhule took the job after the Panthers basically kidnapped him in Charlotte to prevent him from flying to New York for a second interview. Big Cat is actually a fan of the hire because Rhule isn't just another retread or a college guy relying solely on blue-chip recruits.

Loss
Jan 8, 2020
#970
Big CatBig Cat

I would rather hire Matt Rhule than Nick Saban or Urban Meyer

I actually would feel more comfortable getting a Matt Rhule type than like an Urban Meyer or even a Nick Saban... Matt Rule did more with less. Temple is not really a football powerhouse. Baylor was obviously in kind of a disaster zone. So he wasn't beating guys with just going out and getting all the recruits... He was beating them, I would assume, with at least some X's and O's.

While Rhule was a turnaround artist in college, his NFL tenure with the Panthers was widely considered a failure (11-27).

Then there’s the Cowboys. Jerry Jones had a literal sleepover with Mike McCarthy and decided that he was the man to lead Dallas into the next decade. Big Cat isn't exactly sold on McCarthy being a revolutionary upgrade over the Clapper.

Push
Jan 8, 2020
#971
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McCarthy is just a fatter version of Jason Garrett

It's a great hire for Jerry Jones because he basically just hired a fatter Jason Garrett. Do you think Mike McCarthy's going to steal the show in Dallas? Do you think he's going to make the headlines?

McCarthy has had a higher winning percentage in the regular season than late-era Garrett, but has similarly struggled with playoff breakthroughs in Dallas.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hot Seat is the 'Blake of the Year' title. Hank is getting worried because the Blake fraternity is falling apart. Blake Griffin is out for the season with surgery, and Blake Bortles has basically disappeared. PFT is starting to think there's a supernatural element at play here.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

There is a Blake of the Year curse

So it's time to ask, is there a Blake of the Year curse? You've got Griffin [surgery]. Bortles got traded. He moved teams... and went bald.

The bad luck continued for various Blakes, though 'curses' are inherently superstitious.

Also on the Hot Seat is anyone standing in the way of Stephen A. Smith. The face of ESPN is going on a seven-day apple cider vinegar cleanse, which means he's going to be hungry, irritable, and ready to unleash hell on Max Kellerman.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Stephen A. Smith will be extra spicy because of his apple cider vinegar cleanse

Stephen A. Smith just announced that he's going on a seven-day apple cider vinegar cleanse... He's going to be on a First Take just with a mouth tasting like all kinds of soy sauce... and he's going to have an empty belly. He's going to be sweating... a hungry dog runs faster.

Stephen A. Smith is perpetually 'spicy', making this hard to isolate, but a fun prediction.

Cool Throne goes to the Miami Heat for the most aggressive jersey retirement in sports history. They are retiring Dwyane Wade’s number over three days. Not three games, just three days. Big Cat is convinced there will be an ass-eating booth and Coachella-level festivities for a guy who has been retired for a year already.

Jim Gaffigan

Comedian and friend of the program Jim Gaffigan joined the show to talk about his new movie Troop Zero and his life as a professional slob. PFT immediately opened the interview by accusing Jim of stolen valor regarding his football career at Georgetown, which Jim was more than happy to admit was a Division III struggle bus.

Loss
Jan 8, 2020
#24743
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jim Gaffigan's claim that he played football at Georgetown is a 'perfect crime' lie

I don't think you actually played football at Georgetown. Because you say that you played football there, but that's the perfect crime to say that you played football at a school that is Division III and no longer really keeps records of those games back. I could say I was the starting center on the Hartford Whalers.

Jim Gaffigan did indeed play football at Georgetown (and Purdue) as a lineman.

As a native of the Indiana/Chicago area, Jim still follows the NFL closely and dropped a absolute bomb regarding where he thinks the greatest quarterback of all time is heading next season.

Loss
Jan 8, 2020
#976
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

I think Tom Brady is going to sign with the Tennessee Titans

I think [Tom Brady] is going to the Titans. Because of Vrabel. They've got a running back. They've got a good team. They've got salary cap.

Tom Brady signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in March 2020.

Jim also gave us some insight into the aging process for men. While some fans might think the guys are in their prime, Jim was quick to remind them that for 99% of the male population, it's all downhill from here.

Void
Jan 8, 2020
#977
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

Men turn uglier and uglier as they get older

As you get older, men turn uglier and uglier... George Clooney and Brad Pitt, those guys are flukes. That was like a mistake. I would say that most guys are disgusting, right? It's just a known fact.

Purely subjective comedic observation.

Don't F*ck With Cats Review

To wrap up the show, the guys did a deep dive into the Netflix documentary Don't F*ck With Cats. It’s the first documentary they’ve reviewed since Abducted in Plain Sight, and it lived up to the 'fucked up' billing. Big Cat was particularly impressed with John Green, the online sleuth who actually did the heavy lifting while Deanna Thompson (Body Movin) took most of the credit.

Void
Jan 8, 2020
#24746
Big CatBig Cat

John Green was a much better online researcher than Deanna Thompson

John Green dominated [Deanna Thompson] in terms of researching things online... At the end, when he and [Deanna] were sitting at the diner, and she was like, 'I would have quit without you,' and he was like, 'I know you would have.'

This is a subjective ranking of the two individuals' contributions as depicted in the film.

While the documentary tries to paint the killer, Luka Magnotta, as a brilliant 'Catch Me If You Can' style mastermind, Big Cat wasn't buying the hype. The guy was a narcissist who left his own name and address in the trash next to the crime scene.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

The murderer in Don't F*ck With Cats was not a genius mastermind

This guy is not as smart as everyone's making him out to be. He is not some mastermind. He's a fucked up piece of shit... he's narcissistic and he got caught in like three days.

Magnotta was indeed caught shortly after fleeing and left his own name/address in the trash, supporting the 'not a genius' claim.

There was also a somber realization at the end of the review. The documentary asks if the internet sleuths actually fueled the fire by giving a narcissist exactly what he wanted: an audience.

Void
Jan 8, 2020
#24745
Big CatBig Cat

The online cat-hunter group is somewhat responsible for the murder in 'Don't F*ck With Cats'

Media and our obsession with crime documentaries and their obsession with finding someone... they are somewhat responsible. There are psycho people out there, but [Luka Magnotta] wanted to be chased and they chased him. We kind of gave it all to him.

This is a moral and sociological opinion on the events of the documentary.

Next time you see a weirdo on Facebook, maybe just keep scrolling instead of starting a global manhunt.

nfljim-gaffiganbachelornetflixcoaching-carouselgiantscowboys

More Takes

Win
Jan 8, 2020
#24741
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Judge is probably not that talented of a coach because he went to Mississippi State

Joe Judge... negatives, everyone had to Wikipedia who [he] was. Also negative, he went to college at Mississippi State. So probably not that talented.

Judge went 10-23 in two seasons with the Giants and was fired, though his alma mater likely wasn't the reason.
Void
Jan 8, 2020
#972
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McCarthy only winning one Super Bowl with Aaron Rodgers makes him just an okay coach

If you asked any Packer fan, though, and let's just say that Aaron Rodgers is not going to win another Super Bowl, the fact that Mike McCarthy had Aaron Rodgers that type of talent and they only won one is an okay coach.

This remains a subjective debate in NFL media regarding McCarthy's legacy.
Void
Jan 8, 2020
#24742
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL has only 3 or 4 difference-maker coaches and about 20 interchangeable ones like Mike McCarthy

The NFL is probably three or four difference maker coaches. Then there's 20 guys who are all kind of interchangeable. That's Mike McCarthy. And then four or five guys that will like actively hurt your team.

This is a subjective classification of coaching talent across the league.
Void
HankHank

College bowl games are boring and pointless

Good riddance. Bowls are boring. What's the point?

Subjective opinion on the entertainment value of bowl games.
Void
Jan 8, 2020
#24744
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

Comedy will see a trend back toward heckling in the next few years

There's going to be a trend towards [heckling], back to it. You know, like the whole roasting trend has really kind of brought that out too.

While crowd work and 'roast' culture have grown on social media, whether this constitutes a 'trend back to heckling' is subjective and difficult to quantify.
Loss
Jan 8, 2020·Bachelor Talk
#978
HankHank

Madison Prewett will win The Bachelor because her dad is the Auburn coach

My prediction is there is a girl who is a four-time state championship basketball player, and she goes to Auburn, and her dad is the coach of Auburn... My money's on her. Clearly, she knows the long haul, the grind.

Peter Weber initially became engaged to Hannah Ann Sluss; while he and Madison Prewett attempted a relationship after the finale, she did not 'win' the show.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers