Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
HankHank

Magic Johnson is the greatest nickname in sports history

I think it's probably the greatest nickname of all time because it just becomes his name. It is Magic Johnson. There is no one better than Magic Johnson. Irvin Johnson becoming Magic. I mean, it's just synonymous.

This is a subjective pick for a Mount Rushmore segment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tiger Woods' nickname is better than any other because it's synonymous with his dominance

This one is another synonymous name. It's an all time nickname... it is Tiger Woods. He's Eldrick Woods. His nickname is Tiger. It was given to him when he was a kid. There's nothing better. Like when he's in his red shirt on a Sunday hunting down his prey, Tiger Woods.

Subjective opinion for Mount Rushmore.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dale Earnhardt Sr.'s nickname 'The Intimidator' is an all-time great moniker because of the fear it struck in opponents

I'm going to go a little NASCAR. Maybe the greatest nickname. I know. Time... The intimidator, Dale Earnhardt Sr. I mean, what are you going to do when the intimidator comes for you?

Nickname quality is a matter of personal opinion.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

Usain Bolt is the greatest sprinter because he's the only one of the all-time fastest who hasn't tested positive for steroids

Basically of all the sprinters to break [ten] seconds, 9 out of the 10 have tested positive or been accused of using steroids except Usain Bolt.

Among the 10 fastest 100m runners in history, Usain Bolt is indeed the only one who has never been linked to a doping violation or ban.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JaVale McGee is the greatest American athlete of all time

JaVale McGee... three-time NBA champion and Olympic gold medal. In my opinion, the greatest American athlete.

JaVale McGee is a successful role player, but he is not the greatest American athlete by any objective measure.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Draymond Green is officially a Basketball Hall of Famer

Draymond is a Hall of Famer now. Like, he has everything. Two Final Fours, three titles, two gold medals, Defensive Player of the Year. When you look at his resume, you're like, whoa.

Draymond Green's resume (multiple titles, DPOY, All-Stars) is widely considered a first-ballot Hall of Fame resume by basketball analysts.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Race walking is the most metal sport in the Olympics

I think I've actually changed my tune on race walking... because it is the funniest looking sport by far, but it's insane. The dude that is the best in the world at it... he was just shitting himself during the race... his body just gave up. It's actually the most metal sport.

Whether a sport is 'metal' is entirely subjective, though the description of the physical toll fits PFT's definition.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peyton Manning will become the Commissioner of the NFL

I thought that Peyton Manning's speech points us in one direction only, and that is that he wants to follow in the footsteps of his dad and become commissioner of the NFL. So that when Arch [Manning] gets to the league, he can implement some weird draft rule.

Peyton Manning has focused on media (Omaha Productions) and shows no immediate signs of seeking the commissioner role, though it remains a theoretical future path.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A Manning will be on every American television screen for the next 40 years

Eli and [Peyton] are doing that thing on ESPN, the simulcast for Monday Night Football. I also think Cooper is going to get involved at some point. You're not going to be able to turn on a television in America and not have a Manning staring at you.

The ManningCast (Peyton and Eli) has been extremely successful and renewed through 2024. Arch Manning is also a top college prospect, ensuring the name stays in the headlines.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Gable Steveson is the next Kurt Angle

Gable Stevenson, who's a Barstool athlete... that was incredible. The backflip, fucking legend. He's the next Kurt Angle, I think.

Despite signing a major deal, Steveson struggled to transition to pro wrestling and was released by WWE in 2024 without ever reaching the heights of Kurt Angle.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

OJ Simpson's son was the real killer in the 1994 murders

OJ did a great job distracting everybody about his son. His son was recorded attempting to stab someone... now you think of OJ not as this murderer, but this father... I think it's still a murderer was covered up.

This is a conspiracy theory that has never been proven or legally substantiated, despite a popular book on the topic. OJ Simpson was acquitted and no other person was ever charged.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Italian sprinter Lamont Jacobs 100% used steroids to win Olympic gold

Did [Lamont Jacobs] do it? Yeah, 100%. If you look at his Instagram photos from him like two years ago, he's like rail thin. And then if you look at him now, he's like kind of jacked.

While Jacobs' nutritionist was investigated, Jacobs himself has never failed a drug test and no proof of doping has been established to strip him of his medals.
Loss
HankHank

LeAngelo Ball will be a rotation player for the Charlotte Hornets

My who's back is LeAngelo Ball. Back in summer league for the Hornets. 16 points. Love it. Five three-pointers made. Making a lot of noise. People saying he could be a rotation guy off the bench.

LeAngelo Ball never played in a regular-season NBA game and never became a rotation player.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ed Sheeran is 'not football' and shouldn't play the NFL Kickoff

Roger Goodell needs a guy that hangs out with him that's like, 'Hey, that's not football.' Ed Sheeran is not football. Not opening night football. Coldplay, not football. Imagine Dragons is way more football than Coldplay.

This is a subjective aesthetic judgment on brand alignment between the NFL and pop artists.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Imagine Dragons is much more 'football' than Coldplay

Imagine Dragons is way more football than Coldplay. For the most part, there's no situation where you're playing Coldplay where Imagine Dragons wouldn't be a gigantic upgrade.

This is a subjective assessment of cultural 'vibe' and cannot be definitively proven.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Trying to cancel Joe Rogan only promotes his show

It is the dumbest thing ever that they try to cancel Joe Rogan every other month. And then a bunch of people just tweet out Joe Rogan clips that probably just make new Joe Rogan fans. They're just doing his promotion for him.

Joe Rogan's listenership reportedly grew during his most controversial periods (e.g., Spotify/COVID-19 controversies), supporting the idea that the publicity was net-positive for his reach.
Void
Guy FieriGuy Fieri

The Apple Pie Hot Dog is a culinary combination that works

What we came up with actually should be prepared and sold in frozen food sections because we take a flaky pie crust, we take an all-American beef hot dog, we make a bacon jam... what we came up with, it so works.

Taste is subjective, but the Apple Pie Hot Dog became a viral sensation during the 2021 Field of Dreams game, with many adventurous eaters agreeing the flavors were surprisingly compatible.
Void
Guy FieriGuy Fieri

Runny egg yolks are gross 'liquid chicken'

I'm just not a fan of the liquid chicken part of the runny yolk thing that my wife loves. She had to dip the toast in that. I just sit there and go [ugh]. I'm not a big fan of the smell.

Food preferences are inherently subjective.
Win
Guy FieriGuy Fieri

I am going to release a line of Guy Fieri boozy ice cream soon

I got into this thing of boozy ice cream. So you may keep an eye out. There may be a Guy Fieri boozy ice cream coming out sometime soon. Tell me that would be gangster.

Guy Fieri eventually launched 'Flavortown Boozy Ice Cream' in partnership with various brands.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

N'Keal Harry is a great late-round fantasy football sleeper for 2021

N'Keal Harry is doing amazing, apparently. So that would be a good late round fantasy pick.

N'Keal Harry had a very disappointing 2021 season with only 12 catches for 184 yards and zero touchdowns, making him a wasted fantasy pick.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Texas' move to the SEC was an attempt to recruit Arch Manning

Texas' move to the SEC might be trying to court Arch Manning as a potential reason.

Texas did eventually land Arch Manning, but the SEC move was almost entirely driven by media rights revenue and long-term conference stability.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm taking the over on the Hall of Fame game's 32.5 point total.

I think the over-under was like 32.5 tonight. Take me over. The Hall of Fame game has changed where it used to be you'd get maybe like a series of the starters. Now we get nothing.

The Steelers beat the Cowboys 16-3, resulting in a total of 19 points, well under the 32.5 mark.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm taking the Cowboys to win the Hall of Fame Game because Mike McCarthy wants to set a tone for Hard Knocks.

For that reason, I'm going to take the Cowboys in the game tonight just because I think that McCarthy, he knows that Jerry Jones has his, like, Emperor Palpatine breath breathing down his neck all the time. So he wants to set a tone, and he knows that he's on Hard Knocks.

The Cowboys lost the Hall of Fame game to the Steelers 16-3.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The US men's 4x100 relay team is terrible.

So our four by 100 team sucks. And there were like a lot of people who were like, this is a debacle. How are we so bad at this? ... I really just don't care. Like, I want us to win, but if we don't, I don't lose any sleep over it.

The US men's 4x100 team failed to qualify for the final after a disastrous 6th-place heat finish.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Australia is a mortal lock to beat Slovenia in the Olympic Bronze Medal game.

Mortal lock of the century, Australia, third place game. You've got to find the teams that actually, it's like bowl season... Luka just carried his team to the semifinals, and now is he going to be like, I'm going to really want a bronze medal? Australia, that group together, has never won a medal.

Australia defeated Slovenia 107-93 to win the bronze medal on August 7, 2021.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A pizza place's ability to make a plain cheese pizza correctly is the true metric of their quality.

If you can do a plain pizza right, then I think that you can do everything else right. ... Start with the basics and build off that.

This is a subjective food philosophy that cannot be proven right or wrong.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Black olives have the most flavor per surface area of any pizza topping.

Black olives have the most flavor per surface area of any pizza topping. ... I like doing a mixture [of green and black].

Flavor intensity is a matter of personal palate and cannot be objectively measured by 'surface area.'
Void
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

If Justin Herbert had played in the SEC, he would have been the number one overall pick.

I scouted [Justin Herbert] for two years. I go to ESPN, and I'm standing on the table like, I want this guy... And I said it, which was if Justin Herbert played in the SEC, he would have been the number one pick in the draft. But he's quiet. He's in Oregon.

This is a hypothetical claim that cannot be proven, making it subjective.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

It is way too early to call Tua Tagovailoa a bust and he needs more time to develop.

Tua had major hip surgery a year ago. Basically an abbreviated offseason. Like we got to give the guy a chance to see like what he has. ... Obviously this is a consequential year but I think sometimes like we move on from guys way too fast.

Tua Tagovailoa eventually developed into a Pro Bowl quarterback and league leader in passer rating, proving that 'bust' labels in 2021 were premature.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

The Packers will not blink in the Aaron Rodgers standoff until he actually skips a regular season game.

Green Bay will not blink or even think about blinking until [Aaron Rodgers] doesn't show up. Now, when he doesn't show up, now they're going to take a half a step back and say, hey, can we get three ones from Denver? ... But until then, they're going to assume that, hey, he's bad like a lot of us are at his boss, but when rubber meets the road, he's going to show up.

Aaron Rodgers reported for the 2021 season, played all 17 games, and won the NFL MVP award.
Loss
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

I am betting against the Los Angeles Rams' 'stars and scrubs' roster model paying off.

It's a huge calculated risk that may pay off, but if I had to bet, I'm betting against it... they're saying, F that. Like, we're going to get Jalen Ramsey, Aaron Donald. Like, we're going to go play five against 11. But our five are so good, we're going to win. I think when you look at their offensive line guys, they are paper thin.

The 2021 Los Angeles Rams went on to win Super Bowl LVI, proving the model was successful for that season.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

Baker Mayfield is a height and speed deficient quarterback who should not be paid a top-of-market contract.

Baker Mayfield is a guy that is just objectively short and slow... you can't pay him $40 million a year because you've got to keep Chubb and Ward and all these other guys... In my opinion, he's somewhere between the 6th and 8th best quarterback in the AFC. How are you going to win a championship?

Mayfield's career subsequently declined with the Browns, leading to his trade. While he had a resurgence later with Tampa Bay, Tannenbaum's assessment that the Browns shouldn't pay him top market value proved accurate for Cleveland.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

Carson Wentz is lacking the 'battlefield commander' leadership qualities needed to win championships.

If you're worried about Nick Foles as your backup, you've got the wrong guy. You think Brett Favre, Dan Marino, Patrick Mahomes, Tom Brady cared who their backup was? No... And that's the part about Carson Wentz that he may be lacking.

Wentz's tenure in Indianapolis and later Washington was marred by leadership critiques and inconsistent play, eventually leading to him becoming a backup.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

In NFL front offices, a player's production determines the level of tolerance for their off-field behavior.

In every single GM's office, they have one mathematical equation. Production equals tolerance. ... You want to have standards, protocols, and culture. But you know what? Hey, if Tiger Woods is not in the offseason program, he's still going out there as one of our guys.

While cynical, this is an observation of industry practice that is widely accepted as the 'unwritten rule' of professional sports.
Win
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

Josh Allen's massive jump in completion percentage is a historical aberration that is unlikely to be repeated by others.

He is a very good player, and historically he has done something that no one else has in terms of improving his completion percentage... People don't leave college football and become as accurate as he has... his increase in completion percentage is historically good. [It is an aberration].

Josh Allen maintained his high completion percentage and elite play for years after this take, confirming that while it was a rare development, it was a permanent change for him.
Push
Mike TannenbaumMike Tannenbaum

Jameis Winston will be successful with the Saints because of the humility he showed by sitting for a year.

He is someone that bet on himself and showed great humility a year ago by sitting behind Drew Brees. And that's hard to do when you're the first pick in the draft. Now, we have to go see it pay off, but I thought what it did was really be selfless and take long-term view.

Winston started the 2021 season with 14 touchdowns to only 3 interceptions before suffering a season-ending ACL tear. While he showed improvement, his tenure as the Saints' franchise QB was short-lived.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James would obviously beat Mike Tyson in a street fight because of his size and reach.

LeBron James would obviously beat up Mike Tyson. He's way bigger, Billy. Dude, reach. He's bigger. Mike Tyson... LeBron James is like 6'9". And LeBron's tough. He's never flopped.

This is a hypothetical fight between a basketball player and one of the greatest heavyweight boxers ever. It is subjective, though logically most would favor the professional boxer.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

This is a 'Mickey Mouse Olympics' because host countries are manipulating tracks to ensure records are broken.

It's a Mickey Mouse Olympics. ... It's basically, and I kind of love this, that every host Olympics wants to break a bunch of records so they just make the track better. ... Every host country is like, how can we make this legal but also break all the records?

The Tokyo Olympic track was indeed engineered with new technology to be significantly faster, leading to several world records, though this doesn't officially make the games 'Mickey Mouse.'
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants aren't tough enough if their quarterback thinks he's even able to swing in a training camp fight

I say that I don't think that the New York Giants are tough enough if their quarterback is thinking that he's even able to swing on him... I don't think that they're tough enough if Daniel Jones thinks he's a fighter.

Subjective opinion on team dynamics.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dan Campbell is the most 'football guy' to ever coach in the NFL

Dan Campbell, man Campbell. He's alpha-ed the entire ranks of every – he's the most football guy to ever coach in the NFL, I think. He's starting to blur the line where he's no longer really a football guy. He's just kind of a football.

The definition of a 'football guy' is a specific PMT trope, and Campbell has become the poster child for it.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Judge making NFL players do laps and push-ups after a fight will not end well

Joe Judge is dealing with it as well because part of the giant scrum... they did laps, 100-yard laps, and then he didn't like how everyone did it, so then he made everyone do push-ups. And I feel like that's not going to go over well with a bunch of millionaire athletes.

Joe Judge was fired after just two seasons, with reports citing his hard-nosed 'tough guy' style as a factor in losing the locker room.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I'm legitimately excited for the Bulls after the Caruso, Lonzo Ball, and DeRozan signings

The Bulls are back. They have gotten very aggressive. Caruso, Lonzo Ball, and now DeMar DeRozan all in the Bulls next year. I'm actually legitimately excited.

Big Cat is expressing a personal feeling of excitement, which is subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Once the Lakers get to the playoffs, it will be Carmelo Anthony's team, not LeBron James'

I'm also rooting for the takes to start flying because when you have that many guys on a team, it's no longer LeBron James' team. I think once they get to the playoffs, it's Mello time, baby.

The 2021-22 Lakers failed to even make the play-in tournament, and it was never 'Mello time' in any meaningful playoff sense.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alex Caruso is a top-five player in the Eastern Conference

Caruso is legitimately, I think, now a top five player in the East.

Caruso has never made an All-NBA or All-Star team; he is objectively not a top-5 player in the Eastern Conference.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Olympic runners are breaking world records because there are no fans to suck the oxygen out of the stadium

If there's no crowd at all, does that mean that there's more oxygen for the people to breathe on the track? ... They're sucking all the oxygen out normally, but when there's no fans there, it's a richer environment for especially distance runners to be able to breathe more efficiently.

The presence of fans in an open-air stadium does not significantly deplete oxygen levels for athletes. Records were likely due to new shoe technology and track surfaces.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 49ers are only saying Jimmy Garoppolo is playing well to pump his trade value before sending him to the Colts

John Lynch went on Adam Schefter's podcast, said that Jimmy is playing his best football since he's been here, which sounds to me like a general manager pumping a guy up before they send him somewhere else, maybe to a place like Indianapolis.

Garoppolo remained with the 49ers for the entire 2021 season and was not traded to the Colts.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The U.S. women's soccer team sucks at soccer now

My hot seat is the U.S. women's soccer team because they lost and we stink... I tweeted about like, oh, we suck at soccer now.

This is a subjective emotional reaction to a loss; the team remains one of the top-ranked in the world, though they did fail to win gold.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The USA men's basketball 'Golden Generation' is just getting started

Our [USA] men's team golden generation has just begun... The USA's golden generation is just getting started. Hell yeah, we are.

The USA men's team won gold in 2020 (2021) and 2024, maintaining their dominance even if the gap is closing.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

You need at least $50 million in the bank to successfully use your parents' wealth to get out of jail

He was screaming like, my parents have $2 million. That's a lot of money, but it's also not like... I feel like if you're trying to get out of jail for free, your parents have to have like $50 million.

This is a matter of opinion on social dynamics and wealth thresholds.
Open
Calvin JohnsonCalvin Johnson

Matthew Stafford will make the Hall of Fame if he wins a Super Bowl or has several consecutive winning seasons with the Rams

It all depends how much longer Matthew intends to play. And if he gets that ring out, he's out there. You know, if he goes out there and lights it up and has consecutive, like three, four or five consecutive winning seasons, even if he don't win the Super Bowl, I think he has a chance.

Stafford won the Super Bowl that same season (Feb 2022). While his HOF entry is pending his retirement, he met the criteria Calvin set.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers