Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Whitney, Author Jeff Pearlman + Week 3 NFL Picks

Friday, September 21, 201818 takes

The Browns have finally won a Football game (this is just a guess because we had to tape early if the Jets won forget we said anything)(-) Jimmy Butler started major drama and now Stephen Jackson may kill the Wiggins brothers (-). NFL Week 3 Preview + Picks (-). Fantasy Fuckboiis(-). Author Jeff Pearlman joins the show to talk about his new book about the USFL "Football For A Buck" and has some wild stories about the creation and demise of the USFL including a player that once went on the IR because he slammed his dick in a car trunk(-). Ryan Whitney checks in to talk about what he's been up to, does anyone try in preseason hockey, and how he's been doing gambling on the NFL this year + a bonus lock (-). Segments include the debut of "Just Stop Talking Jon Gruden”(-), Respect the Biz for the Browns sideline reporter who yelled at a ref (-), Trouble in Paradise for the 10,000th time Belichick and Brady(-) and a special guest, Dana B from Mickstape with Dana's Thoughts.(-)

Ryan Whitney & Jeff Pearlman on USFL Chaos and Week 3 Picks

We are living in a choose-your-own-adventure world because the Cleveland Browns finally won a football game. Big Cat and PFT had to record this before the Jets-Browns Thursday Night game actually kicked off, but the energy in the room was undeniable. PFT is so bought into the Baker Mayfield era that he is already looking past the regular season.

Loss
Sep 21, 2018
#17581
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cleveland Browns will make the playoffs

Welcome to being a winner Cleveland. I say the Cleveland Browns are going to make the playoffs.

The Browns finished 7-8-1 in 2018 and missed the playoffs.

Speaking of teams in transition, the Jimmy Butler saga in Minnesota is reaching a fever pitch. Big Cat and PFT broke down the reports of Butler yelling at Karl-Anthony Towns and the beef with the Wiggins brothers. While the talent is undeniable, PFT isn't sure Butler is the guy you build a championship foundation around.

Win
Sep 21, 2018
#17582
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You cannot win a championship with Jimmy Butler as your number one guy

I would not want to pay [Jimmy Butler] a max deal right now. I don't think that you can win a championship with Jimmy Butler as your one or one a guy.

Butler reached the 2020 and 2023 NBA Finals as the primary star but has not won a championship as of 2024.

Week 3 Preview and Picks

The slate for Week 3 features a massive "Loser Leaves Town" game between the Texans and the Giants. Both teams are winless, but Big Cat thinks the stakes are much higher for Deshaun Watson and company if they drop this one to a struggling Eli Manning.

Loss
Sep 21, 2018·Picks
#17583
Big CatBig Cat

The Texans' season is over if they lose to the Giants

This is officially if the thing is, I'm pretty sure the Giants are terrible. And if the Texans lose to a terrible team, their season's over.

The Texans did lose to the Giants to start 0-3, but they famously won their next 9 games and finished 11-5, winning the AFC South. Thus, the take was incorrect.

In the "Are We Sure They're Good?" category, the guys looked at the Bengals and Panthers. Even though Carolina is coming off a solid start, Big Cat isn't ready to buy into the hype quite yet.

Win
Sep 21, 2018·Picks
#21283
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers are not a good football team even if they win

I actually think this is kind of a, are we sure they're a good game for the Panthers too? Because if the Panthers lose, I'm going to start asking, are we sure they're good? I don't think the Panthers are good, even if they win.

The Panthers started 6-2 but then lost seven games in a row to finish 7-9, proving Big Cat's skepticism somewhat correct.

PFT has his eye on the matchup at FedEx Field, specifically how the notoriously bad turf in Washington might affect a certain hobbled superstar quarterback.

Win
Sep 21, 2018·Picks
#17584
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bet the Redskins +3 because of the bad turf at FedEx Field

One, Aaron Rodgers, he says that his knee's getting – like he's afraid that it's going to get worse. And the Redskins' defensive line is pretty good... Aaron Rodgers' knee, the Redskins' turf. That's all you need to say for that game.

The Redskins beat the Packers 31-17, easily covering the +3 spread.

Jeff Pearlman and the Wild West of the USFL

Author Jeff Pearlman joined the show to discuss his new book, *Football for a Buck*, which chronicles the insane rise and fall of the USFL. The stories are legendary, ranging from a player who went on the IR because he slammed his dick in a trunk to Donald Trump's role in the league's demise. Pearlman noted that while the league was a chaotic mess, the talent level at the top was surprisingly high.

Void
Sep 21, 2018
#17586
Jeff PearlmanJeff Pearlman

The best USFL teams would have been 7-9 caliber NFL teams

Philadelphia Stars back then would have been a 7-9 NFL team.

Subjective historical comparison, but based on the talent level (Jim Kelly, Sam Mills, etc.), it is widely accepted by historians.

Pearlman also shared the story of Greg Fields, a player so terrifying that coaches had to hire Liberace’s security guard to protect them. The interview is a must-listen for anyone who misses the days when professional football players were paid in paper bags full of cash.

Ryan Whitney and the NHL Preseason

Our good friend Ryan Whitney checked in to talk about the return of hockey and the reality of the NHL preseason. While most stars are just looking for reps, Whit shared a hilarious story about being kicked out of his billet family's house as a teenager and having to sleep in his car. He also didn't hold back on Vontae Davis's infamous halftime retirement.

Void
Sep 21, 2018
#21286
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Vontae Davis retiring at halftime was a selfish move

You can't quit on your team. If you want to quit after the game, fine. You've got to finish the game. You've got to at least be standing on the sidelines rooting the guys on that you're trying to help or hope to win... It was a selfish move in a weird way to, I mean, everyone's going to remember how that guy retired instead of his career.

This is a subjective opinion on the ethics and decorum of professional sports retirement.

Whit is also deep in the gambling streets. After a rough Week 2, he is looking to bounce back with a specific divisional matchup in the AFC East.

Win
Sep 21, 2018
#21285
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

My lock of the week is the Dolphins -3 over the Raiders

I really like Miami this week at home against Oakland. It's only minus three, and Miami's actually sneaky, like not that bad, I don't think... Dolphins are my pick this week.

The Dolphins defeated the Raiders 28-20, covering the -3 spread.

Just Stop Talking Jon Gruden

Jon Gruden continues to say things that make PFT wonder if there is a deeper conspiracy at play. Every time Gruden complains about the lack of a pass rusher after trading Khalil Mack, PFT moves closer to a theory involving Al Davis's ghost.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jon Gruden is intentionally sabotaging the Raiders to get back at Al Davis

I think this might be intentional... he had like a feud with Al Davis and whispered in his ear on Al's deathbed: 'Listen to me, you son of a bitch. I'm going to come back, and I'm going to wreck your franchise.'

Satirical conspiracy theory that cannot be factually proven.

We wrapped things up with Fantasy Fuccbois, where Frankie Roast Beef (Big Cat) and Tommy Tornado (PFT) gave their starts and sits. Big Cat used his time to send a very clear message to the Giants' quarterback.

Push
Big CatBig Cat

Eli Manning should just retire already

Fuck Eli Manning. How many times is Eli Manning going to sack himself when I put a little fucking cashola on the Giants in a Sunday night game? Fuck you, Eli Manning. Just retire, you fucking asshole.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Eli Manning played one more full season before being benched for Daniel Jones in 2019 and retiring.

The show concluded with the debut of Dana’s Thoughts from Dana B of Mickstape. From the dominance of target practice in the bathroom to the untrustworthy nature of men who smell like a department store, Dana provided a window into a truly unique mind.

Void
Dana BDana B

You cannot trust a guy who consistently wears cologne

You can't trust a guy who consistently wears cologne. You just can't. You're trying too hard.

This is a subjective social judgment.

If you ever get hit with a poop-filled sock, just remember it’s called a Hot Brian now.

nflusfljimmy-butlerraidersfantasy-footballhockey

More Takes

Loss
Sep 21, 2018
#21282
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets are exactly what we thought they were, a 7-9 team

The Jets are exactly what we thought they were like a seven and nine team. You want to crown their asses? They're 7-9. I think that's actually a pretty realistic expectation for them.

The Jets finished the 2018 season with a 4-12 record, failing to reach the 7-9 mark.
Win
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

Josh Allen is my sleeper of the week and will 'take flight' against the Vikings

My sleeper is Josh Allen. Against the Vikings, D. Everybody's talking about him. People forget they tied. They didn't win. They didn't lose. They don't know what the fuck is going on this week. That rocket arm about to take flight.

This was the famous 'hurdle game' where Josh Allen leapt Anthony Barr and led the Bills to a massive upset victory over Minnesota with 3 total TDs.
Void
Sep 21, 2018
#17588
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Derek Carr is an overrated quarterback

Derek Carr's overrated, I think. It's the Raiders. They've been a gong show forever.

Subjective, but Carr's career has been defined by statistical productivity without significant playoff success.
Loss
Sep 21, 2018
#17587
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Patriots will roll over Matt Patricia and the Lions

I also think the Pats roll over [Matt] Patricia. Big Cat, you have sources. They hate Patricia, huh?

The Lions actually beat the Patriots 26-10 in Week 3 of 2018.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Silicon Valley removing vowels from apps is a war against Italy

Silicon Valley disrupting apps where they take out all the vowels, is that anti-Italian? Absolutely. It's a full-on war against Italy.

This is a satirical claim intended for comedic effect and cannot be factually evaluated.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady and Bill Belichick actually hate each other

I do actually believe that Brady and Belichick hate each other. I think they hate each other, but I think that they have such a productive hate for each other. And they're both such like competitive psychos that it just makes each one of them be better at their jobs.

While 'hate' is a strong word, both have admitted since Brady's departure that the relationship became strained and strictly professional toward the end.
Void
Dana BDana B

Spitting in your own pee stream is a sign of dominance

Number one, spitting in your pee stream is a sign of dominance... once it hits the stream you're in for a good day. Target practice. It's like going skeet shooting.

This is a purely subjective and absurdist life philosophy.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers