Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17958
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I predict the Bengals will eventually be back

I don't know if they're back yet, but I predict that they will be back... September's a bad month and then they get hot. And I think that's what's gonna happen again.

The Bengals struggled with defense and injuries all season and missed the playoffs, never truly 'returning' to elite status.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17959
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Surtain II is one of the best, if not the best cornerback in the league

Patrick Surtain, who we did put respect on last week, is like one of the best cornerbacks, if not the best cornerback in the league.

Surtain II is widely regarded as an All-Pro and top-3 cornerback in the NFL.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17960
MaxMax

There is a chance Nick Sirianni doesn't make it through the bye week

I think there's a chance that Sirianni doesn't make it, make it through the bye... there's a problem between coach and quarterback.

Sirianni made it through the bye week and remained the head coach throughout the season.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17961
MaxMax

Jalen Hurts is addicted to turning the ball over

And Jalen Hurts is addicted to turning the ball over.

Hurts continued to struggle with turnovers in 2024, leading the league in giveaways for several stretches.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17962
Big CatBig Cat

Nico Collins is a top three wide receiver

Is Nico Collins a top three wide receiver? 'Cause it feels like he is. He's awesome. He's so good.

Collins was leading the league in receiving yards at the time and is widely considered elite, though 'top 3' is a high bar.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17963
Big CatBig Cat

Laremy Tunsil is going to break the record for flags this year

Is Laremy Tunsil going for the record for flags this year? ... I'll say right now, Laremy Tunsil, I support your aspirations to break the record for most flags in a season. I think he's going for it.

Tunsil did not break the all-time record, but he did lead the league in penalties for most of the season.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17964
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Commanders defense is even average, we could win a playoff game

If our defense is 16th in the NFL... I'm thinking a win in the playoffs. I'm thinking maybe divisional week.

The Commanders' defense improved to be roughly average, and they won two playoff games (vs. Buccaneers in Wild Card, vs. Lions in Divisional Round) before falling to the Eagles in the NFC Championship. PFT's prediction of a playoff win was correct.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17965
Big CatBig Cat

Amar'e Cooper wants out of Cleveland

Amari Cooper wants out. He does not want to be there anymore.

Amari Cooper was traded to the Buffalo Bills shortly after this episode aired.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 30, 2024
#PMT-2024-0930-17966
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs will win every game but it will always be ugly

It's also pretty clear that these Chiefs are just gonna win every game, but just it's gonna be ugly.

The Chiefs started 9-0 with almost all wins being close, ugly games.
Void
#PMT-2024-0930-17967
Big CatBig Cat

Tattoos are not a quarterback's look

I have a theory on Carson Beck. I think the, I think the tattoos are too much for a quarterback. That's just not a quarterback's look.

This is entirely a matter of aesthetic opinion.
Loss
#PMT-2024-0930-17968
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Karl-Anthony Towns is a terrible fit for the Knicks

Was your initial reaction like mine, which was basically that KAT could not be a worst fit for this team?

Karl-Anthony Towns proved to be a great fit for the Knicks. New York advanced to the Eastern Conference Finals in the 2025 playoffs, beating the Celtics in the second round. Towns was a key contributor to their success.
Loss
#PMT-2024-0930-17969
Big CatBig Cat

New York is going to eat Karl-Anthony Towns alive

I think Knicks fans are going, I mean they were really mean to Julius Randall and if KA... I just don't think [New York] is going to eat him alive.

Karl-Anthony Towns thrived in New York. The Knicks beat the Celtics in the second round and reached the Eastern Conference Finals. Towns was a key player in their playoff run, proving he was 'built like that' for New York.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2760
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Al Michaels is at his best when he is visibly annoyed by the quality of football

When Al Michaels is at his best now is when he's annoyed with the quality of football. And he was so annoyed. He gets into surly old man mode very early on in the first half. He was just like, well this is awful. This is terrible, Kirk, get me outta here.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2763
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am 100% in on the Vikings; their success is not a fluke

I am, I think I'm a hundred percent in on the Vikings. I think I'm in on 'em. I don't think what they're doing is a fluke. I think that their defense is really confusing. And I think that Sam Darnold, I don't know if Sam Darnold's like a, a great starting quarterback at large in the NFL, but in this offense with this head coach, I think he's really, really good.

The Vikings continued to have a strong season and made the playoffs with Darnold playing well, proving it wasn't a fluke through Week 4.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2765
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings at Packers game is an absolute sell-high spot for Sam Darnold

I somewhat agree with like, it's not fluky in the fact that I think they're a good team. I just think this is like their absolute sell high spot. It's like everyone's, like the Vikings are for real. I am feeling like this is a spot where Sam Darnold's gonna lay an egg and everyone's gonna get off the scent.

The Vikings actually beat the Packers 31-29 in Week 4 and Darnold threw for 3 TDs, so it wasn't a sell-high clunker.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2767
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams is already 'out' after throwing for 363 yards

I mean he threw for 363 yards last week. I think he's gonna, I think he's already out. You think he's out? Yeah, he's out. [PFT: if he goes dummy this game, I think he's out already] then I think that's the coming out party. He's already out. I don't need Nerd Stats to know. He's already out. He's been out.

Williams had a strong rookie season showing franchise potential, though it was a rocky start.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2769
MaxMax

Bryce Huff sucks and I am already done with him

Is this a get right game for Bryce Huff? Nah, he sucks. I'm done with him. I hate Bryce Huff. He sucks.

Huff struggled significantly early in the season and was benched from his starting role, partially validating Max's frustration.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2771
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are winning because the line making no sense means Vegas knows something

Honestly, it makes no sense that they're two point favorites in this game. I like the Eagles. I think we talked our way through it. I like the Eagles specifically because Vegas knows something. It makes no sense. The only sense I can think of is the way the Bucs have won... I think we take the Eagles as a team.

The Eagles lost to the Buccaneers 33-16 in Week 4. The fishy line theory failed.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2773
HankHank

Shut Drake Maye down for the entire season to protect him

I hope not [seeing Drake Maye play]. Even in the one drive that he played, he got crushed. When we have an offensive line that can block for him. So not until next year and maybe the year after. Not shut him down, but I, I would not get like, I, I get more scared than excited if he goes in.

Drake Maye actually started later in the season (starting in Week 6) and played well, proving he was ready despite the line.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2775
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

I heard a rumor that Christian McCaffrey might retire

Did you hear Ryan Whitney say that he heard a rumor that he's might retire? [Whitney: Really? That seems crazy. Whitney also... admitted in the interview that they just fuck around a lot with rumors. Yeah, it's a crazy rumor. Definitely not true.]

McCaffrey returned to play later in the 2024 season and did not retire.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2776
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes is having the most 'fuck you' career by playing average regular season football and winning Super Bowls

Patrick Mahomes has not been very good. I have a fun stat for you. In the last eight regular season games, Patrick Mahomes is 11 touchdowns, nine interception... Which made me believe that there's a chance, Patrick Mahomes might just have the most fuck you career of all time to everyone who watches football and win like 10 Super Bowls and just play average football every regular season.

Mahomes stats remained lower than his career averages throughout the 2024 regular season while the Chiefs continued to win.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2777
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Bruins lowballed Jeremy Swayman with a four-year, $6.2 million offer

I find out that the offer is four years times 6.2 crazy low ball. And that they, that they haven't talked in like three weeks. It's August camps in 10 days... I had the contract offer. Right. He [Don Sweeney] didn't argue that. So whether it was two weeks, three weeks, or 10 days, right. There's been enough silence in August with your star goalie that it's seriously alarming.

Swayman eventually signed an 8-year, $8.25M AAV contract, confirming the previous offers were significantly lower as reported.
Open
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2778
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Conor McDavid will win at least one Stanley Cup in the next four years

No doubt in my mind [McDavid can win the big one]. I'm very confident that this is the year... Life or death four years, like a four year span, gun your head. I would say they, yeah, I would say they would win one cup. That would be my guess. Life or death.

Pending the results of the 2025-2028 NHL seasons.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 27, 2024
#PMT-2024-0927-2779
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Shohei Ohtani is a better global superstar and better at his sport than anyone ever

Do you remember when I came on the show and you guys relentlessly tortured me for saying McDavid was better at his sport than anyone else in the world. I've now switched it to Ohtani. And I'm like obsessed with watching this guy play baseball. And it might be Travis Hunter. No, Tani... nobody's done consistently offense and defense in the NFL... it's not, it's insane watching this guy.

Subjective claim about GOAT status, but Ohtani is widely considered to be performing unprecedented feats.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4618
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels' Monday night performance was the best game I've ever seen a quarterback play for the Commanders

What I saw last night made me feel emotions that I have not felt in my cold dead football heart in decades... what really got me excited about Jayden was how he handled like third downs, fourth downs. He was cool. He was directing guys around. He was calm in the pocket... I think that's the best game I've ever seen a quarterback play for my team.

Daniels finished with a 91.3% completion rate, the highest for a rookie in NFL history, supporting the claim that it was a historic performance.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4619
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals are in deep trouble after starting 0-3 with a defense that can't be fixed

I do think the Bengals are in trouble... only six of the 225 teams that started 0 and 3 in the Super Bowl era have made the playoffs... I don't know where the fixes are on defense. The only fix I have for the Bengals is Joe Burrow has to change his hair color. You can't be 0 and 3 with those frosted tips.

The Bengals did not make the playoffs in 2024.
Open
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4620
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels will win a Super Bowl in the next five years

I did fire off a tweet at like 3:00 AM as I was, I got back from the casino... and I said that I think [Jayden Daniels] is gonna win a Super Bowl in the next five years. Whoa. And I think he is. Maybe even two.

The outcome is pending as the 5-year window spans through 2029.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4621
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is the second-best quarterback in the NFL

Josh Allen is what a franchise quarterback looks like. And we've said it a million times. Just because he's not Patrick Mahomes doesn't mean he's [not] the second—he is the second best quarterback in the NFL.

Subjective ranking of quarterbacks.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4622
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bills losing Stefon Diggs was addition by subtraction

It probably is addition by subtraction, losing Diggs. Oh, definitely. And Gabe Davis... it feels like this. Josh [Allen] is like star. He's turned a brand new page clean slate for this team. So he doesn't have any of that excess baggage that he used to have.

The Bills' offense remained highly efficient in 2024 without Diggs, often performing better than with him the previous year.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4623
Big CatBig Cat

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman winner because he is the best football player in the country

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman. And maybe it's because I bet on him pre-season, but Travis Hunter should be the Heisman... if you actually voted for Heisman how it should be voted—best player, not how every award now gets voted on... Travis Hunter should be your Heisman Trophy winner because he is the best football player in college football.

Travis Hunter won the 2024 Heisman Trophy, as Big Cat predicted. Hunter won as a two-way player for Colorado.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4624
Michael SilverMichael Silver

Mike Shanahan essentially acts as a 'shadow GM' for the 49ers by watching all film and meetings

I did spend a bunch of time with [Mike Shanahan] in May and June of 2022... there is something at 49ers headquarters referred to as the 'Shana-Cam', which basically means Mike Shanahan needs to watch meetings and practice ASAP virtually. So he's, some people think he's the shadow GM. I think that's an exaggeration. But he's... he's still got it.

It's a well-documented claim within the NFL reporting community that Mike Shanahan remains a consultant and heavy influence on the 49ers.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 25, 2024
#PMT-2024-0925-4625
Michael SilverMichael Silver

The Chicago Bears are the most under-marketed entity in American commerce

I don't believe that there is a more under-marketed entity in American commerce than the Chicago Bears... in this city... it's a football town... and with the Bears, you know, in '85 and like that was, it was just, it engulfed everything. And they've been living off it since.

Subjective business/marketing opinion.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13767
Big CatBig Cat

The start of the 2024 season proves that coaching matters more than anything else in the NFL

The big picture for me before we get into all the games is Sam Darnold's three and oh, Geno Smith's three and oh... this start of the 2024 season has just been a red blinking light of coaching matters a lot.

The season-long success of Sam Darnold and Jared Goff, contrasted with the struggles of highly-drafted QBs in poor systems, generally supported this theme throughout 2024.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13768
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kevin O'Connell is one of the best coaches in the NFL

Minnesota might have one of the best coaches in the league. Yes. And I would also put McVay's performance this week right up there too.

O'Connell led the Vikings to a surprisingly successful season and is widely regarded as a top-tier offensive mind.
Push
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13769
Big CatBig Cat

I'm not worried about Caleb Williams; I'm worried about the Bears' coaching staff ruining him

Nothing has changed about my opinion about Caleb Williams other than the fact maybe everyone was right that Matt Eberflus is a fucking moron... Caleb Williams is not my worry at all. I know people were going to say he is a bust and all that shit. He's not my worry. I swear to God, I'm not worried at all. I'm worried about the coaching staff just like ruining him in a way that makes me worried.

The Bears eventually fired Shane Waldron mid-season, validating Big Cat's concern about the coaching, though Caleb Williams' overall performance remained a subject of debate.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13770
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Malik Nabors is the frontrunner for Offensive Rookie of the Year

Malik Nabors is really, really, he's awesome. He's right now Rookie of the Year.

Jayden Daniels ultimately won Offensive Rookie of the Year, though Nabors remained one of the top candidates.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13771
Big CatBig Cat

Deshaun Watson has the worst contract in NFL history

Deshaun Watson will go down as the worst contract ever.

Watson's poor play and injury history, combined with the $230M guarantee, make this a consensus opinion among analysts.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13772
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers cannot bench Justin Fields for Russell Wilson as long as they are winning

It feels like he's [Fields] kind of rounding into form to being a winning quarterback... I personaly would not [bench him]... you cannot bench a three and oh quarterback... You gotta wait until something bad happens and like he has a bad game and then maybe make a switch.

Mike Tomlin eventually did bench a winning Justin Fields for Russell Wilson in Week 7, and the team improved, proving Big Cat's 'you cannot' rule wrong in this specific instance.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13773
Big CatBig Cat

Matt LaFleur is the current NFL Coach of the Year through three weeks

Matt LaFleur is the coach of the year through three weeks. It's insane... two wins without Jordan Love.

LaFleur remained a top candidate for COY throughout the season, leading the Packers to the playoffs with a young roster.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13774
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers should trade Bryce Young immediately while he still has some value

You've got to trade Bryce Young right this second because what could happen is David Tepper could be like, Hey, maybe this team isn't so bad, Bryce Young, get back in there. Don't do that. Play with Andy Dalton. Trade Bryce Young for anything you can right now.

The Panthers did not trade him in-season, though his long-term future with the team remained uncertain. He eventually returned to start later in the season.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13776
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a Hall of Famer

Matthew Stafford, Hall of Famer. Matthew Stafford has 99 total wins in his career... almost half of Matthew Stafford's wins have needed Matthew Stafford to have a game winning drive. He's an absolute baller when it comes down to late game situations.

This remains a subjective debate, but Stafford's career stats and Super Bowl ring make it a very strong case.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13784
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially buying into the Seahawks as a legitimate team

I am getting very close to buying in on the Seahawks... Mike Macdonald seems to be a very good head coach in three games. I am dangerously close to believing in the Seahawks.

The Seahawks remained competitive but ultimately fell back in the NFC West, finishing with a mediocre record.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13779
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson is 21-1 in his career against the NFC

Lamar Jackson now 21 and one against the NFC. He kills them. He kills the NFC.

As of September 2024, Lamar Jackson's record against the NFC was indeed 21-1.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024
#PMT-2024-0923-13782
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Tucker is officially washed

We also had a passing of the torch in this game. We've talked about it, but Justin Tucker missing a 46 yarder and Brandon Aubrey making a 65 yarder. I think it's official washed.

Tucker had a statistically poor 2024 season compared to his career norms, finishing with his lowest career field goal percentage.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 23, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0923-13786
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

One of the underdogs will win outright in the Monday Night Football doubleheader

Just pick one of the other, one of the underdogs is gonna win out. Right. That's guaranteed.

The Commanders (underdogs) defeated the Bengals outright 38-33.
Win
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024
#PMT-2024-0920-5367
HankHank

The Patriots' offensive line is currently worse than the Bears'

[The Patriots] looked horrible. Their offensive line like looked worse than the Bears. [Jacoby Brissett] never had more than one second to throw. They missed a ton of tackles on defense.

While both units were bottom-tier, the Patriots' line was statistically among the worst in terms of pressure rate allowed throughout the 2024 season.
Void
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024·Null
#PMT-2024-0920-5368
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player of all time

I'd say that this, he is the best baseball player of all time. Whether or not he'll have the best career of all time is kind of up for grabs. But we've never seen anybody that's doing what he's doing.

This is inherently subjective, though Ohtani's 2024 season and dual-threat history make him a consensus top-tier candidate for the 'best ever' title.
Push
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024
#PMT-2024-0920-5369
Big CatBig Cat

NFL offenses are struggling because they are taking the bait on two-high safety looks

Everyone's blaming the two high safeties. And I actually read an article... essentially deep passes still work, but offenses are taking the bait with the two high safeties and just they're running the ball into light boxes and it's just not, it's not as effective... stop taking the bait.

The 'two-high' shell was a dominant talking point in 2024. Offensive production did eventually tick up as teams adapted, though passing yards remained historically low for much of the year.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024·Picks
#PMT-2024-0920-5372
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will beat the Colts because Caleb Williams will have a breakout game

I think this is the week [against the Colts]. I think the Bears are gonna run it down their throats... I think this is the week that the offense looks good. I think the Bears are gonna win... Caleb Williams is gonna go off against the Colts.

The Bears lost to the Colts 21-16. While Williams threw for 363 yards, the offense still struggled with turnovers and efficiency.
Loss
Take Slip·Sep 20, 2024
#PMT-2024-0920-5370
MaxMax

The Eagles' coaching staff is currently talentless

They are a player led team. It's, it's true... Just coordinators. No head coach. [The coaches] are not talented right now... talent's not something you can just, like, it doesn't go up and down. No. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's not a hot and cold thing.

Hot TakeFootballFireSarcastic
The Eagles struggled with identity but remained a playoff contender, making the claim that they have 'no talent' on the coaching staff hyperbolic.