Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Pardon My Take Featuring Mike Portnoy 03/11/2016

Friday, March 11, 201612 takes

NFL Free Agency, winners and losers, Goose Gossage and bat flips, Heath Evans, and Adam Schefter cracking are today's topics. Today's segments are O-VER-RATED, sorry not sorry and dumbest thing I did all week.

Mike Portnoy on ESPN Legal Battles and the Houston Texans' Quarterback Graveyard

NFL Free Agency is in full swing, and Big Cat and PFT Commenter are trying to make sense of a world where the Cleveland Browns are somehow the most logical team in the league by simply doing nothing. While other teams are throwing money at problems, the Browns are letting everyone walk out the door, which PFT argues is actually a galaxy-brain move to avoid the inevitable public failure of a splash signing.

Push
Mar 11, 2016
#16084
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cleveland Browns are smarter to do nothing in free agency than to fail spectacularly again

I think the Browns are just playing the game where they fucked up so bad in the past and everything that they've done that not doing anything is actually a smarter move than trying to do something and failing because you can't stay still. You're going to piss off your fans for about six months if you don't do anything in free agency. But a fan's not going to remember that like a year from now.

The Browns went 1-15 in 2016, so doing nothing did not lead to success, though it fits the narrative of their 'Moneyball' era strategy at the time.

PFT also pointed out that for a team like Cleveland, the only way to actually acquire talent is through the draft, which he views as a more sanctioned form of human trafficking.

Void
Mar 11, 2016
#27167
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL Draft is essentially just kidnapping players for the benefit of the Cleveland Browns

The only reason [the Browns] can get players to play on their team is by essentially tricking them to join the team via the draft. That's pretty much – the draft is kidnapping players, if we're going to be honest with themselves.

This is a satirical philosophical take on the draft, not a literal claim of criminal kidnapping.

Meanwhile, the Houston Texans decided to back up the Brinks truck for Brock Osweiler. Big Cat is convinced this is a match made in heaven, mostly because Osweiler perfectly fits the mold of the mediocre-to-terrible white quarterbacks that have defined the Texans' franchise since its inception.

Win
Mar 11, 2016
#16086
Big CatBig Cat

Brock Osweiler is the perfect fit to continue the Texans' lineage of awful quarterbacks

Brock Osweiler to the Texans, there has never been a better fit in the entire world. And I'm not talking about fit like, oh, the Texans need a quarterback... I'm talking about Brock Osweiler is the perfect guy to continue the Houston Texans mantle of awful quarterbacks. David Carr, Sage Rosenfels, T.J. Yates, Matt Schaub, Brandon Weeden, Ryan Mallett, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Brian Hoyer.

Osweiler was indeed a massive bust for the Texans, lasting only one season before being traded away.

Beyond the scheme fit, Big Cat has a very specific physical concern for the new $72 million man. At 6'8", Osweiler is simply too much human being for the NFL field.

Loss
Mar 11, 2016
#16088
Big CatBig Cat

Brock Osweiler is so tall that he will trip a lot in the NFL

Brock Osweiler. He's like six-eight. He's crazy tall, too tall. I feel like he's going to trip a lot in the NFL. Is that crazy?

While Osweiler struggled with pocket presence, there is no data suggesting he 'tripped' more than other players due to his height.

The Fall and Rise of Adam Schefter

There is a war brewing in the NFL insider world, and Adam Schefter is feeling the heat. With Ian Rapoport snatching scoops and Schefter getting caught by fake troll accounts, the guys think we are seeing a man on the edge. PFT actually likes the desperation, noting that Schefter's recent outburst at Hannah Storm is a sign that the competitive fire is still burning.

Win
Mar 11, 2016
#27168
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adam Schefter is a 'strong buy' because he still has the fire to make a comeback

I like that fire, though. You got to have that fire to make a comeback. So Adam Schefter is a strong buy for me.

Schefter remained the preeminent NFL insider for years after this take, so the 'buy' was correct in retrospect.

Goose Gossage vs. The Nerds

Baseball is back, and so is the irrational anger of old men. Goose Gossage went on an all-time rant against Jose Bautista and the "Harvard nerds" ruining the game with their rotisserie baseball. The guys are fully on board with the entertainment value of a 60-year-old man who still wants to give wedgies to anyone who looks at a spreadsheet. The debate naturally shifted to bat flips, which Big Cat uses as his definitive moral compass for the human race.

Void
Mar 11, 2016
#16091
Big CatBig Cat

Hating bat flips is the ultimate litmus test for being a bad person

Is there a better litmus test in the world than people who hate bat flips being like just shitty people. Like if you hate a bat flip, it's basically like people who like kill like puppies and people who hate bat flips. That's the quickest way to figure out if you're a bad person. If you don't like bat flips, I don't even know where I would love to hear someone explain to me how they got to the point where they're like, goddamn backflips.

Inherently subjective moral judgment used for comedic effect.

Legal Counsel with Mr. Portnoy

Since ESPN sent a cease and desist letter regarding the show's name and logo, the guys did the only logical thing: they called Dave Portnoy’s dad. Mike Portnoy, the only lawyer they know, joined the show to provide some pro bono (and very noncommittal) advice. He confirmed that Disney is indeed pushing around the little guy, but warned that simply telling them to kick rocks might not be a sustainable long-term strategy.

Win
Mar 11, 2016
#16092
Mr. PortnoyMr. Portnoy

Disney and ESPN have the power to push Pardon My Take around as a 'big guy' vs 'little guy' dynamic

Oh, it's definitely ESPN and Disney pushing around the little guy, but they have the ability to push you around. That's what big guys do to little guys. That's what the economy and life is all about, I guess. ... This isn't going to go away unless something is done. I don't think you can keep in the posture that you're in right now and basically get back to them and say, F you. I don't think that's going to get you very far.

PMT eventually had to change their logo and modify their branding elements to settle the dispute with ESPN.

In the spirit of compromise, Big Cat and PFT announced they are changing the logo to avoid further confusion with certain four-letter networks, but the name is staying put.

Win
Mar 11, 2016·Jimbos
#16096
Big CatBig Cat

Pardon My Take will not change its name despite ESPN's cease and desist

We've changed the logo. ... We are not changing the name. We will fight to the death to not change this name. So ESPN, come at us. We're not fucking budging on that.

They never changed the name 'Pardon My Take', so Big Cat was correct and stood his ground.

Overrated and Jimbos

In a special 3/11 edition of Overrated, PFT took aim at the band 311, calling them the ultimate soundtrack for the middle schooler who started smoking weed way too early.

Void
Mar 11, 2016·Overrated
#16094
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The band 311 is one of the top five most overrated bands of all time

In honor of 311, I'm going to talk about overrated bands. And number one on my list is the band 311. ... 311 is the band that your friend in middle school that started smoking weed before everybody got really into. ... The fact is that 311 just sucks. And they have maybe one or two songs that I will not change the radio station to. But overall, I would say that 311 is, even when you're high, 311 is one of the top five most overrated bands of all time.

Music preference is subjective.

Big Cat followed up by attacking Oasis, not for their music, but for their blatant attempt to trick the general public into thinking they were actually the Beatles.

Void
Mar 11, 2016·Overrated
#16095
Big CatBig Cat

Oasis is an overrated band because they were just confusing the marketplace by ripping off the Beatles

My one overrated band, I'm going with Oasis because I honestly – you want to talk about copyright infringement? I thought Oasis were the Beatles for a really long time. So I'm saying Oasis. They clearly were trying to rip off the Beatles and make everyone – they were confusing the marketplace. And I don't appreciate that.

Subjective musical opinion.

The show wrapped up with the inaugural "Jimbo of the Week" segment, featuring a listener who actually ran himself over with his own car while trying to stop it from rolling away in neutral. It’s a high bar for stupidity that will be hard to top next week.

If you see a man in yoga pants at a Lululemon this weekend, just know it might be PFT trying to confuse the marketplace.

nfl-free-agencyhouston-texanscleveland-brownsmlb311legal-advice

More Takes

Win
Mar 11, 2016
#16090
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adam Schefter is on the comeback trail after getting 'killed' by Ian Rapoport

I would not be surprised to see Schefter on the comeback trail. You see a little life coming out of him when he's yelling at Hannah Storm. You see a little life when he's getting pissed off about getting [fake reported]. ... Don't count him out just yet.

Schefter did indeed maintain his top spot despite the heavy competition from Rapoport.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Harper would be more likable if he shaved male pattern baldness into his head

If he didn't have the hair that he had, I think he would get a lot more love. Like think about Mike Trout. You don't hate Mike Trout because Mike Trout's kind of pudgy. He's like, doesn't have very good hair. ... Bryce Harper. He's doing every, every time I look around, he's got his hair flowing everywhere and he's got his shirt off. He's doing this. He's hitting home runs. You can't have it all. So either you change your name to Bruce or you shave your head, maybe shave male pattern baldness in, and then I'll start being a fan of Bruce Harper.

Subjective take on athlete branding and public perception.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers