Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Comedian Jimmy Carr + Odell Beckham Traded

Wednesday, March 13, 201917 takes

Odell Beckham traded to the Browns, we taped an emergency segment at the start of the show ( - ). NFL Free Agency recap ( - ). NCAA scandal and breaking news rich people are paying for their rich kids to get into college ( - ) . Hot Seat/Cool Throne ( - ). Comedian Jimmy Carr joins the show to talk about the history of comedy, his new netflix special, and being British ( - ). Segments include "How horny is Stephen A Smith?", Locker Room Talk for Russ Westbrook, bachelor talk for guys that don't watch the bachelor, PR 101 for Conor McGregor, and Guys on Chicks.

Jimmy Carr on the History of Laughter + Odell Beckham Traded

The NFL world was set on fire right as the show was being taped, forcing Big Cat and PFT to jump back into the studio for an emergency segment. Odell Beckham Jr. is officially a Cleveland Brown, and while the Giants are left holding the bag on dead money, the guys are looking at a brand new landscape in the AFC North.

Big Cat isn't pulling any punches when it comes to how the Giants handled their superstar receiver. By waiting until after they gave him a massive extension and trotting out Eli Manning for one last ride, they managed to mess up both their present and their future.

Win
Mar 13, 2019
#17781
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants are tanking a year too late

They're tanking a year too late from what they... Like, last year they should have, like you said, not given... they trotted out Eli Manning's corpse. You then didn't lose enough to be the number one pick this year and get Kyler Murray, so then you had to trade Odell Beckham to then get the picks so that you could then trade up for the number one pick that you could have had if you had just done what everyone said, just lose.

The Giants finished 4-12 in 2019 and did indeed enter a multi-year rebuild that saw Eli Manning benched for Daniel Jones.

With Odell joining Jarvis Landry and Baker Mayfield, the vibes in Cleveland have never been higher. PFT shared a tip from Leroy the Dog regarding Eric Berry, and Big Cat is officially ready to crown the Browns as the new kings of their division.

Loss
Mar 13, 2019
#17780
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Browns will win the AFC North

The Browns are the best team in the AFC North. Yeah, they are the best team in the AFC North. The Ravens watched part of their defense walk out. The Bengals are the Bengals. The Browns are going to win the AFC North.

The Ravens finished 14-2 and won the AFC North easily; the Browns finished 6-10 and missed the playoffs.

Free Agency Frenzy and College Bribes

The rest of the league is busy moving pieces around as the new year officially begins. While the Jets and Bears are vying for the services of Le'Veon Bell, Big Cat and PFT have different ideas on where the star running back will land.

Win
Mar 13, 2019
#28403
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets will sign Le'Veon Bell

We basically know where everyone's signing except Le'Veon Bell. We should each say one team. I'm taking Jets.

Le'Veon Bell signed a 4-year, $52.5 million contract with the New York Jets shortly after this episode aired.
Loss
Mar 13, 2019
#17782
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Le'Veon Bell will sign with the Chicago Bears

I'll take the Bears... those are the three teams that are hot on his trail. I just can't imagine the Ravens signing [him].

Le'Veon Bell signed with the New York Jets.

Meanwhile, the Jacksonville Jaguars have decided that Nick Foles is the man to lead them into the post-Bortles era. Big Cat is so devastated by the loss of the BOAT that he’s officially placed a curse on the franchise, sparing only Doug Marrone and Shad Khan.

Win
Mar 13, 2019
#17783
Big CatBig Cat

The Jacksonville Jaguars made the biggest mistake in franchise history by signing Nick Foles

The Jacksonville Jaguars made the biggest mistake in franchise history. I have put a curse on them... basically we're just cursing Nick Foles because Nick Foles, you should not have done that... You can't fill the shoes of Blake Bortles in Jacksonville.

Foles was injured in his first game and was eventually benched for Gardner Minshew before being traded after just one season. The contract is widely considered one of the worst in Jaguars history.

Away from the field, the guys discussed Operation Varsity Blues, the massive FBI sting uncovering how rich people were bribing their way into elite universities. Aunt Becky from Full House is on the lam, and the guys are trying to figure out why anyone would pay $500,000 to get their kid into USC just to be a coxswain.

Void
Mar 13, 2019
#28405
Big CatBig Cat

The only reason to get rich is to be able to bribe people

This is a story that is the most common sense story ever. It's rich people paying for their rich, shitty kids to get into college not based on their merit. What is the point of getting rich if you can't bribe people? That's the only reason to get rich.

The claim is inherently cynical and subjective.
Void
Mar 13, 2019
#17784
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rich people are the last people who need college degrees

I think the worst part about this, and it reinforces something that I think a lot of people already know, is that if you're rich, you are the last person who needs a college degree. It's somebody who's very poor that would find value in having the degree.

This is a social opinion that cannot be factually proven or disproven.

Jimmy Carr and the Science of Laughter

British comedian Jimmy Carr joined the show to discuss his new Netflix special and the actual history of why humans laugh. It was a surprisingly intellectual conversation for a show that usually features segments about eating lightbulbs. Jimmy broke down the concept of "benign violation" and why jokes about sensitive topics like cancer can actually be healing rather than harmful.

Void
Mar 13, 2019
#17787
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

No joke is truly offensive because the intent of a joke makes it benign

There's a big kind of intellectual theory around this about benign violation and the idea that no joke is offensive because it's a joke. Because as soon as you put it in that space where you go, okay, it's cancer... But as soon as you make a joke about it, you put it into a space where you go, it's benign. It's actually, it's okay, and it's got no power over us.

This is a subjective philosophical stance on humor theory.

He also shared some wild facts from a documentary he did for the BBC, explaining that laughter is actually an ancient form of "remote grooming" that kept human tribes together before we even had the words to speak to one another.

Win
Mar 13, 2019
#28406
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

Laughter is older than language by a million years

I did a documentary for the BBC... about laughter. Laughter predates language by about a million years. It's a totally different part of the throat that we use to laugh. Laughter was essentially remote grooming.

Evolutionary biologists and anthropologists generally agree that the vocalization of laughter predates the development of complex language in human ancestors.
Void
Mar 13, 2019
#17788
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

Individualism is a relatively new and terrifying concept for human beings

We've never been more connected... And the reason podcasts, I think, are so huge is because people are desperate for conversation... We're built to live in tribes... The idea of individualism is comparatively new and terrifying. It just doesn't work for human beings. We feel incredibly alienated.

Subjective sociological observation.

Jimmy also shared the guys' disdain for the modern outrage culture and the trend of people being offended by transcriptions of jokes they weren't even in the room for. He was adamant that a comedian's job is to chase the laugh, and an apology for a joke is a non-starter.

Void
Mar 13, 2019
#28407
Jimmy CarrJimmy Carr

Comedians should never apologize for a joke

You never have to apologize for a joke. Just on policy, you go, well, I was standing on stage saying that to make people laugh. I'm a drug dealer is what I do for a living. I'm trying to get people [endorphins].

This is a subjective ethical and professional stance within the comedy industry.

RedZone and Horniness

To wrap up, the guys chatted with Jimmy about American football and discovered that he’s already a fan of the most chaotic way to watch the sport: NFL RedZone. Big Cat agreed that while it’s the greatest invention in sports media, it has effectively broken the human brain's ability to sit through a three-yard run in a regular broadcast.

Void
Mar 13, 2019
#17789
Big CatBig Cat

NFL RedZone has 'ruined' the traditional way of watching football

No, Red Zone actually made it better. It's unbelievable, but it's ruined football. No, I agree with you. Have you ever tried to watch a football game having seen Red Zone? Yeah, it's tough. You should go, wow, this is boring... your brain has just become this like... Touchdown, touchdown, touchdown. Every single play has got to be a big play.

This is a common subjective sentiment among NFL fans regarding the 'RedZone effect' on attention spans.

In a new segment, "How Horny is Stephen A. Smith?", the guys analyzed the First Take star's recent admission that he is, in fact, horny for at least a few hours every day. Between his 2009 tweets and his current take quakes, Big Cat is convinced we are looking at an all-timer.

Push
Big CatBig Cat

Stephen A. Smith is horny all the time

Stephen A. Smith addressing his horniness... He's now clarified he's only horny some of the hours. He said a couple hours a day... He responded to someone saying, 'Sexy photo too. Evidently, you're trying to get yourself in trouble,' winky face. He's fucking horny. Dude is horny.

Fact ClaimPop CultureHotSarcastic
While Stephen A. Smith literally admitted to being horny 'a few hours a day,' the general 'all the time' claim is a comedic exaggeration.

Finally, the guys checked in on Russell Westbrook's ongoing war with the fans in Utah. After Russ threatened a fan on the sidelines, Big Cat proposed a new rule that would probably make the NBA the most-watched league on the planet.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA should allow players to fight one fan per year

Russell Westbrook is the perfect case for... we need to have players be able to fight a fan once a year. I like the idea of having players that just hate certain cities.

This is a satirical proposal that has not been adopted by the NBA.

If we can’t have Blake Bortles in the league, at least we still have Stephen A. Smith’s Twitter feed.

nfl-free-agencyodell-beckham-jrbrownsbaker-mayfieldcomedystephen-a-smith

More Takes

Loss
Mar 13, 2019
#28404
HankHank

Mike Davis is a better fit for the Bears' offense than Jordan Howard

I don't know if [Mike Davis] is much more talented than Jordan Howard, but he's shown an ability to catch footballs, which makes him a better fit [for the Bears].

Jordan Howard was traded to the Eagles and had a productive season, while Mike Davis was cut by the Bears midway through the 2019 season after failing to make an impact.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

This is the end of the Golden State Warriors dynasty

The Warriors are on the hot seat because the Warriors are breaking up... Steve Kerr is sick of Draymond's shit. Now, I don't know if that was actually what he was talking about, but it's clear the Warriors have... I feel like this is it. This is it. This is the end. Don't you?

The Warriors lost the 2019 Finals and Kevin Durant left, ending that specific era, but the 'dynasty' arguably continued as they won the championship in 2022.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer will do media for a year then return to coaching at USC or Notre Dame

Urban Meyer's health... seems like he's healthy... This is perfect, though, because it's just the Urban Meyer playbook. He's going to do media for a year and then be like, I hate this so much because it means that he has to talk and smile, two things he's not capable of doing, and then he's going to go back and coach... boom, USC next head coach or Notre Dame.

Meyer did return to coaching after a stint at Fox, but he went to the NFL's Jacksonville Jaguars in 2021, not USC or Notre Dame.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers