Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

CJ Abrams is the best Saber Metric pick in the Dingers Only draft because he leads off

Ideally you want your players to get as many opportunities to hit home runs as possible. Why not take a guy that hits lead off shortstop. CJ Abrams. He's gonna get like four more at bats than some of your guys' clowns.

While mathematically true that leadoff hitters get more ABs, it doesn't always translate to more HRs than middle-of-the-order sluggers.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Judge is not a true Yankee because he hasn't won a World Series

I would go even further and say he's [Aaron Judge] not a true Yankee. Which is funny because he's had some of the best seasons of all time by any offensive player. Still not a true Yankee... You can't be a true Yankee in the regular season. The Yankees season starts in October.

Subjective definition of what makes a 'true Yankee'.
Win
MaxMax

Gunnar Henderson was a massive steal in the second round of the Dingers Only draft

I'll take Gunnar Henderson. Fuck. I didn't—I don't know how he lasted that long... I was hoping that PFT was gonna take judge and I was gonna take Gunner, but I had to—he left me Judge and I had to take him. I wanted Gunner. Gunner slipped to the second round.

Gunnar Henderson finished the 2024 season with 37 home runs, validating his high selection in a home run league.
Loss
MaxMax

The Phillies will beat the Orioles in the World Series

Phillies over Orioles. Okay. So Max has the Orioles.

Neither team reached the World Series in 2024.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The Yankees will beat the Braves in the World Series

Yankees over Braves. Okay.

The Yankees reached the World Series, but the Braves were eliminated in the Wild Card round.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Diamondbacks will beat the Rangers 8-1 in Game 4 of the World Series with Tommy Pham hitting two home runs.

I think it's gonna be eight-one Diamondbacks. Whoa. I think [Tommy] Pham goes yard twice. Whoa. [Evan] Longoria has two hits.

The Rangers won Game 4 with a score of 11-7; Tommy Pham had one hit and zero home runs.
Void
MaxMax

Fernando Tatis Jr. is a 'vibes guy' you want in your clubhouse despite the PED suspension

Tatis is a vibes guy. I mean, that's a guy you want. That's a guy. I wanted my clubhouse... Tatis is a vibes guy. I mean, that's a guy you want. That's a guy. I wanted my clubhouse. [PFT: He's always suspended] Nah, he's a great guy.

Clubhouse 'vibes' are entirely subjective and can't be measured.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Trey Mancini is the Comeback Player of the Year

Comeback player of the year. We're going to [Trey Mancini]. I think that's well-deserved came back from cancer. I mean, who can top that? ... Trey Mancini has won the first Taiki of 2022.

Trey Mancini did in fact win the 2022 American League Comeback Player of the Year award.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Phillies will win the 2022 World Series over the Yankees

I like the Phillies a lot. They have the reigning MVP... I think it's going to be the Phillies against the Padres in the [NLCS] and then the winner of that... I'm going to say as the real world series champion... but no, out of the AL teams, I really think this is the year the Yankees get it done. I think it's going to be the [Phillies vs.] Yankees.

The 2022 World Series was the Astros over the Phillies. PFT got the Phillies right as a participant but the result and opponent wrong.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

The 2022 World Series will be the Yankees against the Braves

Yankees, Braves.

The 2022 World Series was the Astros vs. the Phillies.
Push
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The 2022 World Series will be the White Sox against the Phillies

White Sox, Phillies.

The Phillies made it, but the White Sox did not; the Astros won the World Series.
Push
HankHank

The Red Sox will beat the Yankees 6-4 in the 2021 American League Wild Card game

I think it's going to be Red Sox 6, Yankees 4. Take the over. Red Sox money line.

The Red Sox won 6-2, so the winner and 'over' were correct but the score was off.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Garrett Cole will be chased from the Wild Card game after only two innings

Garrett Cole getting chased after two innings would be great. Schwarber going yard off Cole, hitting the ball 500 feet.

Cole was pulled after exactly 2.0 innings, surrendering two home runs. Kyle Schwarber also homered off him.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The Yankees will beat the Red Sox 7-5 in the 2021 American League Wild Card game

I'm going to go Yankees 7, Red Sox 5. Look for an unlikely hero in the name of Andrew Velazquez or Greg Allen for the Yankees.

The Red Sox won 6-2, making the winner and score prediction incorrect.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

The Yankees will beat the Red Sox 6-3 in the 2021 American League Wild Card game

I'm going to go 6-3 Yankees. I think [Giancarlo] Stanton and [Aaron] Judge are going to be popping off.

The Red Sox won 6-2, making the winner and score incorrect.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The city of Philadelphia will turn on Bryce Harper within five years

I have a prediction. I think that the city of Philadelphia is going to turn on Bryce Harper within five years. Give it four, actually. I think that given Bryce's history... He's such a streaky player. He's got a little bit of an attitude sometimes. But when you're making this kind of money, there's a big, big target on your back.

Five years later (2024), Harper is arguably the most beloved athlete in Philadelphia and led them to a World Series, so the city has not turned on him.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Colin Kaepernick will eventually get Baseball Hall of Fame votes as a contributor to the game

Colin Kaepernick hasn't been offered a job in baseball... As a contributor to the game, I think he would get Hall of Fame [votes].

Kaepernick has not received Baseball Hall of Fame votes and likely won't, especially as a 'contributor' in a sport he didn't play professionally.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Nationals will win the 2017 World Series

I've got the Nats and the Dodgers [in the NLCS]... and then I'm going with the Red Sox [in the AL]... Red Sox-Nats [World Series]. World Series champion? Nats.

The Nationals did not win the World Series in 2017; the Astros did.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs will win back-to-back World Series titles

I'm going with the Astros over the Red Sox in the AL and the Cubs over the Mets in the NL... Cubs over the Astros for the World Series.

The Cubs lost in the NLCS, failing to reach or win the World Series.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Miguel Cabrera will win the AL MVP

I think Miguel Cabrera is going to be the AL MVP because he's in that nice spot. He's like 33, maybe getting up there in years, little steroids, getting a little second life.

Jose Altuve won the AL MVP in 2017. Cabrera struggled with injuries and performance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Home Run Derby participants always screw up their swings in the second half of the season

My other favorite part about the Home Run Derby is predicting which one of the participants the Home Run Derby is going to screw up their swing in the second half. Whoever wins.

This is a long-debated 'curse' in MLB. While some players slump, others don't, making it a general sports superstition.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm betting heavy on Wil Myers to win the Home Run Derby because he spells his name with one 'L'

I'm going heavy on Wil Myers. He is listed at plus 600. The guy is all about winning. And it's so efficient. You know how much time he saves in his life by spelling his name W-I-L instead of W-I-L-L?

Wil Myers did not win the 2016 Home Run Derby; Giancarlo Stanton won.
Win
HankHank

Giancarlo Stanton will win the 2016 Home Run Derby

I have the artist formerly known as Mike Stanton... ooh, plus 365, the favorite.

Giancarlo Stanton won the 2016 Home Run Derby, making this pick correct.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Hammer the Reds as underdogs this year and you will become a millionaire

Hammer the Reds this year. Hammer the Reds. They will be underdogs many, many times. You throw it on the Reds. You take that $10, put it right there. Probably make yourself $20, $17. Then you keep doing it. And hopefully the Reds never lose and you become a millionaire.

PredictionBaseballHotSarcastic
The 2016 Reds went 68-94. If you hammered them every game, you would have lost a significant amount of money.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers