Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Final Four should always be played in Indianapolis

The Final Four should always be in Indianapolis. It should be its forever home. They make it such a big event. They care about basketball to a level that it's the only thing that's going on. You could feel it. New Orleans and Indianapolis are the only two... when the Final Four is in Indianapolis, that is the thing. It's the perfect place for it.

The NCAA has Final Fours scheduled in various cities through 2031, so Indy will not be the permanent home.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke was the best team in the country and should have easily won the tournament

I said on this show a month ago, Duke was the best team in the country and they should easily win the, the NCAA tournament. They were similar to last year's team... I will be front of the line saying, guys, I fucked up. You got it wrong.

Duke lost in the Elite Eight to UConn, so they definitively did not win the tournament.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Duke players suffered severe concussions from the UNC court-storming earlier in the season

I think it's also important to remember that Duke likely had several players that were suffering from severe concussions after the storming of the court that UNC had against them... it's sad that they were forced to continue playing for the rest of the season after such a violent act happened to 'em.

Hot TakeCBBHotSarcastic
There is no medical evidence of season-long concussions; the take is a satirical jab.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Arizona is the best team in the country

Arizona just showing that they are probably the best team in the country because they absolutely whooped Arkansas.

Arizona lost to Clemson in the 2024 Sweet 16, which is the real-world event this likely parodies despite the prompt's 2026 date.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Miami of Ohio 100% deserves to be in the NCAA Tournament despite their first-round loss

I think a hundred percent they should be in. We need to just focus on the fact that there, I believe 31 and one and not do anything about strength of schedule. If you're able to go an entire season without losing a game that's hard to just wake up every day and not stumble once. I wanna see what happens when they play their first quad win one game in the middle of March.

This is part of the satirical 'Future' bit; Miami of Ohio was not 31-1 in 2026 (or 2024).
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If Tom Izzo makes this year's Final Four, I will admit I was wrong about him being overrated for the last 10 years.

I think it just feels like it's Izzo. He's gonna go out in the Final Four. He's gonna get there. This is for whether or not he's overrated or not. I will admit that I was wrong. I had 10 years of being wrong about Tom Izzo if they make it to this Final Four.

Michigan State did not make the Final Four in 2026, meaning PFT did not have to retract his take.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

Purdue will win the 2025 College Basketball National Championship in Indianapolis

The boilers have the pieces to, to cut down the nets and could do it in their home state. That gives me chills. [Purdue is my] top [team] right here, right now.

Purdue did not win the 2025 National Championship. They were a 4-seed and lost to Houston 62-60 in the Sweet 16. Florida won the title.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke will win the 2025 National Championship

I have been saying for a month and a half now that it is Duke's year. And I do fully think that they are, they feel like even though it is a loaded Final Four, they feel a little step ahead. I will not be rooting for Duke, but I am also resigned to the fact they will probably win.

Florida won the 2025 NCAA Championship, defeating Houston 65-63. Duke lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Buzz Williams moving to Maryland is a smart move to reset his coaching clock.

So this move, I believe was a smart move by Buzz in the fact that the SEC has gotten a lot better. He has kind of maxed out what he's got at Texas A&M... So why not move and reset the clock?

OpinionCBBMediumSarcastic
Buzz Williams did not move to Maryland; this was part of an April Fools prank.
Loss
Bruce PearlBruce Pearl

The 2025 Final Four features the four most deserving and dominant teams in the country.

I don't think you can name a fifth team that this year deserves to be playing for the national championship more than the four teams that are, are alive. And there's something really, really good about that.

OpinionCBBMildSarcastic
This was part of an April Fools prank; in reality, these teams did not comprise the 2025 Final Four field.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cooper Flagg should opt out of the Final Four to protect his draft stock

If I was Cooper Flagg, I would sit out. Yeah. And don't get hurt. You're gonna be playing against grown ass men. Sit out, opt out, and then just wait to enter the NBA draft and make money.

Cooper Flagg did not opt out; he played in the Final Four and Championship game, and his draft stock remained locked at #1 overall.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke is going to win the NCAA Tournament

I think Duke's gonna win it all though. I'm pretty set in that thought. I mean, winning a second round game by the way they did against Baylor. Just not competitive.

Duke lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal. Florida won the 2025 NCAA Championship.
Loss
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Maryland needs Florida's Clayton to sprain an ankle to win the Sweet 16 matchup

I think we need Clayton to sprain his ankle. Not badly, not bad. I'm not rooting for it and I'm not rooting for an injury like that guy's got such big balls... Maryland needs to play its best, the best be the best version of itself and I think they can win the game.

Florida defeated Maryland and advanced to the Final Four. Walter Clayton Jr. was healthy and named the tournament's Most Outstanding Player, leading Florida to the national championship.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke will win the national championship.

Who do we got winning all now that we're at the Sweet 16 re-bracket? I don't know, I think it's just gonna be Duke. I think Duke's gonna win it all.

Duke did not win the national championship. They made the Final Four but lost to Houston 70-67 in the semifinal. Florida won the title.
Loss
MaxMax

Tennessee is the best team that nobody is talking about in the tournament.

I picked Tennessee before so I'll stick with Tennessee. I feel like that's the team that has the best shot that no one's talking about.

Tennessee, a 2-seed, made it to the Elite Eight but lost to Houston 69-50. They did not win the championship. While they had a decent run, they were not 'the team no one is talking about' that won it all.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Self is on the hot seat after losing in the first round as a preseason number one

Is Bill Self on the hot seat? I don't know if he's on the hot seat... Kansas also, they became the second AP preseason number one to lose in the first round of the NCAA tournament. Obviously Bill self not on the hot seat, but it's fun to have the conversation.

Hot TakeCBBHotSarcastic
Bill Self is objectively not on the hot seat despite the loss.
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

Mississippi State will beat Baylor because Hubbard can shoot over the zone

I'll stick with the SEC. I'm gonna go Mississippi State. [Hubbard] leads, I think he shoots nine over nine. Threes a game and [Baylor] plays zone over 20% of the time and Hubbard will just shoot over it.

Baylor defeated Mississippi State 75-72 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The UConn vs Oklahoma game will go over 147.5 points

I'm gonna take the over in this game and here's why. UConn and Oklahoma are both elite free throw shooting teams... we're gonna get a lot of trips to the line. And these, both these teams know how to make their free throws... I love the over here.

Big Cat predicted the UConn vs Oklahoma game would go over 147.5 points. The final score was UConn 67, Oklahoma 59, for a combined total of only 126 points — well under 147.5.
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

UNC will beat Ole Miss because the matchup favors the Tar Heels' lacks of bigs

Carolina, you watch them and the biggest jarring thing, they don't have any bigs that are like pros... But Ole Miss doesn't have any bigs really either. So I love the matchup for Carolina here and yeah, it's probably a conference pride deal.

Stanford Steve predicted UNC would beat Ole Miss because the matchup favored the Tar Heels. Ole Miss defeated UNC 71-64 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament.
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

BYU is a legitimate threat to win the National Championship

BYU's a team that everyone's picking against, but they they were on the list. [PFT: BYU can win the national title?] Yes.

BYU was eliminated in the second round (beat Wisconsin but lost in the Sweet 16). They were not a legitimate championship threat.
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

Take the under on Michigan State's team total

Michigan State. I look at their team total under, because they don't care how they win. They're like, alright, we know we gotta shoot some threes, but you know what, you're not gonna make threes. So we're gonna slow it down and make it methodical. But they're not interested in scoring high numbers.

Stanford Steve recommended taking the under on Michigan State's team total, arguing they wouldn't be interested in scoring high numbers. Michigan State scored 87 points in their first-round win over Bryant (87-62). With a projected team total around 84-85, Michigan State exceeded it significantly.
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

Alabama and Tennessee are the two best bets to win the National Championship

I'll give you a they're on the same side. Alabama and Tennessee. I do feel different about Tennessee... they're better offensively. It's not even a question.

Neither Alabama nor Tennessee won the championship. Alabama lost to Duke in the Elite Eight, and Tennessee lost to Houston in the Elite Eight. Florida won the title.
Loss
Mark TitusMark Titus

Michigan State will make the Final Four as a quintessential Tom Izzo team

I settled a, so I have Michigan State going to the final four because I think Auburn's gonna get tripped up somewhere... I do think Michigan State's gonna go to the final four. I think I settled on, they are on a, a typical Michigan State tournament run, but it just started in November.

Michigan State lost to Auburn 70-64 in the Elite Eight and did not make the Final Four.
Loss
Mark TitusMark Titus

St. John's will make the Final Four

I picked St. John's as the final four. I do believe in that... I do believe this St. John's team is special... When the clock hits zero and you think you've beat them, you better make damn sure you've actually beat them.

St. John's did not make the Final Four. The 2025 Final Four consisted of all four #1 seeds: Florida, Duke, Houston, and Auburn.
Loss
Mark TitusMark Titus

Duke is the best team in the country and has no weaknesses

I believe Duke is the best team in the country. I believe Duke has no weaknesses... I think that they're a little bit better than every other team in this field. So I, I'm, I I, I have Duke coming out of the east and I have Duke winning the national championship.

While Duke was very strong and made the Final Four, they lost to Houston 70-67 in the semifinal, proving they did have vulnerabilities.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Louisville will beat Creighton in the first round because Chucky Hepburn will stifle Steven Ashworth

Louisville being an eight seed, but if Louisville wins their first game, which I actually kind of like them to win that game. 'Cause I think Chucky Hepburn's gonna put Steven Ashworth in a torture chamber.

Creighton defeated Louisville 89-75 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament. Creighton shot 57.1% from the field and hit 11-of-24 threes.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Yale will upset Texas A&M in the first round

I also kind of like Yale is over [Texas] A&M. Yale's a good team. I feel like Yale also just, that's just a Yale does it every year kind of guy.

Big Cat predicted Yale would upset Texas A&M in the first round. Texas A&M defeated Yale 80-71 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michigan State will win the South region

I have Michigan State winning this bracket [South Region].

Auburn won the South region, defeating Michigan State 70-64 in the Elite Eight. Michigan State did not win the region.
Loss
MemesMemes

St. John's is going to win the National Championship

St. John's win it all. I filled out my entire bracket. It's kind of, it's a weird final four... Michigan State. St. John's. BYU. Kentucky.

St. John's did not win the National Championship. As a 2-seed, they were upset by 10-seed Arkansas in the second round. Michigan State, BYU, and Kentucky also did not make the Final Four. The actual Final Four was all 1-seeds: Florida, Duke, Auburn, and Houston.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke is going to win the National Championship

I've come to the realization that I think Duke's gonna win the whole thing. Doesn't matter [about Cooper Flagg's injury]. They're so good. I they're gonna win it all. I've just come to accept that. I it would, they're just so well-rounded, so deep.

Duke did not win the 2025 NCAA Championship. They lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal. Florida won the title.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Oregon will beat Arizona in the second round and Caleb Love will shoot 3-for-21

I have Oregon, beating Arizona in the second round. Because that will be, I think that's gonna be the Caleb Love masterpiece. Yeah. I think he'll go three for 21 for 14 points.

Arizona defeated Oregon 87-83 in the second round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament. Caleb Love actually scored 29 points for Arizona, leading them to victory, not shooting poorly as predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The winner of the East region will win the National Championship

I think whoever wins the East winning it all.

Duke won the East region but did not win the National Championship. Duke lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal. Florida won the title.
Loss
HankHank

Alabama will beat Auburn in the National Championship game

In this bracket... I have Bama beating Wisconsin and then Duke on the way to the Final Four... And they're going to beat Auburn to win it all.

Alabama was eliminated by Duke 85-65 in the Elite Eight. Auburn made the Final Four but lost to Florida. Neither played each other in the championship.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Tom Izzo and Michigan State will return to the Final Four this year

I've got Auburn against then Michigan State in a regional final Atlanta. And I've got Tom Izzo getting back to the final four.

Michigan State lost to Auburn in the Elite Eight (70-64) and did not make the Final Four. Auburn advanced instead.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Florida will play St. John's in the West regional final

I have Florida, UConn, Colorado State, Maryland, Drake, Texas Tech... I've got St. John's against Drake in the Sweet 16. And I've got Florida against Maryland in the region of Prestige. I'm going Florida over St. John's in a regional final.

Florida played Texas Tech in the Elite Eight (winning 84-79), not St. John's. The actual regional final matchups did not match this prediction.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Duke will play Wisconsin in the East regional final (Elite Eight)

I've got Duke, Oregon, Wisconsin to the Sweet 16 to take on Alabama. And then I am going to take in a rematch of the 2015 national title... Duke over Wisconsin in Newark to go to the final four.

Duke played Alabama in the Elite Eight, not Wisconsin. Wisconsin was eliminated in the second round by BYU. Duke beat Alabama 85-65 in the Elite Eight.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Houston will win the National Championship

I got Houston going on the final four... Houston against Duke on one side. Houston comes outta the region of toughness on the other side... I got Houston finally breaking through under Kelvin Sampson and winning the national championship.

Houston made the Final Four and beat Duke 70-67 in the semifinal but lost to Florida 65-63 in the championship game.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Illinois will beat Tennessee and Houston to reach the Final Four

I'm gonna take Illinois against Tennessee in the Sweet 16 and I'm gonna take Illinois against Houston in the Elite Eight. And I got Houston going on the final four. [Correction: He says Illinois over Houston at 1:48:02, but then says Houston in his Final Four at 1:48:10. Transcript is slightly contradictory but he later says Houston wins it all].

Jon Rothstein predicted Illinois would beat Tennessee in the Sweet 16 and Houston in the Elite Eight. Illinois was eliminated in the second round by Kentucky (84-75) and never made it to the Sweet 16. The Final Four was Florida, Duke, Houston, and Auburn — all 1-seeds.
Loss
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Wisconsin will make a run to at least the second weekend of the tournament

Wisconsin has enough here to at least get to the second weekend. I know you live and die with that team and they got the best off guard [in] America.

Jon Rothstein predicted Wisconsin would make at least the second weekend (Sweet 16) of the tournament. Wisconsin, a 3-seed, lost to BYU in the second round (Round of 32) and did not advance to the Sweet 16.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Villanova's Kyle Neptune has to be fired

Villanova has been dumped to the next, not even next four out. Just the next, out, out, out, out, out. Kyle Neptune's gonna get fired. Great guy, great guy, but yeah, he's gotta go. He's gotta go.

Kyle Neptune was still the head coach of Villanova through the end of the 2023-2024 season and into the 2024-2025 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Auburn and Duke are the only two teams capable of winning the National Championship this year

Auburn is just really fucking good... They went into Kentucky and they whooped the shit out of Kentucky. I keep trying to figure out who else could win. And it's gonna be Auburn and Duke.

Neither Auburn nor Duke won the National Championship. Florida (a 1-seed) won the title, beating Houston in the final. Both Auburn and Duke lost in the Final Four.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

Wisconsin will bounce back from their loss to Oregon because Greg Gard will rip them apart

Best thing that ever happened to Wisconsin was that [loss to Oregon]... they're gonna go back in the lab. Greg Gard is going to rip his team apart over the next couple of days. Wisconsin can still be trusted.

Wisconsin did not bounce back from their Oregon loss to make a deep tournament run. They were a 3-seed but were eliminated in the Round of 32 by 6-seed BYU.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

St. John's can make the Final Four this year

St. John's can make the Final Four and the statistical data backs it up... This St. John's team plays a lot like those Louisville teams [Rick Pitino's]... They are a real threat to make it to San Antonio this April.

St. John's did not make the Final Four in 2025. The Final Four consisted of all four #1 seeds: Florida, Duke, Houston, and Auburn.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

Maryland is a dark horse to reach the Final Four

I think much like Greg Gard and his staff, Kevin Willard and his staff went to the lab... they're dangerous. They're not over-reliant on any one or two pieces... Maryland can go deep.

Maryland did not make the Final Four. They were eliminated earlier in the tournament. Florida defeated them in the Sweet 16.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

If forced to choose, I would take Duke or Auburn to win the National Championship over the field

Right now, if you force me to take Duke slash Auburn or the field today, I would take Duke slash Auburn.

Neither Duke nor Auburn won the 2025 National Championship. Florida won it all, beating Houston 65-63 in the title game. Duke lost in the Final Four to Houston and Auburn lost in the Final Four to Florida.
Loss
John FantaJohn Fanta

T.J. Otzelberger will be the next head coach at Indiana

If I had to make a prediction right now, I would say T.J. Otzelberger... I think he makes a lot of sense. I think he's done a phenomenal job at Iowa State... He should be the guy that Indiana pursues the most.

Indiana hired Darian DeVries (from West Virginia/Drake) as their head coach, not TJ Otzelberger. Otzelberger remained at Iowa State.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Wisconsin Badgers are good enough to make an Elite Eight run

I officially believe that this Badger team could make a make a run... They're projected a three seed. I fully believe they could be a like, elite eight team and that's always a disaster for me.

Wisconsin, seeded 3rd as predicted, was eliminated in the Round of 32 by 6-seed BYU, falling well short of the Elite Eight prediction.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

St. John's is going to be a force in the NCAA tournament

Johnnys are good people. Your defense is legit. I was looking at some numbers the other day and their profile is like, you know, it was like an Elite Eight or a Final Four team. Johnnys are good... They're gonna be a force in the tournament.

St. John's was not a force in the tournament. Despite being a 2-seed and Big East champions, they were upset by 10-seed Arkansas in the second round, one of the tournament's biggest upsets.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Wisconsin Badgers are playing well enough to make a deep run in the NCAA tournament.

I have started to believe in the Wisconsin Badgers who are ranked and their offense is actually awesome and they wap threes... I actually believe that they could make a, a run.

Big Cat said he believed the Wisconsin Badgers could make a deep run in the NCAA Tournament. Wisconsin earned a 3-seed but lost to BYU in the second round, failing to reach the Sweet 16. Not a deep run.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Marcus Johnson is a future star who should be in the NCAA Tournament

I dunno if you guys have seen Marcus Johnson on Bowling Green, but he's, he might be better than DJ Burns. He's a big man who shoots threes and he's fucking awesome. He looks so smooth doing it. ... We need to get Bowling Green... into the tournament. 'cause he's, he, he's got. He's doing everything.

Big Cat hyped Bowling Green's Marcus Johnson as a future star who should be in the NCAA Tournament. Bowling Green went 14-18 (8-10 MAC) in 2024-25, were eliminated in the MAC Tournament quarterfinals, and did not make the NCAA Tournament. Johnson transferred to Kansas State after the season.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers