Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

MLB Playoffs With Jared Carrabis, Phillies Into The NLCS, Week 6 Picks & Preview + Fyre Fest

Friday, October 13, 202324 takes

The Phillies are on to the NLCS and Max was right. The Braves went down incredibly sad and the Broncos officially may be the worst team in the NFL (-). Week 6 Picks and Preview with travel tips, revenge games, David Tepper being a meddling owner, a debate about future debates and more (-). Baseball Correspondent Jared Carrabis joins the show to talk MLB playoffs, how the teams got there, are the Astros so good we can forget their cheating, the Dodgers failing, and more (-). We finish with fyre fest of the week (-).

Jared Carrabis on MLB Playoffs, Phillies' NLCS Run, and Week 6 NFL Picks

Max was right. It’s the three words Big Cat never wanted to say, but Nick Castellanos has forced his hand. After a week of internal debating about "barrels" and vibes, the Phillies have officially punched their ticket to the NLCS by dismantling the Braves. Max is currently vibrating at a frequency that might be dangerous for human health, having already spit on PFT in a moment of pure, unadulterated joy during the watch party. While Philly celebrates, the Braves are heading home early again, and PFT isn't exactly offering a shoulder to cry on for the fans in Atlanta.

Void
Oct 13, 2023
#10582
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Braves are soft and complainers after their playoff exit

This series [we learned] Braves kind of soft, kind of complainers. If you're a Braves fan, you won a World Series a couple years ago, you'd be happy with that. But now you seem pretty soft. This postseason between the complaining about a reporter tweeting out an accurate statement from the clubhouse... gimme a fucking break.

The Braves were indeed criticized nationally for their reaction to the reporting, and they did lose the series, lending credence to the 'soft' narrative for that postseason.

While the Phillies look like a juggernaut, Max isn't looking past the next opponent. The Diamondbacks are lurking after emasculating the Dodgers, and the vibes in Arizona are surprisingly potent.

Win
Oct 13, 2023
#10583
MaxMax

The Diamondbacks are scary and should not be taken lightly

The [Diamondbacks] are scary. The Diamondbacks are scary. They're very scary. I'm not—Zac Gallen is for real. I'm not looking at that team lightly at all.

The Diamondbacks did push the Phillies to 7 games and eventually won the NLCS, proving they were indeed scary.

Broncos Rock Bottom and Week 6 Preview

Thursday Night Football was a grim reminder that the Sean Payton era in Denver is off to a disastrous start. Russell Wilson threw for 95 yards in a game that felt like it was played in a different era of football, specifically an era where the forward pass was a suggestion. Big Cat is officially out on the Russ Hall of Fame discourse.

Win
Oct 13, 2023
#10584
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos will bench Russell Wilson and he has played himself out of a Hall of Fame career

Russell Wilson stinks. He turtles so fast in the pocket. He threw for 95 yards. It was never close. I think they might bench Russell Wilson. He's played himself out of a Hall of Fame career as well.

Sean Payton officially benched Russell Wilson in Week 17 of the 2023 season. The HOF claim is subjective but Wilson's career trajectory certainly took a massive hit in Denver.

On the other side, Andy Reid continues to treat the regular season like a laboratory for his most insane ideas. PFT pointed out that the Chiefs' offense seems to be intentional with their weirdness because playing straight-up football against teams like the Broncos just doesn't provide enough of a challenge anymore.

Void
Oct 13, 2023
#10585
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andy Reid is playing the NFL on 'expert mode' because he's bored

I think Andy Reid is bored with the NFL. I think Andy Reid is—he's made himself play the NFL on expert mode with the weird shit that he's obsessed with doing. Because I think that this Chiefs offense, if they wanted to play just normal football, would've beaten the fuck out of the Broncos. But they do all these weird plays, almost like Andy is just like—he's playing with his food.

Reid's penchant for 'trickeration' is well-documented, especially in games against inferior opponents like the 2023 Broncos.

To put the Broncos' misery into perspective, the historical dominance the Chiefs hold over them is staggering. We are approaching a decade of one-sided football in this rivalry.

Win
Oct 13, 2023
#22872
Big CatBig Cat

The last time the Broncos beat the Chiefs, Pardon My Take did not exist

Pardon My Take didn't exist. Pardon My Take didn't exist the last time the Broncos beat the Chiefs. It's insane to think about. When they last beat the Chiefs, it was 57, 55 all time Chiefs. And now it is 72, 55.

The Broncos last beat the Chiefs on September 17, 2015. Pardon My Take launched on February 29, 2016.

The guys then rolled through a massive Week 6 preview, starting with the Ravens and Titans in London. PFT is strictly betting based on travel schedules this week, and he’s disgusted by Mike Vrabel’s decision to fly into London just 48 hours before kickoff. Big Cat, meanwhile, is starting to feel the fatigue of the international series.

Void
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#10586
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL London games have lost their allure and are now a burden

I'm kind of sick of the London game. I like the early football. I'm sick of the fact that they have made something that was unique and different into just every week. This is the third week in a row. They're just changing the schedule on us. Now it doesn't feel cool and unique, it just feels like a burden.

This is a subjective consumer opinion on the entertainment value of the NFL's global expansion.

Other highlights from the picks include PFT's "dream bet" involving Seahawks rookie Devon Witherspoon and a possible trade destination for a certain Vikings quarterback if things continue to spiral in Minnesota.

Push
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#22874
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons are a team to watch as a trade destination for Kirk Cousins

I noticed earlier in the week the Falcons made cap room. They did a big restructuring. I could see the Falcons trying to do something like that [trading for Kirk Cousins]. Because if you're being honest as a Falcons fan, you're not really happy with the quarterback situation right now.

Cousins was not traded mid-season (he tore his Achilles shortly after), but he eventually signed a massive free-agent contract with the Falcons in March 2024.

Baseball Correspondent Jared Carrabis

Jared Carrabis joined the show to discuss the state of the MLB Playoffs and the absolute electric atmosphere at Citizens Bank Park. Jared admits he’s jealous of Phillies fans for having a superstar like Bryce Harper who matches the city’s dirtbag energy perfectly.

Void
Oct 13, 2023
#10591
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Bryce Harper embodies the city of Philadelphia more than any superstar

I'm so jealous of Philly fans because you got a player that is a superstar potential Hall of Famer someday. And he's such a dirtbag—like Phillies fans. He is one of them. When he signed his deal, he was like 13 years, I don't want any opt-outs, I want to die here. Bury me in Philly. He embodies everything that fan base is all about.

This is a subjective evaluation of player-city chemistry, but widely accepted by baseball fans and media.

They touched on the Astros reaching their seventh straight ALCS, a feat so impressive that it’s starting to wash away the stench of the 2017 scandal. Jared argues that Houston’s sustained success proves they didn't need the trash cans to begin with.

Void
Oct 13, 2023
#10592
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The Astros have proven they never needed to cheat to be successful

What they've proven to me—and should be to a lot of people—is that they never had to cheat in the first place. Whether or not they would've won in 2017, that remains to be seen... but as far as getting there seven straight [ALCSs], I don't think that they needed to cheat to do that. They were talented all along.

While their talent is undeniable, whether they 'needed' to cheat is a subjective counterfactual.

As for the actual formula for winning in October? Forget small ball and grinding out at-bats. Jared says the current landscape of the postseason rewards one thing above all else: the long ball.

Void
Oct 13, 2023
#22877
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Winning in the MLB Playoffs is almost entirely about hitting home runs

The formula for Playoff success: good pitching, good defense, hit homers. And the D-backs are hitting homers. It's not about grinding out at-bats and wearing down the pitcher. It's: can you hit homers at a rate that you can out-homer the other team? The Playoffs is all about hitting home runs.

The 2023 postseason saw the Rangers and Diamondbacks rely heavily on home runs to advance, supporting Carrabis's point.

Fyre Fest and Harry Potter Talk

Hank’s Fyre Fest has led him down a dark path. Thanks to a single TikTok video, he has been sucked into a Harry Potter movie marathon, leading to a deep realization about the true villain of the series.

Void
Oct 13, 2023·Fyre Fest
#22880
HankHank

Albus Dumbledore is a piece of shit for setting Harry Potter up to die

As I'm watching them [the Harry Potter movies], dude, Dumbledore's a piece of shit. He knew that Harry had to sacrifice himself. He set him up. The guy that you think is like the grandpa that's always there to help him... he's a bad sicko.

This is a subjective interpretation of a fictional character's motivations.

This sparked a debate about the quality of the films versus the source material, with Big Cat standing firm on his stance regarding Michael Lewis adaptations.

Void
Oct 13, 2023·Fyre Fest
#10596
Big CatBig Cat

Books are always better than the movies

Michael Lewis books—always better than the movie. Big Short? Ever heard of it? Moneyball? Ever heard of it? Blindside? Books are always better than the movie.

Purely subjective preference.

We wrapped up with the weekly lottery ball, and a reminder that the new Chicago studio is just ten days away from its grand opening.

Max might actually survive until the World Series, but it's going to be a close call.

mlb-playoffsphilliesnfl-week-6broncosbravesjared-carrabis

More Takes

Win
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#22873
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Titans' strategy of flying to London late in the week is a mistake that will cost them against the Ravens

I don't know why the Titans are flying out late in the week. I don't know why teams do that. Vrabel's strategy is basically, 'fuck it.' Losers complain about time zones. But in this case, I don't know why a team wouldn't choose to go out there earlier in the week. Ravens flew on Monday. Titans flew on Thursday night.

The Ravens beat the Titans 24-16 in London on October 15, 2023.
Loss
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#10587
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Devon Witherspoon will put the 'absolute clamps' on Ja'Marr Chase

I dreamt that [Devon] Witherspoon was going to put the absolute clamps on Ja'Marr Chase in the game. I dreamt a post-game press conference with Ja'Marr Chase being frustrated with him asking him if he was always open this game. He said, 'Hats off to Devon Witherspoon.' So I'm betting the under on his receiving yards.

Ja'Marr Chase finished the game with 6 receptions for 80 yards. While he didn't score, 80 yards is a solid performance, not an 'absolute clamping.'
Loss
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#10588
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially back in on Justin Fields as the guy for the Bears

The Bears might be back if they win this game. And I am all the way back into Justin Fields. I liken it to a relationship where, listen, Justin Fields threw some interceptions, I said some things... but at the end of the day, don't go to bed angry. So I'm no longer going to bed angry. He's the guy again.

Fields was traded the following offseason after the Bears chose to draft Caleb Williams, proving Big Cat's 'he's the guy' stance was incorrect long-term.
Win
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#10589
Big CatBig Cat

David Tepper is a meddling owner who is hurting the Panthers

[David Tepper] basically in those two quotes was like, 'Yeah, this guy is putting his nose where it shouldn't be and micromanaging a football team.' And that's not how a successful organization runs. You can't have the owner forcing the coach to have a meeting multiple times a week. He sounds like a miserable person to work for.

Tepper fired Frank Reich less than two months after this episode. His reputation as a meddling owner has only grown since.
Void
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#22875
Big CatBig Cat

Dante Scarnecchia was the actual GOAT coach of the Patriots dynasty

I think as a podcast we should actually change the debate and make it Dante Scarnecchia was the GOAT. Why not? Option three.

This is a subjective opinion about the relative value of a position coach versus a head coach and QB.
Open
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#10590
Big CatBig Cat

Andy Reid will be considered the GOAT coach if he stays with Mahomes

I think that the 'Andy Reid is the greatest coach of all time' will eventually be a conversation if he stays in Kansas City. Because Bill Belichick without Tom Brady, his record has not been great. If [Reid] coaches for another eight years and you have Patrick Mahomes, that's like 12, 13 wins a year. That's a lot of wins. Andy's gonna go for Shula.

The conversation has already begun to shift in this direction following Reid's third Super Bowl win in 2024.
Win
Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#22876
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Garoppolo will make mistakes trying to show up the Patriots in his revenge game

Garoppolo is probably going to try to play like the best game of his life to show Robert Kraft like, 'Hey, you could've had me.' And when he tries to do that, he's probably going to make some mistakes.

Garoppolo threw one interception and had a modest performance (162 yards) before leaving the game with a back injury, though the Raiders did win.
Void
Oct 13, 2023
#22878
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The MLB should move back to a one-game Wild Card and make the Division Series a best-of-seven

I want to mix up the Playoff format again. I want to go back to the one-game Playoff for the Wild Card, and then I want to make the Division Series best-of-seven. I think it rewards teams with more depth. Something specific to the Braves-Philly series... this deserves to be seven games.

This is a suggestion for a rules/format change.
Loss
Oct 13, 2023
#22879
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Juan Soto could end up with the Red Sox

Juan Soto could end up in Boston. That's the scuttlebutt. He would just go yard all day in that [Fenway Park] short porch.

Juan Soto was traded from the Padres to the New York Yankees on December 6, 2023.
Loss
Oct 13, 2023
#10593
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The Phillies will beat the Rangers in the World Series

World Series prediction: Phillies over the Rangers. It just feels like the Phillies won't be denied. They feel more inevitable this year.

The Rangers did make the World Series and won it, but they defeated the Arizona Diamondbacks, not the Phillies. The Phillies lost to Arizona in the NLCS.
Void
Oct 13, 2023·Fyre Fest
#10594
MaxMax

I only enjoy watching baseball when my team is on offense

What I said was... I like when my team is on offense, and I don't like when my team is on defense. [It's because] in the short series, every [pitch] is so important. You lose one and you're just back that much.

This is a personal preference based on sports-induced anxiety.
Void
Oct 13, 2023·Fyre Fest
#10595
Big CatBig Cat

You would always rather give up a solo home run than a walk in the 9th

Top of the ninth, up 3-1. First batter. Would you rather give up a walk or a solo shot? I'd rather give up a solo shot. [Because with a walk] all of a sudden the tying run is on base and it's just all the nerves. Tension. I texted Dan Haren and he said 'no question you'd rather give up a solo shot.'

This is a tactical preference often debated by players and managers; there is no definitive statistical 'correct' answer, though many pros agree with the 'no free passes' philosophy.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers