Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Ricky WilliamsRicky Williams

Big Cat should buy Bitcoin, but PFT Commenter should stay away

Should you buy Bitcoin? I would say for Big Cat, I'd say for sure do it. For PFT, I would say not a good idea for you right now.

Bitcoin was around $8,700 on this day. It dropped to $3,200 by December 2018 (bad short term), but exploded years later. The disparity between advice for the two hosts makes it more of a horoscope bit.
Loss
HankHank

The Celtics have a 60% chance of beating LeBron James and running him out of Cleveland for the second time.

I said it when the Celtics signed Kyrie that if they can run LeBron out of Cleveland in the beginning of his career and then run it out at the end, it would be the sweetest thing in the world... I put the percentage at 60%.

The Cavaliers defeated the Celtics in 7 games to win the ECF.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Cavaliers will win the Eastern Conference Finals in six games.

I think it's going to be 4-1. Cavs in six. Gentlemen sweep in six. I think the Celtics will win one of the first two. I think they'll win game five, and then they will lose in Cleveland in game six. That is my prediction.

The series went to 7 games, so Big Cat was wrong about the duration, though right about the winner.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I will not pick against LeBron James in the Eastern Conference until he actually loses

Looming is LeBron James, who I'm happy that I'm on the right side of history on this one because there was a lot of talk that he was ripe for an upset in the East this year, and I'm firmly in the I'm not picking against LeBron in the East until he loses, until I watch him lose in the East because it seems like it will never happen.

LeBron James won the Eastern Conference in 2018, maintaining his streak of 8 consecutive Finals appearances. He left the East for the Lakers the following season, never losing a series in the East again.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Capitals don't win Game 6 in Pittsburgh, the series is over

I'm already looking at Wednesday in D.C. Game 7. I've seen this movie before. I know it's going to happen... If we don't win in Pittsburgh, we're fucked. We're fucked.

The Capitals actually won Game 6 in Pittsburgh to win the series, so the 'if' condition was met but the negative outcome didn't happen because they won.
Push
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Baker Mayfield is a great competitor and will be successful with the Browns

No, [Baker Mayfield] is going to be great. He's, you know what, he's just got this thing about him that... Baker, he's just like a competitor, man. Like, I was happy to see him go number one. If anybody can, like, move forward with the Browns [it's him].

Mayfield had some success with the Browns, including a playoff win, but was eventually traded. His career has been a rollercoaster, making 'great' a stretch, though he found a second wind in Tampa.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Harvey will regain his form and have a good season now that he's left the Mets

Matt Harvey's going to still have a good year in his career left simply because it's the Mets... If you're a team looking for a pitcher, you should probably take a flyer on Matt Harvey because it would just be so perfect Mets for Matt Harvey to regain his form.

Matt Harvey never truly regained his 'Dark Knight' form. He struggled with the Reds, Angels, Royals, and Orioles, finishing his career with a very high ERA post-Mets.
Win
HankHank

Terry Rozier is going to get a massive contract

Terry Rozier's going to get paid. [He]'s still got two more years left on his deal, I think. Can you pay everyone? No.

Terry Rozier signed a 3-year, $58 million contract with the Charlotte Hornets in 2019, which was considered a significant payday.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I think all the quarterbacks drafted in the first round have very high bust potential

Darnold, Rosen, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Baker, you could tell me in three years all out of the league, and I would be like, yeah, okay. Because it's one of those things in the NFL, you just talk yourself into these guys.

While Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold were largely busts, Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson became superstars, and Baker Mayfield has had a productive career, making the 'all out of the league' claim very wrong.
Win
Hank AzariaHank Azaria

Josh Allen has the highest ceiling of any quarterback in the 2018 draft class

I almost think [Josh] Allen might have ultimately the highest ceiling.

Josh Allen developed into a perennial MVP candidate and the clear best quarterback from his draft class.
Loss
Hank AzariaHank Azaria

Sam Darnold has the highest floor of any quarterback in the 2018 draft class

He seems like he has the highest bottom to me. If he all these guys don't work out, I think Darnold's bottom is the highest.

Darnold struggled significantly with the Jets and Panthers, failing to reach even a baseline starter level of play for several years, making him one of the bigger disappointments in the class.
Win
Randy MossRandy Moss

Justify is the most likely winner of the Kentucky Derby

I think Justify is probably the most likely winner, although he's going to be the favorite.

Justify won the 2018 Kentucky Derby and went on to win the Triple Crown.
Loss
Randy MossRandy Moss

Midnight Bisou will win the Kentucky Oaks

I think the winner of the Oaks is going to be a horse named Midnight Bisou... She comes from behind, makes this electrifying move from off the pace.

Monomoy Girl won the 2018 Kentucky Oaks; Midnight Bisou finished 3rd.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

David Fizdale will win 32 games with the Knicks

He's going to get 30 wins. I'll go 32. I'm going to say he's going to be a little bit more successful... [based] on the fact that Porzingis is going to have one and a half healthy legs.

The Knicks finished the 2018-19 season with a dismal 17-65 record.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

This feels like the year the Capitals finally get past the Penguins and win it all

Feels like this is a year. Feels good. We might be a little biased because we're all such big Caps fans here, but 2-1 [in the series] feels good.

The Capitals defeated the Penguins in 6 games and went on to win the Stanley Cup.
Loss
HankHank

The Celtics vs. 76ers series is going to a Game 7

I think this series is going to go seven. Like I said, if they can stop Ben Simmons in transition, they have a chance to win. ... They're going to figure it out, win a few games, but Celtics have home court advantage, so it's going seven.

The Celtics won the series 4-1.
Loss
HankHank

Indiana basketball is back because they signed Romeo Langford

My cool throne is Indiana basketball. So they signed Romeo Langford, the number one recruit in the nation. His minister said that Romeo is like Abraham Lincoln. So, I mean, it's going to be huge.

Indiana went 19-16 in Langford's only season and missed the NCAA tournament, meaning they were certainly not 'back'.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Big Ben will play for 3-5 more years because the Steelers drafted Mason Rudolph

Big Ben says he wants to play three to five more years. He's just saying that because they drafted Mason Rudolph. 100%. But it's so fantastic that Big Ben, the guy who was contemplating retirement last year, is now like, yeah, you know what? Pencil me in for five more years.

Roethlisberger played through the end of the 2021 season, exactly 4 seasons after this take.
Loss
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Cleveland is still a very likely scenario for LeBron James this summer

I have been probably one of the only people that still thinks Cleveland is a very likely scenario here. If anybody is telling you they know that LeBron's already decided that he's going to leave, then they may get it right, but they're guessing right now. As of now, the way I understand it is that Cleveland is very much still in play.

LeBron James signed with the Los Angeles Lakers in July 2018.
Win
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The Golden State Warriors are better than the Houston Rockets and will win the series

I still think Golden State is better. I'm not buying into any of the stuff that happened at the end of the season and how they finished. They didn't care. But I'd imagine that they would burn them, you know, the first couple games.

The Warriors defeated the Rockets in 7 games to advance to the Finals.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Paul George is going to stay with the Oklahoma City Thunder

And I actually do think Playoff P [Paul George] is going to stay.

Big Cat was correct; Paul George signed a four-year extension with the Thunder in July 2018.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Capitals will win the Stanley Cup this year

I feel pretty good. I think this is our year. Yeah. I feel pretty good. Yeah, I feel like this is all going nicely for us.

The Washington Capitals defeated the Vegas Golden Knights in 5 games to win the 2018 Stanley Cup.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will eat one bite of horse shit if the Capitals beat the Penguins

I think you should have to eat shit if they beat the Penguins. Agreed. Just one bite. I'm not saying... Just one bite. Everyone knows the rules. ... Caps beat the Penguins. We're going to Central Park, and PFT's going to eat some shit. Just one bite.

The Capitals beat the Penguins in the second round, and PFT Commenter followed through by eating horse shit in Central Park.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield will be a successful quarterback for the Cleveland Browns

I actually think this [Baker Mayfield] is going to work, and I know that's like stepping out on a very, very thin branch saying a Browns quarterback that they drafted really high might actually work, but I like Baker Mayfield. I like him a lot. I think that he is a very, very good quarterback and I like the competitiveness.

Baker Mayfield had initial success with the Browns, leading them to their first playoff win in decades, but was eventually traded after inconsistencies and injuries. He didn't become the long-term franchise savior but was better than most previous Browns QBs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals are the better team than the Penguins and will win the series

We're the better team on the ice tonight. We're the better team overall. You can count that. It's fine. It's 1-0 Caps. ... I don't give a shit if the Capitals lose the Stanley Cup... as long as we beat the Penguins. I'm going to cash that ticket.

The 2018 Capitals finally defeated the Penguins and went on to win the Stanley Cup, making PFT's bias-driven take actually correct this year.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Until the Capitals actually beat the Penguins, I will never pick them to win a playoff series

Until Washington does it, I will never pick them to beat Pittsburgh. ... Crossy's the best player in the world. I know it. But he is. And he turns it on in the playoffs. ... and I just am not picking the Capitals. I'm not doing it.

The Capitals defeated the Penguins in 6 games this very series, proving Whitney's 'never' rule wrong immediately.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Nashville Predators are winning the Stanley Cup

I'm on Nashville because I picked them to win the cup, and I have a big futures bet riding on them.

The Nashville Predators lost in the second round to the Winnipeg Jets.
Win
Ross TuckerRoss Tucker

Josh Rosen will fall further in the draft than people think

I'm going to go with Rosen to fall. Really? I think Darnold goes one. I think maybe some Barkley or a quarterback at two. I think Mayfield at three. I think [Rosen] ends up falling faster than people think.

Rosen fell to #10 (Arizona Cardinals) while other QBs like Mayfield (#1), Darnold (#3), and Allen (#7) went before him.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derrius Guice will have a better NFL career than Leonard Fournette

Two years ago, I thought [Derrius] Geis was going to be the better NFL prospect than Leonard Fournette, and Fournette had a great rookie season. I still think Geis is going to be better than him.

Guice's career was derailed by injuries and legal issues before it began, while Fournette was a productive starter for several years and won a Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Browns will draft Sam Darnold with the first pick

I think the Browns are going to take Sam Darnold. I think so, too. And I think it's going to be the biggest mistake of their life. I think it's going to haunt them for the next 12 months.

The Browns surprised many by drafting Baker Mayfield #1 overall; Darnold went #3 to the Jets.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The game on Wednesday could be LeBron James' last home game in Cleveland

Is Wednesday night LeBron's last home game in Cleveland? I just love doing the last home game in Cleveland. Watch. We're going to hopefully do it all playoffs if they win this series. But it's always the best to be like, ooh, this could be the last home game for LeBron in Cleveland.

LeBron James left the Cavaliers for the Lakers in the 2018 offseason. The Cavs actually won their first-round series against the Pacers, so Wednesday wasn't the absolute last, but the prediction of his departure was correct.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals are going to 'shit pump' the Blue Jackets and finally win the Stanley Cup

I'm super confident in the Capitals. I think they're going to shit pump the Blue Jackets tomorrow night... And then it's the Penguins. And then you're going to lose. Then this is the year, guys. This is the year.

The Capitals beat the Blue Jackets, the Penguins, and eventually won their first Stanley Cup in June 2018.
Loss
Mike MayockMike Mayock

Sam Darnold is the best quarterback in the draft and will be picked #1 by the Browns

I think of the group, I would put Darnold first, and I think Cleveland, my gut tells me Cleveland's going to take him at one.

The Cleveland Browns selected Baker Mayfield with the #1 overall pick. Sam Darnold went #3 to the Jets.
Win
Mike MayockMike Mayock

Lamar Jackson will require a team to completely change their offensive scheme to build around him

I think somebody's going to commit to him in the first round and say, philosophically and schematically, we're buying into this kid, and we're going to change everything we do and build around him.

The Ravens drafted Lamar Jackson at #32 and eventually won an MVP with a scheme built entirely around him.
Win
Mike MayockMike Mayock

Arkansas center Frank Ragnow will be a surprise first-round pick

I think a surprise first-round pick is going to be offensive center Frank Ragnow from Arkansas... Nobody's talking about him, and I think he's gone in the first round.

Frank Ragnow was selected 20th overall by the Detroit Lions.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers are going to the NBA Finals

The Sixers, though, I believe now in them going to the finals. Like, them winning with Joel Embiid playing terrible on offense, like, okay, they're a problem for people.

The 76ers lost to the Boston Celtics in the Eastern Conference Semifinals (4-1).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James and the Cavaliers will not win the Eastern Conference this year

We also have LeBron, who they're not winning the East... But when you score 40 and can barely win the game, your teammates stink and your team stinks.

The Cavaliers actually won the Eastern Conference in 2018, defeating the Celtics in 7 games.
Loss
Kevin HeffernanKevin Heffernan

The Yankees will win the World Series and Giancarlo Stanton will hit 50 home runs in 2018

Well, the Yankees are going to win this year... When [Giancarlo Stanton] hits 50 home runs this year, you guys have to change your tune, right?

The Red Sox won the World Series in 2018, and Giancarlo Stanton hit 38 home runs.
Loss
Erik StolhanskeErik Stolhanske

The Minnesota Timberwolves will win the NBA title next year

I'm going to take your coach and your player, and the Timberwolves are going to win it all next year.

Incorrect. The Timberwolves went 36-46 in the 2018-19 season and missed the playoffs entirely.
Loss
HankHank

LeBron James will probably lose to the Pacers in the first round (but maybe not)

Not only is [LeBron James] about to lose to the Pacers in the first round, which will be embarrassing for him... Probably not.

The Cavaliers beat the Pacers in 7 games.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Browns are smokescreening everyone by pretending to like Josh Allen with the #1 pick

Everyone thinks they're going to take Sam Darnold, but they're making a lot of moves for Josh Allen. And everyone says they like Josh Allen, but it's a smokescreen. And they have the first pick.

The Browns actually took Baker Mayfield, making the Allen/Darnold debate irrelevant to the first pick, though Allen was heavily linked to them.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kawhi Leonard will never play another game for the San Antonio Spurs

Kawhi's never playing another game for the San Antonio Spurs. I don't know... I really don't think so... The fact that he's not even speaking to anyone, it seems like he's not speaking to anyone on the Spurs... I don't think he's ever playing another game for the Spurs.

Kawhi Leonard was traded to the Toronto Raptors in July 2018 and indeed never played for the Spurs again.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James will not go to the Sixers if they win the title this year

The Sixers don't want to win this year... if the Sixers win this year, then there's no chance LeBron goes to Philly. LeBron James is many things now, but he's not a ring chaser.

The Sixers did not win the 2018 title (lost in 2nd round to Celtics). LeBron did not go to Philly — he signed with the Lakers. The conditional prediction's premise (Sixers winning) never occurred, but the broader point that LeBron wouldn't go to Philly was correct regardless.
Win
Marlins ManMarlins Man

Derek Jeter will not last five years as Marlins owner

I'm being told by some other people I know in baseball... We don't think Jeter lasts the five years. We think that the owners and investors have a pressure on him.

Jeter officially stepped down as CEO and shareholder of the Marlins in February 2022, just under 5 years after taking over (Sept 2017).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bucks might sweep the Celtics in the first round

Bucks are maybe even going to sweep the Celtics.

The Celtics actually beat the Bucks in 7 games.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am going to go viral singing Cardi B songs

I think I can go viral being a Cardi B remixer... I'm literally just going to sing her lyrics into a camera and just be like, check it out, y'all. I love Cardi B... My goal is in the next week to go viral singing Cardi B.

Big Cat did post several videos singing Cardi B that gained significant traction among the Barstool audience.
Win
Pat FitzgeraldPat Fitzgerald

Success for Northwestern means winning the Big Ten West

We can't control that [Rose Bowls], but we got to win the West.

Northwestern actually won the Big Ten West in 2018.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Colin Kaepernick will not get an NFL job this year

No, I don't think he's [Kaepernick] going to get a job this year.

Kaepernick never played in the NFL again after the 2016 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am nervous that Scott Frost is building a powerhouse at Nebraska

I'm very nervous about Nebraska... We're going to walk into Nebraska and Scott Frost is going to build an 11-win team. And I'm going to be very, very upset about it.

Scott Frost famously struggled at Nebraska, never winning more than 5 games in a season and finishing with a 16-31 record.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Harden is in such bad shape that he will get winded and struggle if a playoff series goes deep

James Harden's in such bad shape that if a series goes six or seven games, he's going to be winded and he's going to go like one for 20 again like he did last year.

Harden actually played well in the 2018 playoffs, leading the Rockets to Game 7 of the WCF against the Warriors, though he did struggle with shooting efficiency at times.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers