Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Oregon's loss to Oklahoma State should be heavily discounted

They literally did have all their plays. Oklahoma State had all of Oregon's plays. And I'm not saying it had a spy gateway, but they were, we saw the tape after, they had every single tell on Dante Moore. They were stuffing every single run. So how much of that Oklahoma State loss can we throw out and say Oklahoma State stopped them at an insane level because they knew exactly what was coming every time?

The claim about Oklahoma State knowing Oregon's plays is presented as a factual film-based assertion, but it cannot be independently verified from the transcript alone.

More from this episode

View episode
Void
Sep 30, 2026
#31541
Big CatBig Cat

The Phillies being in the playoffs is making the Eagles bad

So the Phillies being in the playoffs is making the Eagles bad.

The claim is a humorous interpretation of a small statistical sample and is not a stable factual proposition that can be definitively judged.
Open
Sep 30, 2026
#31520
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Man City should face the death penalty

It sounds like this is probably should be death penalty stuff because it's pretty much the worst thing that's ever happened in English soccer in terms of rule violations.

The episode only covered the liability finding; the eventual punishment had not yet been decided.
Void
Sep 30, 2026
#31543
Big CatBig Cat

Baseball broadcasts only need one announcer

You just need one announcer in baseball. NBC's doing too much. I'm sorry.

This is a subjective broadcasting preference.

More from Big Cat

View profile
Void
Big CatBig Cat

John Harbaugh personally cost the Giants the game

This was a John Harbaugh masterclass loss, like a classic John Harbaugh loss. They had so many chances to ice this game away. That loss is on John Harbaugh.

Whether the loss should primarily be assigned to the coach is an evaluative judgment rather than a definitively verifiable fact.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are still a playoff team without Puka Nacua

I'm higher on the Rams than you. I think the Rams are gonna be a playoff team. They've won three in a row.

The Rams did not make the playoffs that season, so this prediction was incorrect.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys are the perfect team to beat the 49ers and fool everyone

This would be the perfect game for the Cowboys to win, to get everyone to be like, 'The Cowboys are for real,' and then have them lose the Titans next week. It would be so Cowboys.

The Cowboys did not complete the exact predicted sequence of beating the 49ers and then losing to the Titans.