Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Open
John SalleyJohn Salley

Giannis Antetokounmpo will be the greatest player of the 2020-2030 decade

It might be Giannis. Yeah, that was my [pick for the next 10 years].

Giannis has remained a top-tier player, though others like Jokic and Luka are in the conversation.
Void
John SalleyJohn Salley

Isiah Thomas is the greatest player I ever played with, even over Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, and Shaq

The greatest player I've ever played with is Isiah Thomas. And I have played with Michael. I have played with Kobe and Shaq, but the greatest player was Isiah Thomas. He's six foot and he did everything everybody else was doing.

Subjective preference for a teammate.
Loss
John SalleyJohn Salley

Kyle Korver is a better 3-point shooter than Steph Curry

I actually am looking at the list right now [Big Cat speaking]... Kyle Korver does have a higher percentage than Steph. [Salley]: You guys did cheat in college. I can tell because you only looking at the cliff notes. [Salley earlier arguing Dell Curry, Reggie Miller, Dale Ellis were better than Steph].

While Korver has a slightly higher career 3P% (42.9% vs Curry's ~42.6% at the time), Curry has more than double the makes and is universally regarded as the superior shooter.
Loss
John SalleyJohn Salley

Caucasians have only been on the planet for 6,000 years and were originally cave dwellers

Black people have been on the planet for 16,000 years. They say the Caucasian has only been on the planet for 6,000 years... light hair, light color, skin, light eyes, obviously a cave dweller. And it's because you had to come from you couldn't deal with the sun, your nose was elongated because it was cold.

Modern humans (Homo sapiens) appeared roughly 300,000 years ago. Light skin and European features evolved far earlier than 6,000 years ago.
Loss
John SalleyJohn Salley

Jayson Tatum will be the 2022 NBA Finals MVP

How about if you can accurately predict who the NBA finals MVP will be right now? [Salley]: Tatum. Yep. [PFT]: Oh, then Billy has to go vegan for a month.

The Celtics lost the 2022 Finals to the Warriors. Stephen Curry was the Finals MVP.
Push
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

Kenny Pickett is superior to Mitch Trubisky because Kenny followed my fiancee on Instagram

Mitch gets picked up by the Steelers show Respect immediately. DM show the wife respect. I ain't get an answer. Now, you know Kenny Pickett followed me. Kenny Pickett's a fan of mine... after dinner, you know what I got? I got a follow from Kenny's fiancee. Oh wow. Follow. Not doing that holds more weight in my book than a message. So where I stand right now... Kenny ain't coming here to take part Kenny come in here to take over man.

Pickett did eventually take the job from Trubisky, but his performance as a starter was mediocre before being traded to the Eagles in 2024.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

Kenny Pickett will win multiple Super Bowls

I ain't seen Superbowl. I'm seeing super bowls [for Kenny Pickett].

Pickett was traded away from the Steelers after two seasons with zero playoff wins.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Suns are officially dead after one of the most embarrassing Game 7 performances ever

Suns are cooked, absolutely cooked. We're calling it. This game. Suns are cooked, absolutely cooked... This is an embarrassing performance game seven at home... The Suns are playing like they have Chris Paul and four James Hardens in a game seven. That's how they're playing.

The Suns lost by 33 points, confirming the 'cooked' status.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Chris Paul is a fraud and the best NBA player of all time that has sucked

I'm going to call it right now. I'm going to use a hard D-bomb. What's that? Hank? A fraud. ... Chris Paul is literally the best NBA player of all time that has sucked. ... Don't get too committed to one player who's 37 years old and chokes in the playoffs.

Subjective label of 'fraud', though Paul's playoff failures are statistically significant.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

David Stern saved the NBA by nixing the Chris Paul to the Lakers trade because Paul is a loser

Go back to when the Chris Paul to the Lakers trade didn't happen because David Stern nixed it. I think David Stern accurately knew like, 'Hey, the league's better when the Lakers were winning championships, I'm not going to let this trade go through just because I know that [the Lakers] will never win a ring when Chris Paul's on the team.' I think it wasn't a matter of making a super team that made him step in... I think he actually saved the NBA.

Subjective historical analysis of intent, though Paul indeed has never won a ring.
Push
HankHank

The Celtics will beat the Heat in five or six games

I do think the Celtics are a better team. Like I think this should be a five or six game series. And I just, you know, Heat culture all that shit, but that was, you know, even the bubble, like the Celtics team is a much different team than they were in the bubble. They're way better.

The Celtics did beat the Heat to advance to the Finals, but it took the full seven games, not five or six.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers had better assistant coaches than head coaches over the last seven years

This is now three assistant coaches the Sixers had... they had three assistant coaches in the last seven years that have gone to a conference final. Mike D'Antoni... Monty Williams... and Ime Udoka now. As they wrestle with Brett Brown and Doc Rivers, they had three guys who... are better coaches than they've had in their former coach and their current.

Verified coaching movement; Ime Udoka went on to the NBA Finals in 2022.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Danny Woodhead is better at golf than Tony Romo

My guy Danny Woodhead... He is very close to qualifying for the U.S. Open in golf. ... He's better than Tony Romo at golf.

While subjective, Woodhead's attempt to qualify for the U.S. Open was statistically impressive for a former NFL player.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Drew Brees is going to return to the NFL

Drew Brees... he could be returning to football. He could go back to NBC... usually when someone ends up, they're coming back to play, they're probably going to come back.

Drew Brees did not return to play in the NFL after this episode.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Big 10 needs Ohio State to be in the playoffs every year to stay relevant

We need to get another title soon. And it might be—you're probably going to have to be Ohio State. Cause I'm just being honest, I'm a very honest Big 10 fan... we gotta be in the playoffs every year to stay relevant. The PAC-12 is no longer relevant. Ohio State, as much as I hate them, they're the best chance every year.

The Big 10 has struggled to win titles outside of Ohio State in the modern era.
Void
Will ComptonWill Compton

In-N-Out burger is so overhyped

But you go in the conversation as best tasting burger. We're not talking about all the bells and whistles of everything else. And I think that's what In-N-Out does... Great service, great experience, the ingredients yes, very quality. But again, we're talking about a great taste. We're talking about the best tasting burger out there and to me In-N-Out is so over-hyped.

Taste is subjective, though In-N-Out remains a highly debated topic in fast food.
Void
Will ComptonWill Compton

It is not a veteran's job to mentor their replacement

It's not Ryan [Tannehill's] job to mentor the young guy. Like he takes on the young guys. It's definitely a young guy's job they're like pick, get as much from the vet as you fucking can... You never think I'm going to go out of my way and do like, this is in my job responsibility or my job description to mentor somebody else to teach you.

This is a philosophical stance on NFL locker room dynamics.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Derrick Henry's long legs are detrimental in short yardage

I had this theory that Derrick Henry has super long legs for his height. ... I feel like it's actually detrimental in short yardage between the tackles, because people can wrap up his legs more. ... every time he like does well in short yardage, it's like in a sweep or he's bouncing out of the tackles.

The guests (NFL players) largely dismiss this theory, noting Henry's overall dominance.
Loss
Will ComptonWill Compton

I would have been the Defensive Player of the Year if I played the whole season

If I were playing the entire year, I'm fucking Defensive Player of the Year. Yeah. Why not? You can't prove them wrong.

Compton was a backup/special teamer and would not have won DPOY over the likes of T.J. Watt.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Maple Leafs getting more respect in the handshake line is a pathetic baby step

Sheldon Keefe said after the series, they got a lot more respect in the post-series handshake line from the Lightning than after previous loss. It's baby steps. He did go on to say, 'We're not in the respect game. We're in the winning game.'... But just saying, 'we got a lot more respect.' Hey, that's a win. You guys, people respecting how [you lost].

Verified quote from Keefe; mocking the concept of 'respect' wins.
Loss
MemesMemes

The Hurricanes will sweep the Rangers

Big Canes fan now. Canes in four. They can't lose at home.

The Rangers beat the Hurricanes in 7 games. Memes was wrong on the sweep and the winner.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The James Harden for Ben Simmons trade was a lose-lose for both teams

I think you go back to the trade and neither team won. It was the classic lose-lose trade, like both teams in, in a weird way, got a little bit worse from this trade.

Both teams struggled significantly post-trade; Simmons barely played for Brooklyn and Harden eventually forced his way out of Philly after more playoff disappointment.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am the last person in the world who still believes in Ben Simmons

I'm, I'm, I'm the one sucker alive that still believes in Ben Simmons. So I'm like nets could still get some out of them. Crazy, stupid irrational. So I'm not giving up on Ben Simmons. I'm the last person in the world because I'm like six, 10 point cards don't grow on trees.

Ben Simmons' career continued to decline due to injuries and mental hurdles, making the belief that he could still be an elite piece incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Doc Rivers has had zero impact on the 76ers since arriving

Dr. Rivers got there. He's been there for two years... they've literally just gone. It was like, they, they they've been just doing the same thing year after year after year, Dr. Rivers has had no impact on it. They were on the exact same trajectory and he's like, we were a mess when I got here, but I fixed it all to get us right back to where we were.

The Sixers continued to struggle with second-round exits and eventually fired Doc Rivers in 2023, largely confirming the stagnation narrative.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 'Process' is overrated and Nick Saban is full of shit

I think Nick Saban's full of shit. I think the process is overrated. We're results guys on the podcast, right? It's oh bad. I don't care about the process... just give me the result. I don't care how we get there.

The Sixers' 'Process' era is widely viewed as a failure given they never reached a Conference Final with the core it produced.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Heat are the sign of a truly elite franchise for having three different championship-contending eras in 20 years

If the Heat somehow could win a championship this year... That would be what four titles over the course of 20 years, less than 20 years with all three completely different rock busters. I mean, that's the sign of what a really, really good franchise.

The Heat reached the Conference Finals in 2022 and the Finals in 2023, validating their status as an elite franchise.
Loss
HankHank

The Suns are definitely going to win Game 7 against the Mavericks

I tend to agree. But now the sons are in a spot where they're playing against Lucca in a game seven where he can easily be the best player on the court...

The Mavericks blew out the Suns 123-90 in one of the most shocking Game 7 results in NBA history.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

It would be better for the future of the Mavericks if they lose Game 7 to the Suns

I'll take it one step further. How's this for take, it would actually be better for the future of the Dallas Mavericks. If they lose this game. ... if they had gotten blown out in the second round, then I feel like mark Cuban would kind of like have to go nuclear and try to put something good together and get like an awesome player to team up with Luca to take that next step.

Subjective. However, the Mavs made the WCF and eventually traded for Kyrie Irving later, suggesting they didn't need a total nuclear option after that run.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Maple Leafs will win Game 7 against the Lightning

The fear in the city of Toronto on Saturday morning, waking up is going to be at an all time high. ... I'm nervous for them, but I think they're going to win...

The Lightning won Game 7 with a 2-1 victory, extending Toronto's streak of first-round exits.
Win
HankHank

The Lightning are psychological locks to beat the Maple Leafs in Game 7

They've been there. They've experienced it. They've played as a team. They've won championships. This is the first round. ... Toronto has the pressure of a city that needs a championship and an entire country that needs a championship.

The Lightning won Game 7.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

The Jets will finish between 7-10 and 9-8 this season

So I just want to talk about jet schedule, my prediction, what? ... Well, it's either going to be low level seven and 10 high level nine and eight.

The 2022 Jets finished exactly 7-10.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

There will be a quarterback controversy in New England where Bailey Zappe challenges Mac Jones

Maddie. Think about this magic Mack Jones gets benched for Bailey. ... I think there's going to be a court quarterback controversy in new England. That we're is going to actually like really tank them. I'm just saying why they draft Bailey just saying,

A massive controversy did emerge in the 2022 and 2023 seasons, with 'Zappe Fever' taking over and Jones eventually getting benched multiple times.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL intentionally scheduled its best games on Christmas to sabotage the NBA's marquee day

What they did for the for the Christmas day schedule is so mean because they did... They literally just picked out the best NBA teams. I think the, I think the Bulls and the Knicks are gonna just have to play five times on Christmas day... They just took. They just completely cocked the NBA on their day.

The 2022 NFL Christmas games were huge ratings hits, significantly outperforming the NBA games as Big Cat predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Over for the Bills-Rams kickoff game will be my biggest bet ever

I've never done a game of the year, but I, I think I'm in advance calling that my game of the summer... the over is going to have her and I'm going to... make this my biggest bet ever.

The game total was around 52.5 and the final score was 31-10 (41 total), meaning the under hit comfortably.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics are still going to win the series against the Bucks despite blowing Game 5

It was a devastating loss. I still think the Celtics are gonna win the series. ... I think they're going to win tonight. It's a must win.

The Celtics won Game 6 and Game 7 to win the series.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Capitals win this Stanley Cup and the next, they are officially a dynasty

I did say when they were up three, nothing. I was like, if we win this Stanley cup and the next Stanley cup, does that count as a dynasty taking into account the 2018 Stanley cup that they have?

The Capitals lost in the first round in 2022, so the condition was never met.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Grizzlies might actually be better without Ja Morant

We have a new narrative. That's very fun. Are the Grizzlies better? Without Ja Morant? ... the stat is the warriors or sorry, the Grizzlies are now I think 21 and six without Ja Morant.

While they had a great record without him in the regular season, Ja Morant is an All-NBA talent and the franchise's centerpiece; the Grizzlies struggled significantly without him in subsequent seasons.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

A bone bruise stings at first but then you are fine because bones don't move

Yeah, no, like a bone bruise. Just like stings at first. ... And then it's like, it's a bone, so it doesn't really move. So it's like not really sore. So just to go with it. ... bones move, but muscles are moving the bone, the bone doesn't actually move

Bones move at joints; a bone bruise is extremely painful because bones are highly vascularized and innervated. It's not a 'two-hour' injury.
Void
Brian CoxBrian Cox

There might be as few as one intelligent civilization per galaxy

I think there's a good argument that there might be a very few of those. And actually there's a reasonable argument we might assume there's about one per galaxy on average, any one time, which means that we're it.

This is a theoretical position in astrophysics that remains unproven but is a significant part of scientific debate.
Void
Brian CoxBrian Cox

The universe appears to be a hologram where reality can be represented by information on 'the walls'

Everything that's going on in the room can be perfectly represented by a quantum theory that lives on the walls. So the universe appears to be in some sense, a hologram, right, it's called, it's got a fancy name. It's called the ADS CFT correspondence... you can characterize everything that's going on in a regional space, by a theory that just lives on the edge.

This is a valid scientific hypothesis/principle (AdS/CFT correspondence), though still theoretical and not strictly 'proven' as physical reality.
Void
Brian CoxBrian Cox

Information is never truly destroyed by a black hole and could theoretically be reconstructed

It seems now that's what happens in black holes. So you throw the book in, and then at some point in the distant future, you could collect all the Hawking radiation that comes off and reconstruct the book... if some sufficiently clever, super advanced civilization, if they could collect all the Hawking radiation and put it into some quantum computer would actually reconstruct you.

This represents the current consensus in theoretical physics following developments in the early 2020s.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Fridays are better than Saturdays because the weekend feels like it will last forever

I'd take Fridays over Saturdays, but that's just me... there's no better feeling than Friday after lunch. There's just, it feels like the weekend is forever.

Purely a matter of personal preference and perspective on time.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The winner of Game 5 in a 2-2 series wins the series 83% of the time.

Here's a fun stat... if you look at it, that that is a correct, but the more important stat is 83% of the time that a series is tied 2-2, that winner of game five goes on to win the series.

This is a statistically verifiable historical fact in the NBA playoffs.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Heat and Suns will both win their Game 6 matchups.

And honestly, like, I, I would bet that both of these teams that won tonight are probably going to win game six.

The Miami Heat won their Game 6 against the Sixers, but the Phoenix Suns lost their Game 6 to the Dallas Mavericks.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Skip Bayless definitely has burner accounts on Twitter

This is proof. Skip Bayless has burners. I've got a mission now for the next three weeks, which would be to find, skip Bayless's burners and see what the takes that he puts out on the burn. The ones that like, he doesn't think are ready for prime time yet the ones that he's testing out.

This is a widespread belief based on Skip occasionally replying to himself or referencing his own tweets, but it has never been formally proven or 'unmasked' like Kevin Durant's burners.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Deandre Ayton is the one guy in the NBA who should be able to dominate any game he is in.

I think [Deandre] Ayton might be the one guy in the league right now where he can, when I watch him play, I'm like, why is he [not] always just play like this? It feels like he should be able to dominate any game that he's in.

Whether Ayton 'should' dominate is subjective, but his career since 2022 has been marked by inconsistent effort and a trade to Portland, supporting the idea that he doesn't always live up to his potential.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Leafs are perfectly set up to lose to the Lightning in Game 6

The Leafs are back, which means that's where they're perfectly set up to lose. And I mean, we might have to game of the year, the Lightning in game six.

The Lightning did beat the Leafs in Game 6 (4-3 in OT) and eventually won the series in 7 games.
Void
HankHank

Al Horford is Batman and Jason Tatum is Robin

[Al Horford]'s Batman. Jason Tatum's Robin, Jaylen Brown the Joker.

This is a subjective characterization of team roles based on a single game's performance.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady's Fox broadcast will be better than Peyton Manning's because he'll have a better staff

I think that that Peyton Manning as an individual is going to be better than Tom Brady. But Tom Brady is going to have a much better staff around him. And so on a whole, his broadcast will be much, much better known as a dynasty.

Comparing Tom Brady's Fox broadcast quality to Peyton Manning's ESPN broadcast is a subjective media opinion. Brady's first Fox season (2024) received mixed reviews, making this debatable.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Harden plays worse in cities with high strip club populations

You know the stat that we were talking about a couple of years ago with James Harden and how he demonstrably plays worse in cities that have high strip club populations.

A detailed 2019 Reddit analysis famously made this correlation, though it remains an unofficial, non-causal statistic.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers