PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Take Slip·Nov 27, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1127-4540
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears should fire Matt Eberflus immediately after a Thanksgiving loss

They should fire him after we get embarrassed by the Lions. Because at this point I know the Bears have never fired a coach in a hundred years history in Midseason at this point. You should honestly tell Caleb like, Hey we fucked up with Shane Waldron and Matt Eberflus our bad. We're firing him right now.

The Bears did fire Matt Eberflus mid-season, a few days after the Thanksgiving game.
Win
Take Slip·Nov 27, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1127-4541
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions are the best team in the NFL in every category

I think the Lions... I think they're the best at everything. I really do. I think that they're, they have maybe the best running attack in the NFC... the Lions are better than the Eagles at almost everything.

The Lions finished the regular season with the best record in the NFC.
Loss
Take Slip·Nov 22, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1122-13059
HankHank

The Patriots are the team nobody wants to play in the AFC East

I think so. Usually the, you know, with the Patriots, it's like all the trends reversing the Dolphins have always been like the boogeyman even when the, when Brady was there and the Patriots are good. This is the trend weekend reverse in our favor.

The Patriots lost to the Dolphins 34-15 that weekend, failing to be the 'boogeyman' or a threat in that specific matchup.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 22, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1122-13061
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants are starting Tommy DeVito because they are trying to tank

I think they're trying to lose. I think they're trying to lose and try to tank for a quarterback. Yeah. Which would make sense.

While impossible to verify intent, DeVito's start resulted in a poor offensive performance, supporting the 'better draft pick' outcome.
Loss
Take Slip·Nov 22, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1122-13063
Big CatBig Cat

The Cardinals are for real

I'm ready to fully believe in the Cardinals. I might crown their asses. I just know the Cardinals feel like a very sound football team through and through off the bye week. Their eyes are there. They have the NFC West. If they could string together some more wins, especially in the division, they're undefeated in the division right now.

The Cardinals lost to the Seahawks 16-6 immediately after this take, stalling their momentum.
Loss
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11455
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens' offense is unstoppable

I think the Ravens I believe are gonna be there no matter what because their offense feels unstoppable.

The Ravens offense was held to just 16 points by the Steelers two days after this episode aired.
Push
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11457
Big CatBig Cat

Shane Waldron was the primary issue behind the Bears' struggles

Shane Waldron is the Antichrist. Shane Waldron caused all the problems. Shane Waldron, every war tragedy, anything you can think of in history. Shane Waldron was the issue behind it... The only way I can tell myself that the Bears have a chance is that Shane Waldron was deliberately holding the Bears back in every capacity and now everything's gonna be different.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
While Waldron was fired for poor performance, the Bears' offensive struggles continued after his departure, suggesting deeper structural or talent issues.
Open
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11459
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears' organization has ruined Caleb Williams

The organization's a fucking joke... None of it makes sense. Everything sucks. The organization is a joke. They've ruined Caleb Williams.

Williams has struggled significantly, and the Bears' history with quarterbacks supports the narrative, though it is too early to declare his career 'ruined'.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11461
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Caleb Williams just needs a comfortable system and he will still be a good quarterback

Caleb Williams is still a good quarterback. He just needs to get in a comfortable system. He needs to not be like surrounded by a hurricane of shit... Don't make him feel like he's got too big a part of that failure right off the bat. Give him easy shit to do.

This is subjective, but many analysts agree that the Bears' offensive infrastructure has failed several young quarterbacks.
Win
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11463
MemesMemes

The Jets' defense does not travel well

Defense doesn't travel... We got smoked by the Cardinals. Graveyard teams.

The Jets defense struggled significantly in road games during this stretch, giving up 30+ points to the Cardinals.
Open
Take Slip·Nov 15, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1115-11470
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons are the perfect team to lose in Wild Card weekend

I think the Falcons, they're the perfect team that you would put into the slot of losing a Wild Card weekend playoff game.

This remains to be seen until the playoffs occur.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 8, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1108-9177
MaxMax

Villanova head coach Kyle Neptune is a worse coach than Nick Sirianni

I will not say a bad word about Nick Sirianni for the rest of the year... You don't have to watch Kyle Neptune coach basketball. [He is worse than Sirianni] without question. They lose to everyone. He has more... seven [losses to teams above 100 on KenPom] to two for four times as many years.

This is a subjective comparison between a college basketball coach and an NFL coach, though Villanova's loss to Columbia supports Max's frustration.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 18, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1018-1700
Big CatBig Cat

I officially apologize for hating on the Buccaneers

I've retracted my take. I've done some soul searching about the Bucks. I apologize for saying the Bucks aren't very good. It is a hundred percent Chaps bias. I sat with Chaps for an entire game watching him and it just—it sits with you and it really eats away at you.

The Bucs were legitimately good in 2024, competing for the NFC South until injuries derailed them.
Void
Take Slip·Oct 18, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1018-1702
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers' all-white 'Winter Warning' uniforms are a disgusting affront to football

The Packers going with the all-white uniforms and all-white helmets are a disgusting affront to football color rush. It's a disgusting front. The Green Bay Packers—and I hate them—their football jerseys and color scheme are football. They should never do any type of gimmicky alternate bullshit. If you're a Packers fan, you should be disgusted by this.

Purely subjective aesthetic opinion.
Push
Take Slip·Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1004-4910
MemesMemes

The Vikings are the best team in the NFL

The Vikings are the best team in the NFL... Sam Darnold potential revenge game. Even though we already had it one time. But it's a bounce back. There won't be any rain.

The Vikings started 5-0 and were widely considered a top-tier team, though they later lost back-to-back games, losing the title of undisputed 'best.'
Void
Take Slip·Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1004-4911
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Jefferson is the best wide receiver in the league and it's not close

Justin Jefferson is the best wide receiver in the league and it's not close. I agree. I know that not close is a stupid thing to say. He has scored in every single game this year. He's so goddamn good that it's, to me it's not close right now.

This is subjective, but Jefferson leads most statistical categories and expert rankings.
Loss
Take Slip·Oct 4, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-1004-4915
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins should start tanking for the #1 overall pick

The only team that I could say confidently that should tank as of right now is Miami Dolphins. Yeah. I think that's the only team I would say you should tank. 'cause you're gonna need a sit... because Tua, you can't, you can't say that he's gonna go through a whole season.

The Dolphins did not tank; they welcomed Tua back and continued to try and win games.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0920-5373
Big CatBig Cat

You should never have a quarterback wearing number 19

Skylar Thompson wearing number 19 is terrible. That's a bad quarterback name number. It's Johnny Unitas and nothing else. You can't, yeah. Number 19... it's a just warning sign that this is a very backup quarterback.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion about uniform numbers.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 6, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0906-12969
Big CatBig Cat

Robert Kraft and Bill Belichick have beef

I think there might be beef there between Belichick and Kraft. Do you think so? I I mean I'm What would, listen, I wasn't able to make a, a definitive statement on it until I figured out who he followed. Yeah. [Belichick] follows 12 people... No Patriots, no craft.

While not a formal declaration, reports throughout 2024 confirmed significant friction between the two after 'The Dynasty' documentary and Belichick's exit.
Void
Take Slip·Jun 26, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0626-17214
MaxMax

Jalen Hurts is definitely a good NFL quarterback

Everyone knows that Jalen Hurts is good quarterback. Is he? Yeah. Jalen Hurts is the guy.

Subjective evaluation of talent, though supported by Hurts' record.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 19, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0419-2057
HankHank

JJ McCarthy is my 5th ranked QB because he's a game-managing system quarterback

JJ McCarthy... is the bottom... He doesn't throw, he didn't see any long balls or all the long balls are wide open. Short throw. Short throws... he's seen the, he, he was a game manager. System quarterback.

JJ McCarthy was drafted 10th overall by the Vikings, lower than the big 3 and Penix, which aligns with Hank's ranking (5th among the top group).
Loss
Take Slip·Apr 19, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0419-2058
HankHank

Drake Maye looks short on film and the ball looks heavy in his hands

Drake Maye... This was the biggest, the biggest deterrent and, and the thing that I see happening the most, the ball seems very heavy in his hands... It just seems like it takes him a long time to get the ball up and out... [He] looked short in the film that I was watching.

Drake Maye is 6'4'', which is tall for a QB, and his arm strength is considered elite by actual scouts, making the 'heavy ball' take highly subjective and likely incorrect.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 5, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0405-20067
Big CatBig Cat

UConn only needs to play a 'C-minus' game to beat most teams

UConn is just a kind of a, there's levels and they're just at a different level right now if they come out and play. Like UConn would have to play what a c minus game to give Alabama a chance. Like if I think of, if UConn plays a B game, they beat everyone.

UConn won every game in the tournament by double digits, including the championship.
Win
Take Slip·Jan 26, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0126-8617
Big CatBig Cat

Deebo Samuel is a bigger factor for the 49ers than the weather or Brock Purdy's skill set

That is way more significant than the rain and how Brock Purdy looked is losing Deebo Samuel. If he's not playing, the Lions are as live as live could be. He's that much of a game changer.

The 49ers were 12-1 when Deebo finished games in 2023 and struggled whenever he was out, reinforcing his status as the team's engine.
Loss
Take Slip·Dec 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1229-18735
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield should win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

He [Baker Mayfield] should win Comeback Player of the Year. Joe Flacco. I no disrespect to DeMar Hamlin, but why is he winning? He should not win Comeback Player of the Year.

Joe Flacco actually won the 2023 NFL Comeback Player of the Year award, not Baker Mayfield.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1229-18736
Big CatBig Cat

DeMar Hamlin should not win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

I'll be the brave one and say, this guy shouldn't win the award... It is just a fact. He shouldn't win the award.

DeMar Hamlin did not win the award; Joe Flacco did, making Big Cat's opinion on who should NOT win technically aligned with the voting outcome.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1229-18737
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Antonio Pierce has earned the full-time head coaching job for the Raiders

I do think that Antonio Pierce has, has coached his way into being the full-time head coach. Agree. If they really wanna win this game, Mark Davis should announce before the game starts. Like you're giving away a scholarship like this, this Walk-on now has earned his position.

The Las Vegas Raiders did indeed hire Antonio Pierce as their full-time head coach in January 2024.
Void
Take Slip·Dec 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1229-18738
Big CatBig Cat

There isn't a single team in the NFL right now that can be fully trusted

I don't think there's a team you can trust right now in the NFL. You go down the list... I don't think there's one team that you can, you could say like, put my life on the line. They win this game.

This is a subjective assessment of the league's parity at that specific moment.
Void
Take Slip·Dec 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1229-18739
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson played himself out of a Hall of Fame career

We'll always have the danger witch. Yeah, he, he definitely played himself out of a hall of Fame career. Right. I don't know that, that's gonna be a tough one... Russell, Wilson is nowhere near top 10 now.

While Wilson's stock dropped, whether he ultimately makes the Hall of Fame is still a matter of future voting and legacy assessment.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 15, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1215-11064
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers' injury is the most human thing ever, not a superhuman recovery

Aaron Rogers is not even human. I'd actually say missing the entire season because you got injured is the most human thing ever. Well, was he injured scenes? That was, I mean, he's literally showing that he's human. The fact that he hasn't been playing.

Rodgers did not return to play in the 2023 season, confirming he was, in fact, injured and unable to play.
Loss
Take Slip·Dec 15, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1215-11065
HankHank

The report that the Patriots have decided to fire Bill Belichick is 'fake news'

As a Patriots fan on this podcast, I'm just gonna say that that seems like fake news to me. Seems like a fake news media report from Tom Curran. You know, the media's been out to get us since 2000... Belichick didn't do anything wrong... there's no chance. 0% chance. I don't think Belichick would leave.

Belichick and the Patriots 'mutually agreed to part ways' on January 11, 2024, essentially confirming the reports were accurate.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 15, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1215-11066
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL wants the Chiefs to play on Wild Card weekend to maximize ratings from Taylor Swift fans

I think if the NFL wanted anything, they should want the Chiefs not to get the bye. 'cause that's one extra game of ratings for the Swifties Super Wild Card weekend.

The Chiefs did not get a bye (Ravens did) and played on Wild Card weekend against the Dolphins.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 15, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1215-11068
HankHank

Dolphins fans are insufferable and it would be funny to see them lose the AFC East

Dolphins fans are annoyingly cocky and Bills fans... I feel more of a connection to... Dolphins fans are insufferable. Like they're super annoying. They're super cocky. They haven't won shit. And seeing them blow a season and somehow lose the AFC East would be funny.

The Dolphins did eventually lose the AFC East to the Bills in Week 18.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 17, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1117-464
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baker Mayfield was the best thing to ever happen to the Cleveland Browns.

Do you think people are coming around to the take that Baker Mayfield was the best thing that's ever happened to the Browns and they should never have let him go?

This is subjective, but Baker is the only Browns QB to win a playoff game in the modern era, supporting the argument.
Loss
Take Slip·Nov 17, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1117-465
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Dobbs is the ultimate 'fix-it' quarterback for struggling NFL teams.

There are so many teams right now being like Josh Dobbs could fix all of our problems. If the Jets had Josh Dobbs, they would be a playoff team... he basically is the guy that everyone looks to and is like, he could solve everything.

Dobbs' magic eventually ran out with the Vikings and he was benched by December, showing he wasn't a long-term fix.
Loss
Take Slip·Nov 17, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1117-466
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Dolphins are officially off the NFL 'Fraud List'.

I think I'm ready to take Miami off the fraud list. They won't do it this week, but I'm gearing up for them to be off the fraud list because I'm thinking that their defense is gonna start playing really well... I'm ready to push the button and say no longer fraud.

The Dolphins lost the AFC East on the final day of the season and lost their first playoff game convincingly, leading most to re-label them as frauds.
Win
Take Slip·Nov 17, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1117-468
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are no longer one of the 'truly terrible' teams in the NFL.

The bears are not as bad as people think they are. They are. They're [not] the worst teams in the league... which are the Panthers, the giants, maybe the Patriots, the Cardinals... I think the Bears are a step above that. They get lumped in there. They've actually been playing really good defense.

The Bears finished 7-10, significantly better than the Panthers (2-15) and Patriots (4-13), proving Big Cat right that they weren't in the bottom tier.
Push
Take Slip·Nov 3, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1103-5711
Big CatBig Cat

Bet on any team playing the Bears to win their division

I've told everyone, If, you want to If you like the Saints this week. Which you should. 'cause they'll beat the Bears. Bet 'em to win the, the, the division. Now's the time. It's a free win bet. Every team who play, every team who plays the Bears just bet that team to win the division. 'cause you know, you'll get at least better odds once they beat the Bears.

This is a strategy take rather than a specific prediction, but the Saints (the team they were discussing) did not win the division; the Buccaneers did.
Loss
Take Slip·Oct 27, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1027-2850
Big CatBig Cat

Arthur Smith is a sneaky genius for limiting Bijan Robinson's touches to keep him fresh

Could Arthur Smith be a sneaky genius? Could he be saying we just spent a lot of money on this first round pick running back. Don't put too many miles on him early in the season. Bijan is gonna look that much faster late in the year.

Arthur Smith was fired at the end of the season partly due to offensive underperformance and poor usage of star players. Robinson's production did not significantly peak later.
Void
Take Slip·Oct 27, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1027-2855
Big CatBig Cat

Trent Williams is the most important player on the 49ers offense

I think Trent Williams is [the most important player on the offense] for sure. Christian McCaffrey at 85% without Deebo Samuel and without Trent Williams... things look different.

Inherently subjective as it's an opinion on player importance.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 20, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1020-19954
Big CatBig Cat

Jared Goff is a top-five quarterback this season

I think Jared Goff has been playing... I think he's a top five quarterback in terms of this season.

Goff had a stellar 2023 season, finishing 2nd in passing yards and 4th in touchdowns, making this a very defensible top-5 claim for that year.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 20, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1020-19955
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Benching Desmond Ridder would mean the Falcons are giving up on the season

I think if you benched Desmond Ridder right now, it's, you're done, you're done over him... You're giving up.

The Falcons did eventually bench Ridder for Heinicke later in the season, and it coincided with their season falling apart and Arthur Smith's eventual firing.
Void
Take Slip·Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1013-10586
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL London games have lost their allure and are now a burden

I'm kind of sick of the London game. I like the early football. I'm sick of the fact that they have made something that was unique and different into just every week. This is the third week in a row. They're just changing the schedule on us. Now it doesn't feel cool and unique, it just feels like a burden.

This is a subjective consumer opinion on the entertainment value of the NFL's global expansion.
Loss
Take Slip·Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1013-10588
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially back in on Justin Fields as the guy for the Bears

The Bears might be back if they win this game. And I am all the way back into Justin Fields. I liken it to a relationship where, listen, Justin Fields threw some interceptions, I said some things... but at the end of the day, don't go to bed angry. So I'm no longer going to bed angry. He's the guy again.

Fields was traded the following offseason after the Bears chose to draft Caleb Williams, proving Big Cat's 'he's the guy' stance was incorrect long-term.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 13, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1013-10589
Big CatBig Cat

David Tepper is a meddling owner who is hurting the Panthers

[David Tepper] basically in those two quotes was like, 'Yeah, this guy is putting his nose where it shouldn't be and micromanaging a football team.' And that's not how a successful organization runs. You can't have the owner forcing the coach to have a meeting multiple times a week. He sounds like a miserable person to work for.

Tepper fired Frank Reich less than two months after this episode. His reputation as a meddling owner has only grown since.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 6, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1006-16525
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brock Purdy is an MVP candidate

Should we be talking about Brock Purdy MVP Watch? If you look at his stats right now, Brock Purdy has MVP level stats right now. That's all I'm saying. He's the number one quarterback in the entire NFL in yards per attempt.

Brock Purdy finished 4th in the 2023 MVP voting and led the league in several efficiency metrics.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 6, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-1006-16526
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos' offensive success is a result of playing terrible defenses

Is there a chance that Russell Wilson, he's looked better, but he has not played a good defense? ...he played the Raiders, bad defense. Commanders, bad defense. Dolphins, bad defense. And then last week they played the Bears, the worst defense. So is there a chance that we see bad Russ here against the Jets defense?

The Broncos lost to the Jets 31-21 that Sunday, and Wilson struggled (196 yards, 0 TDs), validating the take.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-0929-6140
Big CatBig Cat

Defense wins championships

Defense wins championships. I'll go to my grave thinking that. The Bucs defense smothered Patrick Mahomes [in the Super Bowl]. That was completely a defensive effort. The Patriots' last Super Bowl was a defensive effort when they stopped the Rams.

Subjective sports philosophy, though recent Super Bowl winners (Chiefs) often rely on elite QB play as much as defense.
Push
Take Slip·Sep 29, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-0929-6145
Big CatBig Cat

I want Jim Harbaugh to coach the Bears and draft Caleb Williams

I want Caleb Williams. I have said the names Caleb Williams and Jim Harbaugh probably a hundred times in the last four days. I want to bring back man football. Let Jim Harbaugh just stuff all the dorks in Halas Hall into a locker and just go back to being a man football team.

The Bears did draft Caleb Williams #1 overall in 2024, though Jim Harbaugh went to the Chargers.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 22, 2023·Picks
#PMT-2023-0922-9461
HankHank

You can't appreciate a lighthouse if you don't go out to sea

It's good to get away from the lighthouse. It makes it that much better when you see it on the way back. You know, as any sailor knows, you can't appreciate a lighthouse if you don't go out to sea.

This is a poetic, subjective sentiment that cannot be proven or disproven.