Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL preseason should have a full Sunday slate with RedZone to help fans practice for the regular season

I think that the preseason should mimic the regular season and that we should have a full Sunday of football with a red zone to get us ready because the random start times... Give me, let me actually practice what it feels like to get up on a Sunday and get my body ready and watch every team play.

The NFL has not changed the preseason schedule to a uniform Sunday block; it remains spread across various days and times.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL's new taunting rule is going to be brutal and should be complained out of the league

The taunting rule fucking sucks. It's going to be brutal and we're going to all... It is the dumbest rule ever. We need to [complain it away].

The rule was heavily criticized and enforcement was somewhat softened in subsequent seasons, though it remains on the books.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mac Jones might win NFL Rookie of the Year

I think I'm going to Zig while everybody's zags. I think Mac Jones might be the rookie of the year... If Mac Jones gets in week four, then how many games? 13 games. Yeah. If he goes nine and four, see, I think, I think he gets rookie of the year.

Mac Jones did not win Rookie of the Year; the award went to Ja'Marr Chase.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

If Trevor Lawrence throws more than 20 touchdowns, he will win Rookie of the Year

Trevor Lawrence throws more than 20 touchdown passes, he gets rookie of the year. Because it always, especially because the Jaguars, he's not expected to win. He just has to worry about stats.

Trevor Lawrence only threw 12 touchdown passes in 2021 and Ja'Marr Chase won Rookie of the Year.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Saints should start Jameis Winston over Taysom Hill

There was one article that said that Taysom Hill is the assumed starter for the year. It is bullshit. Hashtag start Jameis bullshit. Give me Jameis, feed me Jameis. How can you start Taysom Hill? Cause then you can't use him for the gadget plays.

Jameis Winston was indeed named the starter for the 2021 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I don't want the Waterdogs to win the championship if it is played on an NFL Sunday

If the Waterdogs want to be the best dogs possible, they would lose in the semifinals. So we don't have to watch them in the finals... I don't want to have to be burdened with them on an NFL Sunday.

OpinionSoccerHotSarcastic
The Waterdogs lost in the semifinals in 2021, meaning Big Cat's 'wish' to not have to watch them in the final on an NFL Sunday was granted.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Fighting in public should be allowed as long as there are no face shots

I actually think that fighting in public should be allowed. As long as you all agreed, no face shots. You could just, you should be allowed to just body everybody up all day long... Kidney shots. That's fine. Wedgies break. A couple of ribs. Go for it. Kick some shit. Maybe one need of the balls. That's okay.

This is a satirical lifestyle opinion that cannot be factually proven.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Tony La Russa will win MLB Manager of the Year

He's gonna win manager of the year. It's going to be so funny when that happens and everyone's going to be [pissed].

Kevin Cash (AL) and Gabe Kapler (NL) won the awards in 2021. La Russa was a finalist but did not win.
Void
Jim CalhounJim Calhoun

Winning a Big East regular season and tournament championship meant more than a National Championship

I think that actually might mean more than the national championship. Deep down it is... Boy did we all miss, you know, Jimmy [Boeheim] and all of us... it's much better fighting your own neighborhood. The guys you know, the guys you have to recruit against.

This is a subjective value judgment based on Calhoun's career experience.
Void
Jim CalhounJim Calhoun

If you play for Rick Pitino, you always have a chance to win

Pitino who I don't like, he doesn't like me. And that's cool. Tell you one thing, man can coach all the other bullshit aside. You'll play for them. If you play for them, you got a chance to win.

This is a subjective assessment of Pitino's coaching ability by a contemporary.
Void
Jim CalhounJim Calhoun

The current college basketball transfer portal is bad for the game

I see what 1500 1600 kids transferring. It's a different game, but I don't think it's a good game... The problem is, are we in fact making [it]? ... transferring, I don't think it's a good game.

This is a subjective opinion on the quality of college basketball.
Void
Jim CalhounJim Calhoun

SEC Football and Big East Basketball were the two hardest things in sports at the time

The Southeast conference of football and the Big East basketball, the two hardest things I've ever seen at that time. Six out of nine of us are in the hall of fame that coached. And that's crazy.

This is a subjective comparison of historical conference strength.
Void
Jim CalhounJim Calhoun

The 2004 UConn team had the best talent of any I ever coached

I think the magical team might've been '04... Because number two in draft Emeka Okafor, Ben Gordon, Josh Boone, Hilton Armstrong, Marcus Williams... that may be Kentucky and other teams. That's not us. And that was the best team I should say. Best talent.

Subjective evaluation of talent by the head coach.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Drivers should be ineligible for speeding tickets if they are listening to Steely Dan or The Allman Brothers

I think if you're listening to the Allman Brothers or Steely Dan, you should be ineligible to get a speeding ticket... I like my driving songs to make me drive faster. Reeling in the Years is one of those songs.

This is a comedic proposal that cannot be verified.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

There is nothing better than listening to Bob Seger's 'Night Moves' while driving alone at night

Night moves, Bob Seger, late at night. Just fucking when you're alone in the car, you and you're like the only one on the highway. There's fucking, nothing like that. Nothing like that.

Subjective lifestyle preference.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

I can turn Ben Mintz into a 'lab rat turned muscle hamster' by controlling his diet and supplements

I now have the perfect opportunity [to] control all the variables and turn Ben Mintz into a lab rat turned muscle hamster... Basically I control all the variables. Like literally he's not going to be able to eat a meal without me. I'm going to pump this guy full of creatine, get him squatting heavy and see what happens.

Ben Mintz did engage in some fitness content with Billy, but he did not undergo a massive, lasting transformation into a 'muscle hamster' as Billy described.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Cowboys fans should be freaking out about Dak Prescott needing a second MRI

But QB Dak Prescott is planning on getting another MRI... if you're a Cowboys fan, you have to be freaking out right now.

While Dak did miss the preseason and some time later in the season (calf), he started 16 games in 2021. The 'freak out' over this specific shoulder MRI proved to be slightly overblown as he played Week 1.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dak Prescott should have teammates tackle him in practice to stop overthinking his injury

If I'm Dak... even if my shoulder is still not good to go right now, I would still have people do, like, tackling drills against me in practice where I would get hit because you've got to get that first hit out of your system to stop thinking about it all the time. I would just have people, like, tackle me into a big mat so I didn't hurt my shoulder falling on it.

Dak Prescott did not do this. He returned to play in Week 1 against the Bucs and threw for 403 yards, showing the 'psychological' hurdle was handled through traditional rehab.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Preseason football performance is like 'Play-Doh' that fans can mold to fit whatever narrative they want to believe about their team

Preseason really is just, it's like a Play-Doh that you can just mold to however you want to feel about your team going into the regular season. You can twist what you're watching in a preseason game to fit however you want. If Justin Fields comes out and he's awesome, I'd be like, well, this is incredible. If he stinks, I'd be like, well, COVID, preseason.

This is an observation about fan behavior and the nature of preseason football, which is inherently subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If Ben Affleck put on a baseball uniform and walked into the corn at the Field of Dreams, he would look like a 'loser'

All I'm going to say is if Ben Affleck tried to put on a baseball uniform and walk into the Field of Dreams corn stalks, I think he would look like a loser. I think we can all agree on that, right?

The aesthetic appeal of Ben Affleck in a baseball uniform is a matter of pure opinion.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Major League Baseball made a mistake by having an outfield fence at the Field of Dreams game

I think if they play this game in Iowa, they should not have an outfield fence... It should just be the corn. If there's like a grounder that would bounce into the wall, they have to run into the corn and try to grab the ball... that's probably the biggest mistake that Major League Baseball has made this week.

The game was a massive success with the fence, ending in a dramatic walk-off home run into the corn. The lack of a fence would have likely made the game unplayable by MLB standards.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Nick Saban could make Alabama the number one soccer team in the world immediately

I know we joke, but if Nick Saban and the Alabama football team decided they wanted to be number one soccer team in the world, they would. Immediately. Zero training. Yes, they just would.

Inherently untestable, but objectively false given the technical skill gaps between American football players and world-class soccer players.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

US vs Mexico is no longer a soccer rivalry because the US wins every time

I would actually go as far as to say that it's not even a rivalry. A rivalry implies that both teams win occasionally. And if you look back at the history of our last two League of Nations Golden Cups, it's just basically us showing up out there.

While the US did have a great run (the 'Dos a Cero' era continued), Mexico won matches later, and rivalries are based on more than just a 1-2 year window. In 2021, the US definitely had the upper hand.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The Miami Heat franchise would cease to exist if they ever stopped re-signing Udonis Haslam

If they ever don't bring him back on the Heat, the Heat as a franchise, I think, just ceased to exist. He's literally the definition of Heat culture.

Udonis Haslam retired in 2023, and the Miami Heat remain a functioning and successful NBA franchise.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Every NBA team should have a 13th roster spot reserved for a 40+ year old legend

There should be just a 13-man on every team that's like a million dollars. Everyone gets it, and it has to be, the player has to be 40 years or older. Just so we can see, like, imagine Shaq just standing on a sideline. Just every now and then, just let him go in.

The NBA has not implemented this, though the 'Udonis Haslem' role essentially exists unofficially for many teams.
Void
TH
Tony Hale

Promoting Veep and Toy Story at the same time is the most extreme contrast possible for an actor

I remember promoting Veep and Toy Story at the same time once and I was like, yeah, those you can't get more opposite than that.

The 'contrast' between two creative projects is a subjective artistic assessment.
Win
HankHank

Billy Football will not have a six-pack for next year's Grit Week either

I'm not trying to be a hater, but I don't think you'll have a six-pack for next grit week either. [to Billy Football]

Billy admitted in the episode and throughout the following year that he did not achieve a six-pack.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Trevor Lawrence is trending downward while Sam Ehlinger is trending upward in their respective training camps

Trevor Lawrence trending downward. Sam Ehlinger trending upward. Stock up, stock down. I'm just saying.

Trevor Lawrence became a franchise cornerstone and Pro Bowler, while Sam Ehlinger never became a regular starter, proving this 'trend' was a training camp illusion.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I will quit my job if Sam Ehlinger has a better NFL career than Trevor Lawrence

Billy, if Sam Ehlinger has a better career than Trevor Lawrence, I will quit my job. My only job in life would be to be your PR agent to just remind people that Billy Football correctly predicted Sam Ehlinger over Trevor Lawrence.

Trevor Lawrence has been a Pro Bowl starter and playoff winner while Ehlinger remains a backup; thus, Lawrence has had the better career.
Loss
HankHank

Jameis Winston will be the Saints starting quarterback for the next 13 years if Sean Payton can 'figure him out'

Hasselbeck was like, yeah, you know, Jameis is young, 27. Like, if Sean Payton figures it out, this is your starter for the next 13 years.

Sean Payton retired after the 2021 season, and Jameis Winston never established himself as a long-term starter in New Orleans, eventually leaving in 2024.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bears are officially set at quarterback for the next 24 years with Justin Fields

The Bears are now set for 24 years [with Justin Fields]. Think about that. Let me be the first to say the Bears are back.

PredictionFootballFireSarcastic
Justin Fields struggled as a starter and was traded to the Steelers after just three seasons, failing to provide 24 years of stability.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially in on the Chicago Bears and betting on them for the 2021 season

By the way, I think I'm in on the Bears this year. The clips that have been coming out of training camp are incredible. No, I'm serious. I bet on them. I'll put a future down.

The 2021 Bears were unsuccessful, finishing with a losing record and firing their coach and GM shortly after.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Elephants think humans are cute in the same way we think puppies are cute

Elephants look at humans like humans look at puppies. Elephants think that humans are cute the same way we think puppies are cute because we're like small creatures to them.

There is no scientific study or MRI data supporting the claim that elephant brains react to humans in this way; it is considered a viral myth.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Dallas Cowboys are going to win the Super Bowl this year

I can't see a world that Dallas don't win at least 15 games and CD Lamb should be a first rounder and Amari Cooper should be a first rounder and Dak Prescott... should be a first rounder... they are going to win the Super Bowl.

The 2021 Cowboys won 12 games and lost in the Wild Card round to the 49ers. They did not win the Super Bowl or 15 games.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ezekiel Elliott will return to his elite form this season because he finally has his six-pack back

Zeke is going to be back to physique this year... the dude has the six pack back. He doesn't have the belly anymore. physique-iel Elliott. He looks skinny. He looks, it looks very skinny.

Elliott rushed for 1,002 yards and 10 TDs in 2021. While a solid season, it was not a return to his league-leading 'elite' form from his first few seasons.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A head coach finding out their star quarterback is injured is the most devastating news possible

I need every head coach to be miked up when they get that type of news, because it is absolutely devastating. It's like stuff... I'm talking, you could tell them their family just got kidnapped and they'd be like, all right, well, we'll figure out after practice, but [the trainer] walking up being like, 'Hey, it's a muscular thing. We don't know.'

Subjective hyperbole about the relative importance of football vs personal life for NFL coaches.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Micah Parsons looks too small for a linebacker wearing number 11

Michael Parsons wearing number 11. It's going to take a lot of getting used to... I was watching it. I was like, this guy weighs 205 pounds and he's a linebacker. And then I looked up his stats and he's like 6'2" and 250 pounds. The 11 totally screwed me.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion about jersey numbers.
Loss
HankHank

The Celtics are getting great value in Dennis Schroeder because he'll be incredibly hungry after losing out on a massive contract

He rejected the deal. He said he wanted a hundred million dollars... Cool throne Celtics. It's good for the Celtics. Like you're going to get the hungriest Dennis Schroeder you can get.

Schroeder averaged 14.4 points in 49 games for Boston before being traded to the Rockets in February 2022. He didn't have the massive 'bet on himself' payoff season Hank anticipated.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Ben Simmons is a 'penny stock' worth investing in right now

I'm kind of low key addicted to Ben Simmons because he really is like a penny stock. If he could figure it out a little bit, it would be incredible. Like he would be, you know, a starter on the all-star team because he has all the other stuff. Defense, passing, dribbling... If he could just figure out when to shoot and have the balls to shoot, I'm telling you invest now.

Since this take, Simmons sat out a year, was traded to Brooklyn, and has seen his career derailed by injuries and continued shooting hesitancy, his 'stock' value has actually plummeted.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm betting on the Lions this season because Dan Campbell has successfully flushed all the 'turds' out of the organization

The lions have no turds. That's Dan Campbell said that they got no turds. So officially they flushed all the turns out... I'm ready for some Dan Campbell football. I think I'm expecting the lions. I'm going to bet the lions in this.

The 2021 Lions finished 3-13-1, the second-worst record in the NFL.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You should always fade Mike Greenberg's gambling advice when he feels strongly about a pick

He was saying that like, he's gonna take the under on not only the lions, but the Texans and they might not win more than like three or four games. This is a major Greenie weeny alert. If Greenie feels that strongly about something, when it comes to gambling, you fade Greenie big time.

Greenie took the under on the Lions and Texans. The Lions won 3 games and the Texans won 4. Fading him would have resulted in losses on both counts.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL's new taunting rules are a disaster for the game of football

[Jake Marsh]: I see it as taunting. So the NFL came out with new rules and automatic ejection for two taunting violations... [Big Cat]: Oh yeah, no [fun] for the game. No, no, no, no, no. I love this.

The rules were widely criticized by fans and players for being overly restrictive, though they remained in place.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Impossible burgers might cause serious kidney damage

My hot seat is vegan. So impossible burgers and new study came out on them. Turns out that they might be seriously damaging to your kidneys according to a study released.

The claim originates from a non-peer-reviewed report by an anti-GMO advocacy group and has been widely debunked by health professionals and researchers.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Sam Ehlinger will be a better NFL quarterback than Trevor Lawrence

Sam Ehlinger has been taking reps with the first team offense... Sam Ehlinger was going to be better than Trevor Lawrence. That was a 12-1 upset [in my bracket].

Trevor Lawrence became a franchise QB and Pro Bowler for the Jaguars, while Sam Ehlinger remained a career backup for the Colts.
Void
Gable StevesonGable Steveson

Freestyle wrestling is harder than Greco-Roman wrestling

I'm going to say freestyle in a sense is a lot harder than Greco, because you just, you could take shots in the legs. You can get cheap points off of easy shots and stuff.

This is a professional opinion from an Olympic gold medalist.
Win
Gable StevesonGable Steveson

I want to have a trial with an NFL team

I would hope one day that I can get a trial with the NFL. And I mean, there's some teams that have came and have mentioned me to some, some agents and stuff that have sparked interest to me. So, I mean, it'd be cool to go out there and play football and be in NFL for a little bit.

Steveson did eventually get a trial and sign with the Buffalo Bills in May 2024, confirming his goal.
Void
Daymond JohnDaymond John

Hot fashion brands typically only last five to seven years

The cycle of generally for fashion, a hot fashion brand lasts about five to seven years. There's a unicorns like Nike and Louis Vuitton. But you'll notice whether it's Benetton or Levi's... [they] chip away.

This is a general business observation from a fashion mogul.
Void
Daymond JohnDaymond John

If I were starting FUBU in today's social media landscape, the brand would be ten times bigger than it originally was

If you had to do it again today, your, you know 20 year old Daymond John, do you think it still works... This would be, I would, it would be, it would be 10 times bigger. Really? Yeah. You remember, I didn't, the internet didn't even exist. Social media didn't exist. So I had to physically walk up and get into people's face to sell them something.

This is a hypothetical claim that cannot be proven, though it aligns with modern brand scaling trends.
Void
Daymond JohnDaymond John

The only way to make real money in the stock market is to hold for 20 years

If you buy something on one of those [Robinhood/Ameritrade], the real way you're going to make money is to hold it for 20 years. If it's a value. But if you buy it, you naturally look at your account and you go back and go, 'oh, I'm Gordon Gekko. I just made $200. Let me sell it.'... It takes away your discipline.

Standard financial advice regarding long-term compounding vs short-term trading.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kobe Bryant's 'Black Mamba' is one of the greatest athlete nicknames of all time

We are going to go with, may he rest in peace, the black Mamba... it's probably the greatest nickname of all time because it just become, his has become his name.

Nickname quality is a matter of personal opinion.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers