Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Randy MossRandy Moss

Justify may be running low on energy heading into the Belmont Stakes

In the Preakness, he wasn't quite as good as he was in the Kentucky Derby... Energy level might be getting a little bit low. He really needed that wire to come up when it did in the Preakness... How much he's got left in the tank is the big question.

Justify won the Belmont Stakes to secure the Triple Crown, proving he had enough in the tank.
Loss
Randy MossRandy Moss

Gronkowski the horse does not have much of a chance in the Belmont Stakes

We talked to the trainer, and he doesn't even know what to expect... It's like he's been going up against Class A pitching, and now he's got to go against the Yankees. So you have no idea what to expect. Big, nice, good-looking horse. I don't think he has much of a chance.

Gronkowski actually finished a surprising 2nd in the Belmont Stakes, nearly pulling off the upset.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A cup becomes a bowl once it is wider than it is long

I think it's when it's wider than it is long. When it becomes a chode. When it's a chode, it's a bowl.

This is a subjective matter of terminology.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If Alex Ovechkin wins the Stanley Cup, he might be the GOAT

If [Ovechkin] gets the Stanley Cup, which would be his third Stanley Cup in this playoffs, you've got to say, is he the GOAT? He might be. GOAT Vetchkin? It's either him or Gretzky.

The GOAT debate is subjective, but Ovechkin winning his first cup solidified his legacy as one of the greatest ever.
Win
HankHank

The Yankees' protest against ESPN's scheduling is a power move using Aaron Boone's inside knowledge

It's also a power move because you know Aaron Boone knows the inside deal with ESPN, so he knows the leverage he has.

ESPN did eventually move the game to 1 PM, suggesting the Yankees' leverage worked.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Darren Rovell officially killed 69 jokes

Rovell has caught on... He did it on the Browns to win the Super Bowl, $6.90. And get this, the ticket writer laughed no less than three times... This is like when your parents figure out how to text emojis... it just kind of all loses its luster.

The joke certainly felt dead to the PMT audience once Rovell tweeted it.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The best way to kill a stale joke is to have Darren Rovell use it

The best way to kill a joke... the best way to kill that would be to have Darren Rovell just hop all over, and then everybody just... so it's dead.

Subjective media theory, but widely accepted by the PMT audience.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Miss America is no longer a beauty pageant if it removes the bikini portion

It's also ridiculous that a beauty pageant is no longer being judged on beauty. That's where we're at.

The organization rebranded as 'Miss America 2.0' specifically to move away from the 'pageant' label.
Void
Dan ReynoldsDan Reynolds

Selling songs to commercials is a valid way to support a family and not 'selling out'

I've always viewed music with the eye of like... laughing and kind of throwing up like, kind of like that, that whole thing that exists in the urban world. That's kind of like, yeah, yeah, I'm in this commercial and it's dope and it's taking care of my family... I've just never understood the mentality... of like, hey, it's sellouty to make money and I'd rather be like a cool hipster that is not making money for my family.

This is a personal philosophy on career success.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James' bad body language on the sidelines in Game 1 was weird and indefensible

To never even look at your teammates in the eye and be like, hey guys, we could still win this game. That was a little weird to me. ... he did the bad body language where he was like, we will lose to Golden State. He didn't look, and he kind of moved his shoulders like, oh, fine. You guys have cooties. I don't want to touch you.

The body language was widely criticized at the time, though LeBron's performance was also historic.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The referees are taking the torch this postseason by being consistently bad

I think the torch goes to the referees. Yes, the refs were also bad. They take the torch from Kevin Durant. A combination of game one and two. They followed it up. At least they're consistent. They're consistently bad.

The quality of officiating is a matter of opinion.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Draymond Green should get credit for the dress shorts look, not LeBron

Shorts are definitely back. But [LeBron] got co-opted by Draymond Green. Green showed up in some dress shorts, too. I think that's the new look. It's like ACDC chic. Draymond said that he should be getting credit for shorts, not LeBron.

Purely a matter of fashion opinion and credit for a short-lived trend.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nothing short of injuries to Klay Thompson and Kevin Durant will allow the Cavs to win the series

When I say they're dead, I mean they could win a game, maybe even two games, but there's nothing short of like Klay Thompson and Kevin Durant both getting injured that would make the Cavs win this series.

The Warriors stayed relatively healthy and won the series easily.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dan Snyder is sitting somewhere pissed off that a DC sports team is actually winning a championship

What I really do like about this run that we're on is that Dan Snyder is sitting somewhere so pissed off. So, so mad that a sports team in Washington, D.C. is winning something.

This is a subjective psychological assessment of Dan Snyder's state of mind, which cannot be verified.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jon Taffer is a curse on everyone

Well, there's definitely a Taffer curse. Yeah, Taffer's definitely a curse. It's a curse on everyone.

The Golden Knights lost the series after Taffer's appearance, jokingly 'confirming' the curse.
Win
HankHank

Pusha T killed Drake in their rap beef

So Pusha T killed Drake. Yes. Drake cannot stop. He's still going to come out with an album. We'll probably have some subtle shots, but I don't think he's going to come out with a full-on diss track.

Most hip-hop analysts and fans agree Pusha T won the 2018 beef. Drake never released a direct rebuttal diss track.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drake doesn't have the bars to keep up with Pusha T in a rap beef

Drake doesn't have the bars... Slash Drake is also very scared. I'm just going to say this. Drake doesn't have the bars.

Subjective opinion on rap skill and the outcome of a lyrical battle.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You can't fire an FBI agent for breakdancing

You can't fire someone for feeling a dance circle. If you've ever been at a wedding, any kind of party, there's nothing more awkward than a dance circle where no one goes in. So this guy had to go in. He did an unbelievable move.

The agent was eventually charged with second-degree assault and reached a plea deal, though he was not immediately fired, he faced significant legal and professional repercussions.
Void
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

Raleigh Fingers has a better sports mustache than me

I don't think so [that I'm the #1 sports mustache]. Who's number one? You've got to go way before you guys. Raleigh Fingers with the handlebar mustache.

Mustache quality is subjective.
Void
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

Radar guns should be removed from baseball so pitchers actually pitch instead of just throwing hard

I would take the radar gun out. Pitchers watch. I talked to Jacob deGrom, and he said he looks up there, and if he's at 94, he wants to get to 95. You know they're watching and I think just take them off the board... Just so the pitchers would pitch instead of throw. Nothing better than a pitcher that knows how to go out and watch a guy throw a beautiful game.

This is a subjective opinion on the quality and style of the sport.
Win
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

Mike Trout is the best player in the game

Oh, Trout. Trout's the best player in the game. He's ungodly.

Mike Trout led the league in bWAR in 2018 (9.9) and was the runner-up for AL MVP. He was widely considered the best in the world at this time.
Void
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

Steroid users who were caught should not be in the Hall of Fame

He's tainted. You're right. You shouldn't get in the Hall of Fame. Yes, I do [believe that]. If you're caught.

This remains the standard stance for many Hall of Fame voters, as evidenced by Bonds and Clemens remaining out of the Hall.
Win
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

The Tom Seaver trade was the beginning of the Mets' downward spiral in 1977

I didn't really appreciate when I was coming up... the Mets were very good, but starting to fade a little... And then they made the Seaver trade, and I think that was the beginning of the spiral in '77, and they were horrible teams.

The Mets had 7 consecutive losing seasons after trading Seaver in 1977.
Void
Keith HernandezKeith Hernandez

If Doc Gooden hadn't missed time in 1987, the Mets would have won 10 more games and the division

if we had had Doc [Gooden] I think that it would have been... we would have had 10 more wins. We would have won the division and no one would be talking about this. So that i just those things piss you off... '87 will always stick in my craw.

A historical counterfactual that is inherently subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cavaliers lost Game 1; the Warriors did not win it

I would say that the Cavaliers lost this game. The Warriors did not win it. So it's still 0-0.

The Warriors officially won the game and the series 4-0.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If you don't appreciate LeBron James' greatness while watching him, you aren't a sports fan

LeBron, at this point, you can hate him... but if you're sitting and watching LeBron and not being like, this is incredible, everything he does, then you're not a sports fan. Even his teammates do it.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about what qualifies someone as a 'sports fan.'
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers must fire Bryan Colangelo after the burner account scandal

So what happens with Bryan Colangelo? He's got to get fired. You got to fire him. You got to fire him. You got to fire him.

Bryan Colangelo resigned/was fired on June 7, 2018, just days after this episode aired.
Void
Gary PaytonGary Payton

The modern NBA is soft because referees bail out scorers like James Harden with constant fouls

Basketball has changed. It's not like when we played. We were more physical. We could put our hands on guys. All the jumping into everybody and all the fouls going towards the offensive player, that wasn't happening in our era... Nowadays in this era... letting [scorers] go underneath your arm and letting [them] get the threes when he jump up and you're trying to guard him and the referees bail him out.

This is a widespread opinion among former players and many fans regarding the shift in officiating focus.
Void
Gary PaytonGary Payton

The 2004 Lakers were lucky to even make it to the NBA Finals

We were even lucky to get into the championships... Shaq didn't play 50-some games. Kobe didn't play 40-some games. And [Malone] 62. So it was a situation where we were even lucky to get into the championships... we just so happened, got everything together and we lucked up and got into the championship.

A veteran's perspective on a historical team's internal health and luck is subjective but highly credible.
Void
Gary PaytonGary Payton

Dikembe Mutombo has the worst feet in NBA history

You know, I used to watch his [Shaq's] feet a lot. ... have you seen the Dikembe Mutombo feet? That's the worst.

Feet quality is subjective, though Mutombo's are famously large/worn.
Void
Gary PaytonGary Payton

Draymond Green is the best trash-talker in the NBA today

Draymond is probably the one that can do it the best... Draymond was like me, but he takes it far. And some of the referees would have kicked him out a lot, and he would have had a lot of texts like me.

Trash-talking prowess is subjective, but Draymond is widely considered the league's top irritant and talker.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Yu Darvish reading hate on Twitter is making him sad and affecting his play

Yu Darvish is sad because he thinks that all of the Cubs fans and all of Chicago hates him because he's been on the DL twice and it's just now June 1st. And he also reads everything on Twitter and doesn't like getting the hate.

Darvish's sensitivity to social media and struggles in 2018 were widely documented by Chicago media.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Jimenez is a terrible friend for publicly revealing that Yu Darvish is sad about Twitter hate

How terrible, though, is it for your friend to go on record and be like, hey, every time you go on Twitter and hate on Yu Darvish, he reads it and he despises it and gets him really sad. Yeah, that's basically the worst thing he could do. I know he was trying to be a good friend. Terrible friend. Very bad friend.

This is an opinion on social etiquette and loyalty.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Nick Saban needs to relax and stop trying to expand the SEC schedule

Nick Saban said that he wants to expand the SEC schedule so that you can play nine SEC teams, which is just... Nick, just relax, man. Just chill out. Just fucking chill out. You beat the fuck out of everyone already. Just relax.

The SEC did eventually move to a nine-game schedule following the addition of Texas and Oklahoma, though Saban had retired by then.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Hue Jackson jumping in Lake Erie on June 1st is a total cop-out

He waited until June 1st? Kind of a cop-out. That's the biggest cop-out I've ever fucking heard. ... You can't wait until June 1st to jump in a lake.

Hue Jackson did jump in on June 1st, 2018, when the water was significantly warmer than during the season.
Void
HankHank

Automatic tip screens are intimidating and the minimum amounts are getting too high

When you go to pay for something, the people, when you swipe your card, the tip screen automatically comes up. It's intimidating... it's too much. The lowest amount is too much. If you get a sandwich and they show you it, you've got to tip $3 for a sandwich. That's too much.

This is a subjective take on social norms.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Sam Hinkie is the 'smoking gun' who tipped off the Ringer about Bryan Colangelo's burner accounts

A Twitter egg tipped off the ringer, which people actually think this is now Sam Hinkie that tipped him off. I think it is... Sam Hinkie definitely has a smoking gun here, right?

While never definitively proven, investigative reports later suggested the tip came from a person using data analysis techniques, but Hinkie denied involvement. The burners themselves were eventually linked to Colangelo's wife.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers must fire Bryan Colangelo over the burner account scandal

They gotta fire [Bryan Colangelo], obviously... obviously, the guy is like live tweeting University of Chicago basketball games and getting upset about his collar size. Like, obviously, it's him.

Colangelo resigned/was fired on June 7, 2018, just over a week after this take.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drake lacks the 'clutch gene' in rap feuds

I don't think that Drake has it in him. I don't think he's got the clutch gene [against Pusha T].

Drake did not respond to Pusha T's most devastating diss track, effectively losing the beef.
Win
HankHank

LeBron James is breaking his social media blackout by using his wife's Instagram

LeBron James, who said he's not going on social media one time the entire playoffs... decided that after the Eastern Conference Finals that he was going to do an Instagram takeover on his wife's Instagram account, which to me seems like he was on social media and not focusing on the biggest series of his life.

The event happened as described; whether it affected his focus is subjective.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Braden Holtby's poor rebound control and lack of mobility will cost the Capitals the Cup

My biggest worry for a Caps fan is [Braden Holtby]... these rebounds, those are not – that will not win you the cup, those rebounds... his mobility isn't nearly what it used to be. So if you're going to come out and take away those angles, the rebounds can't go anywhere but the corner.

Holtby turned it around, including 'The Save' in Game 2, and the Capitals won the Stanley Cup.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The NBA is an embarrassing joke of a league because it lacks parity

Being completely serious, it's the most embarrassing thing I've ever seen for a sport. Four goddamn years in a row and you've got the same team... How about you get the Golden State Warriors owner... complaining about what team you're playing against. That shows how much of a joke of the league it is.

This is a subjective opinion on the league's quality, though the fact of the four consecutive identical finals matchups is true.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Golden Knights forward Thomas Nosek is the definition of a true 'hockey player' who shows up in the playoffs

Say [James Harden] makes 20 million... and you know who had two goals last night? Thomas Nosek. And what does he make? I don't know, a million? That's a guy who shows up to the playoffs. That's a hockey player.

Purely subjective 'grit' analysis.
Void
RoneRone

Half-Baked Idea: A traffic app that gives you directions in the local city's accent

When you go to a city, a traffic app that gives you directions in that city's accent... you go to Chicago and you get a little bit of, 'you go left on the Dan Ryan Expressway.'

While Waze has custom voices, a native localized-accent-only app hasn't become a standard market leader.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Wilson is a star and a complete badass

Tom Wilson, that dude's a star. I fucking love Tom Wilson. He's a badass. We make fun of him a lot because he tries to cut people's head off with his skates. And he like intentionally hits people in the head... but he's no longer on fraud watch.

Tom Wilson became a key part of the Capitals' championship core and signed a massive extension, validating his status as a top-line player.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors' lack of bench depth makes Andre Iguodala being out a series-ruining injury

Iguodala being out ruins everything the Warriors do because they don't have a bench. That's the problem with super teams. Can't get a bench.

The Warriors eventually won the series and the title, but the loss of Iguodala was widely cited as the reason the Rockets pushed them to seven games.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

JR Smith is the most important player on the Cavaliers

J.R. Smith, whether he's shooting his threes or not, whether he's making threes or not, that's how the Cavs go. You can basically say that J.R. Smith is the most important player on the Cavs.

JR Smith would later commit one of the most infamous blunders in NBA history in Game 1 of the 2018 Finals, arguably proving Big Cat right about his 'importance' in determining the team's fate.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL's new anthem rule is a trial balloon and a needles complication

It was ridiculous that they did this in the first place. Essentially bringing up a story that they wanted to have die in the middle of the summer for no reason... They not only did that, but they didn't even do it officially. It's such a perfect NFL story because they made it needlessly complicated.

The policy was indeed criticized for its complexity and was eventually shelved following a grievance by the NFLPA.
Void
Doug MarroneDoug Marrone

Grit is defined by being relentless and having maniacal work habits

For me it's it's very simple and we talk to our players about all time it's about being relentless. We talk about intensity. We talk about maniacal work habits and going about it, determination, teamwork, all those things, toughness, hardness about ourselves. Those are the things that we describe grit to.

Subjective definition of a personality trait.
Void
Doug MarroneDoug Marrone

You can hear grit on a football field without seeing it

I think a lot of it for me is really what I hear, meaning when the practice starts and the pads are on, I can hear grit without actually having to see it. And sometimes during the nine-on-seven drills... I'll just kind of close my eyes and listen, you know and say okay was that a good play for grit? Was that a good toughness play?

Subjective coaching philosophy.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers