Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Draft With Todd McShay And Daniel Jeremiah, Jimmy Butler Is A Dawg, Trae Young Stuns Boston And The Return Of Jimbos

Wednesday, April 26, 202320 takes

Trae Young ripped Hank's heart out while he was on a peloton and the Celtics have to go back to Atlanta (-). The Nuggets and Suns are set for a second round matchup (-). Playoff hockey talk and the Leafs may win a series (-)? We talk Monday's games with Jimmy Butler having an all time playoff performance and Lebron shutting Dillon Brooks up (-). Aaron Rodgers is finally a New York Jet (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including people sending Morgan Wallen itemized reimbursements (-). Todd McShay joins the show to talk about the draft, what players he loves, what he's hearing around the league and he correctly nails Aaron Rodgers news (we taped on Monday morning ) (-). Daniel Jeremiah joins us to tell us his favorite QB's and defensive players, how scouting departments are looking at different players and much more (-). We finish with the return of Jimbos and the lottery ball machine (-).

NFL Draft with McShay and Jeremiah, Jimmy Butler's 56, and Aaron Rodgers to NYC

The Boston Celtics are officially playing with their meat. After having a 13-point lead with six minutes left, Hank had to watch from his Peloton in horror as Trae Young ripped his heart out. The Hawks forced a Game 6, and while Max is gloating about Joel Embiid getting extra rest, Hank is trying to figure out how his "formality" workout turned into a nightmare. Even with the collapse, Big Cat is still looking at the betting board for the Bucks vs. Heat series, even if it feels like he's chasing a ghost.

Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2134
Big CatBig Cat

I am heavily thinking about betting on the Milwaukee Bucks to win the series against the Heat

I am heavily thinking about betting on the Milwaukee Bucks to win the series still. I think it's like plus 1 15, 1 20. I know that's a short price. I still think they'll probably win it.

The Bucks lost the series to the Heat in 5 games, so a bet on them to win the series would have lost.

The Heat are currently being carried by a man who might be the most terrifying postseason player on the planet. Jimmy Butler’s 56-point masterpiece against Milwaukee was the kind of efficient, cold-blooded performance that makes you rethink the entire NBA hierarchy. PFT is ready to give him his flowers as the ultimate postseason riser.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2135
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Butler is officially back to being the most underrated player in the NBA

Jimmy Butler is officially back to being maybe the most underrated player in the nba in the playoffs. It's playoff Jimmy.

Butler went on to lead the 8-seed Heat to the NBA Finals, cementing his status as an elite playoff performer.

The King and The Jets

LeBron James decided to remind everyone that he’s still the King by putting up a 20-20 game and making Dillon Brooks look like a complete clown. It’s rare for Big Cat and PFT to find themselves actively rooting for LeBron, but Brooks has managed to unite the world in wanting to see him silenced. With the Lakers looking like a legitimate threat, the Western Conference is suddenly wide open.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2137
Big CatBig Cat

I'm officially on the 'Lakers might be really good' train

LeBron proved that he's still got a lot of gas in the tank. And I am officially on like, Lakers might be really, really good watch.

The Lakers reached the Western Conference Finals as a 7-seed.

Speaking of shifting power balances, Aaron Rodgers is finally a New York Jet. Billy Football is officially in a state of euphoria, planning backyard hangouts with Rodgers and predicting a dynasty in East Rutherford.

Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2138
Billy FootballBilly Football

The Jets are definitely going to the playoffs and might make a Super Bowl run

Jets are definitely gonna go to the playoffs. They might make a run Super Bowls. I'm actually so hyped. They top five defense. They have weapons and they have Aaron Rodgers. I really don't see how this goes wrong.

Aaron Rodgers tore his Achilles in the first game, and the Jets finished 7-10, missing the playoffs.

PFT, ever the visionary, thinks Rodgers needs to establish his status as the true alpha of the locker room in the most New Jersey way possible.

Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#24001
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers will date or sleep with Zach Wilson's mom to establish dominance as the Jets' alpha

I think [Aaron Rodgers] is gonna fuck Zach Wilson's mom. Just get it out of the way. Be an alpha. Because I mean, Zach said he is gonna make whoever's gonna be the starting quarterback, he's gonna make their life hell.

There is no evidence this happened.

Todd McShay’s Draft Intel

Todd McShay joined the show and immediately nailed the Rodgers news, predicting the trade would be finalized by Wednesday. He also dove deep into the chaos of the top ten, specifically the Texans' weirdness at number two and the draft stock of Jalen Carter.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2144
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Aaron Rodgers will officially be a New York Jet by Wednesday

He will be a jet by Wednesday. Ooh. Ooh. Ooh. So when this runs Aaron... I will be shocked if the two teams have not agreed the terms on Aaron Rodgers going to the New York Jets.

The trade was finalized and reported shortly after this interview was recorded.

McShay isn't buying the smoke around CJ Stroud falling, noting that the Georgia tape is simply too good to ignore. However, he does see some high-end players potentially sliding due to character concerns or team needs, specifically Jalen Carter, who he considers the best player in the draft despite some "immaturity" red flags.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#23998
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Jalen Carter is the most talented player in the draft but could fall to the Chicago Bears at number nine

Jalen Carter, arguably the best player in this draft, I would say from talent standpoint, my tape study, he's the best player in the draft. But if [Carter] doesn't go five six... Jalen Carter... could go number nine to Chicago.

Jalen Carter was indeed drafted at #9, though the Eagles traded up with Chicago to take him there.

McShay also highlighted the depth of this year's class, specifically at tight end, calling it one of the best groups he’s ever scouted. He also expects some activity in the running back market on night one.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2143
Todd McShayTodd McShay

There will be two running backs drafted in the first round

There's gonna be two running backs taken in the first round this year. So if, if you got one of those prop bets and it's one and a half, I believe take the over, it's gonna be two in the first round.

Bijan Robinson (#8) and Jahmyr Gibbs (#12) were both first-round selections.

Daniel Jeremiah’s War Room Philosophy

Daniel Jeremiah brought his scouting background to the table, discussing how teams use the new S2 cognition test and why he trusts certain college pipelines over others. He disagrees with the Texans-passing-on-Stroud rumors, arguing that it’s the only logical move for a franchise in desperate need of hope.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2146
Daniel JeremiahDaniel Jeremiah

The Houston Texans will draft CJ Stroud with the second pick

The quarterback thing. I feel like Rice [Young] is going one and then after that... I'm just gonna kind of trust my gut and go back to what makes the most logical sense. And I'm just gonna put Stroud to Houston [at #2].

The Texans selected CJ Stroud at #2.

DJ also broke down why he loves specific prospects like Devon Witherspoon and Dalton Kincaid, emphasizing that "feistiness" and "processing" are the traits that actually translate to NFL success. He also offered some comfort for teams looking to build through the trenches by pointing out the reliability of Big 10 blockers.

Win
Apr 26, 2023
#23999
Daniel JeremiahDaniel Jeremiah

Big 10 offensive linemen with over 40 starts are incredibly safe NFL prospects

If you get offensive linemen that started in the Big 10 for like 40 games, they might not ever be a great NFL player, but they're gonna play because they're all gonna be smart and tough and you can play with them.

The Big 10 continues to be a primary pipeline for reliable NFL offensive line starters.

Between the draft experts, Jimmy Butler's heroics, and the return of Jimbos, it’s the busiest time of the sports calendar. Just remember: if you're ever using a bidet at a party for the first time, don't turn the dial both ways unless you want to spend the night explaining why your pants are soaking wet.

Big Cat finally got the lottery ball for the second time ever, proving that if you just think hard enough, the universe will eventually stop hating you.

nba-playoffsnfl-draftaaron-rodgersjimmy-butlerboston-celtics

More Takes

Void
Apr 26, 2023
#24000
HankHank

The Atlanta Hawks might be a better team without Dejounte Murray

They might be better without [Dejounte Murray]. I'm already thinking that like, hopefully he comes back and they're back to being discombobulated.

The Hawks won Game 5 without Murray but were eliminated in Game 6 upon his return, giving this take a shred of credibility at the time.
Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2136
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Nuggets will beat the Suns in six games

I'm just, I'm calling it right out. Nugs and six.

The Nuggets defeated the Suns in exactly 6 games.
Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2139
Big CatBig Cat

Jordan Love is not that guy

Jordan Love not that guy. I'm just gonna enjoy it until he proves that he eventually obviously is gonna become that guy. Cause that's what the Packers do. But I have a little window here where I can talk shit and be like, maybe I'll be right.

Jordan Love had a stellar 2023 season, leading the Packers to a playoff win over the Cowboys and proving he is indeed 'that guy.'
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The Pittsburgh Pirates are actually a really good baseball team

Just tip of the cap to the Pittsburgh Pirates. Yeah. With the Sacramento Kings doing that nba, they've been made fun of. They've been bad. The pirates have been awful. And they're... the pirates are really good. The Pittsburgh Pirates.

The Pirates cooled off significantly and finished the 2023 season with a losing record of 76-86.
Win
Apr 26, 2023
#23996
Todd McShayTodd McShay

The 2023 NFL draft class features the best tight end group in over 20 years

This might be the best tight end group that I've been a part of in the NFL draft in 22 years of doing it. Everyone knows about Dalton Kincaid from Utah... Michael Mayer from Notre Dame is gonna be a stud... Luke Musgrave, Sam LaPorta... the list goes on and on.

The 2023 tight end class proved to be historically productive, with Sam LaPorta and Dalton Kincaid having immediate high-level impacts as rookies.
Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2141
Todd McShayTodd McShay

The Houston Texans will not take CJ Stroud at number two

I'm not hearing that anymore. I'm hearing it's coming down to Tyree Wilson from Texas Tech... or Will Anderson, the outside linebacker. I'll be surprised if they take a quarterback at two.

The Texans selected CJ Stroud with the second overall pick.
Win
Apr 26, 2023
#23997
Todd McShayTodd McShay

CJ Stroud is definitively the best pure pocket passer in the 2023 NFL draft class

I mean, find me a better tape than [CJ] Stroud versus Georgia. I mean, that's an NFL defense. And what he did, he just ripped them apart. He almost ended the Georgia run. And I just think he's the best pure pocket passer in the class.

Stroud's historic rookie season in Houston proved him to be an elite pocket passer immediately.
Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2142
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Will Levis will be drafted by the Indianapolis Colts at number four

I still, all the information I'm getting is that Will Levis is gonna go [number] four [to the Colts].

The Colts selected Anthony Richardson at #4. Will Levis fell out of the first round entirely and was taken #33 by the Titans.
Loss
Apr 26, 2023
#2145
Daniel JeremiahDaniel Jeremiah

Zay Flowers will be the first wide receiver drafted

I think Zay Flowers from Boston College can be the first receiver picked ahead of Jackson Smith-Njigba, which I think would surprise a lot of people.

Jackson Smith-Njigba was the first WR taken (#20), followed by Quentin Johnston (#21) and Zay Flowers (#22).
Win
Apr 26, 2023
#2147
Daniel JeremiahDaniel Jeremiah

The New England Patriots will trade back from the 14th pick

Belichick loves to just trade back and accumulate fifth rounders. I don't think that they're gonna pick at 14.

The Patriots traded down from 14 to 17 with the Steelers.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers