Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Garoppolo will make mistakes trying to show up the Patriots in his revenge game

Garoppolo is probably going to try to play like the best game of his life to show Robert Kraft like, 'Hey, you could've had me.' And when he tries to do that, he's probably going to make some mistakes.

Garoppolo threw one interception and had a modest performance (162 yards) before leaving the game with a back injury, though the Raiders did win.
Void
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Bryce Harper embodies the city of Philadelphia more than any superstar

I'm so jealous of Philly fans because you got a player that is a superstar potential Hall of Famer someday. And he's such a dirtbag—like Phillies fans. He is one of them. When he signed his deal, he was like 13 years, I don't want any opt-outs, I want to die here. Bury me in Philly. He embodies everything that fan base is all about.

This is a subjective evaluation of player-city chemistry, but widely accepted by baseball fans and media.
Void
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The Astros have proven they never needed to cheat to be successful

What they've proven to me—and should be to a lot of people—is that they never had to cheat in the first place. Whether or not they would've won in 2017, that remains to be seen... but as far as getting there seven straight [ALCSs], I don't think that they needed to cheat to do that. They were talented all along.

While their talent is undeniable, whether they 'needed' to cheat is a subjective counterfactual.
Void
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Winning in the MLB Playoffs is almost entirely about hitting home runs

The formula for Playoff success: good pitching, good defense, hit homers. And the D-backs are hitting homers. It's not about grinding out at-bats and wearing down the pitcher. It's: can you hit homers at a rate that you can out-homer the other team? The Playoffs is all about hitting home runs.

The 2023 postseason saw the Rangers and Diamondbacks rely heavily on home runs to advance, supporting Carrabis's point.
Void
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The MLB should move back to a one-game Wild Card and make the Division Series a best-of-seven

I want to mix up the Playoff format again. I want to go back to the one-game Playoff for the Wild Card, and then I want to make the Division Series best-of-seven. I think it rewards teams with more depth. Something specific to the Braves-Philly series... this deserves to be seven games.

This is a suggestion for a rules/format change.
Loss
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

Juan Soto could end up with the Red Sox

Juan Soto could end up in Boston. That's the scuttlebutt. He would just go yard all day in that [Fenway Park] short porch.

Juan Soto was traded from the Padres to the New York Yankees on December 6, 2023.
Loss
Jared CarrabisJared Carrabis

The Phillies will beat the Rangers in the World Series

World Series prediction: Phillies over the Rangers. It just feels like the Phillies won't be denied. They feel more inevitable this year.

The Rangers did make the World Series and won it, but they defeated the Arizona Diamondbacks, not the Phillies. The Phillies lost to Arizona in the NLCS.
Void
HankHank

Albus Dumbledore is a piece of shit for setting Harry Potter up to die

As I'm watching them [the Harry Potter movies], dude, Dumbledore's a piece of shit. He knew that Harry had to sacrifice himself. He set him up. The guy that you think is like the grandpa that's always there to help him... he's a bad sicko.

This is a subjective interpretation of a fictional character's motivations.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Books are always better than the movies

Michael Lewis books—always better than the movie. Big Short? Ever heard of it? Moneyball? Ever heard of it? Blindside? Books are always better than the movie.

Purely subjective preference.
Void
MaxMax

I only enjoy watching baseball when my team is on offense

What I said was... I like when my team is on offense, and I don't like when my team is on defense. [It's because] in the short series, every [pitch] is so important. You lose one and you're just back that much.

This is a personal preference based on sports-induced anxiety.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You would always rather give up a solo home run than a walk in the 9th

Top of the ninth, up 3-1. First batter. Would you rather give up a walk or a solo shot? I'd rather give up a solo shot. [Because with a walk] all of a sudden the tying run is on base and it's just all the nerves. Tension. I texted Dan Haren and he said 'no question you'd rather give up a solo shot.'

This is a tactical preference often debated by players and managers; there is no definitive statistical 'correct' answer, though many pros agree with the 'no free passes' philosophy.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jordan Love might suck

Jordan love might suck. I was smiling... He looked pretty bad. Both teams look bad.

Jordan Love had a rough start but turned his season around late, leading the Packers to a playoff win and earning a massive contract extension.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Garoppolo's move to the Raiders was a 'dog move' just to fuck around in Vegas with zero expectations

My respect for Jimmy G went up thinking about the fact that he took the contract to go play in Las Vegas. 67.5 million dollars to go hang out in Las Vegas and just fuck around for a few years with probably zero expectation of winning. That's a dog move. He did not do that to win football games. He did that to fuck around and have a good time.

Subjective interpretation of a player's career motivations.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If Travis Kelce and Dr. Fauci don't accept Aaron Rodgers' debate challenge, they officially lose

Under debate laws, if Travis Kelce and Dr. Fauci do not accept the debate they have lost. That is how debates work online.

They never debated, and by internet 'challenge' logic, this is how 'wins' are claimed by the challenger.
Void
MaxMax

The Phillies losing Game 2 was a 'better way to lose' than a bad loss because they showed fight

I would much rather see go down like that than if they were to roll over. It's not a good loss. It was a bad loss... but the team showed enough fight to win that game. The Braves just played better in the ninth. I would rather see [that].

Inherently subjective 'cope' logic.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The MLB will change the rules to help the Dodgers if they get swept again

Only thing I fear is that if the Dodgers lose again, they're 100% gonna get the rules changed to make it so that the Dodgers can be like automatically in the NLCS. 'Cause this would be back to back years.

Hot TakeBaseballHotSarcastic
The rules weren't changed to automatically seed them, but discussions about changing the playoff format for top seeds have continued.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Miami's failure to take a knee against Georgia Tech might be the worst regular season loss ever

I think that Miami loss might've been the worst loss ever. Not taking a knee 35 seconds left in the game... The game is won. Game is over. I watched that clip so many times and I still couldn't comprehend what was going on.

Widely regarded as one of the most statistically unnecessary and preventable losses in college football history.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

This season might be Nick Saban's best coaching job ever

I'm actually gonna go, I'm gonna reverse everything we said a couple weeks ago after the USF game... Is this Nick Saban's best coaching job? He doesn't really have a quarterback... Jalen Milroe throws a great, great ball [but] neither quarterback can throw the intermediate stuff. But Alabama has found something like we are a defensive team... it could be Nick Saban's best coaching job.

Saban led a team that struggled early to an SEC Championship victory over Georgia and a CFP appearance, which many analysts retrospectively agreed was one of his most impressive developmental seasons.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

NIL is actually good for college football because players stay longer and market themselves

Maybe the NIL isn't the death of college football. America's getting smarter and we're watching more football... players get to stay longer because now they can make money. Players get to market themselves... the fact that players can actually, we can put a face to their name now and they're out in front of it, it might be good for the sport. Who would've thought?

Viewership and engagement have continued to rise alongside the expansion of NIL.
Void
HankHank

The Official World Golf Ranking's decision to ignore LIV Golf is absolute bullshit

The official golf world ranking has chosen to just ignore LIV golf as a real sport or league. Shit. So LIV golf players are not gonna be able to qualify for majors and things like that... it's a problem for them when you have LIV golf players that are winning majors to then say that the tour that they play on doesn't produce players that are good enough.

The ranking controversy remains a major point of debate in golf, though some LIV players have since seen pathways open through other criteria.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mark Davis invented the 'muff' style hand warmer

Mark Davis invented the hand warmer. The owner of the Las Vegas Raiders. Mark Davis developed the Muff in 1986... for use by professional football teams. And that year, Davis began to market them for the fans. It's the muff style hand warmer.

Mark Davis did indeed patent the muff-style hand warmer in the mid-80s.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James being left off the NBA executive poll for clutch shooters is a personal insult

Which player would you want taking a shot with the game on the line? Number one was Steph Curry... LeBron James wasn't there. LeBron getting left off that list, that seems personal. He's gonna have to use that. He's gonna go to Zero Dark 30.

The poll is factual, but the 'personal' nature is Big Cat's opinion on how LeBron will react.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry Jones wants the Cowboys to run the Iowa offense with an all-tight end focus

Jerry Jones went on radio and said something ridiculous... They asked him about getting CeeDee Lamb more involved and Jerry Jones said, 'I don't know about that. I like seeing the ball go to tight ends.' Oh, your star wide receiver? That is a mismatch. Nope. Let's go tight ends. Jerry Jones, he wants to run the Iowa offense.

Lamb eventually became the focal point of the offense and had a career year.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The future of the Green Bay Packers looks bleak

I'm actually gonna go with the Green Bay Packers. Oh, I like it. Just strictly based on what we saw on Monday night.

Incorrect. The Packers went on a tear in the second half of the season, finished 9-8, and destroyed the Cowboys in the Wild Card round, establishing Jordan Love as a franchise star.
Void
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Jared Goff is a 'poor man's Matt Ryan'

He reminds me a lot of your former QB [Matt Ryan], maybe a poor man's Matt Ryan. It's not a slight on him. Matt's a great quarterback... Jared's great at the play action. He's great when you give him time. Get after him a little bit, speed up his clock. He's playing great right now. He's a guy that's resilient.

Subjective comparison between two successful, pocket-passing QBs.
Push
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The top four teams in the NFC are the 49ers, Eagles, Lions, and Seahawks

San Fran obviously. Philadelphia. My boy Jared Goff and his Lions... the fourth best team in the NFC? I'm gonna say Seattle.

The 49ers, Eagles, and Lions were indeed the class of the NFC, but the Seahawks finished 9-8 and missed the postseason while the Cowboys and Packers surged.
Void
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The top four quarterbacks in the NFL right now are Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Tua Tagovailoa, and Brock Purdy

Patrick Mahomes. Josh Allen. I've got two more I'm gonna go with—people are gonna be furious—Tua and Brock Purdy. [Leaving off Jalen Hurts] Brock knows his weaknesses, he knows his strengths... he's on a different level than most other quarterbacks in the league.

Subjective ranking of performance at that specific moment in the 2023 season.
Win
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Brock Purdy's processing ability is on a different level than most NFL quarterbacks

The processing ability of [Brock Purdy] read one, read two, read three, every time he makes a decision to scramble outside the pocket, like the guy is almost perfect in the way that he thinks about the game and his mind just computes what's happening. So it's an amazing thing. This guy, he's throwing the ball down the field. It's not Checkdown Fest... Him up here [in the head], he's on a different level than most other quarterbacks in the league.

Purdy went on to finish top 4 in MVP voting and led the 49ers to the Super Bowl.
Loss
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Sam Howell has already shown enough to be a franchise quarterback

Sam Howell has impressed me as being a tough motherfucker too. And he is making some good throws. There's no doubt and I think, I think he's already there [being a franchise QB].

Incorrect. Howell led the league in interceptions, was benched late in the season, and was traded to the Seahawks in the offseason after the Commanders used the #2 pick on Jayden Daniels.
Win
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The Ravens will be a dangerous team at the end of the year and very difficult to beat in the postseason

What I said all along about the Ravens is they're gonna be really difficult in the postseason. And the reason why is they're just going to continue to get better on offense... Todd Monken and Lamar [Jackson] are still figuring things out in his system... they're gonna be a really dangerous team at the end of the year.

Correct. The Ravens earned the #1 seed in the AFC and reached the AFC Championship game.
Void
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

Russell Wilson is playing himself out of Hall of Fame consideration with his performance in Denver

If that was a Hall of Fame career, those first 10 years and winning the Super Bowl and all those wins, it does feel like he's playing himself outta consideration the last few years. You look at his relationship with Sean Payton and how already you're getting the eye rolls.

Wilson's subsequent benching and release by Denver further supported the idea that his legacy took a significant hit.
Void
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The only way to stop the Eagles' 'tush push' is to legally or illegally blow up the center and quarterback to make them uncomfortable

How do you stop the tush push? Why are you not taking your biggest defender and having them try to time out the snap count and just blow up the center and the quarterback? Worst case scenario, that's a five yard penalty... next time they're like, 'oh my God, this is gonna happen again.' Jason Kelce's gonna be like, 'look, we gotta stop calling this play.' Make Jason Kelce uncomfortable.

The 'tush push' remained highly effective through the end of the 2023 season, and no team successfully implemented this specific 'deterrent' strategy to stop it.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You cannot tank in the NFL because everyone is playing for their next contract

It's a great point that we forget... The tank—you can't tank in the NFL, it's impossible to tank. Because everyone's trying, playing for a job. So even when a team looks terrible, they're still gonna go out... you can't tank on a full season.

This is a philosophical take on the nature of professional football incentives.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You cannot tell the story of football without Ryan Fitzpatrick

So we thank you. Wow. So you, we just made your case for the Hall of Fame. You cannot tell the story of football without Ryan Fitzpatrick.

Inherently subjective criteria for Hall of Fame induction.
Loss
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

The Super Bowl will be 49ers vs. Dolphins

I think, you know, this is not a hot take that, I think San Francisco's the best team in the NFC. So let's go San Francisco. Miami.

Incorrect. The 49ers made the Super Bowl, but the Dolphins were eliminated in the Wild Card round by the Chiefs.
Win
MaxMax

Aaron Nola's upcoming Game 3 start defines everything for his Phillies legacy

This is the everything Aaron Nola game. This defines everything because I'm kind of an Aaron Nola hater, but if he pitches well, I'll love him forever. If he pitches poorly, I never wanna see his face again... Mentally he will be dead in my brain.

Aaron Nola pitched a masterpiece in Game 3 vs the Braves (5.2 IP, 0 ER, 9 K) and subsequently signed a massive 7-year extension with the Phillies, meaning Max's 'love him forever' outcome was met.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 49ers would win the Super Bowl if it were played today

The 49ers. Congratulations. The 49ers. They won the Week five Super Bowl. If the Super Bowl were played today, I say that the 49ers would win easily.

The 49ers were the #1 seed and reached the Super Bowl, though they eventually lost to the Chiefs in overtime. At this specific point in the season, they were arguably the best team.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Brock Purdy is 100% a top 10 quarterback

Brock Purdy is 100% a top 10 quarterback. If you disagree, you aren't watching the games. Brock Purdy is just good. He's just very good.

Purdy finished the season as a Pro Bowler, led the league in passer rating, and was an MVP finalist. He is widely considered a top 10 QB by metrics and most analysts.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles, 49ers, and Lions are the only three really good teams in the NFC

I feel like today was a day that we found out there are three really, really good teams in the NFC and then there's everyone else. I'm referring to the Philadelphia Eagles, the San Francisco 49ers and the Detroit Lions.

These three teams were indeed the top three seeds in the NFC and the last three NFC teams standing in the playoffs.
Push
HankHank

The Cowboys will get smoked if they make it past the divisional round of the playoffs

This team [Cowboys] might make it to the divisional round of the playoffs. They're gonna get smoked if they make it any, anywhere past that. And you can't feel any differently.

The Cowboys actually lost in the Wild Card round to the Packers, so they didn't even make it to the divisional round where Hank thought they might get 'smoked'.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills threw away the Jaguars game because of their terrible travel schedule to London.

The Bill's schedule to go to London... made no sense. ... They actually looked like they were sleepwalking in the first half. ... The Bills basically threw this game away with how they travel.

Subjective claim about the cause of a loss, though the Bills did start very slowly in that game.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL teams should fly to London earlier and use medically induced comas to acclimate

What should happen is the moment you get a chance, like maybe that Monday... you put your guys in medically induced coma, knocked them out, put them onto London time, get their body naturally acclimated, fly them over while they're all knocked out. And then you get there, you practice through the week. You use a copious amount of drugs to put them asleep at night and wake them up in the morning.

This is a medical impossibility and highly illegal, though the Bills did play 'sleepy' as he noted.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jalen Warren should be getting Najee Harris's touches for the Steelers

Jalen Warren should get Najee Harris' touches. He's so good. So much better than Najee Harris. Anybody with eyes can see Jalen Warren carry the ball and be like, this guy has 10 times the burst Najee has.

Warren continued to outproduce Najee in efficiency (5.3 vs 4.1 YPC) throughout the season, leading to a much more even split by season's end.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Gardner Minshew is the best backup quarterback in the NFL.

Gardner Minshew is the best backup in the league. ... He has now had to come in what, three times this year. And the Colts are three and two.

Minshew went on to start most of the season for Indy, nearly leading them to the playoffs and making the Pro Bowl as an alternate.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Panthers will get their first win of the season at home against the Falcons.

They might win that one [against the Falcons]. I think they might win that one. Yeah. ... There's gonna be, they're gonna beat the Falcons at home.

The Panthers defeated the Falcons 9-7 at home on December 17, 2023.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions have one of the best rosters in the NFL and are almost a 'great' team.

If you look objectively at their roster right now, they're one of the best rosters in the NFL. ... Lions are almost a great team.

The Lions backed this up by winning the NFC North and reaching the NFC Championship game.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I still believe Bryce Young is going to be a good NFL quarterback despite his early struggles.

I still think Bryce Young's gonna be good... I just watched him so much in college and I'm like, he can't be that bad and he's playing on a bad team, so I'm just gonna keep holding out hope.

Young continued to struggle throughout his rookie year and was benched early in his second season (2024) after a poor start.
Win
HankHank

The Patriots should rebuild around the lighthouse and fire Bill Belichick and Mac Jones

The lighthouse is all we got. That's really the only, like, I think you rebuild around the lighthouse. Get rid of Belichick, get rid of Mac Jones and just build around the lighthouse. Build an entire team around the lighthouse.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The Patriots did eventually move on from both Mac Jones and Bill Belichick after the season.
Win
HankHank

I wouldn't be surprised if Bill Belichick wants to leave the Patriots.

I think Belichick, whatever he wants to do... I wouldn't be surprised if he is like, 'I need to get the fuck outta here.'

Belichick and the Patriots mutually agreed to part ways following the conclusion of the 2023 season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick is ruining the Patriots on purpose to make them easier to beat when he joins a new team

I think he's ruining the Patriots because he's gonna go somewhere else and then he'll make the Patriots easier to beat when he's at the next location. Vrabel to the Patriots Belichick to the Titans... Vanderbilt is where my dad coached Nashville is where I was born... It's coming home.

Belichick did leave the Patriots, but he did not join the Titans; he remained a free agent and media personality for the 2024 season.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers