Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

A. J. Pierzynski

Monday, July 10, 201717 takes

We are live from the MLB All Star Game in Miami and we're facing a little advertisy. Sucking at journalism, a hotel guest that decided to just not leave the room we booked and a ghost ( - ). Mt Rushmore of ways to stay cool in the summer ( - ). Who's back of the week ( - ). Former MLB Catcher AJ Pierzynski joins the show to talk about baseball, the art of catching, what it was like to be hated, his fight with Michael Barrett, and how often Hawk Harrelson calls him for pillow talk ( - ). Segments include Mike Greenberg's Dumb Rules for the All Star Game. Just Chill Out Man for Darren Rovell. Put one in his earhole for the guy mad about snacks and the Indians fan angry at sex. Drunk Ideas and thats enough internet for today.

AJ Pierzynski on Cubs Rivalries, Mark Buehrle, and Being Hated

Big Cat and PFT are live from Miami for the MLB All-Star Game, though things haven't exactly gone smoothly. Between a ghost in the hotel room that only communicates through loud electronic Latin music and a guest who simply refused to check out of their booked room, the show is officially operating under "we are doomed" status. The humidity in Miami is reaching levels that might have actually ended careers before they could get to the ballpark.

Loss
Jul 10, 2017
#5340
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Berman retired from ESPN because he knew the All-Star Game was in Miami and he'd sweat too much

Chris Berman retired from the All-Star game and ESPN last winter... I think maybe Chris Berman was like, oh, fuck. The home run derby is going to be in Miami. I think he was. They don't make a sweatshirt that's dark enough to cover up the stains that Berman would be sweating through.

Berman did retire/step back in 2017, but the sweating reason is a joke.

Mount Rushmore of Ways to Stay Cool

With the Florida sun melting everyone in sight, the guys sat down for a Mount Rushmore of ways to stay cool in the summer. Hank decided to take the prompt in a very literal, and then very metaphorical, direction that left everyone else confused.

Void
Jul 10, 2017·Mt. Rushmore
#5341
HankHank

Meditating is a top-four way to cool down in the summer

My last one is just meditating. Meditate... when I said meditating, I meant cool down like when you get hot in an argument. Like when you ever get in a really big argument. You need to take a deep breath.

This is subjective, but widely considered a 'bad' take within the context of the segment's intent.

While Hank was busy meditating his way through arguments, Big Cat leaned into the more physical sensations of a summer bender.

Void
Jul 10, 2017·Mt. Rushmore
#5342
Big CatBig Cat

Laying on the bathroom floor is the greatest feeling when you have the spins

This is actually more for when you have the spins, but it still is the greatest thing in the world. Just laying down on the bathroom floor... There's actually no better feeling in the world. It's great. When you're hot, when you're drunk, when you have the spins.

Subjective personal preference.

Who's Back and the Face of MLB

James Harden is back after signing a contract so massive that the math starts to break the brain. While the numbers are staggering, PFT is more concerned with the logistics of actually spending that kind of cash in a city where the cost of living doesn't exactly match a half-billion-dollar portfolio.

Void
Jul 10, 2017·Who's Back
#28393
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NBA players shouldn't be allowed to spend their entire contract in Houston because everything is too cheap

The nice thing about [James Harden's] contract is I don't think it's possible to spend this much money in one lifetime in Houston, Texas. Everything there is, like, really cheap.

Subjective claim about spending habits and regional economics.
Void
Jul 10, 2017·Who's Back
#5343
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers loves to get angry at other athletes' contracts

This is like the Aaron Rodgers specialty. Aaron Rodgers loves to get pissed off at other quarterbacks' contracts. That's like his thing. I want him to start jumping into other sports too and getting pissed off and be like, hey, I'm a better quarterback than James Harden is a shooting guard. How come I'm not getting paid?

Rodgers has historically been very vocal and strategic about his contract positioning, though 'loving' getting pissed is PFT's comedic spin.

As the All-Star festivities kick off, the conversation naturally turned to the state of baseball and who truly owns the spotlight. Big Cat has a theory that market size eventually dictates everything when a superstar emerges in the Bronx.

Win
Jul 10, 2017·Who's Back
#28394
Big CatBig Cat

A good Yankee player will always eventually be the face of Major League Baseball

You have Aaron Judge, Yankees, big market. People forget if there's a good Yankee, he's going to be the face.

Judge indeed became one of the most recognizable faces in the sport, validating the theory.
Void
Jul 10, 2017·Who's Back
#5344
Big CatBig Cat

Every great pitcher needs to have a streak of being an asshole

I think every pitcher, if they're going to be a really good pitcher, they need to have a streak of being an asshole.

Subjective theory about sports psychology.

AJ Pierzynski

Former White Sox and Braves catcher AJ Pierzynski joined the show and immediately leaned into the friction, admitting he doesn't like Big Cat any more than Big Cat likes him. They got into the nitty-gritty of being the "most hated man in baseball" and the transition to the media side where he now gets to decide who earns that title next. AJ gave some incredible insight into catching Mark Buehrle’s perfect game, noting that while Buehrle never shook off a sign, the pressure on the catcher to not put down the wrong finger is immense.

Void
Jul 10, 2017
#5345
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

Catchers and calling the game are more important than hitting or throwing

Number one is catching and calling a game no matter what. You have to be able to call a game, know the right pitch, know your pitching staff, know when to call and what to call at certain times... throwing would have to be last, and probably hitting and then throwing is last.

This is a professional opinion from an expert, though analytics-heavy fans might argue for hitting value (Piazza model).
Void
Jul 10, 2017
#28395
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

Starting pitchers deserve 100% of the credit for no-hitters, but catchers deserve more recognition

The pitchers deserve most of the credit. Look, it's their ball and it's their game at the end of the day. But I wish the catcher would get a little bit more credit.

Subjective opinion on the distribution of credit in baseball achievements.

AJ also defended his old friend Hawk Harrelson against Big Cat's accusations of extreme homerism, though he did admit Hawk lives just around the corner from him and they're basically family at this point.

Void
Jul 10, 2017
#28396
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

Hawk Harrelson is the best announcer in baseball

Every time [Hawk Harrelson] calls me, it's a great feeling to know that the best announcer in the game is calling me.

Strictly a matter of taste in sports broadcasting.

Before letting him go, AJ played along with some Headline Grab, weighing in on the legends of the game and some current players trying to find their way on the diamond.

Void
Jul 10, 2017
#5346
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

Shoeless Joe Jackson belongs in the Hall of Fame

You think Joe Jackson should be a Hall of Famer?... Yes, I do... He had a pretty good World Series for someone trying to throw it.

The debate remains unresolved as Jackson is still officially banned from the Hall of Fame.
Win
Jul 10, 2017
#5347
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

Tim Tebow should 'go for it' in baseball even if he doesn't make it

Why not? Go for it. I mean, hey, if someone wants to give you a job to play professional sports and you want to try it, why would you say no?... If you don't make it, you don't make it, and you can always go back to ESPN and do the SEC.

Tebow did exactly this, playing in the minors until 2021 before returning to broadcasting.

Mike Greenberg's Dumb Rules and Drunk Ideas

The show wrapped up with a salute to Mike Greenberg’s favorite pastime: inventing unnecessary rules for the All-Star Game. Big Cat wants to see a "Freaky Friday" fifth inning where pitchers play the field and position players pitch, or perhaps just utilizing the fastest man in Atlanta.

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Groundskeeper 'The Freeze' should be an all-time pinch runner in the All-Star Game

The freeze is hot, right? Hilarious... So pinch runner, all-time runner, the freeze. So he just stands behind the catcher, and as soon as the ball's in play, he's running.

Hot TakeBaseballHotSarcastic
This was a joke rule proposal that has never been implemented.

Finally, Big Cat shared some of his "Drunk Ideas" from the weekend, which included a revolutionary way to handle your daily hygiene and fitness goals while sitting in traffic.

Loss
Jul 10, 2017·Drunk Ideas
#5351
Big CatBig Cat

We should have portable gyms in trucks so people can work out during their commute

We need to have portable gyms. So instead of your commute, you get in the back of a truck and you work out while you're commuting to your job. No one likes to commute. No one likes to go to the gym. Get them both out of the way at once.

Mobile gyms exist as trailers, but working out in a moving vehicle during a commute is not a mainstream reality due to safety.
Loss
Jul 10, 2017·Drunk Ideas
#5350
Big CatBig Cat

Dentist offices should be installed on airplanes to save time

I'm also the guy who has the idea that we should start having dentist offices in planes so we can, you know, kill two birds with one stone... obviously we're gonna have to get through some of these hurdles [like turbulence].

Logistically impossible and has not happened.

If you see a U-Haul with a treadmill and a shower in the back stuck on the I-95, just know the future has arrived.

mlball-star-gamechicago-white-soxchicago-cubsjames-hardenmount-rushmore

More Takes

Void
Jul 10, 2017
#5348
AJ PierzynskiAJ Pierzynski

St. Louis Cardinals fans are the classiest in baseball, followed by the White Sox

Rank the classiest fan bases... Well, St. Louis is number one. You could be 0 for 100, and they'll tell you you're going to get a hit tomorrow, even though you know you're not going to... For me, the White Sox, too, probably. Braves, three.

Subjective ranking of fan bases.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL players should only be allowed to have sex between September and Christmas to avoid off-season distractions

You're only allowed to fuck between September and Christmas. No fucking after Christmas... so that you're not going to be having kids during a stretch run.

This is a satirical lifestyle 'rule' that cannot be factually proven correct or incorrect.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers