Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Dallas Cowboys are dead

The Dallas Cowboys are dead. D-E-A-D dead. Mike McCarthy... six weeks into the season and there's already a mutiny. He looks like he's given up. [The Cowboys] are ridiculously bad.

The Cowboys finished 6-10 and missed the playoffs in Mike McCarthy's first season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Every team in the NFC East should try to get Ryan Fitzpatrick

Any one of these... anyone in the NFC East should try to get Ryan Fitzpatrick. The reason is pretty simple. You can maybe win the division at 6-10. Seven and nine, you're a lock. And all you need to do is like hope that the Fitzmagic times up perfectly at the start of the playoffs.

No NFC East team traded for Fitzpatrick in 2020. The WFT did win the division at 7-9 as predicted, and they actually signed Fitzpatrick the following offseason.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is no longer an MVP candidate

Josh Allen... he played bad. The Bills looked they have not looked great in the last two weeks. You know, he was not going to be the MVP now. He had a great start to the year. He's probably not gonna be the MVP now. I think that's fair to say.

Josh Allen finished 2nd in MVP voting in 2020 behind Aaron Rodgers.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Clemson could beat the Jets if the Jets had mono

Do you think that Clemson could beat the Jets if they all had mono? Yeah, I agree. [If] Trevor Lawrence has mono and just straight up against Alabama... If Clemson like kills both all the quarterbacks that are listed for the game then they have a chance.

The Jets were terrible (2-14) but the talent gap between NFL and college is historically massive. This is a satirical hypothetical.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts would be better with Ryan Fitzpatrick than Philip Rivers

I have a take that's going to hurt my own myself, but I think the Colts would be better with Ryan Fitzpatrick. That would be wild wouldn't it? That would be wild now we're now that you said it it kind of makes sense.

Rivers led the Colts to an 11-5 record and a playoff berth. Fitzpatrick remained in Miami.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ezekiel Elliott is officially fat

Ezekiel Elliott. Is he fat? I think Ezekiel might be fat now. Well, yeah when he starts mumbling he is. And also the nose ring's gotta go when you fumble you gotta take it out.

Elliott struggled in 2020 with 6 fumbles and his lowest yardage total to that point, though 'fatness' is subjective.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers are officially back

Niners are officially back. Also George Kittle is a hundred percent back because I don't know how he got that open, but he he deserves a couple easy ones... Niners are officially back a hundred percent back.

The 49ers finished 6-10 in 2020 and missed the playoffs, largely due to a massive wave of injuries. They were definitively not 'back' to their Super Bowl form.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am still buying the Eagles to win the NFC East

I have actually two takeaways from this game. And the first one is I'm still buying the Eagles. Yeah, so I think that there are they could have beaten the Ravens today... the NFC East is terrible Dak Prescott got hurt and the next four games for the Eagles are giants Cowboys Giants Browns. Mmm. I think they're going to go at least three in one and we're going to be sitting here being like watch out for the Eagles.

The Eagles went 1-3 over their next four games and finished the season 4-11-1, last in the NFC East. Washington won the division at 7-9.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson can't come from behind when trailing

Lamar, he's not really that great playing with a small lead either... we talked about him not being able to come from behind at all. Even if you're up by like two scores. He's just he's limited some time.

Lamar Jackson has since won two MVPs and led multiple double-digit comebacks, notably a massive 19-point comeback against the Colts in 2021, largely debunking this specific 'limited' tag.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Tannehill's success is officially not a fluke

Ryan Tannehill good is we made all the jokes in the world, but the Step has been taken and it is fully been taken. This is not a statistical anomaly anymore because last year the end of the year, we're like, oh he's doing it. But he's just playing out of his head. We're now six weeks into the 2020 season... He's good.

Tannehill finished 2020 with 33 TDs and 7 INTs, a 106.5 passer rating, and led the Titans to the AFC South title. His success in Tennessee was verified as sustainable for several seasons.
Loss
HankHank

There is a zero percent chance the Patriots miss the playoffs

What do you think that the chances are that the Patriots miss the playoffs entirely is here? Zero. Zero percent chance here.

The 2020 Patriots finished 7-9 and missed the playoffs for the first time since 2008.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

There are too many quarterbacks in the NFL right now

There are too many quarterbacks in the NFL right now. Yes, there aren't enough teams that have like a dire dire situation... We've got kind of a log Jam and come through... There's like I don't know maybe five teams where it's like, you know for a fact they're gonna be okay want a quarterback.

This is subjective, but the 2021 draft saw 5 QBs taken in the first 15 picks, suggesting the league disagreed and felt there was a major need for high-end talent.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will be underdogs every week and I will keep betting on them

The Bears are 5-1. I don't give a fuck how they're winning. They're going to be underdogs every single game. I'm going to keep betting on them... the defense is back... I know that deep down the Bears are destined for a 10 and 6 11 and 5 record and then to lose in a heartbreaking way in the first round and everyone to shit down my throat.

The Bears finished 8-8. They did make the playoffs (as the 7th seed) and lost in the Wild Card round to the Saints, which matches the spirit of his 'heartbreaking exit' prediction but the record was worse.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Gase's ability to stay employed is commendable

I actually am going to zag on everyone and say like I I applaud Adam gase for getting this far in life. Yeah, it's incredible what he has done... It is a great lesson for everyone out there get yourself next to someone great and have everyone else think that you had something to do with it. And you're set for life.

Gase's tenure is statistically one of the worst for an offensive coach. The 'commendable' part is purely a joke about his survival skills.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers struggle when they step up in class against physical teams

This is the same issue the Packers had last year they step up in class. They step up against a physical team and they don't look like the same, you know team that was started this season 5 and over... but the Bucks played physical they Blitz they fucking play great defense. Aaron Rodgers look lost.

This was largely proven true in the 2020 NFC Championship game, where the physical Bucs defense beat the Packers again to advance to the Super Bowl.
Loss
Deion SandersDeion Sanders

Trevor Lawrence will pull an Eli Manning and refuse to play for the Jets

I feel like Trevor Lawrence is going to pull a Elway in an Eli. Mmm-hmm and say I'm not doing that... It's something wrong with the organization. You can't have it. It's not too many. That's too many consecutive quarterbacks in the in a system that's bad. That's just bad... Ain't No Way in the world he's going to pull it. He like.

Trevor Lawrence did not refuse to play for anyone; however, the Jets won two games late in the season, losing the #1 pick to the Jaguars. Lawrence went to Jacksonville and the Jets took Zach Wilson at #2.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Peyton Manning is definitely using HGH

Billy football spotted that he's got the Omaha Beach... Omaha Beach nipples... possible HGH. ... He's obviously taking always multiple nipples like a pig. ... Definitely juicing, definitely realizing I feel like a lot of retired guys just start juicing because they could never do it during their career.

This is a scandalous claim based on a beach photo and hasn't been verified by any credible source or testing.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andy Dalton is a better quarterback than Dak Prescott because his limitations force the team to play better

I'm going to let's just take it one step further and say that Andy Dalton is a better quarterback than Dak Prescott. ... he's better because he's worse. So the team has to play more cohesively and I have to scheme for Andy Dalton. I can't just coast on Dak's talent anymore.

The Cowboys went 4-7 with Dalton starting in 2020 and the offense significantly regressed compared to Dak's early-season record-breaking pace.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The winner of the Bears vs. Panthers game will make the playoffs

Whoever wins this game, I would say will be in the playoffs. ... if the Bears win this game, they go to 5 and 1. ... It's got to be like 92% of teams that start 5-1 make the playoffs.

The Bears beat the Panthers 23-16 to move to 5-1 and eventually made the playoffs as an 8-8 wild card team. The Panthers lost and missed the playoffs.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Derrick Henry is not a good short-yardage running back because his legs are too long

I agree with at the start of that game when they started feeding Derrick Henry the ball. [Billy] said Derrick Henry actually sneaky not a great short yardage running back. ... Legs are too long. ... Big guys just they can swallow them up.

Derrick Henry led the league in rushing yards (2,027) and touchdowns (17) in 2020 and is statistically one of the best power/short-yardage backs in history.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams -3 line against the 49ers is a 'rat line' and the 49ers will cover

This is my stinky stinky game of the week because the line makes no sense. ... I saw Rams -3 and I was like, 'Oh my god, that's the easiest [bet] of all time.' ... It's a rat line. ... I'm going to take the 49ers.

The 49ers beat the Rams outright 24-16 as 3-point underdogs.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Football field goals go farther at night when it's cold

Kicking sucked at the start of the year. I didn't feel it. Now I'm starting to feel it. The weather's getting a little bit colder. I do think that that has something to do with the ball going farther at night. So I do like over three-and-a-half field goals in the Sunday night game.

Physics dictates that warm air is less dense, allowing balls to travel further. Kicking performance generally drops as the temperature falls.
Loss
Mike FlorioMike Florio

It is not sustainable for the Jets to keep Adam Gase through their bye week

The next four opponents... Bills, Patriots, Chiefs... it feels like it's moving in the direction where it's not sustainable for the Jets to continue with Adam Gase, even if ownership really wants to... I think it's moving in the direction where it's not sustainable.

The Jets kept Adam Gase for the entire 2020 season, only firing him on January 3rd, 2021, after the final game.
Win
Mike FlorioMike Florio

If Drew Brees gets injured, Taysom Hill would be the Saints' starting quarterback over Jameis Winston

If he gets injured, my gut feeling is it would be Taysom Hill over Jameis Winston who would play. ... I've got the impression this year if Brees would get hurt, it would be Taysom Hill playing quarterback.

Brees got hurt in Week 10. Taysom Hill started the next four games while Winston remained the backup, exactly as Florio predicted.
Push
Mike FlorioMike Florio

Kyle Shanahan will look for a new quarterback like Kirk Cousins to replace Jimmy Garoppolo after the season

I think the bigger question here is after the season. What do they do? ... I think that Kyle Shanahan is going to look for somebody else after the season. ... it wouldn't surprise me at all if the Vikings decide, 'You know what, we've had enough with this guy' and Shanahan embraces [Kirk] Cousins.

The 49ers did look for a replacement, famously trading up to draft Trey Lance in the 2021 NFL Draft, though they didn't land Cousins.
Void
Mike FlorioMike Florio

NFL teams absolutely tank, they just do it by playing worse players

Hell yes, there's tanking in football. It's just subtle. The players on the field aren't trying to lose, but someone high up in the organization makes sure the worst players are on the field. 'We want to evaluate the backup quarterback... and if they play like crap, good.'

While difficult to prove legally, several coaches (like Brian Flores) later made allegations supporting this 'front office tanking' theory.
Loss
Mike FlorioMike Florio

DK Metcalf is like Calvin Johnson and Jerry Rice combined

DK Metcalf? Buy. I mean, the guy's Calvin Johnson and Jerry Rice combined and he's starting to become fully aware of what he can do.

Metcalf is an elite receiver, but combining the career stats and skills of the two greatest receivers ever is statistically impossible for anyone to live up to.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Norman should retire immediately after that Derrick Henry stiff arm

Josh Norman should retire like soon after that. Derrick Henry stiff arms are hilarious... he does like The Kill Bill the Five Finger Death Punch on you like Taps who with his fingertips and then your heart stops immediately and you go limp you go flying.

Norman did not retire immediately, but his career was effectively in its twilight as he only played sporadically for a few more seasons.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chargers are just the Seahawks but they lose at the end

The Chargers are the Seahawks. They just lose at the end. They are the JV low-rent version of what the Seahawks do—they play weird games, are always in it till the end, but they are just always on the losing end of those really weird strange fourth quarters. They invent ways to lose.

The 2020 Chargers finished 7-9 with multiple one-score losses, fitting the narrative perfectly.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Drew Brees is officially washed

I am sticking with my Drew Brees has washed. What I'm saying is they have a Super Bowl roster and Drew Brees is probably going to be the thing that holds them back when they get in a playoff game against the pass rush... he's no longer at that level.

Brees retired after this season following a divisional round loss where he struggled significantly, supporting the idea he was no longer at his peak.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I will tattoo Drew Brees' career touchdown total on my arm if the Saints make the Super Bowl

If The New Orleans Saints get to the Super Bowl. I will tattoo the final number of Drew Brees touchdowns for his career somewhere in my arm.

The Saints lost to the Buccaneers in the Divisional Round, so Big Cat did not have to get the tattoo.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Justin Herbert passes the 'eyeball test' as a professional rookie

[Justin Herbert] passed my eyeball test right off the bat... he was a Pro's Pro. He was a precocious rookie. I like the Justin Herbert that I saw in the first few games. I don't want him to lose that edge.

Herbert won Offensive Rookie of the Year and became a top-tier NFL quarterback.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Le'Veon Bell will sign with the Patriots

In which case I think we can all agree. He's probably going to go to the Patriots because that's what always happens.

Le'Veon Bell signed with the Kansas City Chiefs, not the Patriots.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Zimmer made the correct decision to go for it on fourth down against the Seahawks

We 100% agreed together we watch the game and we said Mike Zimmer. This is a good move. Essentially we didn't even do it in a mass way. We said what do the Seahawks want the Vikings to do they? They want to kick they want the Vikings kick a field goal because they haven't stopped shit all night.

The Vikings failed to convert and lost the game, but the take is a subjective defense of strategy.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks defense is so bad that they cannot go deep in the playoffs

Russell Wilson is incredible and maybe when Jamal Adams is out there the Seahawks will look better. But from what I saw. I saw from the Seahawks and watching them. You know, I think we've watched every single one of their games and that defense doesn't get fixed. They can't they can't win a plate like they can't go deep in the playoffs.

The Seahawks finished 12-4 but lost in the Wild Card round to the Rams, essentially proving the 'no deep run' prediction correct.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Vikings are the 'best worst team' in the NFL

The Vikings are fraudulently bad... They're the best worst team in the league right now. It would not surprise me if the Vikings beat any team in the league.

The Vikings finished 7-9 and missed the playoffs, fitting the 'good bad team' description reasonably well.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders' victory over the Chiefs was a blueprint game for the rest of the NFL

The first thing that came to my mind when the Raiders beat the Chiefs I said to myself blueprint game... The Raiders got the blueprint from the Patriots and then executed the blueprint and now everyone else has the blueprint which is essentially have the best offensive line in the game run the ball really well make a few big plays.

While the Chiefs lost this game, they went 14-2 and made the Super Bowl, suggesting no real 'blueprint' was successfully replicated to stop them in the regular season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Defenders are hesitant to hit Patrick Mahomes hard because he is so well-liked

I have a take that I'm working on. It's not ready yet. But essentially if people want to help me with this trying to find some film I think Defenders are not hitting Mahomes as hard as they possibly can because no one wants to be the guy that hurts Mahomes. It feels like when he starts running there are times in a game where he'll scramble. And he'll like they'll almost all agree to give up the play at the same time.

This is a subjective conspiracy theory that cannot be definitively proven or disproven.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are going to win the NFC East

If you're an Eagles fan sitting here on Sunday night after week 5, you're you're winning this division. I really do think you're sitting there saying we're in a good spot.

The Eagles finished last in the division with a 4-11-1 record. The Washington Football Team won the division.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Garoppolo is worth exactly one point more than Nick Mullens or CJ Beathard

I really don't see the difference between Jimmy Garoppolo and Nick Mullens and CJ Beathard... How many points do you think Jimmy Garoppolo's worth like a starting healthy Jimmy Garoppolo? I'll Point. Yeah, probably a point. Yeah, they're essentially the same quarterback.

Jimmy G was benched in this game and struggled with injuries, but the 'one point' valuation is a subjective Vegas-style estimate.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins might make the playoffs with Ryan Fitzpatrick

Imagine if the Dolphins make the playoffs that's just the dolphins with Fitzpatrick make the playoffs. We could only be so lucky... I could see nine and seven might not get them in the AFC so tough.

The Dolphins finished 10-6 but missed the playoffs due to tiebreakers. They also transitioned to Tua Tagovailoa later in the season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I like Nick Foles and think the Bears will have a great effort against the Buccaneers

I like Nick Foles in this. There's not a lot to like, it's Tom Brady and Nick Foles. I've seen this movie before... I feel like the Bears are going to have a great effort tonight.

The Bears beat the Buccaneers 20-19 on October 8, 2020.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Something weird will happen with the kickers in the Bears vs. Buccaneers game

Something weird is going to happen tonight. It's gonna be weird kicker night... I'm thinking Cairo Santos might do something good. I'm thinking... suck up [Ryan Succop] is going to do something weird. Whether it's missing three field goals, maybe missing an extra point.

Cairo Santos hit a game-winning 38-yard field goal with 1:13 left. Ryan Succop made all 4 of his field goals, but the prediction of kicker importance was correct.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

Tom Brady will make a mental blunder that costs the Buccaneers the game

It's going to come down to whether Brady's been aging, whether we see Brady's age physically and kind of mentally... maybe he gets slower as you age... so to recap Billy, you think the Tom Brady is going to make a mental blunder that's going to cost them the game.

Tom Brady famously lost track of the downs on the final drive against the Bears, holding up four fingers thinking it was still third down after the play ended.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I love the Panthers to beat the Falcons

Panthers-Falcons, start there. Falcons, this could be the end for Dan Quinn. I have said many times I'm going to respect Teddy Bridgewater more and that's why I love the Panthers in this game.

The Panthers beat the Falcons 23-16, and the Falcons fired Dan Quinn the next day.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles will win the NFC East with a losing record like 3-5-1

The Eagles win the NFC East at like 3-5-1. The Eagles, they should have stopped playing right now. Yes, 1-2-1 is good enough to get you top of the NFC East this season.

The Washington Football Team won the division with a 7-9 record. The Eagles finished 4-11-1.
Loss
WS
Warren Sharp

The Eagles are better than their record indicates and will improve when healthy

A team I think that's easy to say is better than what the record is is the Philadelphia Eagles because of how injuries have derailed them and the performance of Carson Wentz thus far... when they get their offensive lineman back healthy... I think they're a team that's definitely better than what the record is.

The Eagles did not improve; they finished 4-11-1 and Carson Wentz was benched for Jalen Hurts.
Loss
WS
Warren Sharp

The Tennessee Titans are not as good as their 3-0 record suggests

A team that's worse than what their record is... it's the Tennessee Titans. This is not a team that is undefeated three and oh in the NFL. They're a team that barely was able to come back and beat the Denver Broncos, beat the Minnesota Vikings... I don't think that this team is as good as what their record indicates right now.

The Titans finished the season 11-5 and reached the playoffs, suggesting they were a legitimately good team despite Sharp's skepticism.
Win
WS
Warren Sharp

Dwayne Haskins was benched because he wasn't responding to coaching, not just performance

The bigger issue for Dwayne Haskins is simply was he responding to the coaching... it's about doing what the coaches are asking you to do and having some accountability... I'm hearing Dwayne Haskins was not able to respond to the coaching... at some point they're like, I don't know if this guy's ever going to 'get it'.

Haskins was eventually released by Washington later that season following continued performance and off-field maturity issues, supporting the claim that it was a coaching/culture mismatch.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Quinn will win enough games to save his job and finish 8-8

I think Dan Quinn might rattle off enough wins to get to 8 and 8 and keep this goddamn job... the next five games that you just mentioned right there, they seem all winnable.

Dan Quinn was fired just days after this episode (October 11, 2020) after an 0-5 start. They did not reach 8-8.