Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
HankHank

Paul Skenes is broken after the World Baseball Classic

Paul Skenes is broken... World Baseball Classic hot seat broke him.

Skenes has been elite in the MLB; this was a total overreaction or bit.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mark DeRosa intentionally threw the game to Team Italy because of his Italian heritage

A lot of people were talking about, the last name [DeRosa] is Italian. Very Italian. And he seemed to throw this game to Italy. I'm just saying connect the dots. Paesan.

This is a humorous conspiracy theory based on a surname coincidence.
Loss
VP
Vinnie Pasquantino

I will charge the mound if my teammate Seth Lugo hits me with a pitch

I've got Puerto Rico on Saturday and I believe I'm facing a teammate in Seth Lugo. If he hits me, I'm gonna charge the mound. So, we'll get a little Royals on Royals fight.

PredictionBaseballMediumSarcastic
The game did not result in a mound charge or Pasquantino being hit by Lugo in the WBC.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Blue Jays will win the World Series

The cup is in the building for the Blue Jays... the pointy little flags [are] in Canada... they can win the World Series. The Toronto Blue Jays... what a story. Trey Yesavage is unbelievable... this guy is insane. It's great.

The Blue Jays did NOT win the 2025 World Series. The Dodgers beat the Blue Jays 4 games to 3, winning Game 7 5-4 in 11 innings on November 1, 2025.
Loss
MaxMax

The Dodgers will sweep the World Series in four games.

I will go Dodgers in four... I just think that's going to be the case.

Max predicted the Dodgers would sweep the World Series in 4 games. The Dodgers did win the 2025 World Series but in 7 games against the Blue Jays, far from a sweep.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am changing my World Series prediction to Dodgers in six games.

Just from that alone, I'm changing my prediction Dodgers in six. Okay. Welcome to board. Yeah. Just added another game for the Blue Jays. We believe. We believe Toronto Jays. You're gonna get another game.

Big Cat predicted Dodgers in 6 games. The Dodgers won the 2025 World Series over the Blue Jays, but in 7 games (4-3), not 6. Game 7 went to extra innings with the Dodgers winning 5-4 in 11 innings.
Loss
MaxMax

The Blue Jays have no shot at beating the Dodgers in the World Series

I think [the Blue Jays] got no shot... I just don't think they have the—the Dodgers are too good. They don't have the pitching. [Kevin] Gausman would be [the Dodgers'] fifth starter.

The Blue Jays did have a shot and nearly beat the Dodgers in the 2025 World Series, pushing it to 7 games before losing 5-4 in 11 innings of Game 7.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

There is a 0% chance the Cubs resign Kyle Tucker

There's a 0% chance they resign Kyle Tucker. Kyle Tucker gave a quote after the game that has never, there's never been a guy who has been more gone than Kyle Tucker was gone in that moment... That's the most goodbye you could possibly have.

Kyle Tucker remained with the Astros in reality (he was never on the Cubs). Big Cat is misremembering his own team's roster or a hypothetical trade scenario.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Brewers could absolutely beat the Dodgers in the NLCS

I've got a future on the Brewers that I put in in early August. They could absolutely beat the Dodgers. I've got a future on them... I would be very happy to see the Mariners win the World Series over my future, but I like the Brewers.

The Brewers did NOT beat the Dodgers in the NLCS. The Dodgers swept the Brewers 4-0 in the 2025 NLCS. Milwaukee hit just .118, the worst batting average in any postseason series of 3+ games in MLB history.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Blue Jays are going to be a handful in the next round with Bo Bichette returning

The Toronto Blue Jays... they're getting Bo Bichette back I think in the next round. It's so, the Blue Jays are, they're, they're gonna be a handful.

The Blue Jays did not reach the next round/ALCS in 2024 as they were not in the postseason; the context of the transcript suggests they are discussing the 2024 playoffs (though the date says 2025, the teams mentioned like Tigers/Tars align with 2024 results).
Loss
MaxMax

The Phillies' loss to the Dodgers is the worst in playoff history since Bill Buckner

It's the worst loss in playoff history since Bill Buckner. He should have gone to first. That is a play that you would be shocked to see on a little league field.

While a terrible error, several other high-profile playoff blunders (e.g., Jean Segura, various blown leads) have occurred since Buckner.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Blue Jays are the only team with the mental criteria to beat the Dodgers in the World Series

I ran a mental simulation last night to, 'cause I was pissed off. 'cause it seems like the Dodgers were gonna win the World Series and there's nothing anybody else could do about it. I did 2000 mental simulations. I was laying in bed envisioning a team that I could picture beating the Dodgers in the World Series. And the only team that fits my mental criteria is the Blue Jays.

This is a subjective mental exercise and the Blue Jays didn't win the 2025 World Series (the Dodgers did).
Loss
HankHank

MLB is rigging playoff games and juicing baseballs to extend series

If the Yankees had got swept, it's in like MLB needs to do something territory. Someone's, you know, someone's gotta extend a series. ... I'm saying like MLB is gonna rig games to advance the series. ... when the Brewers and Dodgers are pitching, they'd give him the, the juiced ones.

OpinionBaseballHotSarcastic
While MLB has admitted to varying ball properties in the past, there is no evidence of specific rigging to extend series in 2025.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Guardians are the best team in baseball right now

Guardians are, are red hot. I put a future on the Guardians to win the World Series just because of like how crazy this last month has been for them. The best team in baseball right now. I don't think they're, they're the most talented team, but like, in terms of the streak that they're on, it's worth a shot at least.

The Guardians had a great 2024 season but did not win the World Series.
Loss
MaxMax

Zack Wheeler is likely done for the year with blood clots and the Phillies' season is over

I think [Zack Wheeler] is probably done for the year, which means that the Phillies are probably done. Blood clot sounds bad in his shoulder... everyone for pitching... Yeah. No, I think, I think he's probably done for the year, which is, which means that the Phillies are probably done.

Zack Wheeler remained healthy and active for the 2024 postseason; there were no season-ending blood clots in August 2024.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Milwaukee Brewers' 12-game win streak will inevitably end and they will blow their lead to the Cubs

The brewers are up eight games now. It happened in like two seconds... I think you guys just got out to a hot start... This is by the way, the Ultimate Loser talk that I'm just trying to find Solace being like we didn't blow the lead.

The Brewers actually sustained their lead and won the NL Central in 2024, making this take incorrect.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Yankees should bring back Joe Torre and their old facial hair policy

The year where they decide to change their entire facial hair policy and grooming standards, things go downhill. They should go back to a manager that doesn't manage just off a spreadsheet. They need, they might need to bring back the no facial hair and Joe Torre all in the same.

The Yankees did not hire Joe Torre or change their facial hair policy in late 2024.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Schwarber should be the National League MVP

Kyle Schwarber should be MVP 'cause he hit, but we talk about that a little bit later. He, he, he, he did hit two home runs on Monday night. They were fucking mammoths.

Shohei Ohtani won the NL MVP in 2024. Schwarber finished in the top 15 but was not the winner.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Anyone who truly dedicates themselves to throwing a knuckleball can make it to Major League Baseball

I think anybody that really dedicates themself to throwing a knuckleball, we'll make it to major league baseball. Agreed.

The scarcity of knuckleballers in MLB suggests it is significantly harder to master than the hosts acknowledge.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Schwarber should win the NL MVP

I was gonna say Kyle Schwarber should be MVP. ... Shohei is not pitching. ... I also have a 90 to one ticket on Kyle Schwarber. But that has nothing to do with us saying Kyle Schwarber should win MVP.

Kyle Schwarber did not win the NL MVP; Shohei Ohtani won the award despite not pitching.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cal Raleigh should be the AL MVP

I'm not concerned with the NL race. I'm more concerned Cal Raleigh should be AL MVP. I just feel very strongly.

Cal Raleigh did not win the AL MVP, which was taken by Aaron Judge.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Marlins might sneak into the MLB playoffs

The Miami Marlins... might sneak away into the playoffs. They're six games out of the Wild Card. I don't know, fun story going on in Miami.

The Miami Marlins did NOT sneak into the 2025 MLB playoffs. They finished 79-83 and were eliminated from contention on September 25.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Cal Raleigh will hit 67 home runs this season

Cal Raleigh hit four home runs this weekend... he's now on pace for 67 home runs, which is pretty fucking insane. ... He's gonna hit 67 home runs.

Cal Raleigh did not hit 67 home runs in the 2025 season. That was a tongue-in-cheek extrapolation from an early-season pace that was never realistic.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Judge should be ineligible for MVP because being 6'7" is technically cheating

Aaron Judge should not be eligible for MVP. I agree. He's a beast. It's actually cheating how tall he is. He should not be eligible for MVP. He's different though. And just so we're clear, if Aaron Judge ever comes on this show, we will tell him he's the MVP.

Being tall is not a violation of MLB rules, making the 'cheating' claim factually incorrect despite being a joke.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A no-hitter with 19 strikeouts and one hit batter should be considered a 'perfect game'

I actually think that if you throw 19 strikeouts and you hit one guy and throw a no-hitter, that is the perfect game. [Big Cat]: I think they had a error as well. [PFT]: Unbelievable. For 19 strikeouts. Awesome.

By the literal definition of baseball, it is not a perfect game if anyone reaches base via HBP or error.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian Yelich is going to win the MLB Home Run Derby

When I was in Milwaukee, all the brewers, like almost every single brewer when I walked by said, Christian Yelich is gonna win the home run derby this year. It's disgusting.

Cal Raleigh of the Mariners won the 2025 MLB Home Run Derby, not Christian Yelich.
Loss
Tarik SkubalTarik Skubal

I am officially the best bunter in Major League Baseball history because I am one-for-one

I do say this though. I do say I'm the best bunter in major league history... I had one bunt attempt got it down. So. Anytime big situations, I always say I'm the best bunter in major league history. You ready to, can't take that away from me. I'm one-for-one.

Literally incorrect, but a funny technicality.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Cal Raleigh should be a legitimate candidate for AL MVP.

We talked about Cal Raleigh on Monday and how awesome he is and he should be considered for the MVP.

Cal Raleigh had a great season but did not win MVP; Judge won in a landslide.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Detroit Tigers might be the best team in Major League Baseball right now.

The Tigers are really fucking good. I hate, I see it happening because he's, I think he's due to make a ton of money... they're the best team in the AL. Why would you trade [Skubal]? He's fucking awesome. They might be the best team in baseball. They got, they're the best team in baseball right now, record-wise.

While the Tigers had a strong start, they did not finish with the best record or win the World Series in 2025.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Detroit Tigers will win the American League

I'll say this right now. I think the Detroit Tigers are gonna win The AL. I don't know if they can win the World Series. There's some good teams in the NL... in the last month, it's like [Javi Baez] recaptured something and, and, and come back to the world as, as what the electrifying Javi Baez was.

The Detroit Tigers finished 87-74 in 2025, which was respectable but they did not win the American League. The Blue Jays won the AL pennant.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Cam Smith will win the AL Rookie of the Year

I think I'm rooting for Cam Smith to win AL Rookie of the year. And I might even bet it... if he wins AL Rookie of the Year, then Tom Ricketts has to resign Kyle Tucker.

Cam Smith did not win the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year. Nick Kurtz of the Oakland Athletics won the award. Smith struggled in the second half hitting .190.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Dodgers have a chance to win more games than any team in MLB history this season

They have an incredible team. They have a chance to win more games than any team in Major League Baseball history this season if they can manage to stay healthy.

The Dodgers finished the 2025 regular season 93-69, far short of the MLB all-time wins record (116 wins by the 2001 Mariners). While they won the World Series, they did not come close to the most wins in MLB history as Jeff Passan suggested was possible.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Cincinnati Reds are a sleeper team that could win the NL Central

I think people are sleeping on Cincinnati a little bit. Elly De La Cruz has a chance to be a super duper star... I like a team that has some youth on its side... the Reds feel like they could be that team this year.

The Cincinnati Reds did not win the NL Central in 2025. While they competed for a wild card spot (and narrowly edged out the Mets for the final spot), they did not win their division.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

Bubba Chandler will win NL Rookie of the Year and eventually be better than Paul Skenes

Bubba Chandler with the Pirates... Fastball up to a hundred now. Great breaking stuff, good control and commit. I picked him to win Rookie of the year this year. [He texted Paul Skenes] enjoy it while it lasts because next year I'm going to be starting opening day.

Bubba Chandler did not win the 2025 NL Rookie of the Year. Paul Skenes won the NL ROY. Chandler only debuted in August 2025 and had a limited 4-1 record in 7 appearances.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The New York Yankees will miss the playoffs in 2025

Before Gerrit Cole needed Tommy John surgery, I still had the Yankees winning the American League East. I do not have that as the case anymore. I don't have them making the playoffs... the floor happens to be lower I think, than it is in typical years for the Yankees.

The Yankees made the 2025 playoffs as a Wild Card team with a 93-68 record, though they lost to the Red Sox in the Wild Card Series 2-1. They did not miss the playoffs.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Boston Red Sox will win the American League East

The Red Sox I have winning the division. I feel good about what they did. Getting Garrett Crochet and Alex Bregman this winter.

The Toronto Blue Jays won the AL East in 2025 with a 93-68 record (tied with Yankees but won tiebreaker), not the Boston Red Sox. The Red Sox made the playoffs as a Wild Card.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Texas Rangers will win the American League pennant

The team I'm picking to win the pennant is the Texas Rangers... they get Jacob deGrom back to headline their rotation this season... If the Rangers bullpen can perform... I think they have probably the highest ceiling in the league.

The Texas Rangers did not win the 2025 American League pennant. The Toronto Blue Jays won the ALCS, defeating the Seattle Mariners 4-3.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Nationals will sneakily compete for a wild card spot

I think the Washington Nationals are going to sneaky compete for a wild card spot. That's my wild prediction. They won't be out of it in September.

The Washington Nationals did not compete for a wild card spot in 2025. They were not in playoff contention by September.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Beards are causing baseball injuries because the face is connected to the elbow

My who's back is baseball injuries 'cause Garrett Cole's out for the year... Bad Tommy John. They should never change the rules about shaving your face. Like this, this would not have happened if he was clean shaven. That's true. That's your, your face. Your face is connected to your shoulder, to your elbow.

There is no medical evidence linking facial hair to ulnar collateral ligament tears.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Baseball players should never eat salads to avoid freak injuries

Dustin May, I'm happy you're alive, but this is why you don't eat salads. Never eat salad. Never touch the stuff. Never do it.

Hot TakeBaseballHotSarcastic
Obviously, salads do not cause injuries to 99.9% of the population, but it fits the 'weird baseball injury' trope.
Loss
HankHank

Juan Soto will sign with the Boston Red Sox

I'm seeing some tweets. I'm seeing some reports... Juan Soto's sister looking at apartments in Boston... Kirk Minihane reported that he's a hundred percent signing with the Red Sox.

Juan Soto signed a record-breaking contract with the New York Mets on December 8, 2024.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Grand slams are rally killers because they clear the bases

Grand slams are rally killers. You shouldn't hit 'em because then you get everybody off the bases then it's hard to keep scoring runs.

This is a satirical take; mathematically, 4 runs is better than any other outcome in a single plate appearance.
Loss
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Philadelphia Phillies will defeat the New York Yankees in the World Series

World Series? I think the Philadelphia Phillies are the best team... Philly's over Yankees.

The Phillies were eliminated in the NLDS by the Mets. The Yankees reached the World Series but lost to the Dodgers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The MLB should allow players suspended for steroids back early if they win the Home Run Derby

Our idea that we had last year was one of the best, which is if you test positive for steroids, you can get out of your suspension by winning the Home Run Derby.

The MLB has not implemented a policy where steroids users can commute their suspension through Home Run Derby victory.
Loss
Gunnar HendersonGunnar Henderson

Ryan Mountcastle will have a massive second half because he's over his vertigo

Ryan Mountcastle. He seems to be over the vertigos, but yeah, he does hit a lot of homers. So he's been saving them. He, this is what he told me. He's been saving them for the second half. And I got him having a big second half.

Mountcastle's 2024 season was decent but not 'massive.' He finished with 13 home runs, a similar pace to his first half.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Phillies are a lock to reach the NLCS

The Phillies would have to really fuck up not to be in at least the NLCS because the NL is trash... they will be in big playoff games... there's no way that they're not gonna be in big playoff games... it's a lock.

The Phillies lost to the Mets in the NLDS, failing to reach the NLCS.
Loss
HankHank

I think Shohei Ohtani was gambling

I think he was gambling. [Big Cat: You do, do you think Shohei was gambling?] Yeah.

Federal investigators eventually charged Ippei Mizuhara and cleared Ohtani of any knowledge or involvement in the gambling.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Shohei Ohtani investigation will take a long time to resolve because of federal involvement

I think it's gonna be a long time... This is such a tiny little speck of a much larger investigation that's going on right now into this alleged illegal gambling ring in Southern California.

Actually incorrect; the investigation moved surprisingly fast, with Ippei Mizuhara being charged by federal authorities and pleading guilty by early May 2024, less than two months later.
Loss
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Dodgers will never get over the hump if they don't fix their playoff choking habit

If the Dodgers weren't choking things away in October or the Braves weren't choking things away in October, then the discussion wouldn't quite focus on them the same... you want your postseason to closer represent the regular season.

The Dodgers actually went on to win the 2024 World Series, proving they could overcome the 'choke' narrative in the expanded format.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The New York Yankees have already won the World Series after their opening sweep of Houston

I'd just like to be the first to congratulate the New York Yankees on winning the World Series. Yeah. Four game sweep in Houston. Congrats. Juan Soto has been incredible. The Yankees have won it all.

The Yankees reached the World Series but lost to the Dodgers 4-1.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers