Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Drake Maye is going to win the NFL MVP

Congratulations. It, it feels like Drake Maye's gonna win the MVP. It does. It, it definitely feels that way. Yeah. Matthew Stafford's Monday Night Performance kind of cemented it.

Drake Maye did not win 2025 MVP. Stafford won by 5 points in the closest vote in 23 years.
Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Chase Brown will be the AP Offensive Player of the Year

I'm gonna say it right now. AP offensive player of the year. Chase Brown. Wow... Think about it.

Chase Brown did not win AP Offensive Player of the Year. Jaxon Smith-Njigba of the Seahawks won the award after leading the NFL with 1,793 receiving yards. The Bengals went 6-11 and Burrow was injured most of the season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Bo Nix is 'dog phobic' because he is secretly a dog himself

He is afraid of dogs because he's worried that deep down inside... he's gonna have to tell his parents 'I'm a dog.' I think he's trying to suppress his inner dog because he knows if he becomes the dog that bit him, it's watch out world. He got bit by a dog as a child and became a dog.

Satirical claim about Nix's biology/identity that is obviously not factually true.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

Mike Tomlin has to be fired by the Steelers

Regardless of what happens next week, Tomlin's gotta go. I mean, he just gotta go. It's stale. He has a losing record in the playoffs. He refuses, he changes offensive coordinators all the time. Defense coordinators, the seasons all look the same... everything is always the same because it's Mike Tomlin.

The Steelers have shown zero inclination to fire Mike Tomlin, who signed an extension through 2027 in 2024.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

The Steelers will beat the Texans in the playoffs

If they win on Sunday night, they will beat the Texans. That's a fact. I'm not worried about the Texans. I was worried about the Bills and the other teams and the Jaguars. But I think they could beat the Texans.

The Steelers lost to the Texans 6-30 in the Wild Card round.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Tyler Shough should win NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year

Tyler Shough today with his wide receiver two and three out, RB one, two, and three out... takes the Saints down the field time and time again... there's just something about Tyler Shough... He should win Rookie of the Year. Shook of the year.

Tyler Shough did not win AP Offensive Rookie of the Year. McMillan won. Shough won only the fan vote.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Shanahan should be the NFL Coach of the Year

I still think that Kyle Shanahan should be the coach of the year. I feel like that this is... an incredible season for 'em. Given all that they've gone through and all the people that they're missing and how they might get the one seed. This is his best job that he is ever done coaching in the regular season.

Kyle Shanahan did not win Coach of the Year. Mike Vrabel won. While the 49ers went 12-5, Vrabel's 14-3 Patriots were more impressive.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Chicago Bears will face the Houston Texans in the Super Bowl

I'm actually rooting for the Bears to beat the Packers Bears to get the Super Bowl against the Texans. Because I would that, that if the Texans beat the Bears in the Super Bowl [I'll cut off my pinky].

PFT predicted a Bears vs. Texans Super Bowl. The Bears lost in the Divisional Round to the Rams 20-17, and the Texans lost in the Divisional Round to the Patriots 28-16. The actual Super Bowl was Seahawks 29, Patriots 13.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

The Steelers will win at least two playoff games this season

I'm thinking two playoff wins... Minimum two playoff wins right now. And listen, I mean, can you say [Aaron] Rogers has been pretty damn good this year? Yes... He's dialed in.

The Steelers lost in the Wild Card 6-30 to the Texans. Zero playoff wins, far from the predicted two.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson has radiation poisoning from getting too many MRIs

Do you think Lamar Jackson has radiation poisoning? Mm. From all the MRIs. Too many MRIs and all the x-rays... It might be like Chernobyl.

MRIs do not use ionizing radiation, making radiation poisoning from them scientifically impossible.
Loss
MaxMax

Tyler Shuck should win NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year

He should win Rookie of the Year. Right now he's second in odds on DK... if Tyler Shuck ends the year on this winning streak, it has to be Tyler Shuck. If he ends the year six and three as a starter, insane.

Tyler Shough did not win AP Offensive Rookie of the Year. Tetairoa McMillan won the award.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles will be the team that everyone wrote off who ends up winning the Super Bowl

I feel like the Eagles are one of those teams that, because they had a little hiccup there in the middle of the season, they're now getting healthier. I feel like the Eagles are gonna be the team that everyone has written off and they're the Super Bowl champs.

The Eagles lost in the Wild Card to the 49ers 19-23. They did not win the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

John Harbaugh or Lamar Jackson won't be with the Ravens next season

If I had to guess, it does not feel like next year both those guys [Harbaugh and Lamar Jackson] are gonna be there... there's just enough weirdness around the Ravens that it feels like they're gonna make a change.

The Ravens eventually kept both for the 2026 season despite the speculation.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cleveland Browns will cover the 10-point spread against the Buffalo Bills

I do like the bills, but I think the Browns might cover... I like the Browns at the very least in the first half of this game. I like 'em to cover 10 points.

The Bills defeated the Browns 31-13, meaning the Browns failed to cover the 10-point spread.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants will beat the Vikings because their stock is low and they are still playing hard

I think I like the Giants in this game. The Viking stock very high right now... The Giants very, very low stock right now. But they're, I don't think the Giants are one of the worst three teams in the NFL... they're playing hard and Kafka's coaching the team... I would take the Giants plus three.

The Vikings beat the Giants 16-13 in Week 16. PFT predicted the Giants would win as a low-stock underdog, but the Vikings pulled out the close victory with a late field goal.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions will throttle the Steelers because Amon-Ra St. Brown has found his confidence again

I think [Amon-Ra St. Brown's] got it back. He's feeling it a little bit. He's getting, he's, he's just feeling like he's good again... gonna get fucking smoked in this game [Steelers]. I love Detroit in this game.

The Steelers beat the Lions 29-24 in Week 16. Big Cat predicted the Lions would 'throttle' the Steelers, but Detroit lost in a controversial finish where a Jared Goff TD on the final play was negated by OPI.
Loss
Mike FlorioMike Florio

The Arizona Cardinals are guaranteed to move on from Kyler Murray

They want to be able to move on from Kyler Murray and they're gonna move on from him. They're probably gonna have to release him. And then the question becomes who wants him?

The Cardinals did not move on from Kyler Murray in the 2026 offseason.
Loss
Mike FlorioMike Florio

AJ Brown will likely be traded by the Philadelphia Eagles this offseason

I won't be surprised if AJ Brown is traded in the off season. I think we're at the point where it makes sense for both sides for him to move on. They can find another receiver, they can make their offense go without him.

AJ Brown remained with the Eagles for the 2026 season.
Loss
Mike FlorioMike Florio

The Bills will face the 49ers in the Super Bowl in our fictionalized 2025 season

Let's say, let's say Bills coming out of the AFC and... there's a very easy path for the 49ers... win the division to get the number one seed... pick the Bills and the 49ers. Let's go.

Mike Florio predicted a Bills vs. 49ers Super Bowl. Neither team made it. The Bills lost in the Divisional Round to Denver 33-30. The 49ers lost in the Divisional Round to Seattle 41-6. The actual Super Bowl was Seahawks vs. Patriots.
Loss
Joey HarringtonJoey Harrington

JMU has a legitimate chance to upset Oregon in the playoff due to extreme weather conditions

We have an atmospheric river coming here... you're going to get a sloppy game with potentially some James Madison fans there against an Oregon offense that's missing Corian Moore... Is it going to happen? Probably not. But it could.

Oregon defeated JMU decisively, 38-10.
Loss
Joey HarringtonJoey Harrington

Oregon can win the National Championship behind the maturity of quarterback Dante Moore

What do you need to make a great run in any playoff... you need a quarterback who's going to take control... he [Dante Moore] has absolutely just matured into a guy who's now completed almost 80% of his passes in the back half of the season.

Oregon lost in the semi-finals to Georgia.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers will win a playoff game this year

I think the Steelers, this is the year that they're going to win a playoff game. I've set it all year. ... If they can play the Chargers, if they can get that matchup, I feel like they could win that one.

The Steelers did not win a playoff game in the 2025-26 season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I bet on the 49ers to win the Super Bowl at 21-1

Yesterday I put a future in on the 49ers to win the Super Bowl. 21 to one. ... If the Seahawks beat the Rams, then the Niners have a chance at it. ... They have a real chance to get the one seed. And I kind of like how Brock Purdy's been playing.

The 49ers did not win the Super Bowl in 2026.
Loss
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Travis Kelce will likely retire after this season

If I'm Kansas City, first of all, we gotta figure out what's Travis Kelce gonna do and it, you know, I would guess that he's gonna retire, but I have zero inside information on that.

Travis Kelce did not retire after the 2025-26 season.
Loss
MemesMemes

Jayden Daniels is the worst quarterback from the 2024 draft class

My preemptive take of the year was right. Commanders would miss a playoffs and Jayden Daniels be the worst out of all the quarterbacks in 2024. [Big Cat: 'Michael Penix?'] He looked pretty good before the injury.

By most statistical measures and eye tests, Daniels was far from the 'worst' of the class, having won OROY in many circles.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Arizona Cardinals should fire Jonathan Gannon and hire Josh McDaniels

In the Cardinals' wildest dreams... Probably fire Gannon. Figure out a way to trade Kyler Murray. Hire Josh McDaniels. He's gonna get another shot. Owners love a guy that's failed twice. Spectacularly failed twice.

Satirical take; McDaniels was not hired by the Cardinals.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Shanahan should win Coach of the Year if the 49ers secure the NFC's number one seed

If the Seahawks beat the Rams on Thursday Night Football and then the Niners win out and they get the one seed overall after everything the Niners have been through, I feel like Kyle Shanahan would be [Coach of the Year]. You could also make the argument that this is maybe Kyle Shanahan's best season as a coach.

PFT suggested Kyle Shanahan should win Coach of the Year if the 49ers got the 1 seed. The 49ers did NOT get the 1 seed — they lost to the Seahawks in Week 18 and fell to the 6 seed. Mike Vrabel of the Patriots won Coach of the Year after leading New England from 4-13 to 14-3.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Darnold's performance in December is a major concern for the Seahawks

As a long time Sam Darnold defender, Sam Darnold apologist. I've started to develop some cracks the last couple weeks. ... We're in December and December is not a good thing [for him]. ... I would be worried if I was a Seahawks fan about the playoffs.

Sam Darnold and the Seahawks won Super Bowl LX. PFT's concern about Darnold in December was unfounded - he led Seattle to a championship.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles will lead the Commanders 36-17 next week before the game gets interesting

The Eagles are gonna be up 36 to 17 [against the Commanders next Saturday]. I want the Commanders' sound off and then hopefully JMU gets off to like a seven-nothing lead before everything goes to shit.

The Eagles beat the Commanders 29-18 in Week 16, not 36-17 as PFT predicted. While the Eagles did win and pulled away in the second half, the specific score prediction was way off.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Saints should win the NFC South after Tyler Schuck's takeover

Tyler Schuck might be the real deal. ... Everything post-Shuck should count. They should win the NFC South. Shuck should be a playoff quarterback this year.

The Saints did not win the NFC South. The Carolina Panthers won the NFC South with an 8-9 record. The Saints finished below the Panthers despite Tyler Shough's late-season emergence.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

George Pickens will record two touchdowns and 140 receiving yards on Christmas Day

Christmas Day, George Pickens: two touchdowns, 140 yards [against the Commanders].

George Pickens was traded to the Dallas Cowboys before the 2025 season and did not play for the Steelers on Christmas Day. Playing for Dallas against the Commanders, Pickens had 4 catches for 78 yards and 0 TDs — far short of the predicted 2 TDs and 140 yards.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Pitts will eventually have 20 touchdowns in one season

I predicted that Kyle Pitts will have the greatest year of any tight end of ever in year 20 in the NFL. He'll have 20 touchdowns. That's a fact.

This is a comedic bit based on a pattern, highly unlikely to happen literally.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will stop cussing for the rest of the season if Philip Rivers beats the Seahawks

If Philip Rivers, if they win, I won't cuss for the rest of football season. Yeah. I'm gonna stop cussing. It would be that magical of a moment.

Philip Rivers (playing for the Colts, not Chargers) did not beat the Seahawks. Seattle won 18-16 on a Jason Myers 56-yard field goal with 29 seconds left. Since Rivers lost, PFT's conditional bet (stop cussing if Rivers wins) was never triggered, but the underlying prediction of a Rivers victory was incorrect.
Loss
MaxMax

The Eagles season is dead

This team is dead... Nothing will save this team. The only good thing about this team is that Kevin Patullo will get fired. We'll hire a new offensive coordinator and make the Super Bowl next year. Because it's just a cycle for the Eagles right now.

The Eagles' season was not dead. They finished 11-6, won the NFC East, and made the playoffs (lost WC to 49ers 19-23).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm officially nervous about my pinky bet because the Texans look like they could win the Super Bowl

I'm officially nervous though because I thought you guys [the Texans] were cooked. I'm an idiot... and yeah, that's at stake right now. So you guys are my pinky team and it's very scary with the way you guys are playing football. I think they can absolutely win the Super Bowl... I'm fucked.

The Texans lost in the Divisional Round of the 2024 playoffs, so Big Cat's pinky was safe.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers will lose to the Dolphins on Monday Night Football.

Oh, they're playing the Dolphins on Monday Night Football. They're [Steelers] gonna lose. [PFT: They're Yeah. Probably gonna lose that game. Take Dolphins.]

The Steelers defeated the Dolphins, making this prediction incorrect.
Loss
MaxMax

Tyler Shough is the best quarterback in the 2025 draft class.

I'm an in on [Tyler] Shough. Best quarterback of the class.

Shough was not the first QB taken in 2025 and did not have the most successful rookie year, making this a bold miss.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I still think the Buccaneers will win the NFC South and make the playoffs.

I still think that the Bucks are going to win that division, make the playoffs, but they're fucking around... I think [Mike Evans] should be like a hundred percent healthy by the time he gets back. That's gonna be very big for the offense.

PFT predicted the Buccaneers would win the NFC South and make the playoffs. The Carolina Panthers won the NFC South at 8-9 via a three-way tiebreaker over the Buccaneers and Falcons (all 8-9). Tampa Bay was eliminated from the playoffs.
Loss
MemesMemes

Lamar Jackson sucks and the Ravens would only get a fourth and fifth-round pick for him if they traded him right now.

Lamar [Jackson] sucks... [The Ravens would only get] like a fourth and a fifth [round pick if they traded him right now].

Lamar Jackson is a multi-time MVP whose trade value would be multiple first-round picks; Memes' valuation is objectively incorrect.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Packers look like Super Bowl favorites

I think that the Packers looked like the team that would be maybe favored to win the Super Bowl the way they played today.

The Packers did not win the Super Bowl in the 2025 season.
Loss
MaxMax

The Eagles will find a way to beat the Chargers on Monday Night Football.

I think they [Eagles] win. I think they, the bunny... they're gonna find a way tomorrow. They're gonna find a way... and the bunny bunny's good vibes. I feel like I gotta be good vibes for the bunny.

The Chargers defeated the Eagles on MNF, making this prediction incorrect.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Detroit got their mojo back and looked like the efficient team they were earlier in the season

I feel like Detroit kind of got their mojo back a little bit and like, 'Hey, we're not going out without a fight.' Detroit didn't make those mistakes. Detroit didn't turn the ball over.

The Lions missed the 2025 playoffs entirely, eliminated in Week 17. Getting their mojo back was temporary.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals can make the playoffs if they beat the Bills

I know that I've made the joke that everyone says don't let the Bengals into the playoffs. We won't. There is a chance that Bengals can make the playoffs because if they can win this game [against the Bills], the rest of their schedule is easy.

The Bengals finished 6-11 and did not make the playoffs. They missed the postseason for the third consecutive year.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am 60% sure Jayden Daniels will not play against the Vikings.

I still don't know [if Jayden Daniels is playing]. ... I'm at like 60% that he's not gonna play. ... Big picture, if he gets hurt, I'm gonna be like, why the fuck was Jayden Daniels playing in this game?

Jayden Daniels was cleared and did start the Week 14 game against the Vikings on December 7, 2025. PFT said he was 60% sure Daniels would NOT play, but Daniels did start (though he left the game early with an elbow injury in the 31-0 loss).
Loss
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

The AFC playoffs will go through New England because the Patriots are the most solidified team in the conference.

I've been in the belief... that the home field [in the AFC] was gonna go through New England. I, I firmly believe that because of the schedule and seeing them in person Monday night. ... New England is more solidified and I would lean towards them getting home field.

Stanford Steve predicted AFC home-field advantage would go through New England. The Denver Broncos earned the #1 seed in the AFC at 14-3, giving them home-field advantage. The Patriots were the #2 seed. The AFC Championship was played in Denver, not New England (Patriots won 10-7 on the road).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Tomlin and the Steelers are likely to break up after this season

My Hot Seat is Mike Tomlin and the Steelers. Because I actually think that he might, this might be it... they don't change anything. And it's, I mean, TJ Watt said it. I think the bills ran the same play 27 times on Sunday. Yeah. That's insane. It feels like this is finally [the end].

Tomlin signed an extension through 2027 in the real world, but the sentiment of the 'break up' is a recurring narrative every time the Steelers struggle.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Kansas City Chiefs are officially eliminated from playoff contention

The Kansas City Chiefs have been eliminated from playoff contention... I just don't think that they can run the table because that's gonna be it. It's hard. These aren't the same chiefs.

The Chiefs were not mathematically eliminated at this time, but PFT is making a bold prediction that they won't run the table.
Loss
MemesMemes

The New York Jets will acquire Lamar Jackson from the Ravens next season

I do go to bed and I just thinking who's the next quarterback will be next season. And right now we're on Lamar Jackson... Ravens don't make the playoffs. Raven's good organization. They've moved on from quarterbacks in the past... we got like three years of Lamar.

Lamar Jackson remained with the Ravens, making this a classic 'Jets fan fever dream'.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am suppressing the thought that the Bears are legitimate Super Bowl contenders if they beat the Eagles on Black Friday.

I'm keeping those [thoughts] suppressed because why not though? I, I think superstitious wise, I need to stay in that mode... why don't we just fucking beat the Eagles and go nine to three? Yeah. And like just start fucking ripping on.

Big Cat was suppressing thoughts of the Bears being Super Bowl contenders. The Bears went 11-6 and won a playoff game (Wild Card vs Packers 31-27) but lost in the Divisional Round to the Rams 20-17. They did not make the Super Bowl.
Loss
Stavros HalkiasStavros Halkias

The Ravens will win the Super Bowl as a Wild Card underdog

Yes, of course. They're winning the Super Bowl. It's faded to be, we're going as the fucking wild card... we're gonna fucking get revenge on everyone. This will be, this is how it's done.

The Ravens made the playoffs but lost to the Chiefs in the Divisional Round; they did not win the Super Bowl.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers