Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Taylor Heinicke is just 'a guy' rather than a long-term franchise starter

I may have spoke slightly too soon on saying Taylor Heinicke is our guy. He's a guy. I think he's gone to—he's definitely a guy and he's there and he can be the guy, but a lot of times he's just not the guy.

Heinicke eventually settled into a career backup/fringe starter role, which aligns with being 'just a guy.'
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Football Team exploited Sean Taylor's death to distract from front office scandals

If they literally were exploiting Sean Taylor's death, the one player that I care about... to get the stank off of their front office, that's a new low. And I think they were. I might be out.

The timing was widely criticized by national media as a transparent PR distraction from the Jon Gruden email fallout and WFT investigations.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Fitzpatrick will take the starting job back from Taylor Heinicke as soon as he's healthy

I think we also, the last couple of weeks, we've answered the question. If Ryan Fitzpatrick gets healthy, I think he has his job back.

Fitzpatrick never actually got healthy enough to return in 2021, eventually retiring, so the condition of the take was never met.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Sam Darnold is definitely not fixed

The idea that Sam Darnold was fixed because he left the Jets is just insane. He was bad again today... Breaking news: he's not fixed.

Darnold was benched later in the season and struggled throughout his Panthers tenure.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers are not actually good; they are just 'frisky'

I think we can officially say that the Panthers are not going to be good. They could be frisky... but they're not good.

The Panthers finished the season 5-12, losing 7 straight games after this point. They were definitely not good.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens are a legitimate, very good team (and not frauds)

I actually—I've talked about the Ravens being frauds in the past. I'm not going to say that this year. I think the Ravens are a legit, very, very good team. And they are in that like group of... super bowl contenders in the AFC.

The Ravens were 8-3 and the #1 seed in the AFC before Lamar Jackson got hurt and they lost their final 6 games. They were a good team undone by injuries.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos' 3-0 start was fraudulent because they only beat bad teams

The Broncos are... the biggest fraud start of the season. They beat the Giants, the Jags and the Jets. And we all kind of like, 'Ooh, maybe.' ... No, no, no.

The Broncos finished 7-10 and missed the playoffs, confirming their 3-0 start was indeed a mirage against bad competition.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Vic Fangio is likely in his final season as the Broncos head coach

I also think we might be on Vic watch. Vic Fangio is probably on his last season.

Fangio was indeed fired by the Broncos on January 9, 2022, at the conclusion of the season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tony Romo is no longer a top-tier announcer

That's probably if like in 20 years when they write the book about Pardon My Take, I think that like us being the first to say Tony Romo not that good. That'd be a big one.

The sentiment toward Romo shifted significantly among general NFL fans in the following years.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trevon Diggs will not reach 10 interceptions this season

I feel like in the next couple of weeks, he's probably not going to get above 10 interceptions on the year. The opportunity—at some point they just have to stop throwing to his side of the field.

Trevon Diggs finished the 2021 season with 11 interceptions, meaning PFT's prediction of 'under 10' was incorrect.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Green Bay Packers will not win the Super Bowl because Aaron Rodgers doesn't win championships anymore

I don't think that the Packers can be in [Super Bowl contenders] unfortunately... because Aaron Rodgers, he doesn't win championships.

The Packers lost in the Divisional Round to the 49ers as the #1 seed that season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Coach Ed Orgeron will return as a 'full-time interim coach' for hire

Next time any program needs an interim head coach, he should be interim for hire. He should be a full-time interim coach.

PredictionCFBMediumSarcastic
Orgeron effectively retired from coaching after LSU and did not take any interim roles.
Loss
HankHank

Florida QB Anthony Richardson is Cam Newton 2.0 and a 2022 Heisman candidate

Florida's quarterback that they put in second [Anthony Richardson] is Cam Newton 2.0, yes. He's on my big board for Heisman next year.

Richardson did not win the Heisman and had a volatile collegiate career, though his physical profile did lead to him being the #4 overall pick in the NFL draft.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I was rooting for the Patriots over Tom Brady and the Bucs

I was rooting for the Pats [over the Bucs]. I mean, my guy [Brady] gets a little sensitive sometimes. He's my best friend, and... I don't think he probably would [say I am his best friend] anymore [because I didn't root for him].

This is a personal rooting interest/opinion, so it is inherently subjective.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers are my second favorite team and I love Kyle Shanahan

I'm rooting for the Niners number two. Big Niners guy. I like the Niners. I like [Kyle] Shanahan. I think he's a good coach. I like the defense. I like [George] Kittle, even though he's hurt right now. I grew up loving the 49ers.

Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Antonio Brown is still performing at a freakish, electric level

Antonio Brown adds to the offense... it's just crazy. He looks electric. I mean, he stays in shape. I was around him for two weeks and got to know him a little bit and he eats, breathes, and lives football and taking care of his body. He's a freak. He's still performing at a very, very high level.

AB had a strong 2021 season with the Bucs before his mid-game exit against the Jets later that year.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am selling all my Jalen Hurts stock

He drifts in the most unproductive angles. He runs backwards into the sideline and tries to throw the ball away. He's had a couple games where he's played well. I'm not buying Jalen Hurts. If he's a stock, I think I'm selling all my stocks that I have in Jalen Hurts.

Hurts significantly improved his pocket presence and became a top-tier QB, leading the Eagles to a Super Bowl the following season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts is Mr. Right Now, not Mr. Right

I think I'm sticking with what I said on Monday is that [Jalen Hurts] is Mr. Right Now, not Mr. Right.

Hurts signed a massive extension in 2023, proving he was indeed 'Mr. Right' for the Eagles organization.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick told me it's okay to criticize the Patriots in the media

[Belichick] goes, like, if you have to motherfuck us, you can motherfuck us. He was telling me to do my job. It felt like a mafia meeting. It was cool.

This is a first-hand account of a conversation.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Mac Jones has very impressive pocket awareness for a young quarterback

What I'm most impressed about with Mac [Jones] is his ability to sidestep a guy in the pocket, step up, keep his eyes downfield... and be able to deliver a ball. Those are things that you don't see very often from younger quarterbacks. That calm, cool, collect in his pocket awareness. He's not mobile by any means, but his ability to move in the pocket... he's got a good foundation going.

Jones did make the Pro Bowl as a rookie and showed the traits Edelman described that year, though he couldn't maintain that level.
Push
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Mac Jones has the best ecosystem of all rookie quarterbacks

I definitely think [Mac Jones'] ecosystem was the best out of all the rookies that are entering the league this year. Just as far as... how the team is built, the money that they spent, and the defense that they have and the coaches that they have, you know those guys are going to be there for a while. It's a stability there. Usually when you get a fresh quarterback, you're getting a fresh coach, a new play caller.

While Mac Jones had initial success, the 'stability' claim proved questionable as the Patriots' offensive coaching staff went through significant, poorly-reviewed changes in subsequent seasons.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Chiefs need to abandon the video game plays and use methodical drives

The Chiefs are built differently this year. They're a little banged up on defense... and they have this stigma that every time they're going to go out the offense, they're going to do a video game play. They need to have a little more long, methodical-type drive. Make the easy play. Sometimes you've got to make the easy pass.

The Chiefs did eventually adapt to more shell coverages by using shorter, methodical drives to return to the AFC Championship game that season.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills are the #1 team in the league right now

My current BCS rankings have the Cardinals and the Bills, one and two. [But] the fun fact about the Bills, they have double the point differential than the second team not named the Cardinals... The Bills are plus 108. They are fucking killing people. We can agree. Bills should be at the top.

The Bills finished 11-6 and lost in the Divisional round, while the Rams won the Super Bowl and the Packers had the best record. The Bills were elite but arguably not #1.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cowboys -3.5 at the Patriots is my favorite bet of the week

My favorite favorite is Cowboys, minus three and a half at the Patriots... I like the Cowboys in this one. Patriots are going to have a long Sunday. I've been looking at the rat lines for the last few weeks and just betting the square side of the rat lines. And it's been a pretty successful strategy for me so far.

The Cowboys won 35-29, covering the -3.5 spread.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Browns will beat the Cardinals and hand them their first loss

My favorite favorite is the Browns, minus three... I also just think the Cardinals are due for – they've been flirting with it. They're due for a loss, and they're due for the Browns to run the ball down their throat. I do think the Browns are going to beat them. I think the Browns are going to man up on them.

The Cardinals beat the Browns 37-14, moving to 6-0.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will cover +4.5 against the Packers

I actually think the Bears might win, but Bears plus 4.5... I have a feeling their defense is playing well... By the end of the week, I'm like, we're going to fucking win this game. Jalen Johnson's going to lock down Davante Adams. If the Bears win this game, they are now officially a borderline playoff team.

The Packers won 24-14, beating the 4.5-point spread.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL has figured out Geno Smith

I think the league might have figured out Geno Smith, Big Cat. On that last drive [last week]... I think the blueprint's out there for how to shut him down. The Steelers defense is going to show up.

Geno Smith actually had a late-career breakout (Comeback Player of the Year in 2022) that proved he wasn't 'figured out' in the way PFT implies here.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders will bounce back because Rich Bisaccia is a classic football guy

I am all in on this Rich Bisaccia guy... Crying about your men and your opportunities, that's football guy stuff. I think they're gonna bounce back here for a couple weeks and it's gonna be a few weeks before they fall back to earth. I think they're gonna get something out of this guy. I'm all in.

The Raiders did bounce back under Bisaccia, winning their first two games under him and eventually making the playoffs.
Win
XFactorXFactor

Arrowhead is the loudest stadium in the world because of me

I'm the one that helped bring two Guinness World Records for crowd noise, Arrowhead Stadium. It's the current Guinness World Record for crowd noise, 142.2 decibels. We're the loudest stadium, not only in the NFL, but the world. I brought that to Kansas City with my friends. I got Guinness. I got the Chiefs. I set it all up.

Arrowhead does hold the record (142.2 dB set in 2014). XFactor was a lead organizer of the 'Loud and Proud' group that petitioned Guinness to come, making his claim largely accurate in terms of initiation.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Never plan a Saturday night dinner for a bachelor party

The biggest tip I always give is don't plan a dinner for Saturday night. That's the dumbest thing ever. It's like a tranquilizer dart to your face. You drink all day Saturday, and then you have this... big steak dinner on Saturday night, and then there's just no party afterwards because it's like, holy shit, we drank all day, then we ate a big meal. Who wants to go out after that?

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Red Sox are a team of destiny and are going to the World Series

Red Sox, Team of Destiny. I think they're going deep in Socktober. They're going to the World Series. They have something about them that is going to... I don't know what it is.

The Red Sox lost to the Houston Astros in the 2021 ALCS and did not reach the World Series.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL commissioners should be considered a protected class

NFL commissioners, it's a protected class. Look it up, Big Cat... Roger Goodell, when he saw it, like, okay, the first email got leaked on Friday... He also insulted Roger Goodell and called him gay. Fire that motherfucker right now.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The NFL is a private entity and can prioritize whatever internal conduct it wants; however, commissioners are not a legally protected class in the way PFT is implying.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mark Davis should be the interim head coach of the Raiders

Mark Davis should be the coach. Give us Mark Davis as the coach of the Raiders today. Why not? [Al Davis] did it. His dad did it. He would be awesome.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The Raiders named Rich Bisaccia as the interim head coach, not Mark Davis.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

All NFL kickers are synced up in their misses

We had another missed kick. They're all synced up. It was perfect that Rodrigo Blankenship just ended... He did that on purpose for every kicker because then they brought up how many missed kicks were made. And you're like, I don't even remember half of these missed kicks.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
Kicking performance varies wildly by individual conditions; there is no scientific basis for kickers 'syncing' their misses.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would bet against the Raiders if Deuce Gruden left the staff

Can you really, I don't know, your dad leaves? [Big Cat]: No, I think you've got to stick around. Deuce is probably the one. For the guy's nutrition... Imagine the gains that get lost if Deuce leaves. [PFT Commenter]: Yeah, that'd be bad. He's got to stick around. I would definitely bet against the Raiders if Deuce left at this point.

Deuce Gruden stayed on the staff through the 2021 season, so the condition for the bet was never met.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Chiefs should trade Patrick Mahomes

A lot of people around the league, league circles, are saying the story out of Kansas City is that the Chiefs should trade Patrick Mahomes. They're saying that a lot of willing partners out there... Washington football team would be one, probably. But if I'm a Chiefs fan, man, I'll tell you, I'd run that guy out of town on a rail.

Mahomes was obviously not traded and remains the face of the franchise.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams will be the best quarterback in all of college football

Caleb Williams is like Oklahoma is so unfair that they have a backup who is better than their starter who's now going to be like the best quarterback in all of college football. And they're like, oh, yeah, let's just put this guy in.

Caleb Williams went on to win the Heisman Trophy in 2022 and was the #1 overall pick in the NFL draft, justifying this high praise.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tyler Linderbaum is a first-round pick and the most compelling center to watch in football

Iowa is the first football team that I've ever watched where I can't take my eyes off the center. Tyler Linderbaum. I'm giving you that name right now... This dude, he's going to be first round pick. I would take him as high as it gets. I'm in love with watching... this dude just murders people. He destroys people.

Linderbaum was selected in the first round (25th overall) of the 2022 NFL Draft by the Baltimore Ravens.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Cincinnati will only make the CFP if no one-loss Power 5 team exists

The details are... it has to be Cincinnati will get into the college football playoff over a one-loss Power 5 team. So one loss. It can't be two losses... I just know how the college football playoff works and the bias that happens.

Cincinnati actually made the CFP as an undefeated team, but they didn't have to go 'over' a one-loss Power 5 team in a way that controversial; they were clearly better than the alternatives that year.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2021 Oklahoma Sooners are the 'best frauds of all time'

I actually think that Oklahoma, I think that they're frauds, but they might be the best frauds of all time. They might just continue to win these games that they should lose.

Oklahoma finished 11-2 and missed the CFP, eventually losing to Oklahoma State and Baylor, proving they were indeed flawed despite the high ranking.
Push
HankHank

Ben Simmons will face an all-time 'boo-fest' upon his return to Philadelphia

Ben Simmons has arrived in Philadelphia, took a COVID-19 test as required by NBA protocol... I love going to a good boo-fest. Going to the Sixers' first game, I might have to figure out, talk to Tick Pick and get out there. So perfect that it's Philly... Philly's going to roast him.

Simmons never actually played another game for the Sixers before being traded to the Nets, though he was heavily booed upon his return with Brooklyn later.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The PMT flags are S-tier man cave/tailgate decor

These Pardon My Take flags... those are real nice. We've got a bunch of different colors so you know, tailgate, man cave... [Hank]: Put it on your car. Hang it in your front yard... [PFT]: You drape the flag over. Especially if you have like, let everyone know. If you got a cabin or a beach house.

Purely subjective assessment of merchandise quality.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You cannot be a diehard fan of two rival teams from the same city

I agree with this premise, by the way. If you are a diehard fan of one team from your hometown, you can't be a diehard fan of the equal and opposite team from that hometown... if you're John Cusack and you grew up in Chicago... he's a guy that should only be able to pick one of those two teams.

This is a subjective matter of sports etiquette.
Void
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Defensive football is about hustle and hitting, not X's and O's

Defensive football, Big Cat, is not necessarily about X's and O's. Playing defense is about hustle, it's about effort, and it's about hitting people. As long as 11 people are doing that, we can stop people. It really doesn't matter from a scheme standpoint having a great scheme.

This is a philosophical coaching debate, though modern analytics-heavy defense would argue scheme is increasingly vital.
Void
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Justin Herbert is currently the best-playing quarterback in the NFL

Who is the quarterback you think is playing the best right this second? [Booger]: Justin Herbert. I don't think it's close. We paid so much attention to his personality that we overlooked his talent. And the Miami Dolphins did so much that they took Tua in front of him. How about them apples?

Subjective, but Herbert finished the 2021 season with over 5,000 yards and was a Pro Bowler.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Trey Lance is not ready to start in the NFL

Trey Lance is not ready. And what I mean by not ready... you got to make really good decisions. You got to take care of the football and you have to give your, you have to give your team or put your team in the best position to win... the game is moving too fast for him.

Lance struggled to secure the starting job over Jimmy Garoppolo and eventually Brock Purdy, with analysts citing the same 'processing speed' issues Booger mentioned.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Urban Meyer has lost the trust of the Jaguars locker room and cannot recover it

Is there any way he can get back the trust in that locker room? [Booger]: No, I don't think so. I don't think Urban can... not only did you leave us, you went to the bar and you got a female that's not your wife and she's twerking on you... as a head coach, you just can't do that. That's the only thing I would say. You just can't do that.

Urban Meyer was fired later that season in December 2021 after a series of additional failures and scandals, confirming he lost the locker room.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Spencer Rattler will never start another game for Oklahoma barring injury

Spencer Rattler, to your point, I don't think Spencer Rattler is going to start another game at Oklahoma barring injury over the next couple of years. Caleb Williams came in and galvanized the team. So if Lincoln [Riley] stood in front of the team and said, hey, we're going back to Spencer, he would lose every player in there.

Rattler remained the backup for the rest of the season and transferred to South Carolina shortly after.
Loss
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Super Bowl will be the Buccaneers versus the Bills

Week five Super Bowl prediction. I am still, I'm going to be a homer. I am going Tampa versus Buffalo.

Super Bowl LVI featured the Rams and the Bengals. Both of Booger's teams were eliminated in the Divisional Round.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Signing Blake Bortles will change the entire culture of the Seahawks

Following Russell Wilson's injury, the Seahawks are working out the boat. Blake Bortles. Yes, yes, Blake. Oh, my God. I love it... You bring him in to change the whole culture. You bring him in with a contract already signed.

Bortles was signed to the practice squad but never played for the Seahawks and did not change their culture.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers