Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Whitney, Randy Moss, Kentucky Derby Picks, GoT Predictions

Friday, May 3, 201919 takes

The last show in the old studio. We reminisce about the best memories from the old barn plus talk about plans for the new office. (-) Cleaning up some NBA playoff stuff including the killing of the Nuggets, and KD vs MJ? (-) Fyre Fest of the Week. Ryan Whitney joins the show to talk about NHL Playoffs, the mind of a pest, and playoff hockey adjustments. (-) Randy Moss joins the show to break down the Kentucky Derby and give you winners for Friday and Saturday. (-) Segments include NPardon My Take for Jeff Fisher's stolen credit cards, (-) Kings Stay Kings Jameis wants to stay fat, (-) Mike Greenberg's dumb rules, (-) Bad Visual, (-) FAQ's(-) and Game of Thrones preview/predictions. (-)

Ryan Whitney on NHL Pests, Randy Moss's Derby Picks, and the HQ 1.0 Finale

The end of an era is finally here. Big Cat and PFT are recording the final show in the legendary, yet disgusting, Headquarters 1.0. Between the peeling wallpaper and the time John Cena tried to do something weird to PFT’s belly button, the memories are... there. Mostly, the guys are excited to move to the new spot where Big Cat is dead set on installing a bench press, much to Hank’s annoyance.

Before the move, there was some NBA business to clean up. Big Cat is leaning heavily into the Trail Blazers' hype, specifically their home environment.

Void
May 3, 2019
#10852
Big CatBig Cat

The Trail Blazers have the best home-court advantage in the NBA playoffs

The Trailblazers, I would contend, yeah, I'm going to say it, they probably have the best home court advantage in the playoffs.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about crowd impact and arena atmosphere.

The conversation shifted to the broader legacy of the league, specifically the mounting noise around Kevin Durant’s place in history. Big Cat isn't just listening to the chatter; he's leading the charge on the KD vs. MJ debate.

Void
May 3, 2019
#10856
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Durant vs. Michael Jordan is a legitimate debate

People are saying—I'm not saying. People are saying should the debate be Kevin Durant versus Michael Jordan... I kind of agree.

While KD is an all-time great, very few analysts still consider him in the same tier as MJ for GOAT status after leaving Golden State.

Part of that debate involves the comparison to LeBron James. PFT and Big Cat are starting to think the math on Finals records might actually favor the Slim Reaper over the King.

Void
May 3, 2019
#10875
Big CatBig Cat

A 3-1 Finals record is more impressive than 3-6 when comparing Kevin Durant and LeBron James

And what would LeBron James be? Three and six? [PFT: Three and six.] It feels like three and one better than three and six. We could go all day, folks. We could cherry pick all day.

The records are factual, but the interpretation of which is 'better' is subjective and controversial.
Loss
May 3, 2019
#10858
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James' best years are behind him

LeBron's best years are behind him.

LeBron won a title and Finals MVP in 2020 and has remained an All-NBA player for years after this statement.

Ryan Whitney and the Art of Being a Rat

Friend of the program Ryan Whitney joined the show to break down the NHL playoffs. The big topic was Brad Marchand’s recent "rabbit punch" on Scott Harrington. While the internet was calling for a man-hunt, Whitney stayed true to the code of the ice.

Win
May 3, 2019
#10864
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Brad Marchand should not have been suspended for his 'rabbit punch' on Scott Harrington

I was going to puke if he got suspended. That is not a suspension. Stanley Cup playoffs, a little punch in the back of the head while the guy's on his knees... it was not suspension worthy.

Marchand was indeed not suspended, so Whitney's view of the league's stance was correct.

Whitney also took some time to compare the toughness of hockey players to NBA stars. Let’s just say he wasn't impressed by Kevin Love getting a standing ovation for a broken nose when guys like Ryan Malone are out there using tampons to plug up slap-shot wounds to the face.

Void
May 3, 2019
#10867
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

NBA players and fans are soft for cheering an injury comeback that NHL players do routinely

I saw that asshole from the Cavs [Kevin Love]... broke his nose and came back with a fucking mask on and got a standing ovation. Are you shitting me? Ryan Malone on Pittsburgh... got a slap shot directly in the face... shoved a couple tampons out there and came back, no mask, no standing ovation for him.

The anecdote about Ryan Malone is true, and Kevin Love did return with a mask. The 'toughness' comparison is a matter of opinion.

As for the Cup, Whitney is surprisingly high on a certain team from St. Louis that was in last place back in January.

Win
May 3, 2019
#10869
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The St. Louis Blues have a 100% chance to win the Stanley Cup

They're a really good team. And it'd be one of the coolest stories ever. Last place, January 3rd... I mean, they got a lot of good weapons there... So there's a chance 100% that they could get the Cup.

The St. Louis Blues went on to win the 2019 Stanley Cup.

Kentucky Derby Preview with the White Randy Moss

The original Randy Moss called in to get everyone’s gambling fix ready for the weekend. With Omaha Beach out of the Derby due to an entrapped epiglottis—which PFT accurately diagnosed as "being a choker"—the field is wide open. Randy isn't buying the hype on Maximum Security, calling his recent win a bit of a gift.

Win
May 3, 2019
#10871
Randy MossRandy Moss

Maximum Security's Florida Derby win was 'phony' because he wasn't pressured

Let's make Maximum Security into the villain... there should be kind of an asterisk by his last win in the Florida Derby because the competition in that race just basically handed him the race... Everybody else just decided to take back, and all of a sudden this horse is just cruising.

Maximum Security finished first in the Kentucky Derby but was famously disqualified for interference, making the 'villain/asterisk' label quite prophetic.

If you’re looking to cash a ticket, Randy is pointing toward Bob Baffert’s stable and a few spicy long shots.

Loss
May 3, 2019
#24436
Randy MossRandy Moss

Game Winner is the best of Bob Baffert's three Kentucky Derby contenders

Game winner, trained by Bob Baffert... I think he's the logical horse. Game winner to me is the best one of the three. He's 0 for 2 this year, but he should have won both those races. I think he's coming up to the race in good fashion.

Game Winner finished 5th in the 2019 Kentucky Derby. Improbable (4th) actually finished ahead of him.
Loss
May 3, 2019
#24437
Randy MossRandy Moss

Win-Win-Win and By My Standards are the best long shots in the Kentucky Derby

Win-win-win and a horse named By My Standards, who won the Louisiana Derby... anywhere from 18 to 25 to 1. That's about the price win-win-win is going to be, too. I think [Win-win-win] is set up to run a pretty good race.

Win-Win-Win finished 9th and By My Standards finished 11th. Neither hit the board.

He also gave us the annual Oaks pick, warning everyone to stay away from the favorite, Bellafina, based on how she’s been handling the track at Churchill Downs.

Win
May 3, 2019
#10873
Randy MossRandy Moss

Bet against Bellafina in the Kentucky Oaks because she doesn't like the track at Churchill Downs

The favorite in the Oaks is going to be a horse named Bellafina... The only bad race Bellafina has ever had in her life was... here at Churchill Downs. She doesn't look very good [this week]... for a horse to have those negatives and to be the favorite, I think it's a good horse to bet against.

Bellafina finished 5th in the Oaks as the favorite, making Randy's advice to bet against her correct.

Fyre Fest and Game of Thrones

Fyre Fest of the week featured Big Cat getting cable-shamed by millennials on Twitter. Despite the peer pressure to cord-cut, he’s sticking with his $400 monthly bill because he simply cannot handle the lag during a big game.

Void
May 3, 2019·Fyre Fest
#10862
Big CatBig Cat

I will never cord-cut because streaming sports is too unreliable

I have so many boxes... my cable bill is like probably $400 a month. I watched a bowl game with [a friend] two years ago... It buffered so many fucking times. I had money on the game, and I was sitting there like, what is happening right now? I could never cord cut.

Personal preference and life choice.

The show wrapped up with some heavy Game of Thrones talk. Hank is still reeling from the Battle of Winterfell, but PFT is convinced the body count wasn't as high as it looked. He’s holding out hope for the Dothraki and even a certain Greyjoy.

Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dothraki are still alive in Game of Thrones because we didn't see them die on screen

What if the Dothraki are all alive and they knew that it was a bad battle strategy... We never saw them die. The one thing I know about Game of Thrones, as an expert who's watched the summary twice, if you don't see the person die, you can't be sure they're dead.

The next episode confirmed that a small portion of the Dothraki survived, though most were killed in the charge.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Theon Greyjoy is still alive and will survive his apparent death in Game of Thrones

Theon's alive. Well, if you go by my reasoning of if you don't get shot directly in the heart or directly in the brain on a TV show or movie, you end up surviving. [Big Cat: It took a spike through his body.] Through his appendix. You don't even need—it's right through his body.

Hot TakePop CultureFireSarcastic
Theon Greyjoy was definitively killed by the Night King and did not return to the show.

Big Cat, however, is focused on the internal politics of Westeros. He’s officially out on Daenerys and expects a civil war between the two remaining Targaryens before the series finale.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Daenerys Targaryen and Jon Snow will eventually fight each other

Dany's the worst. I fucking hate her. Khaleesi sucks... She's going to fight Jon Snow... They are going to fight. Dany cannot take anyone else outshining her.

While they didn't have a formal 'battle', Jon Snow killed Daenerys in the series finale after she destroyed King's Landing, fulfilling the core of the take.

Good luck to everyone betting on horses this weekend, and hopefully the move to HQ 2.0 involves fewer boxes of unwashed T-shirts.

nhl-playoffskentucky-derbynbagame-of-thronesfyre-fest

More Takes

Loss
May 3, 2019
#10854
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would cut D'Angelo Russell for being a 'bad decision maker' after his weed arrest

The stupidity is, like, way worse than the crime... Bad decision maker. Honestly, just put it in your pocket. I'd cut him.

D'Angelo Russell was not cut; he signed a max contract and became an All-Star that year. The take is exaggerated for comedic effect.
Loss
May 3, 2019
#24435
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will never return to the NBA playoffs

And LeBron never goes back to the playoffs. [PFT: It would be tough to overlook.] It would be tough to overlook.

LeBron James returned to the playoffs the very next season (2019-20) and won the NBA Championship with the Lakers.
Void
May 3, 2019·Npr
#24440
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The person who stole Jeff Fisher's credit cards should get a seven to nine year prison sentence

If you're a piece of shit that stole Jeff Fisher's credit card, just please give him back... I'm not going to make the joke, but many people have probably said that's a pretty hefty prison sentence. That's like seven to nine years.

This is a satirical joke based on Fisher's career record.
Void
May 3, 2019·FAQ
#24439
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm 'killing' Walgreens because of their partnership with Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos

I'm going to kill Walgreens because they partnered up with Theranos. And they took people's blood and screwed it up. [Big Cat: But she was pretty convincing.] She was. I don't blame Walgreens... [Big Cat: I would get duped too.] Okay. I'm still killing Walgreens.

This is a subjective choice within a game segment.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers