Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Big Cat

Big Cat

Host
2016 — Present
2,825W·2,257L·553P·292 open
@barstoolbigcat
footballbasketballlife5,635 scored

All Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Betting on Ohio State to win the National Championship and the Chiefs to win the Super Bowl is a safe bet that every sports fan should make.

Ohio State to win the National championship and the Chiefs to win the Super Bowl. I think it's like 20 to one. ... It just feels like something that you should just, just do and forget about it. ... a safe [bet].

The parlay of Ohio State winning the National Championship and the Chiefs winning the Super Bowl failed. The Chiefs went 6-11, missed the playoffs entirely (Mahomes tore his ACL in Week 15), and were eliminated from contention. The Seahawks won Super Bowl LX.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

If the Cowboys beat the Broncos next week, they are on a path to be 6-3-1 heading into their game against the Eagles.

If the Cowboys can beat the Broncos next week, they would then be, what? Four, three and one. And they have very winnable games against the Cardinals and the Raiders coming up. That could be a very quick, if they can somehow beat the Broncos next week, we could look up and the Cowboys could be six, three and one going up going into a huge game against the Eagles.

Depends on Cowboys wins over Broncos, Cardinals, and Raiders in the following weeks.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos are the 'messiest bitches' in the NFL, but they are incredibly fun to watch.

The Broncos are the messiest bitches we got in the NFL. But they're fun. They're so fun. ... They'll fuck you crazy and then they'll, they'll freak out about a text message and, and get in a fight with you at a bar for the entire night and ruin your entire night. ... That's the Broncos.

A metaphorical team identity claim.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani's three-home run and 10-strikeout game is the greatest individual performance in sports history.

I feel very comfortable saying that Shohei Ohtani hitting three home runs, pitching six shutout innings with 10 KS in an elimination game was the greatest single game performance I've ever seen a baseball player play. ... might have been the best game in the history of sports.

The event happened in the show's context, but its status as 'greatest' is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Baseball fans should blame their own cheap owners for not spending instead of being mad at the Dodgers.

We should be complaining about the Pirate's owner and the Red's owner and the, and the Rockies owner and all these owners that don't wanna spend a dollar. That's who should get the blame. Not the Dodgers. ... I'm done complaining about it. Blame your owner or not the Dodgers.

Subjective sports business philosophy.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals will finish 10-7 if they beat the Jets and the Bears in their next two games

If they beat the Jets and the Bears... that would be five and four. They play the Patriots, Ravens, Bills, Ravens. Let's say they go one and three there... that would make 'em six and seven. Then they beat the Dolphins, Cardinals and Browns to finish the season. By my math, that's 10 and seven.

The Bengals actually finished the 2025 season 9-8, narrowly missing this 10-7 prediction.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams against the spread are a must-bet because they are 11-3 in their last 14 games

The Rams are just knocking people out against the spread recently... they're 11 and 3 against the spread in their last 14 games. Yep. One of those was the blocked field goal by the Eagles... they should be 12 and 2 at that point.

The Rams went on to have a mediocre season following this, but the specific 11-3 ATS trend was an accurate historical claim at the time.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears vs. Saints game is a Must Win

The Bears are right now, what is it? Four and a half point favorites. This is a game that the Bears have to win. I'm dubbing it a Must Win because the Bears are, you'd think better than the Saints.

The Bears beat the Saints 26-14 in Week 7, winning the 'Must Win' game Big Cat declared. They went on to make the playoffs at 11-6.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially selling on the Colts at their peak for the Week 7 matchup against the Chargers

I'm ready to sell on the peak of the Colts. I'm selling in this game only... I think Justin Herbert's a lot better than all those guys [the Colts have beaten]. I also am worried about the Colts secondary... I think the Chargers are gonna win this game.

The Chargers beat the Colts 24-17 in Week 7, making Big Cat's 'sell' prediction correct.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm starting to believe in the Falcons

I think I'm starting to believe in the Falcons. Are you ready to do that with me? I like 'em man. I like 'em.

The Falcons finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs. Michael Penix Jr. went 3-6 as a starter before a season-ending ACL injury. Not a team to believe in.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Dodgers are essentially a collection of All-Stars that is unfair to the rest of the league

Dudes on dudes. That's what the Dodgers are. They just have dudes everywhere. They just hit home runs. ... It's crazy how good the Dodgers are. It's not fair. ... Like I want that, I want an owner who's just like, oh yeah, we, we already have a, a ton of dudes that are awesome. Let's just pay another dude a hundred, $200 million just to get even more awesome.

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Falcons are really legit

I think they [Falcons] might be really legit. They had two interceptions, four sacks, like they were all over the place. Held the Bills to two for nine from third down. I think they're really legit.

The Falcons finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs. Morris was fired. They were not 'really legit.'
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are unequivocally no longer a bad football team

I would say the Bears are not a good football team, but they're unequivocally no longer a bad football team. And that is a very important distinction to make in the progression of a team.

Subjective tiering of a team's quality.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Indiana is going 12-0

America, be ready and maybe have a sit down and have a conversation with your children... about 12 and oh Indiana, because Indiana is so fucking good. Indiana is gonna go 12 and Oh get prepared.

Indiana went even better than 12-0, finishing the regular season 13-0 and going 15-0 overall to win the national championship. Big Cat undersold it if anything.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Luke Fickell will be fired soon

I think Luke Fickell is fired by the way soon and maybe Macintosh the AD. Wisconsin's a dumpster fire, maybe worst program right now in Power four.

Luke Fickell was not fired from Wisconsin despite a 4-8 2025 season. He remains the head coach, though his contract was not extended. His buyout of ~$21.3M has protected his job.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Sherrone Moore's 'blue-collar' jacket is a cheap, ineffective imitation of Jim Harbaugh

[Sherrone Moore] has his blue collar jacket on and he basically was like, Hey, I'm back to work. ... It worked for Jim Harbaugh because Jim Harbaugh had won... This feels like a cheap knockoff and it's not gonna work.

Subjective opinion on coaching style and branding.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Baseball teams should celebrate every playoff series win, regardless of prestige

I'm a big believer in celebrate everything. I know people get upset about it, but it's like the baseball season is so long you have to celebrate the ride. You don't know where your next celebration's gonna be. ... I'm a celebrate everything guy.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs are going to win the Super Bowl

The Chiefs are gonna win the Super Bowl. Hank's Patriots are back. So back Chargers. Hold off on the Dolphins. Dolphins are bad Vibe City.

The Chiefs did win the Super Bowl in the 2024 season (played Feb 2025).
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I think Aaron Glenn has basically quit on his job as the Jets coach

I think [Aaron Glenn]'s quit. I think he's quit. I think he realizes how bad this team is and he's just trying to get games over with, get the first overall pick and then try to get guys in.

Observation on a coach's mindset is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

There is a significantly better chance for Nick Folk to make a 62-yard field goal than for Justin Fields to pick up a fourth-and-eight

There was a moment where it was a fourth and eight with very little time left. And I said to myself, Nick Folk, his career long in the NFL is 58 yards. There is a significantly better chance for Nick Folk to make a 62 yard field goal than for Justin Fields to pick up a fourth and eight. Yes. That's just without a doubt. I would play the field goal every single time.

The claim is inherently subjective and hyperbolic, comparing a low-probability field goal to a low-probability conversion.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McDaniel will get fired as Dolphins head coach

I don't know. They're, they're just a bad vibes. I mean they're, he's he's gonna get fired so... I think he's a good, he's gonna be a good offensive coordinator somewhere else.

As of the knowledge cutoff, Mike McDaniel remained the head coach of the Dolphins.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am starting to like Spencer Rattler as a quarterback

I kind of, I kind of am starting to like Spencer Rattler... Spencer Rattler didn't play bad and he had a couple, like, there was a, there was one pass that he made that was a perfect pass that just was dropped in the end zone. Like I Spencer Rattler might be Okay.

Rattler eventually lost the starting job in New Orleans once Carr returned.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers should win the AFC North

And with that defense, it, it could be, I mean, they should win the north. They should win the north.

The Steelers won the AFC North in the 2024 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens could be 6-6 after starting 1-5

I think the Ravens could be sitting at six and six even though they're one in five right now. I think they could be sitting at six and six... That to me looks like at minimum five in one with a healthy Lamar.

The Ravens went on a massive run and finished 13-4, meaning they far exceeded 6-6.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The NFC does not have any bad teams this year

The NFC does not have, they have not great teams. They have, they have some bad, bad ish teams, but everyone's, I mean, the Saints are the worst team and they're frisky. Yeah. It's a better conference for sure. Yeah. It just feels like, like top to bottom.

The NFC had several teams finish with 4 or fewer wins (Panthers, Giants), which are objectively bad teams.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts are a legitimately good football team

The Colts are just fucking good. I don't know what else I, I feel like people are waiting for the shoe to drop. The Colts are five in one... Peyton Manning played on some really good offenses. They're good man. They're good. I, again, I think people are just waiting for it to not work, but I think they're just really good.

The Colts finished 9-8 and missed the playoffs in 2024, so they weren't 'elite' but remained solid.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Brian Callahan will be the next NFL head coach to be fired

Who's the next, who's the first coach fired hot list? Brian Callahan, Mike McDaniel, Gannon, Aaron Glenn. Those are the four. Who are you guys picking? I think I'm going with Callahan. If the Patriots win that game, Mike Vrabel will have the same amount of wins in Nissan Stadium as a visiting coach as Brian Callahan does.

Brian Callahan was fired by the Titans on October 13, 2025 after a 1-5 start, making him the first NFL head coach fired during the 2025 season. Big Cat correctly predicted he would be the first coach fired.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield is the current NFL MVP frontrunner

Baker Mayfield. That's it. It's Baker Mayfield... Baker Mayfield, they don't have the, the, the Bucks don't have Mike Evans. They don't have Chris Godwin... Baker Mayfield. Not, not MVP candidate MVP, he might be a front runner right now.

Baker Mayfield did not win the MVP in 2024; Lamar Jackson won his second.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

There is a 0% chance the Cubs resign Kyle Tucker

There's a 0% chance they resign Kyle Tucker. Kyle Tucker gave a quote after the game that has never, there's never been a guy who has been more gone than Kyle Tucker was gone in that moment... That's the most goodbye you could possibly have.

Kyle Tucker remained with the Astros in reality (he was never on the Cubs). Big Cat is misremembering his own team's roster or a hypothetical trade scenario.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs should bring home Kyle Schwarber

I would love [to get] Fram [and] Kyle Schwarber... Schwarber would be awesome. Bring him home. Be awesome.

Schwarber remained under contract with the Phillies through the 2025 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Penn State firing of James Franklin was necessary

James Franklin fired Penn State... You had to because Ir because they're gonna have to recruit and get, like, you can't fire your coach... where's he gonna get drafted? I don't, I don't know. He should've left late. He's gonna, he would've been a first round pick if he went last year.

James Franklin was not actually fired in 2024 or 2025; this was a hypothetical or a reaction to a rumor that did not result in a firing.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Curt Cignetti has to be the next head coach for Penn State

Sigge [Curt Cignetti] has gotta be the guy. They went to Oregon and they just fucking kicked the shit out of them. Sigge is a great coach, don't get me wrong. I don't think he has Indiana in his blood. I think that if Penn State called, he's picking up the phone.

Curt Cignetti did not become Penn State's head coach. Despite being the top candidate after James Franklin was fired in October 2025, Cignetti signed an 8-year, $93 million extension at Indiana and stayed. Penn State hired Matt Campbell instead. Big Cat's prediction was wrong.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Winning against the Commanders would be the threshold for starting to take the Bears' playoff chances seriously

If [the Bears] can find a way to win this game [against the Commanders], then I'll maybe start, maybe thinking to start thinking about playoffs. Still two steps away. And if they lose, it's gonna be like, let's see what happens.

Subjective threshold for a fan's belief.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Judge's postseason home run is a footnote if the Yankees don't win the series

Aaron Judge hit that home run. Listen, that one foot. I said it. If they [the Yankees] don't win that series, it is a footnote and it is absolutely a footnote.

The Yankees lost the series to the Blue Jays, effectively making the home run a footnote in a losing effort.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Boone doesn't actually do anything for the Yankees besides chew on things

I don't really know what Aaron Boone does with that team besides just like chews. He just chews stuff. Yeah, he's like a dog. If you leave him alone, he, and there's something in front of him, he will pick it up in his mouth and he will chew it. But outside of that, I don't know what his day-to-day is.

Subjective opinion about a coach's value.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024 Eagles roster is better than the 2022 Super Bowl team

They're [the Eagles] better than they were two years ago... I'm pretty sure they are. They just won a Super Bowl and the roster's pretty similar.

While the 2024 roster added Saquon Barkley, the 2022 team reached the Super Bowl and had peak O-line play; most analysts would favor the 2022 squad's performance.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Seattle Seahawks will beat the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 6

I love the Seahawks in this game... I feel like there might be a little let down [for the Jags]... Seahawks need to win... you'll get a very strong effort from the Seahawks.

The Seahawks lost to the Jaguars 21-17 in Week 6 of the 2024 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions are a stock that only goes up; I will keep betting them every week

The Lions in their last 50 games are 36 and 13 and one against the spread. That's a stock that you just see. It's like Nvidia... I think I keep betting 'em.

The Lions remained one of the best ATS teams throughout the 2024 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs will be the only team to get swept in the Division Series

I think the Cubs are screwed because I saw Tom Fornelli our good friend who's on later on in the show, who does not like the Cubs tweets. So we're gonna get three out of four of the DS series as sweeps, and now the Yankees won. That means a Phillies are gonna win and the Cubs are gonna be the only team that gets swept.

The Cubs were indeed swept by the Brewers in the 2025 NLDS.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I will retire from 50/50 raffles forever if the Cubs lose when I win

If the Cubs lose tomorrow and I win the 50 50, I will 100% retire from 50 50 for the rest of my life. That's a fact. Because then it would just be like, you literally only won on losses, on big playoff losses. That is a fact.

This is a personal vow. If he wins and they lose, we'll see if he actually stops participating in 50/50 raffles.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL should have a commissioner for every division to run PR and attack ads

Wouldn't it be cool if there was a commissioner for each division? I mean, just had like commercials and stuff and you're like, yeah, hey, here at the AFC South, we actually played winning football now. ... I just wanna watch a football game and see just an attack ad on a certain division. Like, 'The NFC South sucks... they have the Bucs, but what else?'

This is a purely creative/subjective proposal for how the NFL should be structured.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will not retire until the 2028 Olympics in Los Angeles

I was talking to [Mark] Titus about it... he was saying that he doesn't think LeBron's gonna retire till 2028 when the Olympics are in LA. That's so much more LeBron. ... He will, that will be the last basketball. He plays the Olympics in 2028.

LeBron is still playing as of this date; the 2028 Olympics will be the definitive test.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts catching his own Hail Mary rebound would be the coolest play in sports history

The wide angle of the Hail Mary came out and Jalen Hurts tried to get his own rebound. ... I'll say this right now, if that ever happens, that will be the coolest play in all of sports. ... That was sports history. If there, the fact that he got as far down as he did was... if there was a, if there was two bobs, he would've been there.

The 'coolness' of a hypothetical play is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Denver Broncos are for real after their win against the Eagles

It felt like one of those, Hey, this is the win the Broncos needed... the Broncos are for real.

This take refers to a specific simulated outcome within the show.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dak Prescott is definitively in the MVP conversation

Dak is playing very good football... I would disagree with [Booger McFarland] because there's a couple guys who it's definitely close with, but Dak is definitely in the MVP conversation right now.

Subjective mid-season MVP evaluation.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers' comeback win shows they haven't quit on the season

This was a passing of the torch of like, which team is gonna quit on the season? Because there was a moment in this game where it was 17-nothing [Dolphins], and then the Panthers ended up winning 27-24. So for a moment it was like, the Panthers are going to quit on this season. And then they took that torch and they're like, no, you quit on this season.

The Panthers did indeed win the game after being down 17-0, supporting the claim of their resilience.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially sick of the Cardinals' shit

I'm sick of the Cardinals' shit. I'm just am. It's not good. I just, I I am, I don't... I'm just, I'm done with the Cardinal shit. It's been a long time since I've like truly enjoyed watching the Cardinals play football.

Subjective opinion on a franchise's entertainment value.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Emeka Egbuka might be the NFL's next rookie sensation

The Bucks are the most fun team in the NFL. Baker Mayfield is awesome... and I don't think Arian Hampton is gonna win offensive rookie of the year because there's a guy named Emeka Egbuka... he's going lights out once again.

Requires seeing the final Rookie of the Year results and Egbuka's season totals.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Buccaneers are the most fun team in the NFL

The Bucks are the funnest team in the NFL bar none. So much fun to watch. Not even close.

Subjective evaluation of entertainment value.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Pitching Matthew Boyd on short rest was an inexplicable mistake by Craig Counsell

Craig Counsell decided to pitch [Matthew Boyd] on short rest game one. He got absolutely lit up... I don't understand it. Why wouldn't you go bullpen? ... I feel like every short rest is always a disadvantage.

Boyd failed to get out of the first inning, providing immediate evidence for the take.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers