Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Fans don't belong on the court ever and players don't belong in the stands ever

my perspective is fans don't belong on the court ever. And players don't belong in the stands ever. That's, I don't think that's a controversial thing.

Several million college students across America disagreed.
Open
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Someone will eventually get seriously injured during a court storming

It's dangerous, man. Yeah. and it is. It's dangerous now. And we've had significant injuries over the years... Something bad's gonna happen. And when it does, we're gonna have the audacity to be surprised at it.

While several minor injuries occurred (like Kyle Filipowski's sprain mentioned in the episode), a 'catastrophic' event hasn't yet ended the practice nationally.
Push
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Big Cat doesn't know what 'disingenuous' means

Ingenuous means lying.

Big Cat looked it up. The actual definition is 'slightly dishonest and insincere.' Bilas was close but not precise, which is ironic given that he was correcting someone else's word choice.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

I've never been a fan

I've never been a fan.

He has worked as a college basketball analyst for ESPN for over two decades.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

I'll come sprain Big Cat's knee and then he can tell me court storming is fine

Now he got hurt and it maybe the injury wasn't enough for you. So No, I'll come and I'll come and sprain your knee and then you claim that I'm fine.

An ESPN legal analyst offered to physically assault a podcast host to prove a point about player safety.
Push
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Illinois and USF are teams trending toward a strong March run

I think Illinois is starting to trend in that direction... they're starting to look like they could do some real damage there. South Florida's another team that's trending a little bit like Florida Atlantic did last year.

Illinois made it to the Elite Eight (a very strong run). USF won the American regular season but failed to make the NCAA tournament, losing in the NIT second round.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

NIL should have no rules and operate like normal business with multi-year contracts

There wouldn't be any rules. I would have it operate just like normal business does... the schools could just pay the athletes directly... they would sign the players to multi-year contracts... It's really not that difficult. And that way the transfer portal's not as big of an issue.

Subjective policy proposal, though the House settlement in 2024 has moved college sports closer to this revenue-sharing model.
Open
Jay BilasJay Bilas

If court storming ended tomorrow, ratings and engagement would be exactly the same

I think if it ended tomorrow, we would see the same passion and the same ratings and the same level of engagement that we always see.

Court storming has not been banned. The NCAA implemented a $100,000 fine in 2024 and it continued to happen anyway.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Would have tasered the dog that ran on a basketball court in Chile

I would've tasered the dog. And then euthanized the owner.

Bilas's proposed enforcement framework escalated from citations to tasering a dog to euthanizing a human being within the span of one interview.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Would have 'clubbed that dog like a baby seal' to stop court storming

I would've clubbed that dog like a baby seal that all would've stopped.

The man who opened the interview by lecturing about nuance closed it by proposing baby seal clubbing as a deterrent for dogs on basketball courts.
Win
Jay BilasJay Bilas

Josh Schertz at Indiana State is a top 3 schematic coach in the country

Josh Schertz at Indiana State would be number one... It's like watching a European Pro team that's been together for a long time. It's just magnificent.

Schertz's success at Indiana State led to him being hired by Saint Louis in 2024, validating Bilas's assessment of his coaching talent.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

I don't need an agreement to disagree — why can't we just disagree?

I've never understood what that means. Why can't we just disagree? I don't need an agreement to disagree.

Bilas took issue with a common English phrase on the grounds that he had not signed any paperwork.
Void
Jay BilasJay Bilas

I knew what 'disingenuous' meant in high school

No, I think what it meant is not only did you not know what disingenuous means, I did. But you did. You had to look it up. No, and that's not, didn't I actually knew what that meant when I was in high school.

A Duke-educated attorney bragged about knowing the word 'disingenuous' since high school to a man whose job is making people laugh.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

There should be a 'free fight' rule allowing players to defend themselves against court-storming fans

I think like if there should be a rule that if you're a player and a fan comes at you, you can just go hog wild on 'em. Free the free fight rule that I've had for a very long time. Let the players have a free fight.

This is a subjective rule proposal that has not been adopted by any governing body.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Filipowski was not seriously injured during the Wake Forest court storming

I just, I think he's probably fine. I think it might've been a phantom roll of an ankle. Like, oh shit, we lost and I just shoved the guy possibly—ow my ankle hurts now my arm.

Filipowski played in Duke's next game against Louisville only three days later, scoring 9 points, and didn't miss any subsequent time, supporting the claim that it wasn't a severe injury.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Rick Pitino is good for the sport of college basketball

You have to like Rick Pitino, he's good for college basketball. Show, I mean, win. Yes. I respect Rick when he's wearing the white suit. This guy doesn't understand that. We like Rick Pitino.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about the entertainment value of a coach.
Loss
MaxMax

Villanova will make the NCAA Tournament

They're gonna be in. They started the day yesterday at first four out. They finished the day at first four out... If you [beat] Georgetown and then win two of the next three we're in.

Villanova missed the 2024 NCAA Tournament and played in the NIT instead.
Void
HankHank

Julian Edelman is the 4th greatest New England Patriot of all time

In the number four spot... Friend of the program. It's Jules, it's Gronk. Great guy. Jules. Gritty receiver, basically. Fought through seven concussions against the Seahawks. Made a miraculous catch against the Falcons. Super Bowl MVP against the Rams. Wow. Julian Edelman.

Rankings are subjective, but placing Edelman #4 all-time for a franchise with many Hall of Famers is a controversial take among analysts.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Flaco the Owl was likely murdered and didn't just die from a building collision

It says he didn't break any bones, but he sustained massive hemorrhaging inside his body. This seems like somebody else had a hand in it. We need to check the flight logs. Was Flaco on the list? This Owl probably had information that would've led to the arrest and subsequent conviction of Hillary Clinton.

The autopsy confirmed the death was due to acute traumatic injury from hitting a building, compounded by pigeon herpes and rat poison in his system. The Hillary Clinton link is a joke.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 'pregnant' stingray Charlotte isn't actually pregnant and is just fat

Charlotte, the pregnant Stingray has still not given birth, which makes me think this might be a publicity stunt... if a shark had relations with a female Stingray who is pregnant even though she hasn't seen a male stingray in eight years... we need a conclusion to this. Otherwise she's just fat.

The aquarium eventually announced that Charlotte was not pregnant but actually suffered from a rare reproductive disease, confirming Big Cat's skepticism.
Void
Payton PritchardPayton Pritchard

It is significantly harder to score in college basketball than in the NBA

I think it's way harder scoring college than it is in the NBA... you have this no three-second in the key [rule in college]. So you got a big that's just sitting there. You also have like two or three people in college you can help off of.

This is a subjective experience from a player who excelled at both levels.
Win
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

The Boston Celtics are heavy favorites to win the 2024 NBA championship

I think yeah, they're my favorites... I don't wanna put bad juju on 'em, but Yeah, they're heavy favorites in my mind.

The Boston Celtics defeated the Dallas Mavericks in the 2024 NBA Finals to win the championship.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

JJ Redick is playing a character on 'First Take' to lean into his Duke heel persona

I do think he is doing a little bit of a bit when he goes on first take, it's the heel in him. If you watch it under the idea that JJ is being like the Duke smart ass, I know more Ball than you, it's great TV.

Subjective analysis of a media personality's performance style.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Big Dom's suspension is the definitive reason why the Eagles' season fell apart

The report is essentially that Big Dom was a lot more than just a security guard. He was essentially Nick Sirianni's emotional support animal. And when he got suspended from the sideline, Nick Sirianni spiraled outta control was fighting with players. And Big Dom is the reason why their season fell apart. And I 100% believe it.

While the Eagles did collapse after the Big Dom incident (starting in Week 13 against the 49ers), attributing it solely to a security guard is largely a comedic narrative.
Loss
MaxMax

Big Dom is the most important person in the Philadelphia Eagles organization

Big Dom is the most important person in the Philadelphia Eagles organization. I think we can all agree on that. He's a leader of men. Big Dom is a leader of men.

Hyperbolic claim; obviously players and coaches are more vital, but the impact was notable.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

MLB's transparent pants are a clever way for the league to stay relevant

This was smart by the MLB. 'Cause we're talking about him. Way to stay relevant baseball. Just make some shitty uniforms that have everyone's balls showing.

The controversy did generate massive engagement, though unlikely to be the intended goal.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Eberflus's new beard makes him look like a winning football coach

Matt Eberflus debuted a new beard. He looks totally different. That's good. He looks like a winning football coach now. Tell me that's not a fucking football coach. Now he's gonna win some games.

The Bears did improve in the 2024 season, though unrelated to facial hair.
Void
HankHank

Ty Law is the fifth-best Patriot of the dynasty era

My number five Patriot of all time... Swaggiest Patriot maybe on this whole list. Ty Law. That's number five.

Purely a subjective ranking of team legends.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

Every team in college basketball currently sucks on the road

I think I wanna kind of say everyone sucks, but that's not a good way to get people into the sport. Everyone sucks on the road. That's the thing... Home court will lie to you.

Statistically, the 2023-24 season saw an unusually high number of top-ranked teams losing on the road to unranked opponents.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

John Calipari is on the hot seat because the 'meme' has become the reality

At some point the meme becomes the reality. I don't think they're gonna fire him. He has a lifetime contract... but Kentucky fans are absolutely ready for a change though. Absolutely. If he fucks this up, he's completely lost the magic.

Shortly after the season ended in another first-round loss (to Oakland), Calipari left Kentucky to take the Arkansas job, effectively resolving the hot seat situation.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

This Purdue team is legitimately better and more versatile than last year's squad

I think this Purdue team's better than last year. The guard play has first of all their guards are older. Braden Smith last year was like a game manager more and now he's actually a stud. And then Lance Jones, the kid they got in the transfer portal is fucking awesome. I do think that Purdue is going to make a final four.

Purdue successfully made the Final Four and reached the National Championship game in 2024.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

The Mountain West has replaced the Atlantic 10 as the 'hipster' basketball league

The Mountain West has kind of become that... It is has become the league that's like if you don't know what game to watch, just throw on a random ass mountain West game. It's what the A-10 used to be.

The Mountain West received six bids in the 2024 tournament, reflecting its increased stature.
Loss
Mark TitusMark Titus

My 2024 Final Four is Purdue, Houston, Arizona, and Tennessee

I think Purdue is gonna make the final four. I have to trust Houston. Gimme Arizona... and then I gotta ride with Tennessee. Tennessee, I'll take out Houston and put in Butler. No, I'll take Tennessee.

Only Purdue made the Final Four. Houston and Tennessee made the Sweet 16/Elite 8, while Arizona lost in the Sweet 16.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Hurley is the only coach in college basketball I trust to win a title right now

Who do we trust that's gonna win a national championship this year? Dan Hurley. 'Cause I saw it last year. That's it. That's literally it. These other guys haven't proven they can win.

UConn went on to win the 2024 National Championship.
Loss
HankHank

I will be able to dunk a basketball and hit twenty three-pointers within the next ten months

I'm going hard to dunk... summer, that's exactly my plan. I'm already over leveraged. What if I do both and hit 20 threes? I just have to basically change my entire lifestyle way of thinking and everything.

Hank famously failed to dunk despite months of 'training'.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adam Silver is the number one cuck commissioner in sports

Adam Silver though. He kind of, is he the number one cuck commissioner now? He doesn't do shit. I mean, Roger Goodell, he does get bullied, but he gets bullied by the owners.

Subjective label based on perception of league leadership and player power.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA All-Star game should be changed to a 'White vs. Black' format

What about the Rashard Mendenhall rules? What if we make the All-Star game white versus black. So who's the white starting five? Luca [Dončić], Jokic, Caruso, Kristaps [Porzingis] and Grayson Allen. I'd put that five up against [everyone else].

This will almost certainly never happen in the modern NBA.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

To fix the All-Star game, the losing team should pay the winning team $10,000 per point scored

Losing team has to pay winning team $10,000 per point. Because now you play defense. You play defense. And it doesn't matter if you're losing, you still try. Damian Lillard would've gotten $500,000 [from them].

Financial penalties like this for All-Stars haven't been enacted.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Doc Rivers is an unlikable snake who stabbed Adrian Griffin in the back

Doc Rivers is really unlikable. He had the balls to, after taking someone's job and saying he was working for the Bucks as an analyst... You can't complain about a job that you stabbed somebody in the back for.

Subjective opinion on likability and professional ethics.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The day you stop liking tits is the day you die

Sydney Sweeney's boobs... Which I was getting shamed for like, come on guys. The day you stop liking tits, kill me. I think and I die. I'm a red-blooded American male.

Subjective life philosophy.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Notre Dame will never get higher than a 5-seed in the 12-team CFP

If Notre Dame is the best team in the country, they get the number five seed. [Because] the four highest ranked conference champions will be seeds one through four.

The rule for the 12-team CFP specifically grants the top 4 seeds to conference champions. As an independent, Notre Dame cannot be a top 4 seed.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Fields is probably going to get traded by the Bears

Justin Fields did unfollow the Bears. I don't think it's, I think he's probably gonna get traded. So that's what's, like I said, I mean it could mean literally anything.

Justin Fields was indeed traded to the Pittsburgh Steelers on March 16, 2024.
Win
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

Florida and the Rangers are the favorites to win the Stanley Cup in the East

I'm gonna do Florida. I think that especially what they did last year... hard team to play against. And the Rangers coming out of the East. Goal tending has been... I think Shesterkin could be a little better, but it's one of those things when you get into playoffs.

The Florida Panthers won the 2024 Stanley Cup. The New York Rangers won the President's Trophy and reached the Eastern Conference Finals.
Win
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

Canada will not win a Stanley Cup anytime soon

Also Vancouver too, Vancouver what they've done this year, but I don't think Canada's gonna win a Stanley Cup anytime soon.

The Edmonton Oilers (a Canadian team) reached the Stanley Cup Final in 2024 but lost to Florida, extending the drought. Yandle's prediction held for the 2024 season.
Win
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

The Maple Leafs won't win a Cup because their fans are mean to them

I think it would strictly be because their fan base is too hard on them... They have one bad period or one bad game, they're sell the farm, get rid of everyone. I think their fans just need to be a little bit nicer than the players.

The Maple Leafs lost in the first round of the 2024 playoffs, continuing their struggle.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dunk Contest is unfixable because we have already seen every possible dunk

There's really no way to fix the Dunk Contest. I think they've jumped over the biggest human they can find... maybe it's just that we've seen every cool Dunk and there's only so many cool dunks that you can do.

The 2024 dunk contest was widely panned as one of the worst ever, supporting the idea that it is stale.
Void
HankHank

Mac McClung should be ineligible for the NBA Dunk Contest because he is in the G-League

Mac McClung should be ineligible because he is not in the [NBA]... That is the NBA dunk contest, not the G League dunk contest. If you're going to do that, just bring people off the street.

This is a subjective eligibility debate, though the NBA continues to allow G-Leaguers to participate to save the contest.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A G-League player who wins the NBA Dunk Contest should receive a two-week NBA contract

If you win the Dunk contest and you're on a G League team, you should get like a two week contract.

Mac McClung won in 2024 and did not receive an immediate NBA call-up following the event.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James would choose a retirement tour over winning a fifth NBA title if he were being honest

If you had true serum with LeBron right now... I think he might take the Retirement Tour [over a fifth title]. The fact that he's pretending that he like will be reluctant in any way on this Retirement Tour is the most ridiculous comment I've ever heard.

This is a psychological evaluation of LeBron that can't be factually proven.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially a Caitlin Clark superfan because she agitates people and creates constant debate

I think I'm gonna become a Caitlin Clark super fan because she makes people so, so angry. And I love it... I'm all for anyone who just agitates the world like she does... I'm in on Caitlin Clark all the way.

Big Cat consistently supported and discussed Clark through the end of the season and into the WNBA draft.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers