Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
George BrettGeorge Brett

Barry Bonds and Alex Rodriguez should not be in the Hall of Fame.

[Barry Bonds, in or out?] Out. Alex Rodriguez. Oh. [Steroid era guys] had already broke my record... they were always saying, if they let these guys in, I'm never coming back. And I respect their opinion.

Subjective opinion on a contentious Hall of Fame debate.
Win
James HolzhauerJames Holzhauer

Reading children's books is more effective for Jeopardy preparation than using the internet.

I went to the children's section of the library and I picked a basic book on every subject that I had lots of pictures, kept the reader engaged... usually I'd read two or three books on every subject just to make sure I was covering all the basics. I thought that that kind of intro level interesting books really helped me more than like an encyclopedia [or the internet] would have.

As the most dominant player in the show's history, his preparation method is the gold standard for that specific goal.
Win
James HolzhauerJames Holzhauer

Aggressive, large betting on Jeopardy is actually less risky than conservative play because it protects a lead.

I'm not sure this is correct, but the way I look at it is it's actually less risky to make big bets because if you think about it, if you have a big lead, you're pretty safe... if you don't have a big lead, the person who's behind you can hit a daily double... You need those big plays to win sometimes.

His record-breaking run proved the effectiveness of this strategy.
Void
James HolzhauerJames Holzhauer

It is better to spend big on top-tier free agents than to sign middle-market players who hamstring a team's salary cap.

I think that it's often better to play at the top of the free agent market than in the middle. In the middle, the Tyler Chatwoods are the real signings that kind of hamstring the team in the long run. And, you know, you can't criticize Yu Darvish without also saying, Oh, John Lester, it's worked out great for the Cubs.

This is a subjective philosophy on baseball team building.
Win
James HolzhauerJames Holzhauer

The best strategy for in-game sports betting is to wager against the most recent momentum.

If I'm betting in-game, I'm often betting directly against the momentum. You know, I find myself, if a touchdown's just been scored, I'm probably betting the under, not the over, or, you know, I'm probably betting on the team that just gave up the touchdown... fans overrate the impact of a play that just happened.

This is a recognized sharp betting strategy known as 'fading the public' or fading momentum.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Cubs organization banned the 'circle game' fan without a proper investigation to gain positive PR.

If the Cubs didn't actually investigate it and they were like, hey, we can get a quick fucking W here before we have Addison Russell, who is a shitty person... Cubs, if you didn't actually, if Crane Kenney didn't actually investigate this, I fucking hope he did. Because if he didn't and he was just like, we got to catch a quick W right here. Yeah, that sucks.

The Cubs maintained they investigated the fan's social media, though the incident remains a polarized moment in 'cancel culture' history.
Void
HankHank

Game of Thrones should end in a way that makes the most fans angry.

I'm at the point where I'm now rooting for them to do whatever will make people the most angry... I just want them to do whatever. There's a lot of things people are excited for, and I want them to fuck it all up.

Subjective preference for a TV finale.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Nurse is an awful name for a head coach

I'd like to just go ahead and apologize to Nick Nurse. I judged a book by its cover big time when they hired him. And I'm wrong. It's a terrible name. Nick Nurse is an awful name for a head coach. I stand by that take.

Whether a name is 'awful' for a profession is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I do not miss LeBron James in the NBA playoffs anymore

I don't miss LeBron. I don't miss LeBron in these playoffs anymore. I missed him in the first round. The first round felt hollow without LeBron. But I do not miss LeBron anymore because these are the best playoffs we've had in a very long time.

The 2019 NBA playoffs are widely regarded as one of the most competitive in recent years, featuring Kawhi's run and various Game 7s.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

True basketball fans prefer the Nuggets-Trail Blazers series over Warriors-Rockets

If you're a basketball purist, you say, forget about the Rockets and the Warriors just tricking each other into fouling on three-pointers. That's not basketball. You know what my basketball is? Guard play. Excellent guard play and good, crisp dribbling. And that's what you get in the Nuggets Trailblazers.

This is a subjective opinion about entertainment value and 'pure' basketball styles.
Void
HankHank

Kyrie Irving is primarily to blame for the Celtics' disappointing season

Kyrie, one. Far and away. He's supposed to be the leader. He's the guy. He kind of fucked himself here because the whole way he left Cleveland, he's like, I want to be the guy. You're going to get judged as the guy.

Kyrie Irving's tenure in Boston is widely viewed as a chemistry failure, and he left for the Nets shortly after this.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kyrie Irving is only the seventh or eighth best player in the NBA and cannot be the 'alpha' on a title team

Kyrie, he's right below it, but he's not one of those guys. He's not a Giannis. He's not a Kawhi. He's not a KD, a LeBron... He's, like, maybe the seventh, eighth best player in the NBA, but the top five guys are the guys that you need to win to be the alphas on a championship team.

Subjective ranking of players, though Irving's subsequent failure to lead a team to a title as the primary 'alpha' supports this view.
Void
Theo VonTheo Von

Hollywood lacks real stories because it is run by third-generation nepotism

I think Hollywood just didn't see like they thought that they just like narrowed everybody's mind and cornered them and owned them so much and corporations that they had just owned them so much that they could do whatever they want with them... it's nepotism now. It's a lot of third generation. Nobody from the middle of America. Nobody has any stories.

This is a subjective sociological observation about the entertainment industry.
Void
Theo VonTheo Von

Louisiana is the stray animal belt of America where animals still have 'alphaness'

I mean, I think look dude, a lot of legend lives down there... I wouldn't say a zoo, but I think [the lemurs] escaped somebody, somebody who may be a startup zoo... I just like there to be alphas because you got to even it all out, man... you had dog balls everywhere. You had more of an ecosystem.

Subjective and hyperbolic description of a region's character.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Rogan is like a golden retriever that's brave enough to do DMT

I think Joe Rogan's the best interviewer because he's curious. He's genuinely curious. He's like a golden retriever that's brave enough to do DMT.

Subjective characterization.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Country House skipping the Preakness is a smart move to protect his legacy

If I'm country house, if I'm that horse, I'd probably do the exact same thing. Because you're never going to top that. You are going out completely at the top of your game. You're a Kentucky Derby winner. And why would you ever try to follow that up?

Country House never raced again after the 2019 Derby due to various ailments, effectively ending his career at the peak as predicted.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Maximum Security's disqualification from the Kentucky Derby was 100% the correct call

The actual change from Maximum Security getting kicked out of the race at the end, that was the correct call. 100%. You can't just drift in front of other horses. You have to give them a path.

Maximum Security was disqualified for interference, and despite appeals, the decision was upheld by racing commissions and courts.
Void
HankHank

Giannis Antetokounmpo is like a fifth grader who hit puberty before everyone else on the playground

[Giannis] looks like a fifth grader that hit puberty before everyone else on the playground and [is] just dominating everyone.

Subjective comparison of physical dominance.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Knicks fans should buy tickets to every James Dolan concert to keep him away from the team

If you're a Knicks fan, you should buy tickets to every single show in every city and just have him go on a worldwide tour... Just keep him away from home as much as possible. Make him the next Kiss.

A humorous strategy that cannot be formally proven correct or incorrect.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Steph Curry gets the least criticism of any superstar in sports for playing poorly

Watching [Steph Curry] play and watching him shoot and get hot is awesome. But there is not one single superstar that I've ever seen in any sport that gets less shit for sucking than Steph Curry.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Joel Embiid has a bad immune system and is sick every playoffs

Joel Embiid, what is wrong with him?... Wired, just having a really bad immune system and being sick all playoffs.

Embiid has historically struggled with various illnesses and injuries during playoff runs.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

It doesn't matter if your team wins or loses, as long as you don't get embarrassed

In the long scheme of things, if you're a sports fan, it doesn't really matter if your team wins or loses. It just matters that you don't get embarrassed... Don't be the butt of everyone's joke.

Inherently a subjective philosophy on how to enjoy (or survive) sports fandom.
Void
Richard JeffersonRichard Jefferson

Kevin Durant is the most unguardable human being ever created

What I'm saying is that when you look at all these guys [MJ, Shaq, Kobe, LeBron]... [Durant] does things at such an efficient level and at such a high rate. He's a seven-foot two-guard. He shoots 90% from the free-throw line. He's shooting 50% from three right now... if you had to create a basketball player, I think the two guys that you would create are probably Bron and KD for very different reasons.

Void
Richard JeffersonRichard Jefferson

Kevin Durant turned Steph Curry into Scottie Pippen

We all know how great Steph is, but how good are you when you show up to a team with a two-time MVP and you immediately turn him into Pippen? And he's in the prime of his career.

Subjective ranking of hierarchy, though KD did win both Finals MVPs during their healthy championships together.
Void
Richard JeffersonRichard Jefferson

To fix the Lakers, the front office needs to be cleared and someone should be stolen from the Spurs

I would change everyone that's in my front office, and then I would go and steal someone from the Spurs... There needs a lot more checks and balances. I think even Jeanie Buss needs somebody that can tell her no or can go in there and win an argument. And it doesn't have to be someone that she's friends with for 20 years.

Void
Richard JeffersonRichard Jefferson

Scott Foster is the ideal referee for a road team because he is a 'dickhead' who ignores the home crowd

If I was going into Boston on the road, I want to see Scott Foster. Those kind of dickheads, those assholes, those guys that are kind of just like, 'leave me alone, I have to do my job.' ... If anything, if the home team or the home crowd starts acting like jerks, they will actually go the other way.

This is an expert opinion on referee psychology that can't be objectively verified but is a well-known sentiment among some players.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Daenerys Targaryen is the worst dragon owner of all time

Daenerys is the worst leader of all time... she gets her fucking dragons killed every single turn. She's the worst dragon owner of all time. Honestly. Like, they would come and take those dragons away. Be like, you are not fit to own a dragon because everywhere you go, the dragon gets killed. fly them up in the stratosphere dude they can't hit them up there she's so stupid.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Trail Blazers have the best home-court advantage in the NBA playoffs

The Trailblazers, I would contend, yeah, I'm going to say it, they probably have the best home court advantage in the playoffs.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about crowd impact and arena atmosphere.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James' best years are behind him

LeBron's best years are behind him.

LeBron won a title and Finals MVP in 2020 and has remained an All-NBA player for years after this statement.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will never cord-cut because streaming sports is too unreliable

I have so many boxes... my cable bill is like probably $400 a month. I watched a bowl game with [a friend] two years ago... It buffered so many fucking times. I had money on the game, and I was sitting there like, what is happening right now? I could never cord cut.

Personal preference and life choice.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Brad Marchand should not have been suspended for his 'rabbit punch' on Scott Harrington

I was going to puke if he got suspended. That is not a suspension. Stanley Cup playoffs, a little punch in the back of the head while the guy's on his knees... it was not suspension worthy.

Marchand was indeed not suspended, so Whitney's view of the league's stance was correct.
Win
Randy MossRandy Moss

Maximum Security's Florida Derby win was 'phony' because he wasn't pressured

Let's make Maximum Security into the villain... there should be kind of an asterisk by his last win in the Florida Derby because the competition in that race just basically handed him the race... Everybody else just decided to take back, and all of a sudden this horse is just cruising.

Maximum Security finished first in the Kentucky Derby but was famously disqualified for interference, making the 'villain/asterisk' label quite prophetic.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm 'killing' Walgreens because of their partnership with Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos

I'm going to kill Walgreens because they partnered up with Theranos. And they took people's blood and screwed it up. [Big Cat: But she was pretty convincing.] She was. I don't blame Walgreens... [Big Cat: I would get duped too.] Okay. I'm still killing Walgreens.

This is a subjective choice within a game segment.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Warriors and Rockets would both easily beat the Celtics in a series

I think either team could beat the Celtics... any of the three teams, the Warriors, the Warriors, or the Rockets, I think match up very well against the Celtics.

The Warriors were far more talented than the 2019 Celtics, though this matchup never occurred as Boston lost in the second round.
Loss
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Teams should be allowed to draw their own custom three-point lines on their home courts

Imagine if the Heat could draw their own line or the Warriors are playing at home, and they have one line. Then they go to Houston, and there's a different line... it gives a home field advantage. It's fun for the fans. So I think that would be interesting because right now, dudes, the shot is too easy for too many guys.

The NBA has not adopted variable court dimensions or custom 3-point lines.
Win
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

James Harden is the most analytically correct basketball player in history

[James Harden] deserves a lot of credit for being the most analytically correct player our league has ever seen... The shots he takes are the right ones. The shots he doesn't take are the wrong ones.

Harden's shot chart during his peak Rockets years was famous for having almost zero mid-range attempts, adhering strictly to 'Moreyball' principles.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers roster is a collection of pieces that don't fit together at all

The Sixers have a shitload of pieces that don't fit. Nothing. I don't love the geometry of the Sixers as they assemble together.

This team famously lost in the second round and Jimmy Butler left in free agency that summer, proving the roster construction was flawed.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I don't wash anything below my neck in the shower

I don't wash anything below my neck.

This is a subjective lifestyle choice/opinion and cannot be verified for 'correctness' in a scientific sense.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Raiders and Giants draft grades are an automatic F every year

You can pencil in the Raiders for an F every year. You can pencil in the Giants for an F every year. You can pencil in the Redskins usually for an A every year. And that usually works out pretty well for us.

This is a sarcastic comment on how they assign grades, not a verifiable prediction of performance, but for 2019, both teams made highly criticized picks.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Al Davis being dead is the only reason DK Metcalf wasn't a top-10 pick

By the way, credit to the entire NFL and the draft process for not picking DK Metcalf top 10, being like, hey, this guy's really good at running in a straight line. He's really jacked, but he can't do anything else that makes you a good receiver. And when I say credit to the NFL, I mean Al Davis is just dead.

Metcalf proved to be an elite receiver, making this take partially incorrect regarding his skill set, although the Al Davis comparison is humorously accurate for the era.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The narrative that Josh Rosen is a bad teammate is complete bullshit

The whole Josh Rosen is a terrible teammate, terrible human being is like the biggest runaway narrative of all time. Josh Rosen is a little abrasive. He's a little arrogant. He thinks he's smart... Aaron Rodgers, kind of the same guy... I haven't seen, nobody from the Arizona Cardinals said anything bad about him, right? His teammates seem to really like him.

While Rosen's talent failed to translate, teammates rarely criticized his character after the trade, supporting Big Cat's point that the 'bad guy' narrative was mostly speculation.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins made a smart move by taking a risk on Josh Rosen

The Dolphins did something smart. Okay, if [Josh Rosen] is bad, you got a guy who's drafted 10th overall last year for a fucking third round pair, second round pick. It's worth a risk.

Josh Rosen was a complete failure in Miami, starting only three games and throwing 1 TD to 5 INTs before being replaced.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Pace is gambling the Bears' future by putting all his chips into the present

Ryan Pace is doing a big-time future Ryan Pace thing... He basically just keeps trading, putting all the chips into right now. We need our guys right now. In three years, future Ryan Pace is going to wake up if the Bears don't have a Super Bowl. There's going to be a big pile of shit on his doorstep, and I'm okay with it.

Ryan Pace's aggressive trading for players like Khalil Mack and Mitchell Trubisky left the team with few draft picks, and he was fired in 2022 after failing to win a playoff game.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Al Horford will go into the Hall of Fame as the most overrated-underrated player

Al Horford is going to go in, like, I assume the Hall of Fame because everyone goes in the basketball Hall of Fame, as the most overrated, underrated guy. Because everyone's like, Al Horford's so underrated... Eventually, we're like, guys, we get it. He's just good.

This is a subjective evaluation of how Horford is perceived by media and fans, which is impossible to resolve definitively.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors' biggest opponent this year is themselves

The Warriors every year, it's been like no one can beat the Warriors. This year, there finally is a team that can beat the Warriors, and it's the Warriors. So I'm excited to watch the Warriors try to beat the Warriors because this is what happens at the late dynasties... I truly think they all hate each other.

The Warriors did eventually 'beat themselves' via injuries and the roster fracturing, losing the Finals to the Raptors and seeing Kevin Durant leave that summer.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors-Rockets series is the worst officiating assignment in NBA history

This is the single worst series that the referees have ever had to deal with. I will not complain about a single call these refs make... because I can't think of a worse series. You have Chris Paul literally complaining about every play. James Harden is trying to trick the refs on every play. Steph flops like a motherfucker. Draymond is like, you don't know if he's going to punch a ref. KD, triple B.

This is an opinion on the difficulty of a job based on player personalities, which is inherently subjective.
Void
HankHank

The Vladimir Guerrero Jr. hype will get old by mid-season

MLB, I will say, they're kind of overdoing. Every time he does anything, they're like, Vladimir Guerrero, Vladimir Guerrero... I think halfway through the season, it's going to get a little old.

Guerrero Jr. remained a focal point of MLB marketing, especially during his historic 2021 season, though the initial debut craze did settle somewhat.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I would rather be a zombie than be canceled

We're going to all cancel each other until we're the army of the dead. And I'm okay with that. I'm on the record being fine with being a zombie army. You don't have a lot to worry about when you're literally dead.

This is a hyperbolic value judgment.
Void
TS
Travis Shaw

Aroldis Chapman is the toughest pitcher I have faced

[Aroldis] Chapman. [He's] throwing that 99 gas, 101. Left on left.

This is an athlete's personal subjective experience and cannot be proven right or wrong.
Void
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

Clayton Richard is the toughest pitcher I have faced

Actually, Clayton Richard. [I] did not expect that. Yeah, did not expect that.

This is the speaker's personal subjective opinion based on his playing experience.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers