Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Andrew Luck Retires, Rams' Andrew Whitworth And Mount Rushmore Of Guests We Want On The Show

Monday, August 26, 201916 takes

Andrew Luck retired on Saturday night and we pick up all the pieces. Doug Gottlieb's dumb tweet, why Colts fans have every right to be sad, Andrew Luck making the right personal decision and why saying a guy is "too smart" at the combine isn't all that crazy ( - ). Who's back of the week including Breaking Bad and Wayne Brady ( - ). Mt Rushmore of guests we want to come on Pardon My Take ( - ). Future Hall of Famer Andrew Whitworth joins the show to talk about the twilight of his illustrious career, playing in Cincy, the Super Bowl and more ( - ). Segments include talking golf, drunk idea, trouble in paradise dwight howard, and a Monday Reading

Andrew Luck Retires, Andrew Whitworth, and Mount Rushmore of Guest Wants

The sports world stopped on Saturday night when Adam Schefter dropped an absolute nuke in the middle of a preseason game: Andrew Luck is retiring at 29. Big Cat and PFT are picking up the pieces of a franchise and a fan base that just saw their savior walk away for good. While the internet spent Sunday fighting straw men about whether fans have a right to be mad, Big Cat pointed out that the way the news broke was the real tragedy. Schefter leaked the retirement in the third quarter of a game Luck was standing on the sideline for, leading to the viral clips of Colts fans booing him off the field.

Win
Aug 26, 2019
#15903
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Schefter blowing up the retirement timeline caused Andrew Luck to be booed in Indianapolis

Schefter dropped it in the middle of the third quarter of the game and Andrew Luck then left the field... to boos... Schefter did his job, but, dude, you are the reason why the timeline got moved up. You announced it and basically blew up Andrew Luck's entire plan of telling his teammates first.

The factual timeline (Schefter tweeting during the game) is correct. Whether it directly *caused* the boos is an interpretation, but a logical one.

While everyone mocks the draft scouts who ask if a quarterback is "too smart," Big Cat thinks this is the one time that question actually mattered. Luck had a life outside of football, an architecture degree, and a body that had been pulverized by years of gross mismanagement.

Void
Aug 26, 2019
#15904
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL Combine question of whether a player is 'too smart' is actually a valid concern

When we always laugh about the Combine interviews and the Josh Rosen, like, is this player too smart? Yes, 100%. It absolutely is a real question... This is actually a perfect case where Andrew Luck is a very smart guy. He has a ton of interest outside of football. I think he loved football. I think the injuries made him fall out of love with football because he's like, you know what? There's more to life than this.

The take is subjective as it's a philosophy on scouting, but Luck's retirement is the primary evidence used to support the claim.

Speaking of mismanagement, Big Cat didn't hold back on former GM Ryan Grigson for leaving Luck behind turnstiles for the first four years of his career.

Push
Aug 26, 2019
#20689
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Grigson should be charged with war crimes for how he managed Andrew Luck

Ryan Grigson should basically go to like, he should be charged with war crimes. Just put him down to Cuba. Andrew Luck's first four years in the NFL, he got hit more than any other quarterback. They didn't have an offensive line protecting a franchise quarterback.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The factual basis that Luck was the most-hit QB is verifiable and generally true, though the 'war crimes' part is obviously satirical hyperbole.

As for the money, PFT has some theories on why Jim Irsay is letting Luck keep his $25 million signing bonus instead of trying to claw it back. It smells like a mixture of "please come back in a year" and "please don't tell the media what goes on in this facility."

Void
Aug 26, 2019
#20690
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jim Irsay paying Andrew Luck $25 million upon retirement is 'hush money'

I think that Irsay, in the fact that he's paying Andrew Luck $25 million, that's hush money right there. I don't know what Andrew Luck knows. He knows a lot of shit about a lot of shit, and he knows a lot of stuff about Jim Irsay.

This is a speculative theory that can't be proven, though the financial transaction (letting him keep the money) did happen.

Andrew Whitworth Joins the Show

Future Hall of Famer Andrew Whitworth joined the guys in the van to discuss being the oldest offensive lineman in the league and the aftermath of the Rams' Super Bowl run. As a Louisiana native, Whitworth has had to deal with a lot of heat for his take on the infamous pass interference no-call that sent the Rams to the big game over the Saints.

Void
Aug 26, 2019
#15907
Andrew WhitworthAndrew Whitworth

It is just an excuse for the Saints to blame the pass interference no-call for their NFC Championship loss

All I said was that it's just an excuse to blame one moment. And that's the truth. The reality is, as I've said before, if they were winning the game at the moment, or if that play would have ended the game, then that would be a valid argument. But the truth of the matter was the game was tied... You can't say that you for sure won the game based off the one play.

While the missed call was factual, the 'excuse' part is a subjective interpretation of competitive sportsmanship.

Whitworth also gave some incredible insight into playing for Nick Saban at LSU, blocking for Jamarcus Russell, and why he isn't ready to hang it up just yet. Despite the media trying to push a retirement narrative on him after the Super Bowl, he’s feeling better than ever.

Win
Aug 26, 2019
#15908
Andrew WhitworthAndrew Whitworth

I want to play in the NFL until I am 40 years old

If I'm enjoying this game and I like the game, I'm going to keep playing the game. And if I feel good and I can play at a high level, you know what, we're going to keep riding... That's a narrative. I want to play until I'm 40.

Andrew Whitworth played until he was 40 years old, retiring in March 2022 after winning Super Bowl LVI at age 40.

Mount Rushmore of Guest Wants

With the Luck news dominating the weekend, it was only fitting to do a Mount Rushmore of guests the guys haven't landed yet but desperately want. PFT went chalk with Tom Brady, but Big Cat is holding out hope for a specific NBA superstar to finally make his appearance.

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Durant is going to come on Pardon My Take eventually

I'll go with well i i mean i think this guy's gonna come on but i'll go with kevin durant as my first pick i think he is gonna come on but i really really want him to come on.

As of late 2024, Kevin Durant has still not appeared on Pardon My Take.

PFT also threw Guy Fieri onto the list, noting that the Mayor of Flavortown is the ultimate football guy and would likely be an all-time interview.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Guy Fieri would be a Hall of Fame guest for this show

I'm going to go with Guy Fieri. I think that guy would be a great guy to have on the show. He would be a guy's guy. Football guy. A guy's guy's guy guy. A guy's guy. We could talk to him about the Raiders. We could talk to him about Donkey Sauce.

Guy Fieri did eventually come on the show (May 2021) and was widely considered a great guest, though his 'Hall of Fame' status is subjective.

Who’s Back and Monday Reading

Who's Back featured the return of college football names, *Breaking Bad* movie rumors, and the upcoming Burning Man festivities. PFT flagged that there are 40 scheduled orgies at Burning Man this year, but Big Cat offered some veteran advice for anyone thinking of attending.

Void
Aug 26, 2019·Who's Back
#20693
Big CatBig Cat

Don't ever show up to a scheduled orgy

Once you schedule an orgy, don't show up to a scheduled orgy... because every dude, it's like going to Fyre Fest... it's just a bunch of finance bros from New York who are a little overweight... Little life hack. Don't show up to a scheduled orgy. Orgies just happen.

A purely subjective piece of 'street wisdom' that fits the show's comedic tone.

We wrapped up with a Monday Reading that involved a woman suspecting her boyfriend of being a necrophiliac because he likes her to stay perfectly still and cold during sex. The guys suggested she should probably just pretend to be dead and see if he calls an ambulance or starts taking his pants off.

Go Colts, go Jacoby Brissett, and please don't draft your fantasy teams until September.

nflandrew-luckcoltslos-angeles-ramsmount-rushmorefantasy-football

More Takes

Void
Aug 26, 2019
#20688
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Felipe Franks still stinks as a college quarterback

[Felipe Franks] still stinks. He still stinks. But when Andrew Luck retired, the discourse shifted...

Subjective opinion on player performance, though Franks' tenure at Florida was widely criticized for inconsistency.
Void
Aug 26, 2019
#20691
Big CatBig Cat

If Andrew Luck ever comes back to the NFL, it will be for the Colts

I think Jim Irsay is hoping that Andrew Luck... is going to say hey i really miss football and i want to come back... This now makes it, if he ever does want to come back, it's going to be for the Colts.

Andrew Luck never returned to the NFL, so the condition was never met.
Win
Aug 26, 2019
#20692
Big CatBig Cat

Jacoby Brissett is going to play above expectations this year

What's going to happen is Brissett's going to play above his expectations this year. Oh, I'm betting them week one against the Chargers.

Brissett threw for nearly 3,000 yards and 18 TDs to only 6 INTs, generally considered a solid season given the circumstances, though the team finished 7-9.
Win
Aug 26, 2019
#15905
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am betting the over on the Colts' season win total now that it has dropped to 6.5

I'm taking the over on their season total right now. I think it's at eight and a half... no six, six and a half. I'm taking the over on that big time.

The Colts finished the 2019 season with a 7-9 record, which hit the over of 6.5 wins.
Void
Aug 26, 2019·Who's Back
#20694
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I only like Kirk Herbstreit when he acts as Lee Corso's guide

It's the only time that I like Kirk Herbstreit is when he's being Lee Corso's guide. I don't want to say seeing eye dog, but he's helping him with his sentences and finishing his thoughts for him. And that's the only time that I will ever like Kirk Herbstreit is when he's lending a hand like that.

Subjective personal preference.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Brooks Koepka is going to win eight majors next year

Well, he's going to get five, six, seven, eight next year. He's going to get eight majors next year. Yep. Yep. Yep.

PredictionGolfScorchingSarcastic
Factually impossible as there are only four majors in a calendar year, and Koepka did not win any in 2020.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lakers signed Dwight Howard to be the fall guy for LeBron James

Lakers fans, no matter what happens, no matter how shitty the team plays, they're going to hate LeBron or they're going to hate Dwight more than they hate LeBron. So LeBron has a real easy fall guy to point at and Dwight Howard and then be like, we got rid of the fall guy. Now it's time for us to gel as a team.

Subjective. However, the Lakers ended up winning the title in 2020 with Howard playing a constructive role, so he didn't end up needing to be a 'fall guy'.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers