Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Fitzpatrick, Steelers Bounce Dolphins, Hot Seat/Cool Throne + Listener FAQ’s With A Big Show Announcement

Wednesday, December 17, 202529 takes

The Steelers look to be peaking at the right time as they end the Dolphins season and Tua’s future in doubt. Aaron Rodgers looks all the way back and we talk playoff implications going into the 3rd to last week of the season (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including a terrible take by Joel Klatt, LeBron obsessed with golf, smelling your own farts curing diseases and more (-). Ryan Fitzpatrick joins the show to talk ball, Seahawks/Rams, Phil Rivers, who he trusts down the home stretch, teams with nothing to play for and taking the famous Josh Allen picture (-). We finish with listener FAQ’s including a big show announcement for 2026 (-).

Ryan Fitzpatrick on Playoff Trusts, Steelers Hot Streak, and Major Netflix News

The Pittsburgh Steelers are officially the team that refuses to die. After a dominant Monday Night Football win over the Dolphins, the vibes in the Steel City are reaching a fever pitch. Big Cat is finally ready to admit that the version of Aaron Rodgers we saw this week looks suspiciously like the guy who used to terrorize the NFC North for a living.

Void
Dec 17, 2025
#19827
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers is back to his old self

I think Aaron Rodgers might be back. The Old Gun Slinger... the last two games, he has looked old Rodgers like, and if he is going to play like that, then yes, I do think [the Steelers] can win a playoff game.

Rodgers' performance fluctuates, but 'being back' is subjective based on recent statistical surges.

PFT has been driving the Steelers bandwagon all season, and he’s not getting off now. While the rest of the world is waiting for the wheels to fall off, he's already looking at potential wild card matchups where Mike Tomlin’s defense can create some real problems.

Loss
Dec 17, 2025
#19824
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers will win a playoff game this year

I think the Steelers, this is the year that they're going to win a playoff game. I've set it all year. ... If they can play the Chargers, if they can get that matchup, I feel like they could win that one.

The Steelers did not win a playoff game in the 2025-26 season.

However, it wouldn't be PMT without a little healthy skepticism. PFT did some digging into the legendary Monday night home winning streak and found some numbers that might suggest the schedule makers in New York have a bit of a soft spot for the Terrible Towel.

Void
Dec 17, 2025
#19825
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL engineered the Steelers' Monday Night Football winning streak

The NFL has engineered this streak for the Pittsburgh Steelers. The win-loss record, the winning percentage of opponents that the Steelers have played during the streak on Monday night football is 40%. That is by far the weakest schedule of any team that's played on Monday Night Football.

While the opponent winning percentage can be calculated, 'engineering' implies intent which is a subjective conspiracy claim common to the show.

On the other side of the ball, the Miami Dolphins are once again proving that they are a strictly fair-weather operation. The candy-ass uniforms and the South Beach humidity don't travel well to Pittsburgh in December. Big Cat is officially out on the Mike McDaniel cold-weather experience, noting that at some point, you have to stop saying you aren't cold and actually win a game.

Win
Dec 17, 2025
#19826
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McDaniel cannot win in cold weather

The Dolphins have lost 13 straight games, including the playoffs, with kickoff temperatures below 40 degrees since 2016. ... He keeps saying that he's not cold and he gets there early to practice in the cold. ... Mentally, physically, in all the ways, the cold has beaten him.

The stat is verifiable and the Dolphins continue to struggle in late-season/cold games.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne and the War on Joel Klatt

Hot Seat/Cool Throne took a turn for the collegiate as the guys went after Joel Klatt for his recent comments disparaging the NCAA Tournament and the current College Football Playoff format. Hank was personally offended by the notion that the most exciting three weeks in sports could be considered "unfair."

Void
HankHank

The NCAA Tournament is the most fair tournament in sports

My Hot Seat is Joel Klatt. He said that the NCAA tournament is a joke. ... Most unfair tournament in all sports? It's the most fair.

This is a subjective debate about tournament structure and merit.

Big Cat took it a step further, suggesting that the only way to truly embrace the chaos of the sport is to open the gates even wider. If we love Cinderellas in March, why are we trying to keep them out in December?

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The College Football Playoff should expand to a 16-team format

We do love Cinderellas in the first couple of rounds. And this is why they should go to a 16 team playoff and we should give the Cinderellas a chance. I'm excited to see JMU play. Fuck it.

This is a structural opinion on how the sport should be governed.

LeBron James also found his way onto the Cool Throne, but not for anything he's doing on the hardwood. The King has officially transitioned into his retired-dad phase, practicing his interlock grip on the sidelines and obsessing over golf content. PFT is convinced LeBron is only a few weeks away from launching his own vlog or getting into a heated debate about the ruling at the Internet Invitational.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is officially obsessed with golf

He is checked out. He's got the bug. He's officially obsessed with golf. I would like to see his YouTube stats... I think he's deep into the Pop Does Sports Universe. He probably watched the Internet Invitational.

LeBron frequently posts about golf, though his commitment level to YouTube content creators is speculative.

Ryan Fitzpatrick Talks Ball

Our good friend Ryan Fitzpatrick joined the show to help us wrap our heads around a chaotic Week 15. Fitz provided some elite perspective on Philip Rivers' comeback and why the veteran savvy of a 44-year-old can sometimes outweigh the raw athleticism of a younger prospect who doesn't know how to set a protection.

When it comes to the actual contenders, Fitz is narrowing his list down to the teams that have the structural integrity to survive January. He’s buying high on the Rams and Niners, while keeping a very close eye on the Bills because of the guy under center.

Push
Dec 17, 2025
#26917
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

My top five most trusted teams for the 2025 playoffs are the Rams, Bills, Texans, Patriots, and 49ers

The Rams, the Bills, Houston, New England and San Francisco. ... If you ask me next week if the Seahawks win this game versus the Rams, they'll move into being able to be trusted. But you know, just like Shane Steichen, I got trust issues.

Fitzpatrick's top 5 trusted playoff teams were the Rams, Bills, Texans, Patriots, and 49ers. All five made the playoffs. The Patriots made it to the Super Bowl, and the Rams made the NFC Championship. However, the Seahawks (who won it all) and Bears were not on his list. Since all 5 of his teams did make the playoffs and some went deep, this is partially correct.

The conversation shifted to the rookie class, where Big Cat continues to be the president of the Caleb Williams fan club. Fitz noted that while Caleb's ability to create on the move is special, some of the coaching philosophies in Chicago might actually be hampering his deep-ball development.

Void
Dec 17, 2025
#26919
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Ben Johnson's 'no 50/50 balls' mentality actually hurts Caleb Williams' deep ball accuracy

When Ben Johnson said we don't throw 50/50 balls, I actually think that mentality hurts Caleb on his deep passes because there's a lot of deep passes that he throws that get overthrown because he's nervous. ... It's either gotta be the perfect ball or it's gotta be too far and incomplete.

This is an expert interpretation of a player's performance based on coaching directives.

A Massive Announcement for 2026

We wrapped up the show with a bit of a bombshell during the FAQ segment. Big Cat and PFT shared that starting in January 2026, the video version of Pardon My Take will be moving to a brand new home.

Win
Dec 17, 2025·Picks
#26921
Big CatBig Cat

Pardon My Take's video content will be exclusive to Netflix starting in January 2026

Major news. ... in 2026, January, we don't have the exact date, but we have come to a deal with Netflix. So, Pardon My Take is going to be on Netflix. ... the podcast video will be exclusively on Netflix. ... literally nothing is changing [for listeners].

This is a formal business announcement from the hosts.

It’s a massive move for the show and a way to make sure the guys behind the scenes like Shane, Pug, and Memes are taken care of as the podcast continues to grow. Don't worry, the audio feed isn't changing and the content will remain as stupid as ever.

Now we just have to wait for the first Zach Wilson documentary to hit the platform.

nflpittsburgh-steelersmiami-dolphinscollege-football-playoffnetflixryan-fitzpatrick

More Takes

Void
Dec 17, 2025
#26912
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins should start Zach Wilson for the final three games of the season

Why wouldn't you just play Zach Wilson the last three games? ... I don't know if you can just run it back with [Tua Tagovailoa]. [Tua] is just not good. Like the first three and a half quarters was just some really bad quarterback play.

The Dolphins' decision to bench their franchise QB for a draft bust is a matter of coaching strategy that can be debated.
Void
Dec 17, 2025
#19828
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially a 'Quin de Aragua' guy and want to see Quinn Ewers start for the Dolphins

Why not play Quinn Ewers? ... I am intrigued. I'm questioning whether or not I wanna see Quinn Ewers play. ... I think I am a Quinn Ewers guy. ... Quin de Aragua. There's a Venezuelan Street gang... Tren de Aragua. Exactly. ... This is a South American version of the Straub Boys.

The 'Quin de Aragua' bit is entirely satirical, while the suggestion to play Ewers is a testable but unlikely coaching decision.
Loss
Dec 17, 2025
#19829
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I bet on the 49ers to win the Super Bowl at 21-1

Yesterday I put a future in on the 49ers to win the Super Bowl. 21 to one. ... If the Seahawks beat the Rams, then the Niners have a chance at it. ... They have a real chance to get the one seed. And I kind of like how Brock Purdy's been playing.

The 49ers did not win the Super Bowl in 2026.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JMU isn't like Liberty; they will be competitive in the playoff

We're not fucking Liberty, dude. We have sex at James Madison University. It's encouraged, it's mandatory. ... If one of those teams keeps it competitive, they might not change the format too much.

JMU was blown out in their playoff appearance, leading to further format debates.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Miami deserved a spot in the College Football Playoff over Notre Dame

You can't eliminate the fact that the games need to matter. It's why we said that Miami should be in over Notre Dame. It's why that if you win games, you should have a seat at the table.

This is a subjective debate about playoff selection criteria.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams money line is the play because of Sean McVay's new baby

Sean McVay, they, the Rams money line's gotta be the play. ... Absolutely. New baby. Good vibes.

The Rams won their Thursday night game against the Seahawks.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 'Haters' were right about Jayden Daniels being injury prone

The haters were right. Congratulations. Jayden's shut down for the season. RG4, injury prone, made out of glass. ... Haters were right. Can't say anything to the haters. Focus on next year.

Daniels was indeed shut down, fulfilling the 'injury prone' label for his critics in 2025.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA Cup means nothing to me

I'm excited to watch the game. I just don't care who the NBA cup means nothing to me. ... There's no way you'll be able to be like, oh yeah, 2025. That was the year the Spurs won the NBA cup.

The Spurs did win the 2025 NBA Cup, but its long-term significance is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams' throw to DJ Moore was better than 'The Catch'

Caleb's Throw was better than Joe Montana's. He threw it from the 30. Joe Montana threw it from the 18. ... I liked it so much. I thought it was the catch. I sent it to Chris Berman. ... maybe a better throw and maybe a better catch.

While physically a 'better' throw by some metrics, historical significance ('The Catch') is subjective and generally favors Montana.
Win
ZacZac

Cooper Flagg is fully activated after his 40-point game

Cooper Flagg may have fully been activated. He has reached full activation. 18 years old. 40 piece in regulation. ... If we're talking just highlight tapes, he's looking good.

Flagg continues to be a consensus top prospect, validating the 'activation' claim.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The future of the NBA is in Victor Wembanyama and Sam Presti's hands

I would say the future of basketball's in [Wembanyama] and Sam Presti's hands. ... The Thunder are also in Dodger land. They are in Dodger land. ... Which is insane 'cause they're doing it with a cat.

This is a long-term projection of NBA power dynamics.
Win
Dec 17, 2025
#19838
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Philip Rivers won't play as well in his second game back

Seattle didn't come after him at all. ... I have to imagine they're gonna come after him a little bit more this week, put some pressure on him... that ball's gonna come out quick. He's not gonna take a whole lot of hits. ... I don't know that that's gonna bode well for Philip, unfortunately.

Rivers struggled in his second game as defenses adjusted to his limited mobility.
Win
Dec 17, 2025
#19839
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The Jaguars won't make noise in the playoffs despite Trevor Lawrence's form

Trevor Lawrence has certainly gotten better this year. I'm not too concerned about the Jacksonville Jaguars making noise in the playoffs, so— [Big Cat: 'Oh, okay. So yeah, we do overreact to everything.']

The Jaguars were eliminated early in the 2026 playoffs.
Void
Dec 17, 2025
#26916
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The Rams have the most underrated offensive line in football

The Rams, Andrew Whitworth keeps telling me he's in my ear like this is the most underrated offensive line in football. ... Just watch how many times their running back gets through the line without being touched.

Underrated is a subjective label, though PFF grades and rushing stats can provide some evidence.
Win
Dec 17, 2025
#19840
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The 49ers will be a very dangerous team in the playoffs

Brock Purdy, he's starting to really warm up. ... they're getting healthy at the right time on offense. ... I think they'd be a really dangerous team in the playoffs. ... a team rallying to the ball on defense and it pops out to you when you're watching.

The 49ers made the NFC Championship game, proving they were a 'dangerous' playoff out.
Void
Dec 17, 2025
#26918
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams is the best quarterback in the NFL at throwing on the run

I was talking to my kids and we're watching the game and I said, this dude throws better than anybody in the NFL on the run. ... the velocity that that dude can put on the ball and the accuracy that he throws with when he gets outside the pocket.

This is a subjective ranking of a specific skill among NFL quarterbacks.
Loss
Dec 17, 2025
#19841
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Travis Kelce will likely retire after this season

If I'm Kansas City, first of all, we gotta figure out what's Travis Kelce gonna do and it, you know, I would guess that he's gonna retire, but I have zero inside information on that.

Travis Kelce did not retire after the 2025-26 season.
Void
Dec 17, 2025
#26920
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

I would not be in the business of paying Kyle Pitts a big contract

He's a very specific guy. ... you look at a guy like Darren Waller who came out of retirement and the success that he's had in Miami. ... The biggest thing I see with Kyle Pitts... he's a little bit awkward catching the ball over his shoulders. ... Somebody's certainly gonna pay him. And I, I don't think I would be in that business though.

The value of Pitts' next contract and his subsequent performance will decide this, but it remains a matter of GM philosophy.
Loss
Dec 17, 2025·FAQ
#19842
MemesMemes

Jayden Daniels is the worst quarterback from the 2024 draft class

My preemptive take of the year was right. Commanders would miss a playoffs and Jayden Daniels be the worst out of all the quarterbacks in 2024. [Big Cat: 'Michael Penix?'] He looked pretty good before the injury.

By most statistical measures and eye tests, Daniels was far from the 'worst' of the class, having won OROY in many circles.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers