Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Jerry O'Connell + Phil Hughes and the Mt Rushmore of Minor League Teams

Monday, August 6, 201815 takes

Happy Birthday to our friend Scott Van Pelt. We talk Hall of Fame speeches, Ray Lewis giving the worst TED talk of all time, and how we officially feel old with this year's Canton class (-). Who's back of the week including Steven Seagal and Urban Meyer passing the buck (-). Starting Pitcher Phil Hughes is back for the Mt Rushmore of minor league team names (he's not actually back we just taped it with him when he was in studio). (-) Actor Jerry O'Connell joins the show to talk about his new show on Bravo, Jerry Maguire, being a fat kid growing up, and being a nationally ranked fencer at one point in his life (-). Segments include PR 101 for Johnny Manziel's CFL debut (-), Stick to Sports for President Trump bringing MJ vs Lebron to the White House (-), Respect the Biz for Mike Sciosca (-), and Millenials are killing everything, an update. (-)

Jerry O'Connell on Bravo, Jerry Maguire, and Fencing

Big Cat and PFT are checking in from a Skype show while Big Cat is out in Youngstown for Rough N’ Rowdy, but the distance didn't stop them from immediately tackling the most Ray Lewis thing to ever happen: Ray Lewis's Hall of Fame induction. Between the preacher-style lavalier mic and the mention of sex trafficking, it was a tour de force of theater that only one man could deliver. The guys also realized they're officially ancient because they remember the rookie years of this entire Canton class.

Win
Aug 6, 2018
#2110
Big CatBig Cat

Ray Lewis' Hall of Fame speech was the most ridiculous ever while being exactly what we expected

Ray Lewis just now finished his Hall of Fame speech, which was the most ridiculous Hall of Fame speech while also being exactly what we all expected from Ray Lewis. I actually was getting upset, but I couldn't stop watching because it was so ridiculous.

The speech is widely remembered for its intensity and length, making the description of 'ridiculous but expected' a common sentiment among sports fans.

The energy didn't dip for Who’s Back, where the most important takeaway was the legendary status of Nick Saban’s annual lake day. PFT highlighted a story about Saban and Bob Stoops that proves football guys are truly built different, specifically their ability to ignore armed robberies in favor of X's and O's.

Void
Aug 6, 2018·Who's Back
#21684
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban and Bob Stoops are the ultimate football guys for ignoring a robbery while drawing up plays

They're so invested in making their points that they don't notice when a man walks into the bar with a shotgun and robs the place. So they were out having drinks, diagramming football plays, and they were completely oblivious to a dude robbing the bar with a gun. That is an ultimate football guy story.

On a more serious note, Big Cat broke down Urban Meyer’s latest statement regarding the Zach Smith scandal at Ohio State. It seems Urban has pioneered a new offensive scheme: the Triple Option of passing the buck directly to AD Gene Smith while claiming he followed every protocol in the book.

Win
Aug 6, 2018·Who's Back
#2112
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer's defense in the Zach Smith scandal is just 'passing the buck' to Gene Smith

Urban Meyer has figured out his defense, and it is kind of what we all expected. He released a statement... and he basically went with the, I have always followed proper reporting protocols... Gene Smith, you are pretty much fucked and Urban Meyer's just gonna say yeah he told everyone and it's your fault for not doing anything.

Meyer was suspended for three games, and the investigation did find he followed reporting protocols to his boss (Gene Smith), though his handling of the situation remained highly controversial.

Phil Hughes joined for a special Mount Rushmore of Minor League Baseball team names, a segment that really let the guys' creativity (and Phil's surprisingly deep knowledge of ducks) shine. Phil started hot with the Montgomery Biscuits, which features a literal pat of butter as a mascot.

Void
Aug 6, 2018·Mt. Rushmore
#2115
Phil HughesPhil Hughes

The Montgomery Biscuits is a top-tier minor league team name

I got to go Montgomery Biscuits. The best part about it is the tongue is a pat of butter.

This is a subjective opinion on team naming quality.

The draft covered everything from the Albuquerque Isotopes to the Lansing Lugnuts, with Big Cat and PFT eventually veering into a debate about the greatest baseball movies ever made. Big Cat stayed loyal to his roots by taking the Cubs-centric classic.

Void
Aug 6, 2018·Mt. Rushmore
#2116
Big CatBig Cat

Rookie of the Year is the best baseball movie

Best baseball movie... I'm actually going to go Rookie of the Year number one... Because it's the Cubs.

Subjective opinion on movie quality.

Jerry O'Connell then made his PMT debut, and it’s safe to say he brought more energy than maybe any guest in the history of the show. He was wearing a PMT shirt, stroking PFT’s hair, and talking about his new Bravo show, *Bravo's Play-by-Play*. Jerry is a genuine Bravo superfan, comparing the drama of *Below Deck* to prestigious British period pieces.

Win
Aug 6, 2018
#2117
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Below Deck is the modern-day Downton Abbey

Below Deck is great because it's young people. It's almost like Downton Abbey... It's the modern day Downton Abbey because it's the people who live downstairs serving the people who live upstairs.

The thematic parallel of class struggle between staff and owners/guests is accurate, making this a solid analytical take.

The conversation shifted to Jerry's legendary acting career, including the fact that his *Jerry Maguire* character, Frank Cushman, was actually based on Drew Bledsoe. As a massive Jets fan, Jerry also shared his expectations for the quarterback room in New York, which Big Cat was quick to interrogate.

Win
Aug 6, 2018
#21685
Big CatBig Cat

Sam Darnold is likely going to be the Jets' Week 1 starter

You think Darnold's going to start week one? It seems to be that way. I do follow the Jets on Twitter, and they seem to be really posting a lot about Mr. Darnold there. They seem to be really pushing for him there.

Sam Darnold started Week 1 for the Jets against the Lions in 2018.

However, the real tragedy revealed in the interview was Jerry’s fantasy football strategy. Despite being a Hollywood star, he manages his team like a guy who wants to lose money. Between overpaying for middle-tier RBs and a strange addiction to the AFC North and East bottom-feeders, Jerry might be the easiest mark in fantasy history.

Void
Aug 6, 2018
#21686
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

I use a terrible fantasy football strategy of overpaying for two middle-tier running backs

I have a terrible system that I use in auction drafting strategies that has not worked at all, but I still do it. I pay, because I'm an older school guy, I pay for two top 10-ish, like 10th and 11-ish running backs. That's where I spend the bulk of my money. So I'll probably go Saquon [Barkley] and I'll probably go [Leonard] Fournette.

Win
Aug 6, 2018
#2120
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry O'Connell is the worst fantasy football player of all time for drafting only Jets and Browns players

I'm going to pick up Tyrod Taylor. So you take Jets and Browns quarterbacks. You actually are the worst fantasy player of all time... Two Browns, two Jets. You are the worst fantasy football player of all time.

In 2017/2018, the Browns and Jets were bottom-tier offenses, making a strategy of stacking them objectively poor for fantasy production.

The show wrapped up with a check-in on Johnny Manziel’s rough CFL debut, where Big Cat found the silver lining in Johnny’s four-interception performance. PFT also analyzed the President’s recent foray into the LeBron vs. MJ debate, noting that the "Elite" debate has finally reached the highest office in the land.

Void
Aug 6, 2018
#21688
Big CatBig Cat

Johnny Manziel's four-interception CFL debut is actually a decent start because he's essentially playing a different sport

I think that's almost like a good start for him because he's basically playing a totally different role. It's like a baseball player playing cricket. You forget that there's only three downs and they're punting. People are running everywhere.

Win
Aug 6, 2018
#20163
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Donald Trump is officially on the stance of Joe Flacco being elite — he won a Super Bowl, so he'd say he's pretty elite

Donald Trump has also weighed in on the Joe Flacco elite debate. Somebody asked him that back in 2016, and his answer was he won a Super Bowl, so I'd say he's pretty elite. So yes, Joe Flacco — [Trump] is now officially on the stance of Joe Flacco being elite.

Fact ClaimFootballFireSarcastic
Trump did indeed say Flacco was 'pretty elite' because he won a Super Bowl when asked in 2016.

We’ll see if Jerry actually gets Big Cat a spot on Bravo, or if he just gets yelled at on another conference call for leaking more secrets.

nfl-hall-of-fameurban-meyerminor-league-baseballjohnny-manziellebron-jamesfantasy-football

More Takes

Void
Aug 6, 2018
#2107
Big CatBig Cat

Birthdays officially start to suck at age 26

At what age do birthdays just start to suck? Oh, I'd say 26. Everything from there is downhill.

Whether birthdays suck is entirely subjective.
Void
Aug 6, 2018·Who's Back
#2114
Big CatBig Cat

Pretending a player returning from injury is a 'free agent signing' is the ultimate sports radio caller move

It's my favorite sports radio caller when a guy comes back from injury and they're like, 'well, we don't have to do anything in the free agent signings because we basically get the best free agent back.' That's essentially what's happening with Blake Bortles.

Void
Aug 6, 2018
#21687
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL's new helmet rule is just a safeguard against future lawsuits

The rule was put in just as a safeguard against lawsuits, just so they could say we're trying to make it safer. And then now you can't sue us anymore because we care about player safety.

Loss
Aug 6, 2018
#2123
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Millennials are killing drivers by not getting enough DUIs

Technically, by not getting DUIs, millennials are actually killing more drivers. Because the roads are worse now. Because your [DUI] tickets aren't going to fund the renovations.

Hot TakeLifeScorchingSarcastic
This is a satirical inverse of logic and not a factual claim about road death statistics.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers