Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
Fran FraschillaFran Fraschilla

Kansas lacks the cohesiveness of Kansas State and Texas Tech heading into the Big 12 tournament

They're starting four freshmen right now... they don't have the cohesiveness, I think, that K-State and Texas Tech have going into this tournament this week.

Kansas reached the Big 12 final but lost to Iowa State. Neither K-State nor Texas Tech won the tournament.
Loss
Fran FraschillaFran Fraschilla

Utah State is a sneaky mid-major dark horse to watch in the NCAA tournament

If you want a sneaky team, if they get in, and that's a sneaky mid-major, would be Utah State... Sneaky good team. Good coach, a lot of shooters, and a good young big man.

Utah State entered as an 8-seed and lost to Washington in the first round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Raphael is the best and only cool Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle

I'm a Raphael. Raphael was the bad boy who April had a crush on... Raphael was the one who would always get them in trouble because he was such a badass. Raphael was the one, he was like the guy who kind of, the straw that stirred the drink.

Subjective ranking of fictional turtles.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Boneless wings are just chicken nuggets

A boneless wing... It's a fun fact. They're not even wings... They're chicken nuggets.

This is a semantic and subjective culinary classification.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants are tanking a year too late

They're tanking a year too late from what they... Like, last year they should have, like you said, not given... they trotted out Eli Manning's corpse. You then didn't lose enough to be the number one pick this year and get Kyler Murray, so then you had to trade Odell Beckham to then get the picks so that you could then trade up for the number one pick that you could have had if you had just done what everyone said, just lose.

The Giants finished 4-12 in 2019 and did indeed enter a multi-year rebuild that saw Eli Manning benched for Daniel Jones.
Loss
HankHank

Mike Davis is a better fit for the Bears' offense than Jordan Howard

I don't know if [Mike Davis] is much more talented than Jordan Howard, but he's shown an ability to catch footballs, which makes him a better fit [for the Bears].

Jordan Howard was traded to the Eagles and had a productive season, while Mike Davis was cut by the Bears midway through the 2019 season after failing to make an impact.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rich people are the last people who need college degrees

I think the worst part about this, and it reinforces something that I think a lot of people already know, is that if you're rich, you are the last person who needs a college degree. It's somebody who's very poor that would find value in having the degree.

This is a social opinion that cannot be factually proven or disproven.
Void
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

No joke is truly offensive because the intent of a joke makes it benign

There's a big kind of intellectual theory around this about benign violation and the idea that no joke is offensive because it's a joke. Because as soon as you put it in that space where you go, okay, it's cancer... But as soon as you make a joke about it, you put it into a space where you go, it's benign. It's actually, it's okay, and it's got no power over us.

This is a subjective philosophical stance on humor theory.
Void
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

Individualism is a relatively new and terrifying concept for human beings

We've never been more connected... And the reason podcasts, I think, are so huge is because people are desperate for conversation... We're built to live in tribes... The idea of individualism is comparatively new and terrifying. It just doesn't work for human beings. We feel incredibly alienated.

Subjective sociological observation.
Void
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

Comedians should never apologize for a joke

You never have to apologize for a joke. Just on policy, you go, well, I was standing on stage saying that to make people laugh. I'm a drug dealer is what I do for a living. I'm trying to get people [endorphins].

This is a subjective ethical and professional stance within the comedy industry.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

NFL RedZone has 'ruined' the traditional way of watching football

No, Red Zone actually made it better. It's unbelievable, but it's ruined football. No, I agree with you. Have you ever tried to watch a football game having seen Red Zone? Yeah, it's tough. You should go, wow, this is boring... your brain has just become this like... Touchdown, touchdown, touchdown. Every single play has got to be a big play.

This is a common subjective sentiment among NFL fans regarding the 'RedZone effect' on attention spans.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Antonio Brown is the hero to the working man

[Antonio Brown] is the hero to the working man... he basically signed a contract two years ago, got a bunch of guaranteed money, when the guaranteed money ran out he's like 'I want a new deal' and then he got it.

While subjective, the 'working man' label for a multi-millionaire WR is ironically intended.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I bet Alex Rodriguez paid exactly $1 million for Jennifer Lopez's engagement ring even if it cost less

I have a theory about the ring that he gave [Jennifer Lopez]. I think that [Alex Rodriguez] paid exactly $1 million for it. That would be such an [Alex Rodriguez] move, right? He goes in the drawer, and they're like, 'this ring is $600,000.' He's like, 'let me just pay you $1 million for it.'

Purely speculative and likely impossible to verify, making it subjective.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I will fight Jose Canseco in Alex Rodriguez's honor

Jose Canseco's coming at [Alex Rodriguez]. I'm going to have to fight Jose Canseco... I will fight him. I will fight in [Alex Rodriguez's] honor.

Big Cat did not fight Jose Canseco; Canseco eventually fought Billy Football in 2021.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adnan Syed is definitely guilty

The one you're talking about [Serial] came out five years ago about Adnan Syed. Who I think is really, really guilty. But for some reason, they just... I don't know. He just seems like it was a show about a guy that was guilty that had very charming murderer.

Syed's conviction was eventually vacated in 2022 and charges were dropped, though legal debates continue.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Many NBA players are insecure because of the constant criticism on social media

I feel like a lot of guys are very insecure. And that's what social media kind of does a little bit. You always see bad, I mean, you see good things, but you see a lot of bad things... being open to that much criticism on a day-in and day-out basis can kind of fuck with your mind.

This is a subjective assessment of player psychology based on first-hand experience.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Detroit sports fans are better than L.A. fans because they are more 'locked in'

I actually really do like the sports fans [in Detroit]. There's good sports fans in L.A., but there's so much stuff going on that people don't really care that much. So Detroit, when you're rolling, it feels like everywhere you go, people know what's going on. They know whether you lost last night. I love fans that actually know what's going on.

Subjective comparison of fanbases.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Steve Ballmer's attempt to shake my hand before our game was a PR stunt and I didn't like it

I saw [Steve Ballmer], but I'm just like, I'm already done... He wanted [the handshake] for cameras. Absolutely cool. And yeah, I just didn't like it.

This is Blake's subjective interpretation of the event and Ballmer's intent.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

If I were Zion Williamson, I would play again for Duke this season

Yeah, I would play. At the end of the day, you've got to play basketball. I totally get it. If he wanted to sit out, I wouldn't be like, 'oh, that's BS.' If he wants to sit out, cool, but I personally would play.

Zion did eventually return for the ACC and NCAA tournaments.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

The NBA's one-and-done rule should be abolished

[The one-and-done rule] should go away. A hundred percent.

The rule remains a matter of ongoing policy debate and is inherently subjective.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL should replace all officials with combat veterans and Navy SEALs

Jay Glazer... has maybe the greatest idea ever. Hire all new officials—all combat veterans, special operations backgrounds, go hire a bunch of Navy SEALs, Marine Recon, Delta Force, those guys. They literally can react faster than the rest of the world, even when bullets are flying... and also coaches will be a little less inclined to rip into them out on the sideline.

This has never been implemented and likely never will be due to technical training requirements.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will never change my clocks for Daylight Savings again as a test of mental strength

I didn't change any of my clocks in my house, and I made it. It's so satisfying when it turns back. It's just like a battle of strength and wit against my own brain.

This is a subjective lifestyle choice about how he manages his home clocks.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James passing Michael Jordan's scoring record felt hollow because it happened on a terrible Lakers team

Obviously LeBron's career is unassailable at this point... But don't you think it felt a little hollow, the fact that he's doing it on a terrible Lakers team? If it happened in Cleveland, it would have been a lot bigger of a moment in my mind.

This is a subjective assessment of the 'feel' of a sports moment.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Charlie Casserly's criticism of Kyler Murray's leadership is a direct contradiction of his past views

Already Charlie Casserly has contradicted himself. People definitely question Baker Mayfield's leadership, his maturity, the ball grabbing, all these things... [Kyler Murray] has literally lost two games in his entire life playing football from high school on.

Big Cat correctly identifies that Murray's career was defined by winning, and Casserly's comments were widely panned after Murray's successful rookie year.
Void
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Steph Curry is the most disrespected superstar in the NBA by his own peers

I think [Steph Curry] is the most disrespected by his peers superstar, which is weird... I feel like a lot of the athletes hate Steph. In some way, it's some bad thing because he had this awesome upbringing... it felt like all five of these guys had ad campaigns built on addressing the haters.

This is a subjective assessment of peer respect, though many former and current players have since echoed sentiments about 'new' superstars being treated differently than those with Curry's background.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Lakers' failure to trade for Anthony Davis backfired because they made the process too nasty

I get that they thought they had to go nuclear to get Anthony Davis out of there because you can't ask nicely for a trade. You have to make it nasty, and those guys tried to make it nasty, and it backfired for a million different reasons.

General consensus among NBA media at the time was that the public nature of the trade talks destroyed the Lakers' locker room chemistry.
Win
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The Denver Nuggets are actually a good basketball team, not just a regular season mirage

No, the Nuggets are good. I just can't take them seriously until... I just have a hard time with things that are new. [But] the Nuggets are legit.

The Nuggets finished 54-28 and reached the second round of the playoffs, proving they were indeed a top-tier team that year.
Void
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

I could beat up Steph Curry and Klay Thompson in a fight

I don't think Klay would care. Klay would be like, dude, I'm just going to tap out. Is that cool? ... Steph, the thing is, is what if Steph beats me? ... I don't think Steph would beat you. I think you could use your dialing... I'm going to give you two and a half out of five [starters].

This is a purely hypothetical scenario involving a sports media personality fighting NBA players.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bears should not have signed a kicker whose literal last name is 'Blewett'

Bears signed Blewett to help kicking woes. And that's a headline. Wait, your kicker, what's his name? Why the fuck did we do this? That's the dumbest thing ever... You can't sign a guy named Blewett.

Chris Blewett was eventually released by the Bears and never played a regular-season game for them, proving the 'bad omen' correct in a sense.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kyrie Irving's weird behavior is just a quarter-life crisis

My take on this is that Kyrie Irving, he's 26 years old, and I think this is actually a very relatable thing. Stars are just like us. The quarter-life crisis. Kyrie Irving's going through his quarter-life crisis. Everyone hits that point in your mid to late 20s where you're like, what's the meaning of life?

While speculative, it fits the timeline of Kyrie's changing career philosophy.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants are crazy for letting Landon Collins walk for nothing

My hot seat is the New York Giants. So they won't franchise tag Landon Collins. They're going to let him walk. The guy who's 25 years old, made three Pro Bowls, seems to be like the heart of the locker room. So the Giants are letting him walk. And essentially, I think the Giants' plan is to just keep paying Eli forever.

Collins signed a massive deal with the Redskins and his performance declined, while the Giants moved on to Daniel Jones shortly after, so the 'Eli forever' part was wrong.
Void
Adam SchefterAdam Schefter

Tom Brady is definitively the best quarterback of all time

The best quarterback of all time would be Tom Brady. That would be my opinion. Well, I would back it up with facts. The facts are he's won six Super Bowls. I do have two sources that have confirmed that Tom Brady is the best quarterback of all time. My left eye and my right eye.

While GOAT status is subjective, Brady's 7 rings and all-time stats make this a widely accepted consensus.
Void
Adam SchefterAdam Schefter

Jason Witten returning to the Cowboys was the best move for him personally

Honestly, this was the best thing for him to do. Now, the people that didn't like him as a broadcaster, they're happy. Dallas is thrilled. It was a great move on his part.

Witten had a decent return season (63 catches) and successfully exited a broadcast role he was struggling in.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

DK Metcalf's 1.6% body fat is a huge red flag

1.6% body fat is actually a huge red flag for me. Have a burger, man. You're a psycho if you have 1.6% body fat.

While Metcalf had an excellent career, 1.6% body fat is physiologically near-impossible for a living human, suggesting the measurement was likely inaccurate.
Void
HankHank

Lacrosse is the sport of the future

Good indication of the sport of the future. I saw that highlight on my feed more than baseball, rugby, basketball, any other sport.

Lacrosse has seen growth but remains a niche sport compared to the Big 4.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Witten was essentially fired by ESPN

Jason Witten just got fired. Let's just call it what it is. If he was good at his job, he would not have gone back. I think ESPN was essentially like, dude, we're not saying you're fired, but... you're fired.

Witten was widely criticized for his performance on MNF, and his return to the Cowboys after just one year in the booth suggests ESPN was likely ready to move on.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Prime 47 is a better steakhouse than St. Elmo's in Indianapolis

Prime 47 versus St. Elmo's. I have Prime 47. I thought St. Elmo's is you go for the shrimp cocktail, but after that, the menu doesn't have a lot to offer.

Subjective food opinion.
Loss
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh

The NFL should replace the onside kick with a 4th and 15 conversion attempt

The onside kick is pretty much dead with the new rules, I do think they've got to come up with something. Give a team a chance. Maybe you've got to convert a fourth and 15 or something or a fourth and 12 or something just to get the ball back and regain possession.

The NFL has discussed this but as of 2024 has not officially replaced the onside kick with a 4th-and-15 play.
Win
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh

Lamar Jackson's NFL success represents a 'revolution' not 'evolution'

Our job is to make sure that we do everything we can to create this offense. And I would say that, well, the league has never seen before since, like, 1950. So, like, we have to, you know, what comes around goes around. It's not evolution. It's revolution.

Lamar Jackson won two MVPs and transformed how mobile quarterbacks are utilized, validating Harbaugh's 'revolution' framing.
Void
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh

Joe Flacco was elite — elite guy, elite person, absolutely

Was [Joe Flacco] elite? Elite. Elite guy. Elite person. Absolutely.

Harbaugh coached Flacco to a Super Bowl win. He pivots to 'elite guy, elite person' — a diplomatic but genuine endorsement from his former coach.
Win
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh

The NFL should implement a 'Sky Judge' official in the press box

Let's put an official up in the box. He doesn't have to be a replay guy. Just make him the sky judge. Let him officiate the game from up there too. Just the big stuff, just the clear, obvious stuff.

The NFL has since implemented 'expedited review' and more assistance from the Replay Assistant/Art McNally GameDay Central that functions similarly to a Sky Judge.
Void
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh

The 2011 Ravens were more talented than the 2012 Super Bowl team

Really, that was probably our best team, 2011. The most talented team. We were probably better than the 2012 team.

Subjective team comparison.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kyler Murray is officially draftable on my board because he measured at 5'10"

So 5'10", I like him now. He is draftable. He moved up my big board. He is still undraftable for John Elway, like eight inches too short. John Elway even said that. He was like, yeah, he's... You can't get him under center.

Kyler Murray was drafted #1 overall, proving he was indeed draftable, though Big Cat was speaking about his own arbitrary line.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Witten's return to the NFL is a genius move to save his broadcasting legacy

What Jason Witten has just pulled off... with the one year of broadcasting that he did. And he was bad. He was very bad. He is now going back to the NFL, and now he can forever be the guy where, well, he never got his second year, so we don't know. The jury's still out on whether or not Jason Witten is bad, and history will be kind to him and not mock him.

Witten is widely remembered as a poor broadcaster on MNF despite his return to the field, so history was not as kind as Big Cat predicted.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peyton Manning's low eyes-to-forehead ratio would make him great in the booth

I actually think [Peyton Manning] would be very, very good in the booth. You talk about a guy with low eyes. He sets the record for lowest eyes to forehead ratio.

Peyton Manning eventually became a massive success in broadcasting with the ManningCast, though not in the traditional MNF booth.
Win
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

A coach trying to be someone they aren't, like Bill Belichick, is what hurts them most

Trying to be who you're not hurts you. If you try to be Bill Belichick, there's only one Bill Belichick. You can't be that guy. So if your team is practicing outside, when you have an indoor practice bubble, even though it's freezing outside and the players hate it, you're trying to be Belichick. You're not being Matt Patricia. Be who you are.

The struggles of the Belichick coaching tree (Patricia, McDaniels, etc.) are well-documented, supporting the idea that their imitation of Belichick's style failed.
Void
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Bill Belichick now enjoys draft building and roster construction more than coaching

Somebody in the league told me this. They said, I think Belichick enjoys the draft building part of the process now more than he does coaching. Which is weird, right? Because this was his best coaching job ever. This past year.

Inherently subjective as it concerns Belichick's personal preferences, though his personnel decisions often overshadow his coaching in later years.
Win
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Antonio Brown is a 'quitter' and I wouldn't give up more than a third-round pick for him

What would I give up for him? The third round pick. That's it? No more. I tend to agree with you. He quit. He quit. He's a quitter. Let me say it again. He's a quitter. If I'm on his team and the Steelers players weren't happy about it, he quit on them. So do you want that in your building?

Antonio Brown was traded to the Raiders on March 9, 2019, for a third-round and a fifth-round pick, almost exactly matching Prisco's valuation.
Void
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Eli Manning didn't play as poorly in 2018 as the media portrays

Eli didn't play that bad last year. He did not. He did not. Dude, sir. The team stopped. His line was awful. I said he didn't play as poorly as you guys are portraying.

Eli Manning's stats in 2018 (21 TD, 11 INT) weren't his worst, but the Giants went 5-11 and he was benched early in 2019, supporting the 'washed' narrative.
Win
HankHank

The Boston Celtics are a complete dumpster fire

Celtics are a complete dumpster fire. I don't really have any championship spin zones. I don't really have any optimistic to say about them. I'm kind of just hoping that it's like one of those things where they're just going through the motions in the regular season.

The 2018-19 Celtics are widely considered a failure; they were eliminated in the second round and Kyrie Irving left shortly after.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers